HomeMy WebLinkAbout05-12-14-R--
Dave McClung
Ed Werner
www.cityofardenhills.org
Arden Hills is a strong community that values its unique environmental setting, strong residential
neighborhoods, vital business community, wellmaintained infrastructure, fiscal soundness, and our
longstanding tradition as a desirable City in which to live, work, and play.
CALL TO ORDER
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Public inquiries/informational is an opportunity for citizens to bring to the Councils
attention any items not currently on the agenda. In addressing the Council, please state
your name and address for the record, and a brief summary of the specific item being
addressed to the Council. To allow adequate time for each person wishing to address the
Council, we ask that individuals limit their comments to three (3) minutes. Written
documents may be distributed to the Council prior to the meeting, or as bench copies, to
allow a more timely presentation.
STAFF COMMENTS
3.A.TCAAP Update
Jill Hutmacher, Community Development Director
Documents:MEMO.PDF
3.B.Transportation Update
Terry Maurer, Public Works Director
Documents:MEMO.PDF
Community Cleanup Day Update
Ryan Streff, City Planner
Documents:CC MEMO.PDF, ATTACHMENT A.PDF
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
4.A.Approval Of Minutes
March 17, 2014, Work Session
March 31, 2014, Closed Meeting
March 31, 2014, Regular
March 31, 2014, Work Session
Documents:WS.PDF,C.PDF,R.PDF,
WS.PDF
CONSENT CALENDAR
Those items listed under the Consent Calendar are considered to be routine by the City
be no separate discussion of these items, unless a Councilmember so requests, in which
event, the item will be removed from the general order of business and considered
separately in its normal sequence on the agenda.
5.A.Claims And Payroll
Sue Iverson, Director of Finance and Administrative Services
Ariel Schmitz, Accounting Department
Documents:MEMO.PDF
5.B.Motion To Approve Resolution 2014025 Recognizing National Public Works Week
(May 18 May 24)
Terry Maurer, Public Works Director
Documents:MEMO.PDF,ATTACHMENT A.PDF
Nextel Red Fox Site Lease
John Anderson, Assistant City Engineer
Documents:MEMO.PDF,ATTACHMENT A.PDF
Approve November 19, 2007, Work Session Minutes
Amy Dietl, City Clerk
Documents:MEMO.PDF,ATTACHMENT A.PDF
5.E.Approve 2014 Capital Reimbursement To Lake Johanna Fire Department (Invoice 470)
Sue Iverson, Director of Finance and Administrative Services
Documents:MEMO.PDF,ATTACHMENT A.PDF
5.F.Approve 2014 Capital Reimbursement To Lake Johanna Fire Department (Invoice 471)
Sue Iverson, Director of Finance and Administrative Services
Documents:MEMO.PDF,ATTACHMENT A.PDF
PULLED CONSENT ITEMS
Those items that are pulled from the Consent Calendar will be removed from the general
order of business and considered separately in its normal sequence on the agenda.
PUBLIC HEARINGS
7.A.TCAAP Development Discussion Opportunity For Residents
Documents:MEMO.PDF
7.B.Round Lake Road Assessment Hearing
John Anderson, Assistant City Engineer
Documents:MEMO.PDF,ATTACHMENT A.PDF, ATTACHMENT B.PDF,
ATTACHMENT C.PDF, ATTACHMENT D.PDF, ATTACHMENT E.PDF,
ATTACHMENT F.PDF
NEW BUSINESS
8.A.Refinancing Of The 2010 Bond Series
Sue Iverson, Director of Finance and Administrative Services
John Utley, Kennedy & Graven, Chartered
Documents:MEMO.PDF,ATTACHMENT A.PDF
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
9.A.Round Lake Road Improvement Consider Hiring Consultant To Assist With
Construction Administration Inspection/Staking
Terry Maurer, Public Works Director
Documents:MEMO.PDF,ATTACHMENT A.PDF
STAFF COMMENTS 3A
MEMORANDUM
DATE: May 12, 2014
TO: Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM: Jill Hutmacher, Community Development Director
SUBJECT: TCAAP Update
Development and Design of On-Site Infrastructure
On May 1, 2014, Ramsey County received four proposals for the development and design of on-
May 12, 2014, and a consultant team will be chosen in time to allow work to proceed before the
end of this month.
Demolition and Remediation
The demolition of the final remaining building on the site, Building 502, is scheduled to occur in
May/June 2014. Work on soil remediation and removal of building pads and footings is
continuing.
Alternative Urban Areawide Review (AUAR)
Public comments on the draft AUAR and Mitigation Plan are being accepted until May 28, 2014.
The City Council is tentatively scheduled to review the final document on June 30, 2014, with
approval in July.
LCDA Application
The City submitted a Project Concept Plan, which is essentially a pre-application to the
The application includes a request for $1,605,000 in Livable Community Act (LCA) funds for
sidewalks and trails, lighting, landscaping, site preparation and grading, and architecture and
engineering for public improvements in the TCAAP North Gateway Area which extends from
the entrance to the site at I-35W/County Road H south through the town center.
By June 2, 2014, the Metropolitan Council will notify the City if it will be invited to submit a
full application. The deadline for the full application is June 30, 2014.
12
Page of
Future Meeting Schedule
Special and regular City Council work session meetings have been scheduled to discuss issues
related to the Master Plan and City infrastructure. Discussion topics are tentatively planned as
follows:
May 12, 2014, Special Work Session at 5:30 pm, Community Room
Infrastructure Study Update and City Cost Participation Agreement
Discussion on Financial Issues
Legislative Update
May 19, 2014, Regular Work Session at 5:00 pm; Council Chambers
Ramsey County Financial Model
Residential Development and Densities
Flex Space Land Use Discussion
May 27, 2014 (Tuesday), Special Work Session at 5:30 pm, Community Room
I-35W/Highway 96 Interchange Discussion
June 16, 2014, Regular Work Session at 5:00 pm, Council Chambers
Review Revised Master Plan
Review Aesthetics for I-35W Bridges
June 30, 2014, Special Work Session at 5:30 pm, Community Room
Review Final AUAR and Mitigation Plan
June 30, 2014, Regular Meeting at 7:00 pm, Council Chambers
Approve Master Plan
Municipal Consent for I-35W/Highway 96
July 14, 2014, Regular Work Session at 5:00 pm, Council Chambers
Discussion topics to be determined (infrastructure, regulations and policies, etc.)
July 21, 2014, Special Work Session at 5:30 pm, Community Room
Discussion topics to be determined (infrastructure, regulations and policies, etc.)
July 28, 2014, Regular Meeting at 7:00 pm, Council Chambers
Approve Final AUAR and Mitigation Plan
It is anticipated that additional regular and special work session meetings will be scheduled to
discuss TCAAP issues. Future meeting topics will be defined as those dates draw nearer.
22
Page of
STAFF COMMENTS 3B
MEMORANDUM
DATE: May 12, 2014
TO: Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM: Terry Maurer, Public Works Director
SUBJECT: Transportation Update
Background
A brief oral update will be provided at the meeting on the US Highway 10 and County Road 96
project.
11
Page of
STAFF COMMENTS –3C
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
May 12, 2014
TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM:Ryan Streff, City Planner
SUBECT:Community Cleanup Day Update
Requested Action
None.
Background
th
The community cleanup day event is scheduled for Saturday, May 17from 8am to 3pm. It will
be held at the Ramsey County Public Works Facility at 1425 Paul Kirkwold Drive. The event is
co-sponsored by the Cities of Arden Hills and Shoreview and open to residents of both cities.
Unlike previous cleanup events, the City is offering a free cleanup day as a pilot program to
minimize wait times. Participants will not have to pay additional fees based on the amount or
type of items being dropped off. Just remember to bring your ID. The Salvation Army will also
be on site collecting any items that are salvageable for reuse.
Notices have been in the City newsletter for the past twomonths. In addition, direct mail fliers
have been mailed to City residents.
Attachments
A) 2014 Cleanup Day Flyer
11
Page of
Attachment A
To minimize wait times, the City of Arden Hills will begin a pil
Bring items that are general refuse and debris not normally
ACCEPTED DONATIONS
collected by your refuse hauler, including: Appliances, BBQ gril
exercise equipment, generators, mattresses and box springs, lawn
mowers, snow blowers, stuffed furniture, tires, vacuum cleaners,
rugs, lamps
and water softeners.
appliances (working), drinkware, microwave ovens
Unwanted electronics will be accepted for recycling, including
computers, printers, keyboards and televisions however, you do
players
have to wait till Spring Cleanup Day! Many options are availabl
for convenient year-round collection of these items. Please visi
couches, dining sets, bed frames, dressers, night stands
RamseyAtoZ.com or call the Recycling and Disposal Hotline at
651.633.EASY (3279), answered 24/7, for more details.
equipment, lawn equipment (working), exercise equipment
NOT ACCEPTED DONATIONS
Mattresses, box springs, carpeting, large appliances
If you are only bringing household hazardous waste items
for example, a couple of old paint cans you can avoid long
wait times at Cleanup Day. Just visit RamseyAtoZ.com
or
call 651.633.EASY (3279), answered 24/7, to learn options
for other drop-off dates and locations.
ACCEPTED ITEMS
Paint/thinners/solvents/adhesives/driveway sealant/wood
preservatives/stains/aerosol cans/lead/paint chips
Weed killer/insecticides/pesticides
Drain openers/oven cleaners/bathroom cleaners/rust removers
Rechargeable batteries/button batteries/propane tanks/
pool chemicals/gas cylinders
Residents must present a Shoreview or Arden Hills ID.
Yard waste will not be accepted during the Cleanup Day.
Approved:
CITY OF ARDEN HILLS, MINNESOTA
CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION
MARCH 17, 2014
5:00 P.M. - ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL
Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, Mayor Grant called to order the City Council work
session at 5:00 p.m.
Present:
Mayor David Grant; Councilmembers Brenda Holden, Fran Holmes, Dave
McClung, and Ed Werner
Absent:
None
Also present
: City Administrator Patrick Klaers; Director of Finance and Administrative
Services Sue Iverson; Public Works Director Terry Maurer; Community Development
Director Jill Hutmacher; City Planner Ryan Streff; Associate Planner Matthew Bachler;
and City Clerk Amy Dietl
Planning Commission Members present:
Commissioners Brent Bartel, Andy Holewa,
Steven Jones, and Vice Chair Roberta Thompson
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
The Council accepted the agenda as presented.
1. AGENDA ITEMS
A.TCAAP Discussion
City Administrator Klaers
stated that City staff, County staff, and consultants have had a series
of meetings concerning development issues. At this time, Council discussion and direction is
needed to facilitate continued progress.
Infrastructure Study. Heather Worthington and Beth Engum, Ramsey County, will present
information on a proposed infrastructure study which would examine issues related to
stormwater/wetlands, utilities, transportation, land title/platting, and infrastructure financing.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 17, 20142
Development Constraints. Heather Worthington will provide information on development
constraints which may limit types of land use and development in certain areas of the site.
City Financial Modeling. Stacie Kvilvang, Ehlers and Associates, will discuss City financing for
utilities.
Budget Amendment. Sue Iverson, Director of Finance and Administrative Services, is
recommending a budget amendment to move TCAAP expenses into a capital fund for improved
tracking and transparency.
PTRC Review. Terry Maurer, Director of Public Works, will report on the plan to work with the
Parks, Trails, and Recreation Committee as requested by the City Council to complete an analysis
of park and open space needs on the TCAAP site.
Future Meeting Schedule. As TCAAP development proceeds, the issues above as well as other
topics will need regular review and discussion by the City Council and a proposed meeting
schedule will be discussed.
Beth Engum
, Ramsey County, reviewed the infrastructure study with the Council noting that an
RFP for consultant work was being drafted at this time for design of the TCAAP site. She
anticipated that the infrastructure work (stormwater, wetlands, utilities, sanitary sewer,
transportation, spine road, mass grading and platting) would be completed in phases. The County
hoped to have the RFP completed at the beginning of April. This was a tight timeframe, but
would ensure the project was properly moving forward.
Public Works Director Maurer
recommended that the City attach the water and sanitary sewer
analysis and feasibility study onto this RFP. He anticipated that a cost sharing agreement could be
reached between the City and the County for these specific tasks.
Mayor Grant
questioned if the proposed construction timeline would lead to work beginning on
TCAAP in 2016.
Ms. Engum
believed roadways and construction of buildings could begin in 2016. She
commented that the County viewed the infrastructure study to be a pre-development investment.
She indicated that the feasibility of the spine road and potential assessments would be included in
the scope of the RFP.
Councilmember Werner
questioned if TCAAP could be developed without a water tower.
Public Works Director Maurer
stated that this may be possible but this is one of the issues a
consultant would analyze.
Mayor Grant
questioned how the cost sharing for the infrastructure study would be arranged.
Ms. Engum
reported that Mike Norton, attorney for the Joint Development Authority (JDA),
would be drawing up a cost sharing agreement. The City would then enter into the agreement
with the County.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 17, 20143
Councilmember Holden
requested further information on what would be included in the scope
of the infrastructure and feasibility studies.
Ms. Engum
explained that the following categories would be addressed within the infrastructure
plan: transportation, mass grading plan, utilities, water and sanitary sewer, stormwater, wetlands
and platting. She noted that the feasibility study would meet the Chapter 429 (assessments)
requirements.
Councilmember Holmes
asked who the County would be assessing for roadway and utility
improvements.
Ms. Engum
reported that the assessments would be passed along to future landowners.
Mayor Grant
questioned how the City would recover its costs.
Stacie Kvilvang
, Ehlers & Associates, reviewed how the City could recover its costs.
Councilmember McClung
inquired if the water feature would be addressed through the
infrastructure study. He explained that a great deal of information would be needed before he
could make an informed decision regarding the water feature.
Public Works Director Maurer
stated that the water feature would be addressed in the
infrastructure study.
staff would continue to work with consultants on this issue before any final decisions were made
regarding this amenity.
Councilmember Holden
asked when the Master Plan had to be approved.
City Administrator Klaers
indicated that the Master Plan should be approved this summer in
order for the City to move forward with the Policies and Regulations. The goals for the water
feature should be able to be addressed by that time.
Further discussion ensued regarding the water feature.
Public Works Director Maurer
understood that the Council wanted the water feature to hold
water and be a positive amenity for the area. Staff would need to investigate how much land
would be required to ensure the water feature meets the RCWD requirements, wetlands laws, and
.
Mayor Grant
questioned what direction the County was seeking from the Council this evening.
Ms. Engum
explained that the County was hoping the City would agree to enter into a cost
sharing agreement per the Joint Powers Agreement to share in the stormwater study.
Councilmember Holden
asked if the water from the groundwater treatment process the Army
operates on TCAAP would be analyzed through the RFP in terms of its potential use for the water
feature or a geo-thermal system.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 17, 20144
Heather Worthington
, Ramsey County, commented that she had spoken with Mike Fix today
regarding this matter and a request could be made to the Army.
Councilmember Holmes
inquired if the City had already approved a water resources study.
Public Works Director Maurer
noted that the County and City were working to hire a
consultant through the City to complete a water resource study. However, this effort was put on
hold as the County and City felt it would be more beneficial to prepare a global infrastructure RFP
to address all issues including water resources.
Mayor Grant
questioned if the Council supported a cost sharing agreement with the County per
the Joint Powers Agreement for the stormwater study.
Councilmember Holmes
believed this to be a part of the JPA.
Councilmember Werner
recommended that the cost sharing venture as it would reduce
duplication of services. For this reason, he was in favor of the cost sharing agreement with the
County.
Councilmember Holden
agreed stating that the work needed to be done.
Councilmember McClung
had concerns regarding when the results would be available and if
they could be used for the Master Plan.
Mayor Grant
summarized that the Council was in support of the cost sharing venture.
Ms. Worthington
understood that the Council had questions about the development constraints
on the TCAAP site. She indicated certain portions of the site had TCE contamination in the
ground that went into the water table and required monitoring/mitigation into the future. A couple
of these sites would require vapor barriers for basements and sub basements. Therefore, these
areas would not be economically feasible for residential uses. These areas of the site would be
more conducive to commercial or slab based developments.
Mayor Grant
requested further information on the location of TCE contaminated areas.
Ms. Worthington
reviewed the general locations in detail with the Council.
Councilmember McClung
questioned if the current Master Plan conflicted with any of the
contaminated areas.
Ms. Worthington
believed that the current layout for the land uses did not cause a conflict with
any of the contaminated areas.
Councilmember Werner
questioned why the federal government would not pay for vapor
mitigation of these areas.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 17, 20145
Ms. Worthington
stated that the government would not cover the expense for the vapor
mitigation but would pay to treat the water. She reported that a composite map of the TCAAP site
Further discussion ensued regarding the location and development opportunities for the sites that
had development constraints.
Councilmember Holmes
questioned if the entire TCAAP site would be cleaned to residential
standards.
Ms. Worthington
indicated that the entire site would be cleaned to a residential soil value
standard. However, there is existing pollution in the water table that will be the responsibility of
the Army for the next 50 years.
Councilmember Holden
asked if the Certificate of Completion for residential would explain
what areas needed further mitigation.
Ms. Worthington
explained that the Certificate of Completion would address the M
residential soil value standards. It would not address the vapor concerns. She reported that this
was consistent throughout the entire metro area.
Councilmember McClung
commented that there were two broad areas with significant vapor
issues. He statedthatthere were other hot pockets throughout the site but that they were not large
enough to cause economic viability issues. However, the two larger areas would lead to economic
difficulty if developed as residential homes.
Ms. Worthington
agreed stating that these two areas are the best candidates for significant vapor
issues. She explained that the County worked with City staff and Kimley-Horn to provide
information to help guide the Master Planning process.
Councilmember Holden
questioned how the Master Plan would be reviewed if the proposed plan
works best economically. She asked how changes could be proposed by the Council.
City Administrator Klaers
stated that he believed the City had a reasonable amount of flexibility
and could shift property masses by 5% to 10%. The economic impacts would have to be
considered when making these changes. He explained that the PTRC will review the Master Plan
and will be forming recommendations for park and recreational space.
Mayor Grant
asked if the County had any other constraints for the Council to consider.
Ms. Worthington
did not.
Mayor Grant
questions/comments and for the information provided to the Council.
Ms. Kvilvang
reviewed the financial responsibilities of the City with regard to TCAAP. She
reported that the first major component would be the trunk utilities that would need to be installed
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 17, 20146
along the spine road. The County would be the developer and the responsible party for these
trunk utility expenses and the City would follow the 429 process in order to allow for the cost of
the improvements to be assessed back to the property owner.
Ms. Kvilvang
commented that the County will be reviewing their financial options for the
utilities. The City had a risk free proposition, while the County may have to analyze the use of
temporary bonds. The use of temporary bonds would depend greatly on how quickly the County
anticipates the site would develop.
Councilmember Holden
asked about SAC and WAC charges.
City Administrator Klaers
commented that the SAC and WAC fees received by the City would
be used to assist the City in maintaining the utilities, booster stations, pumps, etc. installed on the
TCAAP property in the future. He further noted that the amount of the SAC and WAC fees needs
to be evaluated.
Councilmember Holden
asked about how the assessment would be paid.
Ms. Kvilvang
stated that the expense for the trunk utilities along the spine road would be assessed
back to the County and the County would pay those assessments in the future. The County could
then sell the land cheaper to the end developer with the developer assuming the assessments; or
the land could be sold for more, with the County paying the assessments. The second way that the
assessments could be paid would be through private developers petitioning the City for sub-
utilities. These developers would pay less for land due to the fact that they would be installing
roads and utilities to support the development.
Mayor Grant
inquired who would be paying for the spine road.
Ms. Kvilvang
reported that the County would be paying for the spine road. The City would use
its bonding authority for sewer and water utilities along the road, which would then be assessed
back to the developer (County). She reported that the City would own the utilities.
Further discussion ensued regarding the installation and payment of utilities on TCAAP.
Councilmember Holmes
questioned how the City would be impacted if the thumb was
developed first.
Ms. Kvilvang
stated that this would not impact the City because the County was proposing to
have a private developer pay for extending the utilities into the thumb.
Councilmember Holmes
asked who would be responsible for installing water, if deemed
necessary.
Public Works Director Maurer
reported that this expense could be assessed 100% to the
County.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 17, 20147
Councilmember Holmes
questioned if the Council would have to raise its levy to support the
bonding on TCAAP.
Ms. Kvilvang
stated that this would be part of , but she explained that the budget
would have a line item for debt service which would be covered 100% through special
assessments.
Councilmember Holden
inquired how the City would be impacted if there was another economic
downturn and the TCAAP property was not selling quickly.
Ms. Kvilvang
reported that would be the trunk utilities; however, there
was little risk that the County would default on its assessments. The only other risks are with the
residential developers not paying their property taxes.
Councilmember Holmes
asked what would happen if a private residential developer went
bankrupt.
Ms. Kvilvang
explained that the City would not receive payments and would actually become
responsible for the bonds. The City would need to evaluate its risk threshold in order to best
mitigate this situation. This could be done by the Council analyzing how long it is willing to issue
debt, along with considering letters of credit or up-front cash deposits.
Mayor Grant
commented that another solution would be to limit how much of the development
could be developed at any one moment in time.
Director of Finance and Administrative Services Iverson
reported that the Council could
consider completing the TCAAP development in phases.
City Administrator Klaers
added that the County may also have ideas about the pace of the
development. The County may not want any residential development until the
commercial/business park is completed. This would ensure that the commercial areas are
supported. He explained that this topic will have to be further discussed with the County at a
future work session.
Councilmember Holden
questioned if the City had an understanding of the expense required to
develop areas with vapor issues into residential.
Ms. Kvilvang
did not have information on this topic. She believed that it would be reasonable for
the City to make this request and reported that she would request this information from the
County.
City Administrator Klaers
believed that the County had not run proformas regarding this topic.
Councilmember Holmes
inquired if the City wanted to do TIF on the TCAAP site.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 17, 20148
Ms. Kvilvang
stated that the City may want to receive property taxes sooner rather than later. She
noted that the County did not feel it was necessary to provide TIF to attract future businesses to
this site.
Councilmember Holden
asked if all private utilities would be buried on TCAAP.
Public Works Director Maurer
stated that this was the case.
Director of Finance and Administrative Services Iverson
reviewed the 2013 and 2014 TCAAP
budgets with the Council. She recommended a separate capital account be created for TCAAP
capital expenditures with budget amendments made effective for 2013 and 2014. This would
allow the City to track capital expenses for all projects and studies for TCAAP. In addition, this
would ensure the expenditures would not distort the General Fund.
Councilmember Holden
questioned how staff time would be billed.
Director of Finance and Administrative Services Iverson
explained how staff time would be
billed back for the TCAAP project.
The Council supported the budget adjustment as recommended by staff.
Public Works Director Maurer
commented that he would be meeting with the PTRC on March
18, 2014, to discuss a park analysis. He reported that the planners were good in addressing the
number of ball fields needed on TCAAP; however, the space identified for the fields and other
s analysis. He will discuss this matter further with the PTRC
and a report will be provided to the Council at a future meeting.
B.2014 Joint City Council and Planning Commission Meeting
City Planner Streff
stated that the City Council is being asked to provide input and feedback on
the draft 2014 Work Plan. In addition, this meeting is intended to be an
open dialog and an opportunity to discuss other planning-related items. The City Council may
provide feedback to the Planning Commission on their role, ask questions and discuss items of
concern. The Planning Commission may provide input to the City Council on important planning
items they see in the community and bring up topics of interest or concern.
City Planner Streff
reported that the Planning Commissi
determined by State Statute. The majority of the Planning Commission Work Plan is dedicated to
continuing the work of evaluating and providing recommendations on land use applications,
zoning code amendments, and other planning-related items that come before the City.
Vice Chair Thompson
reviewed the Planning Commission Work Plan in detail with the Council.
She commented that the City was hoping to recruit another Commission member in 2014.
Commissioner Holewa
stated that the Commission would like to see the Sign Code more closely
aligned to those of neighboring communities. He believed that the most common requests
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 17, 20149
reviewed by the Planning Commission are sign standard adjustments and this could be
streamlined by reviewing and making appropriate revisions to
Councilmember Holden
recommended that the Commission consider the base size for
monument signs when the sign standards are reviewed.
Commissioner Bartel
wanted to see more structure in the sign code as this would provide further
guidance to the Commission when reviewing requests for sign standard adjustments.
Councilmember McClung
believed that even if the Sign Code was amended, there would always
be future applicants requesting additional signage.
Commissioner Bartel
explained that by making the sign sizes proportionate to building sizes, this
would address a number of the requests for sign standard adjustments. He was in favor of
temporary sign requests being approved at a staff level.
Commissioner Jones
suggested that the number of tenants within a building and the size of the
parking lot be considered in the Sign Code.
Councilmember Holden
stated that the Sign Ordinance was developed due to the number of
large sign requests. She reported that Arden Hills did not want to become a neon lit community
with extremely large signs.
Mayor Grant
reported that a level of flexibility could be written into the Sign Code, however,
there had to be a limit. He asked if the Council opposed the Planning Commission reviewing the
Sign Ordinance.
The Council supported the Commission moving forward with reviewing the Sign Ordinance.
Mayor Grant
discussed LED lighting and recommended that the City and Planning Commission
get out in front of this issue. He suggested that staff speak with neighboring communities
regarding the regulation of LED lighting.
Vice Chair Thompson
agreed.
Councilmember Holden
questioned which aspects of LED lighting would be reviewed by the
Planning Commission.
Vice Chair Thompson
indicated that this has yet to be determined by the Planning Commission.
City Planner Streff
anticipated that this would include LED lighting on canopies and signs.
Community Development Director Hutmacher
reported that more and more businesses were
changing light fixtures out from incandescent or fluorescent
She
neon-like manner as decorative accents.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 17, 201410
Councilmember Holden
suggested that the Commission review all areas where LED lights could be used.
Commissioner Jones
suggested that the Commission consider the different lumens available in
LED lights and which areas are most appropriate for brighter LED lights and which are not.
Vice Chair Thompson
commented that the Commission would have to research how other areas
of the metro were managing this issue.
Mayor Grant
requested further information on the Illustration Guide for the B-2 and B-3 design
standards.
Vice Chair Thompson
explained how the Planning Commission was approaching the B-2 design
standards.
Associate Planner Bachler
commented that the City had made updates to the B-2 and B-3 district
design standards last year. He explained that building materials and architectural features were
reviewed to provide guidance to future developers in these zoning districts.
Commissioner Bartel
hoped that the Commission could find visual examples of preferred
streetscape design and building materials that the City could incorporate into an Illustration
Guide. This would assist future developers with planning for redevelopments.
Councilmember Holden
recommended that the design standards include LEED building
standards. She commented that these standards would push the use of recycled materials in
redevelopment of the City. She suggested that the Commission create a checklist that can be
reviewed for each Planning Case. She explained that she depends on the Planning Commission to
address drainage and building material issues.
Commissioner Holewa
commented that LEED building standards have been discussed, however,
he believed it would be more important to have good economical design.
Commissioner Jones
had an issue with the LEED standards given the increased building
expense. He proposed the City pursue Energy Star ratings instead.
Mayor Grant
agreed that the energy ratings for buildings should be considered.
Associate Planner Bachler
explained that staff had checklists that were reviewed with each of
the different land use applications. The plans necessary in order to consider an application
complete are spelled out within these checklists. Depending on the nature of the proposed project,
required plans might include lighting plans, traffic studies, grading and drainage plans, etc.
Councilmember Holmes
recommended that the Planning Commission further review the issue of
transparent windows. She believed that this issue would continue to come before the City.
Councilmember Werner
requested further information on the League of Minnesota Cities
training.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 17, 201411
City Planner Streff
discussed the training courses proposed for the Planning Commission
members and staff.
Vice Chair Thompson
explained that the training courses provided valuable information to the
Commissioners.
Councilmember Holden
thanked the Planning Commission for their efforts stating that they did
a wonderful job reviewing Planning Cases.
Mayor Grant
agreed and thanked the Planning Commission for their attendance this evening.
A.TCAAP Discussion (continued)
City Administrator Klaers
provided the Council with a brief overview of the future meeting
schedule. He anticipated that regular and frequent TCAAP discussions would be necessary to
keep the project moving forward. For this reason, he requested that the Council plan on holding a
special Council work session the second and last Monday of every month. He suggested that
these meetings be held from 5:15 p.m. to 6:45 p.m.
A list of potential meeting topics for TCAAP was reviewed with the Council.
Mayor Grant
recommended that the meetings begin at 5:30 p.m. and run until 7:00 p.m. This
would allow the Council additional time to get to City Hall.
The Council agreed.
Councilmember Holmes
indicated that this schedule would have to take into consideration that
the EDA would meet on a quarterly basis prior to Council meetings.
2. COUNCIL COMMENTS AND STAFF UPDATES
Councilmember Werner
discussed a recent Arden Hills/Shoreview Business Council meeting he
attended.
Councilmember Holden
noted that Mayor Dave Jacobsen of New Brighton was voted Chair of
the Energy and Environmental Natural Resources Committee for the National League of Cities.
ADJOURN
Mayor Grant adjourned the City Council work session at 7:44 p.m.
__________________________ __________________________
Amy Dietl David Grant
City Clerk Mayor
Approved:
CITY OF ARDEN HILLS, MINNESOTA
SPECIAL CLOSED CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 31, 2014
5:30 PM - ARDEN HILLS CITY HALL
CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL
Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, Mayor David Grant called to order the special
closed City Council meeting at 5:30 p.m.
Present:
Mayor David Grant; Councilmembers Brenda Holden, Fran Holmes, Dave
McClung (arrived at 5:45 p.m.), and Ed Werner
Absent:
None
Also present
: City Administrator Patrick Klaers; League of Minnesota Cities Insurance
(Greene Espel); City Attorney Joel Jamnik; and
City Clerk Amy Dietl
1. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
The Council accepted the agenda as presented.
2. AGENDA ITEMS
TAT Properties Ltd and 1201 East County Road E vs. City of Arden Hills
A.
The City Council and staff received a briefing from the League of Minnesota Cities Insurance
Trust appointed attorney, John Baker, attorney for the law firm Greene Espel regarding the claim,
which is a challenge to a PUD amendment denial.
Mr. Baker
left the meeting after the briefing was provided.
STUARTCO, E Street Flats and Shoppes, Lisa A Moe vs. City of Arden Hills
B.
ARDEN HILLS SPECIAL CLOSED CITY COUNCIL MEETING MARCH 31, 20142
The City Council and staff then received a briefing from City Attorney Joel Jamnikregarding the
conciliation court claim challenging water, sewer and other utility charges billed to the property
during the time it was temporarily used for student housing. The owners allege that the City
improperly classified the property as commercial rather than residential and consequently over
billed the property during the time period.
ADJOURN
Mayor Grant adjourned the special closed City Council meeting at 6:35 p.m.
__________________________ __________________________
Amy Dietl David Grant
City Clerk Mayor
Approved:
CITY OF ARDEN HILLS, MINNESOTA
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 31, 2014
7:00 P.M. - ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL
Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, Mayor David Grant called to order the regular City
Council meeting at 7:00 p.m.
Present:
Mayor David Grant, Councilmembers Brenda Holden, Fran Holmes, Dave
McClung, and Ed Werner
Absent:
None
Also present
: City Administrator Patrick Klaers; Public Works Director Terry Maurer;
Community Development Director Jill Hutmacher; Associate Planner Matthew Bachler;
City Planner Ryan Streff; Parks and Recreation Manager Michelle Olson; and City Clerk
Amy Dietl
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
1. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Councilmember Holden
requested that Items 6J and 6K be pulled from the Consent Agenda for
discussion at a future City Council meeting.
MOTION: Councilmember Holmes moved and Councilmember Holden seconded a
motion to approve the meeting agenda as amended. The motion carried
unanimously (5-0).
2. PUBLIC INQUIRIES/INFORMATIONAL
Anil Khurana
, 1280 Wynridge Drive, explained that he has lived in Arden Hills for the past 30
years. He expressed concern with a water bill he received last fall that was approximately $600
higher than his average utility bills. He explained that he contacted the City and questioned if his
water meter should be checked. He was told by City staff that an inspection of the water meter
would cost $140. Mr. Khurana reported that he had his sprinkler system checked and there were
no concerns. He requested that the Council look into this matter further as he did not want to
have a delinquent account with the City.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL MARCH 31, 20142
Mayor Grant
requested that staff review this matter further and provide Council with an update
at an upcoming work session.
Charlie Kachel
, 1500 Arden Place, suggested that the City Council hold a Town Hall meeting in
2014. He believed this would be a good way to bring the community together.
3. PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS
A. 2014 Legislative Session Update
Representative Barb Yarusso
discussed the events taking place at the Legislature. She reported
that TCAAP funding has been requested in a bonding bill. She reviewed the changes proposed
within the tax bill, noting that the State was also looking to adjust the minimum wage. She
commented that a pothole repair bill was also being considered at this time and it has support
from the Governor.
Mayor Grant
requested further information on the TCAAP bonding bill. He understood that the
Senate bonding bill included funding for TCAAP.
Representative Yarusso
stated that this was the case. The Senate is proposing funding for
TCAAP, while the House has not proposed bonding for the TCAAP roadway improvements.
However, the final House bonding bill is not complete and numerous people are working to
ensure that TCAAP is included. She noted that the Governor has requested funding for TCAAP
within his proposal.
Councilmember Werner
questioned if the Legislature had created any regulations for e-
cigarettes.
Representative Yarusso
explained that the Governor does not want to see a bill this session on e-
cigarettes.
Councilmember Holden
discussed LGA and stated that Arden Hills does not receive any of this
funding from the State. She questioned if the State would be revising this formula.
Representative Yarusso
commented that an additional tax bill may be addressing this issue.
B. Northeast Youth and Family Services (NYFS) Report to the Council
Jerry Hromatka
, President and CEO of NYFS, provided the Council with an update on the
events taking place at Northeast Youth and Family Services. He reviewed the primary population
development, and day treatment programs. The numerous benefits of these programs along with
the current trends were discussed in detail. Mr. Hromatka provided comment on the number of
municipalities that support NYFS. He thanked Arden Hills for its continued support.
Mayor Grant
thanked Mr. Hromatka for his presentation and stated that he was pleased to see
that this organization was adjusting to meet the needs of the community.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL MARCH 31, 20143
Miriam Ward,
thanked the Council for the being able to serve on
the Board at Northeast Youth and Family Services. She has enjoyed her service with this
organization. She encouraged Council and staff to attend the upcoming Leadership Luncheon
being sponsored by NYFS on Wednesday, May 7, 2014.
4. STAFF COMMENTS
A. TCAAP Update
Community Development Director Hutmacher
stated that the City and Ramsey County are
working together on a Request for Proposals (RFP) for an infrastructure study that will consider
roadways, utilities, surface water management, and grading. Ramsey County will be the lead
agency for the contract which will include analysis and preliminary design for the spine road and
other infrastructure. City utilities will be included in the study, and the City will be asked to enter
into a cost-sharing agreement for its portion of the contract. Staff expects that the RFP will be
released in early April, and a consultant will be selected by mid-May.
Community Development Director Hutmacher
explained that special and regular City Council
work sessions have been scheduled to discuss issues related to the Master Plan and City
infrastructure. Discussion topics are tentatively planned as follows:
March 31, 2014, special work session - following the regular meeting
Infrastructure Study Update
Metropolitan Council Sewer Availability Charge (SAC) Credit Discussion
April 14, 2014, special work session at 5:30 pm
Review Draft Alternative Urban Areawide Review (AUAR) and Mitigation Plan
Financial Modeling for Trunk Utilities
Review of Public Comments on the Draft Master Plan
April 21, 2014, regular work session at 5:00 pm
Ramsey County Economic Development and Redevelopment Goals for TCAAP
PTRC Recommendations for Park and Open Space
City Goals for Surface Water Management
April 28, 2014, special work session - following the regular meeting
I-35W/Highway 96 Intersection Design Recommendation
Staff anticipates that additional regular and special work sessions will be scheduled to discuss
TCAAP issues. Future meeting topics will be defined as those dates draw nearer.
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A.February 18, 2014, Work Session
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL MARCH 31, 20144
MOTION: Councilmember McClung moved and Councilmember Holden seconded a
motion to approve the February 18, 2014, work session minutes as presented.
The motion carried unanimously (5-0).
6. CONSENT CALENDAR
A.Motion to Approve Consent Agenda Item - Claims and Payroll
B.Motion to Approve No Parking Resolution for Round Lake Road
C.Motion to Approve County Road E (B-2 District) Feasibility Report and Authorize
Preparations for the Plans and Specs
D.Motion to Authorize Purchase of a New Tool Cat
E.Motion to Authorize Purchase of One-Ton Truck
F.Motion to Authorize Upgrading Camera System for Sewer Televising
G.Motion to Authorize Consultant Bridge Contract Between Arden Hills, New
Brighton and Ramsey County
H.Motion to Approve Perry Park Fencing Project for Field #3
I.Motion to Approve Premise Permit Application for Roseville Area Youth Hockey
Association
J.Motion to Approve Procurement Policy
K. Motion to Approve Fund Balance Policy
L. Motion to Approve Planning Case 13-021 Boston Scientific PUD Amendment
Agreement
M. Motion to Approve Planning Case 14-010 Lexington Station PUD Amendment
Agreement
MOTION: Councilmember Holmes moved and Councilmember Werner seconded a
motion to approve the Consent Calendar as amended removing Items 6J and
6K and to authorize execution of all necessary documents contained therein.
The motion carried unanimously (5-0).
7. PULLED CONSENT ITEMS
None.
8. PUBLIC HEARINGS
A.Adopting and Confirming Quarterly Special Assessments for Delinquent
Utilities
City Administrator Klaers
stated that delinquent utility amounts are certified to Ramsey County
quarterly. A list of utility accounts with a delinquent balance was compiled and notices dated
February 11, 2014, were mailed. These customers were informed of their delinquent status and
were asked to make payment of the delinquent balance by March 12, 2014. Utility accounts with
an unpaid delinquent balance after March 12, 2014, would be certified to Ramsey County to be
added to property taxes and payable in 2015. The certification amount is equal to the unpaid
delinquent balance plus an eight percent penalty. The City will request that Ramsey County levy
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL MARCH 31, 20145
the delinquent balances against the respective properties. Staff recommended that the Council
approve Resolution 2014-018 certifying the list of delinquent utility accounts to Ramsey County.
Mayor Grant
opened the public hearing at 7:46 p.m.
With no one coming forward to speak, Mayor Grant closed the public hearing at 7:47 p.m.
Mayor Grant
requested that the Council approve the list of delinquent utilities minus Anil
Khurana, who spoke earlier this evening regarding his utility bill concern.
MOTION: Councilmember Holmes moved and Councilmember McClung seconded a
motion to approve Resolution 2014-018, certifying the list of delinquent utility
accounts to Ramsey County, removing Anil Khurana from the list.
Councilmember Holden
questioned why some of the delinquent accounts were $10 or less. She
The motion carried (5-0).
9. NEW BUSINESS
A. 2013 and 2014 Budget Adjustments
City Administrator Klaers
stated that in 2013 the City Council did a budget adjustment for
s costs of
the Kimley-Horn expenses for the planning and transportation studies. These expenses were also
programmed into the 2014 budget.
City Administrator Klaers
be better to set up a separate capital fund for these transactions, as they are infrastructure related
and capital in nature. By doing this, it will be more transparent and easier to track as the
expenditures, fund balance, and revenue sources are expected to come over time as the property
develops. By making this change, the General Fund will not have dramatic fluctuations from
year-to-year, making it easier and more transparent for everyone to follow the costs and fund
balances for both funds and the project.
City Administrator Klaers
indicated that staff discussed this matter with the Council at the
March 17, 2014 work session and the Council directed staff to put this item on the agenda. He
reported that the budget adjustments are reflected in the amended budgets. Staff recommended
the Council approve the budget adjustments for 2013 effective December 31, 2013, and to create a
new fund called the TCAAP Capital Fund. In addition, staff requested that the Council approve
budget adjustments for 2014 effective March 31, 2014.
Councilmember McClung
understood that the proposed budget adjustment would remove spikes
to the General Fund for TCAAP expenses.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL MARCH 31, 20146
City Administrator Klaers
stated that this was the case and that it would also provide more
transparency for the City.
MOTION: Councilmember Holden moved and Councilmember Holmes seconded a
motion to approve budget adjustments for 2013 effective December 31, 2013,
and to create a new fund called the TCAAP Capital Fund. The motion
carried (5-0).
MOTION: Councilmember Holden moved and Councilmember Holmes seconded a
motion to approve budget adjustments for 2014 effective March 31, 2014.
The motion carried (5-0).
B. Presbyterian Homes Bond Refunding to Call Public Hearing
John Utley
, Kennedy & Graven, stated that i
$28,000,000 Housing and Health Care Revenue Note, Series 2010 be refunded by the issuance of
three separate notes in the approximate amount of $9,300,000 each by three cities; Spring Park,
St. Bonafacius, and Chanhassen for a total of $27,900,000. Host approval is required for the
refunding notes as they still include facilities in the City of Arden Hills, so it is necessary for the
issuers to request host approval by the City Council of Arden Hills.
Mr. Utley
stated that the notes cannot be issued as tax-exempt obligations unless a notice of
public hearing is published in a newspaper of general circulation in the City, the City Council
conducts a public hearing consistent with the terms of the public notice regarding approval of the
notes, and following the public hearing the City Council approves the issuance of the notes.
Mr. Utley
explained that Presbyterian Homes has submitted an application to the City with
respect to the requested host approval and has submitted a non-refundable application fee in the
amount of $500 according to the City procedure for application for Private Activity Revenue
Bond Financing.
Mr. Utley
noted that the applicant is requesting that the Council set a public hearing date of
Monday, April 28, 2013. He requested that the Council adopt Resolution 2014-021, a resolution
calling for a public hearing on giving host approval to the issuance of housing and health care
revenue refunding notes to refinance a project by Presbyterian Homes and Services and
authorizing the publication of a notice of the hearing (PHS/Lake Minnetonka Campus Project).
Councilmember Holden
asked if there would be a cost to the City of Arden Hills for the
proposed bond refunding.
Mr. Utley
explained that there would be no cost to Arden Hills.
MOTION: Councilmember Werner moved and Councilmember Holden seconded a
motion to adopt Resolution 2014-021, a resolution calling for a public hearing
on giving host approval to the issuance of housing and health care revenue
refunding notes to refinance a project by Presbyterian Homes and Services
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL MARCH 31, 20147
and authorizing the publication of a notice of the hearing (PHS/Lake
Minnetonka Campus Project). The motion carried (5-0).
C. Planning Case 14-009 Multi-Family Design Standards
City Planner Streff
stated that in January 2013, the City Council requested that staff review the
-family dwelling units. Currently, these standards
require multi-family dwelling units to be a minimum of 600 square feet, with an additional 100
square feet required for each bedroom. The Council expressed concerns that the standards could
permit multi-bedroom apartments that do not provide adequate floor area per resident.
City Planner Streff
noted that staff collected information from seven cities in the metro region
that have adopted minimum unit size standards. The cities included New Brighton, Blaine, White
Bear Lake, Maplewood, Fridley, Coon Rapids, and Bloomington. An analysis was completed
Staff also looked at ten multi-family development projects that have recently been completed or
that are under construction in outer-ring suburban communities to evaluate the average unit sizes
currently being built in the private market. These projects are located in the communities of New
Brighton, White Bear Lake, Arden Hills, Elk River, Apple Valley, Ramsey, Eagan, Osseo, and
Maple Grove.
City Planner Streff
commented that at the City Council work session on January 13, 2014, staff
reviewed this data with the Council. Based on the comments provided by the Council, staff
drafted Ordinance 2014-003, which would revise the minimum unit size standards for multi-
family dwelling units.
City Planner Streff
reported that the amendment to the multi-family design standards would
decrease the required square footage for efficiency apartment units and increase the required
square footage for two-bedroom and three-bedroom units, as well as the additional floor area
required for each additional bedroom. The City Council directed staff to make these changes so
being constructed by the private market.
City Planner Streff
explained that the Planning Commission reviewed Section 1325.045, Subd. 1
of the Multi-family Dwelling Units Additional Conditional Use Permit Criteria of the Zoning
Ordinance during their meeting on March 5, 2014. The proposed changes to the Multi-family
Design Standards were discussed by the Commission and the consensus was that the current
standards for multi-family units do not need to be revised as they are sufficient for future
development. However, the Commission believed that a reduction in size for efficiency units was
reasonable. The Commission supported a change to between 450-550 square feet for efficiency
units.
City Planner Streff
indicated that the Planning Commission thought the City should not be too
restrictive with the multi-family design standards and that the market should be allowed to control
the size of units built. It was also a concern that if a change did occur a significant amount of
variances would be requested in the future to satisfy the needs of developers. The Commission did
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL MARCH 31, 20148
not feel that increasing the size of multi-family units would ultimately ensure that the units built
would be of high quality.
City Planner Streff
stated that the Planning Commission offers the following findings of fact:
1.That the Planning Commission reviewed the proposed amendments to Section 1325.045 at
their March 5, 2014, meeting.
2.That Section 1325.045 addresses the minimum size standards for multi-family dwelling
units.
3.That Section 1325.045, Subd. 1 of the Multi-family Dwelling Units Additional
Conditional Use Permit Criteria of the Zoning Ordinance, as previously adopted by the
City Council, sets sufficient standards for multi-family units.
City Planner Streff
reviewed the actions taken by the Planning Commission, stating that
Commissioner Hames moved and Commissioner Holewa seconded a motion to recommend denial
of Ordinance Number 14-003 in Planning Case 14-009 for an amendment to Section 1325.045,
Subd. 1 Multi-family Dwelling Units Additional Conditional Use Permit Criteria of the Zoning
Code. The motion carried unanimously (5-0). The reason behind the decision was that the
proposed minimum unit size standards are not consistent with the approved ordinances in
surrounding communities and the Commission is recommending that the efficiency minimum unit
size be revisited after staff speaks
City Planner Streff
requested that the Council consider a motion to deny Ordinance Number 14-
003 in Planning Case 14-009 for an amendment to Section 1325.045, Subd. 1 Multi-family
Dwelling Units Additional Conditional Use Permit Criteria of the Zoning Code to revise the
minimum unit size standards for multi-family dwelling units, as presented in the March 31, 2014,
Report to the City Council.
Councilmember Holden
asked if any one came forward to speak at the Planning Commissions
public hearing.
City Planner Streff
explained that no one spoke at the public hearing and no opinions were
voiced for or against the Zoning Code Amendment prior to the meeting.
MOTION: Councilmember Holden moved and Councilmember McClung seconded a
motion to approve Ordinance Number 14-003 in Planning Case 14-009 for an
amendment to Section 1325.045, Subd. 1 Multi-family Dwelling Units
Additional Conditional Use Permit Criteria of the Zoning Code to revise the
minimum unit size standards for multi-family dwelling units, as presented in
the March 31, 2014, Report to the City Council, based on the following
findings of fact:
1.The Council has reviewed in detail multiple times the changes
proposed.
2.The limits were well within the standards, and do not exceed the size of
units being built.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL MARCH 31, 20149
3.Variances from the ordinance could be requested and therefore the
City would be able to negotiate a safe building during the planning
phase.
4.The development community has not spoken against the Ordinance.
Mayor Grant
recommendation.
City Planner Streff
rev
Councilmember McClung
asked if the Planning Commission felt the proposed ordinance was
too restrictive.
City Planner Streff
believed that the Planning Commission saw the proposed ordinance as being
more restrictive than was necessary.
Councilmember Holmes
reported that the Planning Commission was in favor of decreasing the
efficiency unit size to somewhere between 450 and 550 square feet. However, they did not
support any of the proposed increases to the minimum unit size standards. The Planning
Commission commented that there were houses in Arden Hills that were 1,200 square feet in size
and they did not feel it was necessary for three-bedroom apartment units to be 1,200 square feet.
The Planning Commission was in favor of letting the market, rather than City Code, decide the
unit sizes.
Councilmember McClung
questioned if the City should have a policy in place requiring larger
apartment units without an ordinance in place.
City Planner Streff
explained that new developments coming before the City would most likely
This would allow for some flexibility with the unit sizes.
Councilmember Werner
commented that the Planning Commission voted 5-0 to deny the
proposed ordinance and he supported their recommendation.
Councilmember Holden
stated that the Council reviewed this ordinance on several occasions and
she believed that unit standards are a policy decision of the City. She explained that developers
could always request smaller units through a PUD. She supported the ordinance and wanted to
see minimum standards put in place.
Mayor Grant
indicated that Arden Village developed according to the current minimum
standards. He wanted the Council to keep in mind that these standards would be reviewed
throughout the redevelopment of TCAAP. He appreciated the work completed by the Planning
Commission but noted that he was in favor of establishing multi-family design standards as
previously discussed by the City Council. He reported that future developers could always request
a variance from the proposed standards.
size standards.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL MARCH 31, 201410
Councilmember McClung
stated that
and for this reason, he would be willing to support the proposed standards.
Councilmember Werner
thanked the Mayor for his comments. He noted that he now supported
the ordinance.
Councilmember Holden
indicated that she fully supported the ordinance.
Councilmember McClung
asked if the motion on the floor was sufficient.
City Planner Streff
stated the motion on the floor was sufficient; however, the findings of fact
needed clarification.
Councilmember McClung
requested that a friendly amendment to the motion include the
findings of fact as recommended by staff.
Councilmember Holden
agreed to the friendly amendment.
FRIENDLY AMENDMENT TO INCLUDE THE FINDINGS OF FACT:
1.
creates high development standards for multi-family housing that will
visually enhance development and promote compatibility with nearby
properties and neighborhood character.
2.
identified in the Land Use Chapter of the Comprehensive Plan by
developing design standards for multi-family housing that ensure the
construction of high quality, sustainable, and aesthetically enhanced
developments.
3. ause it
will promote the development of a variety of housing options by creating a
framework and process for the City to approve high-quality housing
opportunities that are suitable for a mix of ages, incomes, and household
types.
4. The proposed amendme
identified in the Housing Chapter of the Comprehensive Plan by
establishing design guidelines for new multi-family dwelling units.
The amended motion carried (5-0).
MOTION: Councilmember Holden moved and Councilmember Holmes seconded a
motion to direct staff to publish a summary of Ordinance Number 14-003.
The motion carried unanimously (5-0).
10. UNFINISHED BUSINESS
None.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL MARCH 31, 201411
11. COUNCIL COMMENTS
th
Councilmember McClung
stated that the Friends of the Park tree sale deadline was April 18.
He encouraged residents to take part in this event. Additional information regarding the tree sale
Councilmember Werner
explained that the EDC would meet on Wednesday, April 2, 2014. He
noted this group had several openings and those interested in serving on the EDC could contact
City Hall for additional information.
Councilmember Holden
stated that Greg Mack was retiring from Ramsey County. She
recommended the City adopt a resolution thanking Mr. Mack for his assistance over the years.
Councilmember Holden
suggested that the City work jointly with the school district and the City
of New Brighton to draft a plan for a sidewalk connection near the high school.
Councilmember Holden
indicated that she was in favor of holding a Town Hall meeting and
requested that this be further discussed by the Council.
Councilmember Holmes
discussed the Arden Hills Foundation and was pleased to announce this
organization had received its first tax deductible contribution in the amount of $57. This
contribution was made by John VanValkenberg and he has challenged other members of the
Mayor Grant
stated that if a Town Hall meeting were held, additional information on the Arden
Hills Foundation could be provided to the public.
ADJOURN
MOTION: Mayor Grant moved and Councilmember McClung seconded a motion to
adjourn. The motion carried unanimously (5-0).
Mayor Grant
adjourned the regular City Council meeting at 8:36 p.m.
__________________________ __________________________
Amy Dietl David Grant
City Clerk Mayor
Approved:
CITY OF ARDEN HILLS, MINNESOTA
CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION
MARCH 31, 2014
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL
Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, Mayor Grant called to order the City Council work
session at 8:46 p.m.
Present:
Mayor David Grant; Councilmembers Brenda Holden, Fran Holmes, Dave
McClung, and Ed Werner
Absent:
None
Also present
: City Administrator Patrick Klaers; Public Works Director Terry Maurer;
Community Development Director Jill Hutmacher; Associate Planner Matthew Bachler;
City Planner Ryan Streff; and City Clerk Amy Dietl
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
The Council accepted the agenda as presented.
1. AGENDA ITEMS
A.Update on Reuse Proposal 1203 County Road E
City Planner Streff
provided an update to the Council on the current status of the proposed use
by Creative Catering at 1203 County Road E and asked for input and direction from Council
regarding the proposed use.
City Planner Streff
reported that at the City Council work session on November 18, 2013, staff
brought forward a concept review from Creative Catering for a banquet, catering and retail center
to be located at 1203 County Road E. At that time, the applicant proposed a 15,000 square foot
banquet and meeting room space, in addition to a kitchen, food production and assembly area of
15,000 square feet, and a retail center with approximately 7,000 square feet. The applicant
indicated that it was her intent to use the banquet hall for events for up to 400 people and to lease
five retail bays in the southern portion of the building along County Road E to third party tenants.
The Council generally showed support for the proposed use; however, concerns regarding parking
and traffic were discussed.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 31, 20142
City Planner Streff
stated that since the
concerns regarding parking and the feasibility of acquiring parking easements for off-site parking.
The current proposal consists of a 16,380 square foot kitchen and food assembly area, a 3,456
square foot office, and a 2,288 square foot, 10-seat café. The current proposal does not include an
on-site banquet facility as was first proposed. Approximately 18,000 square feet would remain
vacant and could potentially be used to expand the kitchen and food assembly area at a later date.
City Planner Streff
indicated that the kitchen and food assembly use is defined in the Zoning
-2 Zoning District. By definition, an
accessory use must be incidental to the principal use of the property, which means that the
accessory use must directly
kitchen and food assembly area to support off-site catering events, wholesale
production/distribution to institutional or corporate clients, and retail sales of café meals and
takeout to consumers. The applicant estimates that once the retail portion of the business is
established, the retail will comprise approximately 35% of the business, and the
wholesale/catering will comprise 65% of the business. Given this information and after
conversations with the City Attorney, staff believes that the kitchen and food assembly area are
not accessory uses to the café/retail store.
City Planner Streff
reported that t
property. Its large size and small amount of parking limits the number of uses that could
e B-2
Zoning District. City staff recognizes the importance of finding a reuse for this property, but
believes that additional Council direction is necessary. Staff believes that a Zoning Code
Amendment is required to allow this proposal to move forward.
City Planner Streff
explained that the City has an easement over part of the area where a
sidewalk connection is proposed, however, the City does not currently have easements to allow
sidewalk construction across the entire frontage. The applicant has indicated that she would be
willing to provide the necessary easements, but staff has concluded that the current proposed use
will need all of the available 35 parking spaces. It would be possible to construct a sidewalk
between the curb and the parking lot. The City would request pedestrian easements in the event
that the property eventually was redeveloped.
City Planner Streff
commented that the current proposal suggests that traffic would move
through the site in a one-way fashion from east to west. Customers or clients would enter the site
near the east property line and proceed through the parking lot where upon exit, on the west side
of the property, a right-out only would be permitted. As with each proposal, traffic and pedestrian
safety needs to be evaluated and the City needs to determine what type of access is appropriate.
Staff asked the Council to consider the following questions:
1) Would the City Council support a zoning amendment to allow this application to proceed?
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 31, 20143
2) Does the City Council have concerns regarding the placement of the sidewalk connection
directly behind the curb?
3) Does the City Council have concerns regarding traffic and circulation?
Community Development Director Hutmacher
stated that the applicant was present and would
like to know if this is something that could potentially move forward or if the proposed use would
not fit at the proposed site.
Councilmember Holmes
asked if the applicant supported having one-way traffic through the site.
City Planner Streff
noted that the applicant had agreed to this.
Councilmember Holmes
questioned how a sidewalk could work on this property if the existing
parking were to remain in place.
City Planner Streff
reviewed the sidewalk plans in further detail with the Council.
Councilmember Holden
inquired if a Zoning Code Amendment was required for the use to
proceed or if an interim use or conditional use permit could be approved for the applicant.
City Planner Streff
explained that currently, the proposed use was not permitted through a
conditional use permit. If the City were to make a Zoning Code Amendment, manufacturing and
processing food for catering could be made a conditional use permit in the B-2 district.
Mayor Grant
requested further information about the food assembly that was being proposed for
this site. He stated that the food assembly area was becoming a primary use for the site. He asked
if the office space would be used for offices.
Community Development Director Hutmacher
discussed the proposed food assembly in detail
with the Council, noting that the applicant was proposing to complete food assembly for
wholesale as well as retail.
City Planner Streff
noted that the applicant did intend to use the office space for advertising,
marketing, and other typical office uses.
Councilmember Holden
City Planner Streff
reviewed the applicants request noting that the kitchen size had increased
slightly, the banquet hall has been removed, and the applicant is now requesting a 10-seat café
with retail.
Community Development Director Hutmacher
stated that the applicant is shifting her focus to
wholesale and catering for offsite events. This would require the Council to consider a narrowly
defined zoning amendment.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 31, 20144
Councilmember Holden
inquired how many semi-trucks would be making deliveries to this
property.
Ms. Behymer
, owner of Creative Catering and applicant, reported that a box truck would make
deliveries once daily at 2:00 a.m. Food deliveries would be made three times a week on Mondays,
Tuesdays, and Wednesdays between 6:00 and 8:00 a.m. She discussed the parking situation
onsite noting that she was unable to obtain parking easements from the surrounding properties.
She has negotiated parking contracts, which were deemed insufficient by the City Attorney.
Ms. Behymer
discussed the sidewalk issue noting that she is open to the idea of having a
sidewalk run along the front of the property. She reviewed two extra parking options that she has
available to her with E Street Flats and Bethel University.
Public Works Director Maurer
stated that if the sidewalk were to be placed adjacent to the curb
it would mean that no trees could be planted or lights installed in this area. In addition, it would
be impossible to keep the sidewalk free and clear of snow during the winter months without
hauling away the snow.
City Administrator Klaers
commented that the Council needed to determine if the proposed
land use fit into the long range plans for the B-2 District.
Councilmember Holden
questioned if the proposed site would meet the capacity needs for the
applicant.
Ms. Behymer
believed that her capacity needs would be met at the proposed site and that the box
truck pickup at 2:00 a.m. may increase in size if her business grows.
Councilmember Holden
asked if the additional 18,000 square feet of space could be used as a
kitchen for food assembly in the future.
City Planner Streff
indicated that the conditional use permit would allow for food production
however, conditions could be set in place to allow for a specific amount of square footage.
Ms. Behymer
commented that she would not need any more square footage for wholesale sales.
She further discussed her goals for the site along with how the and go sales would be
managed. It was noted that the café area would have seating for only 10 patrons due to parking
reasons.
Councilmember Holden
expressed concern with the how the semi-truck deliveries would affect
the adjacent properties.
Public Works Director Maurer
stated that semis made deliveries all over the metro area and had
to make tight maneuvers to complete these deliveries to food establishments. He anticipated that
this would not be a concern.
Mayor Grant
indicated that it was unfortunate this site did not have more parking.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 31, 20145
City Administrator Klaers
stated that because of the proposed use and parking limitation the
matter has been brought back to the Council for additional discussion. The site can only be used
by the applicant if an ordinance amendment is considered to allow this use in the B-2 District.
Without direction from Council, staff cannot recommend approval as an accessory use.
Kevin Peck
, Keller Williams Commercial Broker, discussed the issues he has had with trying to
sell the property. He noted that the large size and minimal parking is making it difficult to
repurpose.
Councilmember Holden
explained that she is torn on this request because she loves the
applicant if this is the right fit for the B-2 District. However, she
questioned what else this site could be used for.
Councilmember McClung
stated that he would not support this request. He stated that the
Council did not support the ambulance facility because it was deemed to not be the right fit for the
B-2 District. He indicated that the building should have never been built to its
current size given its location. He wanted to support this new business in Arden Hills, but at this
location it may create too many issues in the future.
Ms. Behymer
reported that the proposed use would have a retail/café component which would
align nicely with the businesses along County Road E and for the tenants in the E Street Flats.
Mayor Grant
stated that part of him supported the request if the front façade was improved to
more closely align with the B-2 District guidelines. The other part of him questioned if this use
would fit into the B-2 District long-term.
Councilmember Holmes
commented that if the Council did not move forward with this request,
the property would continue to sit vacant. She believed that this is a great idea and supported the
Councilmember Holden
stated that the retail/restaurant portion of the use fits into the B-2
District while the food assembly/industrial portion of the business does not.
Mayor Grant
wanted to see the sidewalk go through this site properly and not have it moved to
abut the curb.
Ms. Behymer
indicated that if the sidewalk is completed, she has additional parking options from
adjacent properties.
Mayor Grant
questioned how the Council wanted to proceed with this item.
Councilmember Holden
stated that she would support a conditional use permit.
Councilmember McClung
did not support an amendment change.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 31, 20146
Mayor Grant
explained that if this were to proceed, he would want to see the façade more closely
fit into the B-2 District. He questioned how the applicant would use the additional 18,000 square
feet of space.
Ms. Behymer
stated that she was uncertain at this time but commented that this site met all of her
other needs.
Councilmember Werner
was uncertain how this matter should proceed.
Councilmember Holmes
fully supported the request.
Councilmember McClung
would rather see a proposal for this site that would tear down the
building and replace it with something more fitting in the B-2 District.
Mayor Grant
questioned how many years Creative Catering has been in business and asked how
quickly the space would be open for business, if the matter were to proceed.
Ms. Behymer
reported that she has been in business for the past 10 years. She estimated that the
space would be operational in three to six months.
Mayor Grant
inquired how this item should proceed.
City Planner Streff
explaine
would be added to the B-2 District to allow for kitchen and food assembly through the conditional
use permit process. Staff would work with the City Attorney to draft this language. This matter
would then go before the Planning Commission and City Council.
Based on the consensus of Council, staff was directed to proceed with this item.
Mayor Grant
reiterated that this was not a final decision of the City Council but that there may
be enough support from the Council for the matter to proceed.
B.TCAAP Update
Community Development Director Hutmacher
commented that this was the first of the
sessions to discuss TCAAP matters. She provided the Council with a
schedule of special meetings that are planned for the coming months. She requested that the City
Council discuss and provide direction on the following topics.
Infrastructure Study. The City and Ramsey County are working together on a Request for
Proposals for an infrastructure study that will consider roadways, utilities, surface water
management, and grading. Ramsey County will be the lead agency for the contract which will
include analysis and preliminary design for the Spine Road and other infrastructure.
Metropolitan Council Sewer Access Charge (SAC) Fees. New development is required to pay a
sewer availability charge (SAC) to the Metropolitan Council. The fee amount is variable
depending on the projected volume being added to the metropolitan sewer system. The one-time
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 31, 20147
fee is used to pay regional sewer capital costs. When buildings are demolished, municipalities
may apply for SAC credits based on the previous use or the amount of SAC previously paid. The
City of Arden Hills has received SAC credits for buildings demolished on TCAAP, and City
Council direction on the use of SAC credits is requested.
Future Meeting Schedule. Future discussion topics for upcoming regular and special work session
meetings have been tentatively identified in the attached memo.
Public Works Director Maurer
provided the Council with a brief update on the Infrastructure
Study. He noted that the County was finalizing the RFP and it would be sent out later this week.
st
The hope would be to have proposals returned by May 1. The proposals would be reviewed by a
th
committee on May 5 and the committee wanted to have a decision for the Council to consider on
th
May 12. Staff discussed in further detail the items that would be included in the RFP.
Mayor Grant
requested further information on the timeline for the RFP.
Heather Worthington
, Ramsey County, discussed the proposed RFP timeline with the Council.
She did not believe the three week timeline was a concern.
City Administrator Klaers
questioned when the City would have more information on the cost
sharing.
th
Public Works Director Maurer
believed that the City would have this information by May 12.
He further discussed the utility items that would be covered by the City.
Councilmember Holmes
asked if the City had to cover 100% of the water, sanitary sewer and
private utility expenses.
Public Works Director Maurer
stated that the City would pay no expenses for private utilities.
The City would be responsible for 100% of the water and sanitary expenses. He noted that the
City and County have agreed to share costs for storm sewer and water resource issues. The cost
sharing for these would be further defined after the proposals were received.
Councilmember Holmes
questioned who would be paying for the spine road.
Public Works Director Maurer
noted that this expense would be fully covered by the County.
Councilmember Holden
inquired how the regional storm water feature would be defined.
Public Works Director Maurer
stated that this was a topic for an upcoming Council work
session on TCAAP.
Mayor Grant
recommended that the Council move onto a discussion regarding the SAC credits.
City Administrator Klaers
reviewed a memo he drafted regarding the SAC credits. He
of rates for these credits. He
anticipated it would take 10 to 15 years for the City to collect on these credits depending on how
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 31, 20148
quickly the TCAAP site developed. He explained that the Council needs to have a discussion on
how these funds will be used in the future. He indicated that the funds could be used to cover the
expenses for Kimley-Horn or to cover the expense for the water feature or for park development.
Another option would be for the Council to offer economic incentives to new businesses.
Councilmember Holden
asked how much the City would be receiving in SAC and WAC fees.
City Administrator Klaers
estimated that the City would receive $2,485 at the current Met
Council rate per unit. This equated to approximately $5,000,000 at full development. He
explained that City SAC and WAC fees generated would assist with covering the expense of the
City sewer and water utilities. He noted that Stacie Kvilvang, Ehlers and Associates, is working
on financial studies and models that would be reviewed by the Council at future meetings.
Councilmember Holden
questioned how much of the $5,000,000 would be left after the City
paid for the planning reports.
City Administrator Klaers
stated that about $500,000 would be needed for the Kimley-Horn
planning study. He further reported that trunk utilities would be assessed to the benefiting
property owners, likewise with a water tower if needed.
Councilmember Holden
did not want to see expenses for the property become too high that it did
not develop.
City Administrator Klaers
agreed that this is a concern for the Council to consider.
Mark Ruff
, Senior Financial Advisor at Ehlers & Associates, stated that the County engineering
staff has done some preliminary work on total expenses for this project. As the infrastructure RFP
moves forward, the City will be provided with additional information on the cost estimates.
Councilmember Holden
stated that she would have a difficult time offering incentives when Old
Snelling was in need of repair, and this was an issue that affected current taxpayers. She wanted
to be ensured that the City would break even on the TCAAP project.
Mr. Ruff
believed that the City did not have enough information at this time. It was his
expectation that the JDA was interested in creating a break even project. However, the real estate
market over the next five to ten years was uncertain.
City Administrator Klaers
stated that he anticipated that the project would be self-sufficient
from a City financial perspective.
Mr. Ruff
discussed how some companies were offered certain incentives in order to bring them to
communities.
City Administrator Klaers
stated that for this reason, he wanted the Council to have a discussion
on how the Met Council SAC credits would be administered in the future and to consider having a
policy in place.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MARCH 31, 20149
Mayor Grant
questioned where the County was getting incentive funds from.
Ms. Worthington
discussed the incentives the County was prepared to offer to potential
companies. She apologized for not having the specific numbers in front of her this evening. She
explained this was not public information and did not want to discuss this further until a decision
was made by the County board.
City Administrator Klaers
commented that the City wanted to work with the County to
encourage development.
Councilmember Holmes
the roadway to the north within the thumb.
Ms. Worthington
stated that this was pending negotiation and she was not prepared to discuss
this matter with the Council and was not comfortable discussing specific information at a public
meeting at this time.
Discussion ensued regarding the types of incentives that may be offered to potential businesses
moving into the area.
It was the consensus of the City Council to not charge City SAC and WAC fees and the Met
Council SAC fee (based on 30 units) for the currently proposed user of the thumb site.
ADJOURN
Mayor Grant adjourned the City Council work session at 10:40 p.m.
__________________________ __________________________
Amy Dietl David Grant
City Clerk Mayor
May 12, 2014
Honorable Mayor and City CouncilMembers
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
Sue Iverson, Director of Finance and Administrative Services, Ariel Schmitz,
Accounting Department
Claims & Payroll
2014 Payroll #10 ............................................................................... $ 108,984.14
Paid Claims (Check No 0 US Bank) ...................................................... $ 3,539.38
Paid Claims (Check No 43386-Check No 43412) ................................. $ 58,458.46
Paid Claims (Check No 43413-Check No 43448) ................................. $ 137,842.31
Page of
Payment Method
FIT8,466.65 EFT
SIT3,507.74 EFT
FICA Oasdi4,660.304,660.30 EFT
FICA Medicare1,089.921,089.92 EFT
Health Premium2,099.3914,501.56 A/P Check*
Dental Premium1,302.20 A/P Check*
FSA Health Care Reimb.238.33 A/P Check*
FSA Dependent Care Reimb.150.00 A/P Check*
HSA Health Saving 616.943,516.36
Health Care Savings Plan55.70 EFT
Health Care Savings Plan-2%304.91 EFT
Health Care Savings Plan-4%173.06 EFT
PERA4,177.124,845.48 EFT
ICMA3,732.81341.04 EFT
Central Pension Fund-Union614.40 A/P Check*
MN State Retirement System328.13 EFT
IUOE 49 Dues (Union)131.04 A/P Check*
LTD/STD Insurance1,285.23 A/P Check*
PERA Life Insurance32.00 A/P Check*
Life/Addl/Dep Life124.4599.90 A/P Check*
MN Child Support145.82 EFT
Public Employee Long Term Care 93.72 A/P Check*
UNUM 83.86 A/P Check*
AFLAC163.96 EFT
Avesis-Vision Care5.22 A/P Check*
Total Employee Deductions32,225.00
Net Payroll0.00 PR Check #
Direct Deposit45,033.65 EFT
Gross Payroll Tie-Out78,571.68
STD/LTD Gross - Up0.00
Plus City Paid Benefit30,412.46
ICMA Benefit Held0.00
Gross Payroll78,571.68
Less Total FSA2,487.72
Plus Employer Match ICMA0.00
Plus ICMA Benefit Held0.00
Net P/R Subject to FICA76,083.96
FICA Oasdi @ 6.20%4,660.30
FICA Medicare @ 1.45%1,089.92
Note: Federal and State Payroll Tax obligations are satisfied by means
of utilizing the "Taxtel" Electronic Tax Deposit Service. Trans-
fers are typically made two business days after the payroll date.
ACCOUNTS PAYABLE Check Approval
* A/P Checks can be found on the report.
Checks may be paid this week or the following week.
!"#$%&'&()*
=1*>#$('$?&"*$@$?*"&.)$('$=1*>$?&"*
+#*,-&,.*)0#12."3
%,.!"*/-$4565789:$$;-49$<
!"#$()*$+"#$()*$+"#&, !"%&' !"-,$.)'
/)0$1 "#$%4 +15'1$)23+)
=F8A87+B$CDE845895789:
8G8:789:@,H./#%&,>$B II).*#<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$9G08K
8G8:789:@L,./M&"*,$%#"&J*<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$G:09;
8G8:789:@N,&!"OJJ$F !"$B II).*#<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$4KG0;6
8G8:789:@F "2&P,&.!.!J@QF5RB<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$KA088
8G8:789:@SH*,#T $B*!/$S"<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$9:066
8G8:789:@SH*,#= !.)$R*",*&"<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$9U9460:9
8G8:789:@<!*'%M$B II).*#<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$G:;098
8G8:789:@<!*'%&,>$B II).*#<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$9G:046
8G8:789:@<!*'M&"*,$B II).*#<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$79G06G
8G8:789:@V)#!%&,>$&!/$R*$B II).*#<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$K9:088
8G8:789:@B1*,(=."'$F&))$B II).*#<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$G8047
8G8:789:@B1*,(P,&.!.!J@B1*,(*)<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$986088
8G8:789:@B1.W#%M$B II).*#<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$K70;7
8G8:789:@M.!>*)+!.W,2@?M<&,15I,.)$=1&,J*#$::0;;
P"&)$W,$"1.#$=F$=1*>$W,$X*!/,$8A87-$GU4G60G;
P"&)$W,$4595789:-$GU4G60G;
:GG;A8A88G94;88@D=%ORB$<.!!*#"&845875789:
8:779:@D=%I,.)$%R$?*/ ".!#I,.)$%R$?*/ ".!#$A:088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG;A-$A:088
:GG;K==P !"*2I#845875789:
:87:68;4I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**$490G8
:87:68;4I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**$:GG078
:87:68;4I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**$490G8
:87:68;4I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**$490G8
:87:68;4I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**$490G8
:87:68;4I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**$4G8098
:87:68;4I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**$490G8
:87:68;4I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**$4G8098
:87:68;4I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**I,.)$9;$=!",&"$L**$4G8098
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG;K-$7U7;8088
:GG;;977G/&2Y#$%*#"$=!",)U$S!0845875789:
;K:A;8I,.)$%*#"$=!",)I,.)$%*#"$=!",)$A704:
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG;;-$A704:
:GG;644K:))$%)#./*$B*,H.*#$S!0845875789:
8:7;9:@))%*,2."$R*W !/%*,2."$R*W !/$7690GG
8:7;9:@))%*,2."$R*W !/%*,2."$R*W !/$GK9084
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG;6-$AA70G;
%$=1*>#$('$?&"*$@$?*"&.)$('$=1*>$?&"*$Z4565789:$$;-49$<[%&J*$9
!"#$()*$+"#$()*$+"#&, !"%&' !"-,$.)'
/)0$1 "#$%4 +15'1$)23+)
:GG68446G2*,.&!$\*J&)$% ().#1.!J$=,I0845875789:
6;7A8!! &)$<*2(*,#1.I!! &)$<*2(*,#1.I$:64088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG68-$:64088
:GG699747=&2I(*))$E! "#!$@$"",!*'#$&"$\&]845875789:
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@R\R<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$747088
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@%=$9:@897<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$K8088
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@%=$9:@88G<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$7;8088
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@%=$9G@88G<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$798088
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@%=$9:@898<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$997088
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@P$^$P$M.,*)*##<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$474088
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@BI,.!"<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$7;088
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@B",**"#<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$G80;8
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@P=%<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$9:8088
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@N/].))$%=$9G@89K<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$7;8088
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@/2.!<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$4680A6
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@%=$99@89A<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$6A078
8GG9789:=E<&,1$\*J&)$L**#@%$^$_<&,1$\*J&)$L**#$9UKGK0;8
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG69-$:UG470:6
:GG67=%L9=*!",&)$%*!#.!$L !/845875789:
8:G89:@=%LI,.)$=!",.( ".!#I,.)$=!",.( ".!#$9U77;0;8
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG67-$9U77;0;8
:GG6G98GG=2&#"845875789:
8:999:@=2I,.)$PX$B*,H.*#I,.)$PX$B*,H.*#$;0:7
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG6G-$;0:7
:GG6:::K8N\P=$%,*2. 2$%&'2*!"#845875789:
9G;:6:9<&'$\!J$P*,2$=&,*<&'$\!J$P*,2$=&,*$9;K0::
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG6:-$9;K0::
:GG64S?SS/*&)$/H*,".#.!JU$S!845875789:
GA9:;R*$B II).*#R*$B II).*#$4K8088
GA9:;R*$B II).*#R*$B II).*#$94A088
GA79:R*$B II).*#R*$B II).*#$7U:G7088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG64-$GU94;088
:GG6A44;6S!/*I*!/*!"$VWW..&)#$##.&".!U$\\=0845875789:
97G6BW"(&))$L**BW"(&))$L**$7;A088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG6A-$7;A088
:GG6K;8;9E.2)*'@F,!$&!/$##.&"*#U$S!845875789:
4K8A9:4P=%$=1&,J*#P=%$=1&,J*#$KA90A:
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG6K-$KA90A:
:GG6;8777\*&J *$W$<.!!*#"&$=.".*#845875789:
96677G!! &)$=!W*,*!*@OM!! &)$=!W*,*!*@OM$G74088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG6;-$G74088
:GG668KK;<=LV845875789:
8:G89:@<=LV<*2(*,#1.I$? *#@?5BS<*2(*,#1.I$? *#@?5BS$K8088
%$=1*>#$('$?&"*$@$?*"&.)$('$=1*>$?&"*$Z4565789:$$;-49$<[%&J*$7
!"#$()*$+"#$()*$+"#&, !"%&' !"-,$.)'
/)0$1 "#$%4 +15'1$)23+)
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:GG66-$K8088
:G:8887A9<.!!*#"&$NLV845875789:
7668789:$? *#@C789:$? *#@C$A8088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:88-$A8088
:G:899776<PN845875789:
:;;44:=."'$F&))$R*I&.,#=."'$F&))$R*I&.,#$GU;9G06G
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:89-$GU;9G06G
:G:87A:::<*).##&$D,).!J845875789:
8:7:9:@<D?&!*$S!#", ".!?&!*$S!#", ".!$7U9:4088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:87-$7U9:4088
:G:8GDMLBD,"1]*#"$T "1$^$L&2.)'$B*,H.*#845875789:
8:G8789:@DTLBDTLBDTLB$748088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:8G-$748088
:G:8:K874V!$B."*$B&!."&".!845875789:
@4G:4A7I,.)$%&,>$L**#@F&3*)! "I,.)$%&,>$L**#$6076
@4G:4AGI,.)$%&,>$L**#@S!J*,#!I,.)$%&,>$L**#$6076
@4G:4A:I,.)$%&,>$L**#@L),&)I,.)$%&,>$L**#$6076
@4G:4A4I,.)$%&,>$L**#@R'&)$F.))#I,.)$%&,>$L**#$6076
@4G:4AAI,.)$%&,>$L**#@X&)*!".!*I,.)$%&,>$L**#$6076
@4G:4AKI,.)$%&,>$L**#@%*,,'I,.)$%&,>$L**#$9K0;A
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:8:-$A:0G9
:G:848;99R&2#*'$= !"'845875789:
O<=V<@88G7A9I,.)$699$?.#I&"1`9$%M$R*!"5I,.)$?.#I&"1$4U8760GA
%R<N@887764`9$%M$R*!"`9$%M$R*!"5I,.)$?.#I&"1$7:UA4:074
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:84-$76UA;G0A9
:G:8A4AG6B]&/&$&!/$C&,!&$%) 2(.!J845875789:
97:49=."'$F&))$R*I&.,#=."'$F&))$R*I&.,#$G6;04A
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:8A-$G6;04A
:G:8K8G7KB"&I)*#$C #.!*##$/H&!"&J*845875789:
GG7;98;;74VWW.*$B II).*#VWW.*$B II).*#$:K066
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:8K-$:K066
:G:8;9G88+!.L.,#"$=,I,&".!845875789:
868$8966;AKI,.)$<&"$B*,H.*#I,.)$<&"$B*,H.*#$AA0A8
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:8;-$AA0A8
:G:868K;6+!."*/$R*!"&)#$D,"1]*#"U$S!0845875789:
99;;77;8A@889%M$%&,"#%M$%&,"#$GG046
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:86-$GG046
:G:9899A9X&))*'@R.1$=0U$S!0845875789:
78889B&!."&,'$B*]*,$L,*2&.!$R*I&.,B&!."&,'$B*]*,$L,*2&.!$R*I&.,$AU6780A4
%$=1*>#$('$?&"*$@$?*"&.)$('$=1*>$?&"*$Z4565789:$$;-49$<[%&J*$G
!"#$()*$+"#$()*$+"#&, !"%&' !"-,$.)'
/)0$1 "#$%4 +15'1$)23+)
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:98-$AU6780A4
:G:9987;4a*)$O!*,J'845875789:
:8;K9K69AI,.)$N&"*]&'$B.J!I,.)$N&"*]&'$B.J!$970:G
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:99-$970:G
:G:97A886_.*J)*,U$S!0845875789:
BM84879A944X*1.)*$R*I&.,X*1.)*$R*I&.,$9U87808;
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:97-$9U87808;
P"&)$W,$4575789:-$4;U:4;0:A
=F8G;7S=<$R*".,*2*!"$P, #"$@$98A6::845865789:
%R$C&"1$887880840789:$S=<$O2I)'*,$%*,*!"$:89%R$C&"1$887880840789:$S=<$O2I)'*,$%*,*!"$:89$G:908:
%R$C&"1$887880840789:$S=<$O2I)'**$%*,*!"$:89%R$C&"1$887880840789:$S=<$O2I)'**$%*,*!"$:89$76:088
P"&)$W,$"1.#$=F$=1*>$W,$X*!/,$8G;7-$AG408:
=F8G;KS=<$R*".,*2*!"$P, #"@$bG87:;7845865789:
%R$C&"1$887880840789:$S=<$O2I)'**$?*/ ".!%R$C&"1$887880840789:$S=<$O2I)'**$?*/ ".!$7U;470K8
%R$C&"1$887880840789:$S=<$O2I)'**$%*,*!"%R$C&"1$887880840789:$S=<$O2I)'**$%*,*!"$4;A099
P"&)$W,$"1.#$=F$=1*>$W,$X*!/,$8G;K-$GU:G;0;9
=FG99KQ.))$F "2&1*,845865789:
84849:@QFQ&!@I,.)$<.)*&J*Q&!@I,.)$<.)*&J*$9:A0;A
P"&)$W,$"1.#$=F$=1*>$W,$X*!/,$G99K-$9:A0;A
=FD?OQQ1!$!/*,#!845865789:
84849:@Q<=B=$!! &)$<**".!J<.)*&J*$R*.2( ,#*2*!"$:A0GG
84849:@QR\R$%#"&J*<.)*&J*$R*.2( ,#*2*!"$90G9
84849:@QP=%<.)*&J*$R*.2( ,#*2*!"$970:G
84849:@QN%B$P,&.!.!J<.)*&J*$R*.2( ,#*2*!"$990G8
84849:@QPF98@6A<.)*&J*$R*.2( ,#*2*!"$K069
84849:@Q6A5G4M<.)*&J*$R*.2( ,#*2*!"$40A4
84849:@QR !/$\&>*$R&/<.)*&J*$R*.2( ,#*2*!"$990G8
P"&)$W,$"1.#$=F$=1*>$W,$X*!/,$D?OQ-$6A07G
=F8G;KS=<$R*".,*2*!"$P, #"@$bG87:;7845865789:
%R$C&"1$887890840789:$S=<$O2I)'**$%*,*!"%R$C&"1$887890840789:$S=<$O2I)'**$%*,*!"$G044
P"&)$W,$"1.#$=F$=1*>$W,$X*!/,$8G;K-$G044
:G:9G==P !"*2I#845865789:
:87;G;K:I,.)$74$=!",&"I,.)$74$=!",&"$G640G8
:87;G;K:I,.)$74$=!",&"I,.)$74$=!",&"$:A0;9
:87;G;K:I,.)$74$=!",&"I,.)$74$=!",&"$:;G0K7
:87;G;K:I,.)$74$=!",&"I,.)$74$=!",&"$:;G0K7
:87;G;K:I,.)$74$=!",&"I,.)$74$=!",&"$:A0;9
:87;G;K:I,.)$74$=!",&"I,.)$74$=!",&"$:;G0K7
:87;G;K:I,.)$74$=!",&"I,.)$74$=!",&"$:A0;9
:87;G;K:I,.)$74$=!",&"I,.)$74$=!",&"$:A0;9
:87;G;K:I,.)$74$=!",&"I,.)$74$=!",&"$:A0;8
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:9G-$7U8;8048
%$=1*>#$('$?&"*$@$?*"&.)$('$=1*>$?&"*$Z4565789:$$;-49$<[%&J*$:
!"#$()*$+"#$()*$+"#&, !"%&' !"-,$.)'
/)0$1 "#$%4 +15'1$)23+)
:G:9:\%S))*J,&$%,.!"$^$S2&J.!J845865789:
9:87G8I,.)$D*]#)*""*,I,.)$D*]#)*""*,$9U4KA08;
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:9:-$9U4KA08;
:G:9487;7)).*/$M&#"*$B*,H.*#$b;66845865789:
8;66@887:A6G;8I,.)$P,$B*,H.*I,.)$P,$B*,H.*$47604;
8;66@887:A6G;8I,.)$P,$B*,H.*I,.)$P,$B*,H.*$7A8076
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:94-$K;60;K
:G:9A4A4G!1,$%&I*,$=2I&!'845865789:
98G64G:4@88VWW.*$B II).*#VWW.*$B II).*#$9A7088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:9A-$9A7088
:G:9KA8:KH*#.#$P1.,/$%&,"'$/2.!.#",&",#U$S!845865789:
9:L4K99@SD<&'$X.#.!<&'$X.#.!$980::
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:9K-$980::
:G:9;8A4:C,&>*$^$Oc .I2*!"$M&,*1 #*U$S!0845865789:
9@7;K:A7%M$%&,"#$R*" ,!%M$%&,"#5R*" ,!@G6069
9@G8AG;9%M$%&,"#$X*1.)*$b:89%M$%&,"#5R*" ,!$9890G;
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:9;-$A90:K
:G:964AK7E,.#".!$C ,'845865789:
84849:@ECR*W !/@F.J1$B1)$< #.&)$=&2IR*W !/@F.J1$B1)$< #.&)$=&2I$AG088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:96-$AG088
:G:78=DVD=&!!$L.!&!.&)$B*,H.*#845865789:
9GK:44K9<&'$=I.*,$\*&#*<&'$=I.*,$\*&#*$;770;8
9GK:44K9<&'$=I.*,$\*&#*<&'$=I.*,$\*&#*$9:4078
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:78-$6A;088
:G:79=DV=&!!$B) ".!#$2*,.&845865789:
:897K77689=I.*,$<&.!"0=I.*,$<&.!"0$9U86G049
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:79-$9U86G049
:G:77876A=."'$W$,/*!$F.))#845865789:
84849:@%=I,.)$%*""'$=I,.)$%*""'$=$;A0K:
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:77-$;A0K:
:G:7G8G96=."'$W$R#*H.))*845865789:
879;G;9L*(, &,'$%1!*$C.))L*(, &,'$%1!*$C.))$:88088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:7G-$:88088
:G:7::;;6=22 !."'$L"],>#845865789:
848K789:<&'$K$L"$=).!.<&'$K$L"$=).!.$GAK078
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:7:-$GAK078
:G:748GG6L*,J #!$M&"*,],>#$749A845865789:
KK898%M$B II).*#%M$B II).*#$9A4088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:74-$9A4088
%$=1*>#$('$?&"*$@$?*"&.)$('$=1*>$?&"*$Z4565789:$$;-49$<[%&J*$4
!"#$()*$+"#$()*$+"#&, !"%&' !"-,$.)'
/)0$1 "#$%4 +15'1$)23+)
:G:7A89KAL,&""&))!*Y#$F&,/]&,*U$S!0845865789:
84;K:95%M$B II).*#%M$B II).*#$6076
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:7A-$6076
:G:7K8967N,&.!J*,U$S!845865789:
6:94K784A4%M$B II).*#%M$B II).*#$;;0;8
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:7K-$;;0;8
:G:7;8::KS0+0V0O$\&)$:6$C*!*W."$L !/@S!# ,&!*845865789:
848;9:@S+VO%M$C*!*W."#%M$C*!*W."#$;U86A088
848;9:@S+VO9%M$C*!*W."#%M$C*!*W."#$9U94K088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:7;-$6U74G088
:G:764AKG<&,J*$Q1!#!845865789:
84849:@<QR*W !/@C*J.!!.!J$=2I "*,$989R*W !/@C*J.!!.!J$=2I "*,$989$:4088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:76-$:4088
:G:G8869A\&>*#$= !",'$B*,H.*$=I845865789:
=98KG@F$6Q !*$S!# ,&!*Q !*$S!# ,&!*$GU878048
=98KG@FC$KQ !*$S!# ,&!*Q !*$S!# ,&!*$7UKKA048
=98KG@FO$9Q !*$S!# ,&!*Q !*$S!# ,&!*$GU87;088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:G8-$;U;74088
:G:G94A9;<*'*,$O!"*,I,.#*#845865789:
946:;X*1.)*$b:89$R*I&.,X*1.)*$b:89$R*I&.,$964088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:G9-$964088
:G:G78KG9<S?MT$LVR?845865789:
967A88X*1.)*$b78G$%&,"#X*1.)*$b78G$%&,"#$G409G
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:G7-$G409G
:G:GG::A8<.!!*#"&$C&""*,'$\\=845865789:
99K68X*1.)*$%&,"#$b:89X*1.)*$%&,"#$b:89$9K;088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:GG-$9K;088
:G:G:8778<.!!*#"&$?*I"0$W$\&(,$^$S!/ #",'845865789:
848;789:@?V\C .)/.!J$%*,2."$B ,1&,J*#C .)/.!J$%*,2."$B ,1&,J*#$9U97A0;7
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:G:-$9U97A0;7
:G:G487AA<.!!*#"&$R*,*&".!$^$%&,>$##!0845865789:
84849:@<R%+BBB$=*,".W.&".!$L**#+BBB$=*,".W.&".!$L**#$A86088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:G4-$A86088
:G:GA77K6D,2#$P.,*$B&)*#U$S!0845865789:
7;:GG6X*1.)*$b:89$%&,"#X*1.)*$b:89$%&,"#$;460:8
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:GA-$;460:8
:G:GK8677D,"1$B ( ,(&!$*##$=,I,&".!845865789:
9:@4;6I,.)$= !.)$=&()*$B*,H.*#I,.)$= !.)$=&()*$B*,H.*#$74K0:8
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:GK-$74K0:8
%$=1*>#$('$?&"*$@$?*"&.)$('$=1*>$?&"*$Z4565789:$$;-49$<[%&J*$A
!"#$()*$+"#$()*$+"#&, !"%&' !"-,$.)'
/)0$1 "#$%4 +15'1$)23+)
:G:G;AG:6<&,'$D#*>845865789:
89:@88;<&'$F$D"*#<&'$F$D"*#$978088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:G;-$978088
:G:G6K874V!$B."*$B&!."&".!845865789:
@4G:;;;<&'$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)@L),&)$%&,><&'$%&,>#$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)$47088
@4G:;;6<&'$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)@F&3*)! "$%&,><&'$%&,>#$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)$47088
@4G:;68<&'$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)@%*,,'$%&,><&'$%&,>#$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)$988088
@4G:;69<&'$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)@R'&)$F.))#$%&,><&'$%&,>#$B&!."&".!$R*!"&$47088
@4G:;67<&'$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)@X&)*!".!*$%&,><&'$%&,>#$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)$47088
@4G48:8<&'$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)@= 22.!J#$%&,><&'$%&,>#$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)$AA0;A
@4G47;A<&'$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)@S!J*,#!$%&,><&'$%&,>#$B&!."&".!$R*!"&)$47088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:G6-$:7A0;A
:G::8;8G7%&*$!&)'".&)$L.*)/$BH845865789:
979:8G44<&,1$M&"*,$P*#".!J$L**#<&,1$M&"*,$P*#".!J$L**#$K74048
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G::8-$K74048
:G::99998%."!*'$C]*#845865789:
848;9:@%."<&,1$%#"&J*<&,1$%#"&J*$7UA940G4
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G::9-$7UA940G4
:G::78;99R&2#*'$= !"'845865789:
BFRL\@889G9A<&'$B1*,.WW<&'$B1*,.WW$;AU:7807:
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G::7-$;AU:7807:
:G::G44KAB1.!/)*,$O)*H&",$=,I0845865789:
;98GKG88;;789:$O)*H&",$<&.!"0789:$O)*H&",$<&.!"0$69;0:;
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G::G-$69;0:;
:G:::8K49B1,"$O)).""$F*!/,.>#!U$S!0845865789:
7;8G;8P$^$P$= 22.!J#$%&,>$O#,]$L**#P$^$P$= 22.!J#$%&,>$O#,]$L**#$7U9970AA
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G:::-$7U9970AA
:G::4G4G4B]**I*,$B*,H.*#845865789:
9:888B",**"$B]**I*,$R*I&.,B",**"$B]**I*,$R*I&.,$7U9A8088
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G::4-$7U9A8088
:G::A8GGAP00$B1.W>#'$^$B!#U$S!0845865789:
4AGG8#I1&)"#I1&)"$48604;
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G::A-$48604;
:G::K84KAP.2*B&H*,$VWW$B."*$B*,*"&,.&)845865789:
<78:K;==$M,>#1I5P=%==$M,>#1I5P=%$7940AK
<78:K;==$M,>#1I5P=%==$M,>#1I5P=%$98K0;G
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G::K-$G7G048
:G::;87;4a*)$O!*,J'845865789:
:86K86;;9I,.)$+".)."'$C.))I,.)$+".)."'$C.))$7U8K70A7
:98:9496KI,.)$+".)."'$C.))I,.)$+".)."'$C.))$9U7A:0;7
:98:9496KI,.)$+".)."'$C.))I,.)$+".)."'$C.))$9U8K4087
:98:9496KI,.)$+".)."'$C.))I,.)$+".)."'$C.))$9U69G0A;
%$=1*>#$('$?&"*$@$?*"&.)$('$=1*>$?&"*$Z4565789:$$;-49$<[%&J*$K
!"#$()*$+"#$()*$+"#&, !"%&' !"-,$.)'
/)0$1 "#$%4 +15'1$)23+)
:98:9496KI,.)$+".)."'$C.))I,.)$+".)."'$C.))$9UG7K049
:98:9496KI,.)$+".)."'$C.))I,.)$+".)."'$C.))$7G80G4
P"&)$W,$=1*>$D 2(*,$:G::;-$KU;;:088
P"&)$W,$4565789:-$9GKU;:70G9
R*I,"$P"&)$ZA6$1*>#[-$966U;:8094
%$=1*>#$('$?&"*$@$?*"&.)$('$=1*>$?&"*$Z4565789:$$;-49$<[%&J*$;
CONSENT ITEM 5B
MEMORANDUM
DATE:May 12, 2014
TO:Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM: Terry Maurer, Public Works Director
SUBJECT:National Public Works Week: May 18-28, 2014
Requested Action
Adoption of Resolution 2014-022 Recognizing National Public Works Week: May 18-
24, 2014.
Discussion
National Public Works Week is May 18-24, 2014. This is an opportunity to recognize
the efforts put forth by our Public Works staff in maintaining the City infrastructure
consisting of sanitary sewer, water, storm sewer, streets, trails, parks and public
buildings. The daily efforts by these dedicated employees enhance the health, safety and
quality of life for all our residents.
The Public Works staff is made up of the following employees together with their years
of service to the City of Arden Hills:
Joe Mooney, Superintendent 28 Years
Dave Winkel 36 Years
Mike Schifsky 34 Years
Scott Freyberger 15 Years
Tony Nowlan 8 Years
Jeff Frid 8 Years
Max Arvidson 4 Years
Thomas Mikacevich 3 Year
Darien Schifsky 1 Year
Attachment
Attachment A: Resolution 2014-022
Page 1 of 1
ATTACHMENT A
CITY OF ARDEN HILLS
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RESOLUTION NO. 2014-022
RESOLUTION RECOGNIZING NATIONAL PUBLIC WORKS WEEK:
MAY 18-24, 2014
WHEREAS,
public works services provided in our community are an integral part of our
citizens everyday lives; and
WHEREAS,
the support of an understanding and informed citizenry is vital to the efficient
operations of public works systems and programs such as water, sewers, streets, parks, trails, and
public buildings; and
WHEREAS,
the health, safety and comfort of Arden Hills greatly depend on these facilities
and services; and
WHEREAS,
the efficiency of the qualified and dedicated personnel who staff the Public
Works Department titude and understanding of the
importance of the work they perform.
THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED
by the City Council of the City of Arden Hills,
Minnesota that the City proclaims the week of May 18-24 s the
City of Arden Hills. All citizens and civic organizations are called upon to recognize the
contributions which the Public Works Department makes every day to our health, safety, comfort,
and quality of life.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARDEN HILLS THIS
12th DAY OF MAY, 2014.
________________________________
David Grant, Mayor
ATTEST:
__________________________________
Amy Dietl, City Clerk
CONSENT ITEM 5C
MEMORANDUM
DATE: May 12, 2014
TO: Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM: John Anderson, Assistant City Engineer
SUBJECT: Site Use Lease Agreement with Nextel West fka Sprint
Requested Action
Approve the Site Use Lease Agreement with Nextel West Corporation for the lease of City
property located at 1230 Red Fox Road.
Background/Discussion
Prior to February 2010, d water
the Nextel lease. At this time, Sprint has proposed modifications to its equipment and number of
antenna at the Red Fox water tower. The modifications are beyond what is allowed under the
terms of the current lease which expires in 2020.
As wireless contracts expire, or providers ask to make changes inconsistent with current lease
agreements, the City would like to make the terms of the agreements more consistent for easier
administration of the contracts. Also, the City would like to increase lease rates to be more
reflective of the current market.
SEH provided a master form of a wireless site lease agreement which is based on
recommendations from the League of Minnesota Cities. Staff and the City Attorney negotiated
the lease agreement with Sprint. Sprint has approved the new lease agreement and would like to
move forward with their upgrade project.
The City currently has wireless contracts with Sprint/Nextel, T-Mobile, and TTM at the Red Fox
water tower. The City has contracts with AT&T, T-Mobile, and Zayo at the Cummings Park
water tower. Neither TTM nor Zayo have equipment on the tower which is reflected in their
lower lease rates. A summshown in the following
13
Page of
table. Each wireless contract has different terms. The older contracts have lease rates that are
significantly below the current market.
2014 Arden Hills Cell Lease Information for City Water Towers
Company
2014 Rate Increase Contract
Location
Next Approved
Monthly Yearly Rate Frequency Increase / Revised Expires
Paid
Nextel/Sprint Yearly $33,000.00 4% Yearly 2015 1995/2014 2039 Red Fox
Paid
AT&T/Cingular Yearly $33,000.00 4% Yearly 2015 1989/2014 2039 Cummings
Every 5
T-Mobile 1 $1,322.50 $15,870.00 15% years 2016 2000 2025 Red Fox
Paid
T-Mobile 2 Yearly $20,866.93 3% Yearly 2014 2008 2028 Cummings
Paid
TTM Yearly $3,130.04 3% Yearly 2014 2009 2030 Red Fox
Paid
Zayo Yearly $5,304.50 3% Yearly 2014 2011 2041 Cummings
Updated: 4/22/2014 shows anticipated lease terms
Terms of the Site Lease Agreement
Key terms of the new site lease agreement are as follows:
Lease Rate The Tenant will pay a lease rate of $33,000 per year. No additional rent per year per
antenna will be charged. Rent shall be increased by 4% annually.
Sprint currently has nine antennas installed on the Red Fox water tower. As part of the first
phase of their upgrade project, Sprint proposes to add three antennas. During the second phase
of the project, Sprint will remove three of the currently existing antennas. The terms of the lease
allow Sprint to have a maximum of 12 antennas on the tower.
Site Restoration Escrow. The Tenant will provide an escrow of $5,000 that will be refunded to
the Tenant following the timely removal of all equipment from City property at the termination
or expiration of the lease.
Administrative Fee. The tenant agrees to pay the City for its legal and administrative expenses
associated with this site lease agreement. The Tenant will also pay the
inspections, engineering consulting, and installation project management related to this
agreement.
Lease Term. The initial term of this lease agreement is five years. The lease will automatically
extend for five additional five-year periods. If the tenant chooses not to renew the lease, it must
send a written notice to the City within 90 days of the expiration date of the initial term or any
renewal term
23
Page of
Operation.
tenant at its cost within 30 days of notification of damage.
Repainting and Restoration. The tenant shall temporarily remove its equipment at its cost to
Insurance.
compensation, general liability, automobile liability, and tenant property insurance.
Termination. The lease may be terminated with 60 days written notice by either the tenant or the
landlord provided that the party requesting termination meets conditions for default, inability to
obtain a license/permit, technological reasons, City Council decision, etc., as defined in the lease
agreement.
The City Attorney has reviewed the terms of this lease agreement and recommends City Council
approval.
Attachments
Site Use Lease Agreement
33
Page of
Attachment A
5D
CONSENT ITEM
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
May 12, 2014
TO:
Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM:
Amy Dietl, City Clerk
SUBJECT:
Approve November 19, 2007, Work Session Minutes
Background/Discussion
Staffhasbeenactivelyworkingoncleaningfilesthatareinstorageinthebasement.Indoingso,
asetofunsignedworksessionminutesfromNovember19,2007,wasfound.Itappearsas
thoughtheseminuteswereneverbroughttotheCityCouncilforapprovalandassuchwere
never signed.
Asahousekeepingitem,staffrequeststhattheCityCouncilapprovetheseminutessotheycan
be scanned into Laserfiche for permanent retention.
ItshouldbenotedthatallmembersofthecurrentCityCouncilwereservingin2007,exceptfor
Councilmember Ed Werner.
Requested Action
Approve work session minutes from November 19, 2007.
Attachment
Attachment A: Draft November 19, 2007 Work Session Minutes
11
Page of
Attachment A
Approved:
CITY OF ARDEN HILLS, MINNESOTA
CITY COUNCIL WORKSESSION
NOVEMBER 19, 2007; 5:00 PM
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
1. CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL
Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, Councilmember Grant called to order the City
Council Worksession meeting at 5:10 p.m.
Present:
Mayor Stan Harpstead (arrived at 6:47 p.m.), Councilmembers David
Grant, Brenda Holden (arrived at 5:20 p.m.), Fran Holmes, and David
McClung .
Absent:
None.
Also Present:
City Administrator, Michelle Wolfe; Assistant City Administrator, Noah
Simon; Public Works Director, Gregory Hoag; Finance Director, Susan Iverson; City
Planner, James Lehnhoff; Parks and Recreation Manager, Michelle Olson; Building
Official, Dave Scherbel; City Engineer, Kris Giga; and Recording Secretary Dianna Wise.
2. APPROVAL OF MEETING AGENDA
MOTION:
Councilmember McClung moved and Councilmember Holmes seconded a
motion to approve the meeting agenda as presented. The motion carried
(3-0).
3. AGENDA ITEMS
A.2008 Proposed Budget
City Administrator Wolfe stated she would like discussion on the proposed budget. She
stated staff attempted to capture the key points, which includes the budget as presented
with the goal of using the preliminary levy of 4.95 percent.
Finance Director Iverson explained how she determined the 4.95 percent.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION November 19, 20072
McClung questioned whether the market value is being phased out and coming into the
Finance Director Iverson replied that was not correct.
indfall is at.
Finance Director Iverson showed the limited market value and the impact to the taxpayer
and the local tax rate. She pointed out line number seven of the tax impact worksheet.
Councilmember Grant questioned whether line item five was correct.
Finance Director Iverson replied that was the local portion of the levy last year. She
explained which number was certified to the County.
City Administrator Wolfe stated staff always based the levy discussion on the local
portion as the City controls it.
Councilmember Holden questioned how 3.2 percent for the market value was derived at.
Finance Director Iverson commented this is the average for Arden Hills as reported by the
County; individual taxes could vary widely.
Public Works Director Hoag commented that some of the parks maintenance is a result of
Park staff salary adjustments.
Councilmember Holden asked what the percentage of benefits are based on salary.
Finance Director Iverson stated she has never added it up to determine this. She directed
Council to page 23 and pointed out the numbers. She commented she would email this
information to Councilmembers.
Councilmembers reviewed each chapter and asked for clarification on line items within
the 2008 Budget. City Administrator, Finance Director Iverson, and Assistant City
Administrator Simon made note of changes and requests.
City Administrator Wolfe informed Council that the 2008 Budget is based on a general
tax levy increase of 4.95 percent. She requested discussion on several key items:
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION November 19, 20073
Contingency Amount
Consensus reached by Council to approve a $25,000 contingency.
Consensus reached by Council to approve a 4.6 percent in the general levy.
Deputy City Clerk Position
City Administrator Wolfe stated that the Deputy City Clerk position would take on
specific functions from every department. She stated the major drivers for this position
are to better allocate resources and workload. She stated this is a benchmark position;
therefore, it would be easy to determine a salary. She commented this position is
traditionally more stable and would reduce the impact of turnover.
Mayor Harpstead recommended this position be filled before the next elections.
Consensus reached by Council to take this to the next step.
New Equipment, Building, and Replacement Fund
City Administrator Wolfe recommended establishing a New Equipment, Building, and
Replacement Fund and depositing $500,000 into it.
Consensus reached by Council to set up this fund and deposit $500,000 into it to be used
for City Hall building repairs only at this time.
$6,200 for Membership on the I-35W Corridor Coalition
Consensus reached by Council to eliminate membership in the coalition at this time.
Proposed Part-Time Economic Development Assistant
Fence for South Water Tower
Public Works Director Hoag commented that the original fence was estimated at $24,000;
however, he hopes it could be built for much less. City Administrator Wolfe commented
that the fence might not be required and could be eliminated from the budget given
further research.
Northwest Youth and Family Services Contributions
Consensus reached by Council to purchase a table at their fundraiser for $1,000 and to
make up a shortfall of up to $4,000.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION November 19, 20074
$35,000 Consultant Fee for Design of the County Road E business district
Consensus reached by Council to fund $35,000 for a consultant to assist the City with
design preparation of the County Road E business district.
B.2008-212 proposed CIP
City Administrator Wolfe stated the 2008 CIP Budget is critical at this point. She made
note of the changes and recommendations by Council.
Consensus reached by Council to direct staff to build a concept plan and study in 2008
with implementation planned for 2009 for the CP Rail Bridge, Old Highway 10 Sidewalk
Improvement project.
Consensus reached by Council to discuss the Capital Improvement Plan again in
December 2007.
C.2008 Proposed Compensation Plan/Pay Equity
Councilmember Grant summarized the meeting with the consultant and reported they
decided to base the pay rates on the 55 percentile and to remove Shoreview from the
equation. He explained they looked at implementing symmetry within pay grades.
Councilmember Grant presented the revised Compensation Plan/Pay Equity Plan.
City Administrator Wolfe pointed out the information is based on 2007 data.
Consensus reached by Council that they are in agreement with the assumptions.
Consensus reached by Council to move in the direction of the revised Compensation
Plan/Pay Equity Plan and to direct staff to prepare the new plan for implementation on
December 1, 2007 and a 3% COLA adjustment for 2008.
4. COUNCIL COMMENTS AND REQUESTS
Mayor Harpstead presented the issue of donating $500 to the Lake Johanna Association
to eliminate the geese population at Lake Johanna.
Consensus reached by Council to not donate $500 to the Lake Johanna Association to
eliminate the geese population at Lake Johanna at this time. Council directed staff to find
the information presented earlier this year.
Councilmember Grant questioned whether staff received information about the Holiday
Inn.
City Administrator Wolfe stated she had not heard any definite news.
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION November 19, 20075
Public Works Director Hoag commented the domestic water is shut off.
Councilmember Grant tasked Assistant City Administrator Simon to correct the
instructions directing visitors to enter City Hall via the east door rather than the west.
Councilmember Grant questioned who owned the Chatham area relative to tree removal.
Councilmember McClung requested 15 minutes of discussion time at the December 2007
work session to talk about parking during the election.
Councilmember McClung mentioned a moratorium for County Road E on November 26,
2007.
Consensus reached by Council to direct staff to prepare an agenda item to implement a
moratorium on County Road E on November 26, 2007.
Consensus reached to send Christmas cards this year.
5.ADJOURNMENT
MOTION:
Mayor Harpstead moved and Councilmember Holmes seconded a motion
to adjourn the meeting at 10:04 p.m. The motion carried (5-0).
__________________________ __________________________
Stan Harpstead Michelle Wolfe
Mayor City Administrator
CONSENT ITEM 5E
MEMORANDUM
DATE: May 12, 2014
TO: Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM: Sue Iverson, Director of Finance and Administrative Services
SUBJECT: 2014 Capital Reimbursement to Lake Johanna Fire Department
Budgeted Amount: Actual Amount: Funding Sources:
$9,472$9,472Public Safety Capital
Requested Action
Motion to approve a payment in the amount of $9,472 to the Lake Johanna Fire Department,
which is share for reimbursement of Breathing Air Compressor for Station 2.
Background
The City has received an invoice from the Lake Johanna Fire Department (LJFD) for capital
expenditures in 2014 (Attachment A). This invoice relates to capital expenditures which were
included and approved in the 2014 budget.
These projects were originally budgeted at $37,000 of which Arden Hills budgeted costs were
$9,472. The actual amount of the total purchase is more than budgeted, however the City is only
being charged the amount that was included in the budget according to the LJFD. The Fire
Board has approved this purchase.
Attachments
Attachment A Invoice #470 from Lake Johanna Fire Department, Inc.
11
Page of
Attachment A
CONSENT ITEM 5F
MEMORANDUM
DATE: May 12, 2014
TO: Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM: Sue Iverson, Director of Finance and Administrative Services
SUBJECT: 2014 Capital Reimbursement to Lake Johanna Fire Department
Budgeted Amount: Actual Amount: Funding Sources:
$
$016,838.94Public Safety Capital
Requested Action
Motion to approve a payment in the amount of $16,838.94 to the Lake Johanna Fire Department,
which is share for reimbursement of SCBA (Self-Contained Breathing Apparatus).
Background
The City has received an invoice from the Lake Johanna Fire Department (LJFD) for capital
expenditures in 2014 (Attachment A). This invoice relates to capital expenditures in which the
Fire Department applied and was awarded a FEMA grant. The grant covered 90% of the
equipment that was qualified with the Cities making up the difference. The total Grant received
was $300,234.11 the Cities share of the qualified equipment was $33,359.35 making Arden
The additional equipment that was not covered by the grant was $34,060.91 of which Arden
298.94. The Fire Board has approved this purchase and grant application.
Attachments
Attachment A Invoice #471 from Lake Johanna Fire Department, Inc.
11
Page of
7A
PUBLIC HEARING
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
May 12, 2014
TO:
City Councilmembers
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM:
Mayor Grant
SUBJECT:
TCAAP Development Discussion Opportunity for Residents
Discussion
UnderthisPublicHearing,citizenshaveanopportunitytodiscussideasregardingTCAAP
development.
PUBLIC HEARINGS 7B
MEMORANDUM
DATE: May 12, 2014
TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council members
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM: John Anderson, Assistant City Engineer
SUBJECT: Round Lake Road Area Improvements
Budgeted Amount Actual Amount Funding Source
$2,627,650.00 $2,485,247.71 MSA, Excess TIF,
Assessments, Water
Utility, Surface Water
Funds, PIR
Requested Action
The City Council is requested to approve the following:
1.Hold Assessment Hearing
2.Adopt Resolution 2014-027 Adopting Assessment Roll for the Round Lake Road Area
Improvement (this can be adopted with any changes the Council deems appropriate)
3.Adopt Resolution 2014-028 Awarding the Round Lake Road Area Improvement to
Meyer Contracting, Inc., in the amount of $1,766,605.41
Discussion
On January 27, 2014, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 2014-011 Approving the Plans
and Specifications and Ordering the Advertisement for Bids. Bids were solicited during
March/April and opened on Thursday, April17, 2014.
A portion of the costs for the Round Lake Road Area project are proposed to be assessed against
costs, the City must follow the process outlined in State Statute 429. On April 28, 2014, after the
bids were opened, the City Council adopted Resolution 2014-023 Declaring the Amount of the
Cost to be Assessed and set today as the date for the assessment hearing. A public hearing prior
to adopting the assessments is a requirement of State Statute 429.
13
Page of
practices, which states that 70% of the costs for roadway improvements will be assessed in
commercial/industrial areas, with the remaining portion financed by City funds. Financing for
the project is consistent with City policy and past practices and is summarized in the table below.
The project costs include engineering and overhead costs as outlined in the Assessment Policy.
Funding
Funding
Construction Overhead Total
Construction Overhead Total
Source
Source
Street $1,211,778 $448,358 $1,660,136
Street $1,211,778 $448,358 $1,660,136
Storm Sewer $276,370 $74,619 $350,989
Storm Sewer $276,370 $74,619 $350,989
Water $278,457 $75,183 $353,640
Water $278,457 $75,183 $353,640
Lighting $120,481 N/A $120,481
Lighting $120,481 N/A $120,481
Total $1,887,086 $598,160 $2,485,246
Total $1,887,086 $598,160 $2,485,246
The calculation of the amount to be assessed as approved by Council Resolution 2014-023 and is
shown below. Also, the Council established that the interest rate would be 4.60% and the term
would be ten years.
Item Calculation Result
70% of street
$1,211,778 *0.7 $848,244
construction
Add 37%
$848,244 x 1.37 $1,162,095
Overhead
45% of Storm
$276,370*0.45 $124,366
construction
Add 27%
$124,366 x 1.27 $157,945
Overhead
Total Assessable $1,162,095 + $157,945 $1,320,040
Assessment Rate 1,320,040 / 6,902.13 $191.25
The full detailed assessment notice as mailed to each of the property owners is attached.
On Thursday, May 8, 2014, staff received a formal objection from the property at 1777 Gateway
Boulevard, Arden Towers, Inc. A copy of the objection is attached. This is the parcel at the east
end of Gateway Boulevard that contains a communication tower. In fact, Arden Towers, Inc.
owns two adjacent lots in this area; one vacant and the one with the tower. Since all developed
lots are proposed to be assessed with this project and vacant parcels were not, staff included the
parcel with the tower in the assessment but not the vacant Arden Towers parcel. Staff will be
looking for direction regarding the formal objection for the parcel at 1777 Gateway Boulevard.
Any additional written objections received prior to Monday evening will be provided to the City
Council at the assessment hearing.
23
Page of
As provided for in State Statute, no appeal may be taken as to the amount of any assessment
adopted unless a written objection signed by the affected property owner is filed with the City at
or prior to the assessment hearing. After the adoption of the assessment roll, property owners
who have submitted an objection in writing have 30 days to serve notice of an appeal to the City,
and within 10 days after serving notice to file with the District Court.
Bid Results
Bids were opened Thursday Aril 17, 2014. There were a total of eight bids received. The bids
ranged from $1,766,605.41 to $2,073,963.39
and their total bid:
Meyer Contracting, Inc. $1,766,605.41
Valley Paving, Inc. 1,826,883.05
Northwest Asphalt 1,881,398.19
Forest Lake Contracting, Inc. 1,882,203.00
North Valley Inc. 1,929,408.71
Carl Bolander & Sons, Co. 1,931,081.20
T.A. Schifsky and Sons, Inc. 2,045,093.60
ASTECH, Corp. 2,073,963.39
The lowest bid was submitted by Meyer Contracting, Inc., who has not worked for Arden Hills
in the past however they were a subcontractor on the I-694 project and did work on some of the
City utilities with that project. Elfering and Associates has contacted references relative to Meyer
Contracting, Inc. performance on other similar projects and found their references to be good.
Attached is a letter from Elfering and Associates summarizing their findings from the reference
checks.
Recommendation
The Council should hold the Assessment Hearing first. Staff is prepared to make a presentation
summarizing the project and the assessment process. After the Assessment Hearing is closed
Council should consider adopting Resolution 2014-027 Adopting the Assessment Roll for the
Round Lake Road Area Improvement with any changes they deem appropriate. Following that,
Council should consider adopting Resolution 2014-028 Awarding the Contract for the Round
Lake Road Area Improvement to Meyer Contracting, Inc., in the amount of $1,766,605.41.
Attachments
Attachment A: Assessment Area Map
Attachment B: Assessment Roll
Attachment C: 1777 Gateway Boulevard Formal Objection
Attachment D: Elfering and Associates Letter
Attachment E: Resolution 2014-027 Adopting the Assessment Roll for the Round Lake Road
Area Improvement
Attachment F: Resolution 2014-028 Awarding the Contract for the Round Lake Road Area
Improvement
33
Page of
ATTACHMENT A
ATTACHMENT B
ATTACHMENT C
ATTACHMENT D
ATTACHMENT E
CITY OF ARDEN HILLS
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RESOLUTION NO. 2014-027
RESOLUTION ADOPTING SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR THE ROUND
LAKE ROAD AREA IMPROVEMENT
WHEREAS
, pursuant to proper notice duly given as required by law, the City
Council has met and heard and passed upon all objections to the proposed assessment for the
improvement of the City of Arden Hills Round Lake Road Area.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF
ARDEN HILLS, MINNESOTA
:
1. Such proposed assessment roll, a copy of which is attached hereto and made a part hereof,
is hereby accepted and shall constitute the special assessment against the lands named
therein, and each tract of land therein included is hereby found to be benefited by the
proposed improvement in the amount of the assessment levied against it.
2. Such assessment assessed against each parcel of land shall be payable in equal annual
installments extending over a period of ten (10) years, unless prepaid, the first of the
installments to be payable with general taxes levied in 2014, collectible with such taxes
during the year of 2015. The assessment shall bear interest at the rate of 4.60 percent per
annum from the date of the adoption of this assessment resolution. To the first installment
shall be added interest on the entire assessment from the date of this resolution until
December 31, 2014. To each subsequent installment when due shall be added interest for
one year on all unpaid installments.
3. If the adopted assessment differs from the proposed assessment as to any particular lot,
piece, or parcel of land, the City Administrator shall mail to the owner a notice stating the
amount of the adopted assessment. The administrator must also notify affected owners of
any changes adopted by the Council in interest rates or prepayment requirements from those
contained in the notice of the proposed assessment.
4. The owner of any property so assessed may, at any time prior to certification of the
assessment to the county auditor, pay the whole of the assessment on such property, with
interest accrued to the date of payment, to the City Administrator, except that no interest
shall be charged if the entire assessment is paid by June 11, 2014. The owner may at any
time thereafter, pay to the County Auditor the entire amount of the assessment remaining
unpaid, with interest accrued to December 31 of the year in which such payment is made.
Such payment must be made before November 15 or interest will be charged through
December 31 of the succeeding year.
5. The City Administrator shall forthwith prepare and transmit a certified duplicate of this
assessment to the County Auditor to be extended on the property tax lists of the county.
Such assessments shall be collected and paid over in the same manner as other municipal
taxes.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARDEN HILLS
THIS 12th DAY OF MAY, 2014.
_____________________________
David Grant, Mayor
ATTEST:
_______________________________________
Amy Dietl, City Clerk
ATTACHMENT F
CITY OF ARDEN HILLS
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RESOLUTION NO. 2014-028
A RESOLUTION AWARDING THE ROUND LAKE ROAD
AREA IMPROVEMENT
WHEREAS,
pursuant to advertisement for bids for the construction of the City of Arden
Hills Round Lake Road Area Improvement.
AND WHEREAS
, it appears that Meyer Contracting, Inc., of Maple Grove, Minnesota,
is the lowest responsible bidder at the tabulated price of $1,766,605.41;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF ARDEN
HILLS, MINNESOTA
:
1.The Mayor and City Administrator are hereby authorized and directed to enter into a
contract with Meyer Contracting, Inc., for $1,766,605.41 in the name of the City of
Arden Hills for the above improvements according to the plans and specifications thereof
heretofore approved by the City Council and on file in the office of the City Clerk.
2.The City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to return forthwith to all bidders the
deposits made with their bids, except that the deposits of the successful bidder and the
next lowest bidder shall be retained until contracts have been signed.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ARDEN HILLS THIS 12th
DAY OF MAY, 2014.
____________________________________
David Grant, Mayor
ATTEST:
_______________________________________
Amy Dietl, City Clerk
NEW BUSINESS 8A
MEMORANDUM
DATE: May 12, 2014
TO:Honorable Mayor and City Council Members
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM: Sue Iverson, Director of Finance and Administrative Services
SUBJECT: Host approval for issuance of Financing and Refinancing
bonds for Educational Purposes for Northwestern College
Action Requested
Council Action or direction to staff on how to proceed with this matter. This may
include:
1.Approval of Resolution 2014-029.
2.Authorizing the Mayor to sign a letter granting approval from the City Council on
the refinancing.
3.Direct staff to have further discussions with Northwestern College.
Background
At the request of University of Northwestern-St. Paul, the City of Arden Hills issued
adjustable Rate Revenue Bonds in 2010 to finance the construction and equipping of a
portion of a student center located on the campus. The loan agreement stipulated that the
th
administrative fee is on-eighth (1/8) of one percent per year on the outstanding principal
amount of the bond paid semi-annually. We have been receiving this fee.
Discussion
University of Northwestern-St. Paul has submitted an application to the City with respect
to the requested host approval and has submitted a non-refundable application fee in the
amount of $500 according to our City procedure for application for Private Activity
Revenue Bond Financing.
Counsel, John Utley, if the current bonds are
paid off and reissued through another issuer, the City will no longer collect the
administrative fee as the original obligation will have been paid. This letter includes in
the attachments a proposed resolution and/or a sample letter to provide City Council
12
Page of
consent. It also includes a financing plan explanation from the University of
Northwestern-ST. Paul.
the University of
Northwestern-St. Paul will be present to discuss this matter with the City Council.
Attachment
Attachment A: Letter from John Utley, Kennedy & Graven Letter
22
Page of
UNFINISHED BUSINESS 9A
MEMORANDUM
DATE: May 12, 2014
TO: Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers
Patrick Klaers, City Administrator
FROM: Terry Maurer, Public Works Director
John Anderson, Assistant City Engineer
SUBJECT: Round Lake Road - Construction Engineering Services
Requested Action
Authorize accepting the proposal, on an hourly basis, from Elfering and Associates for
Construction Services (resident inspector and survey crew) for the Round Lake Road
improvement working under the direction of John Anderson, Assistant City Engineer.
Discussion
As the Round Lake Road Improvement heads towards construction, there are some engineering
services that will be needed to complete the project. John Anderson, Assistant City Engineer, -
will lead the project from a City staff perspective but will need a resident inspector and survey
crew. Attached is a letter of proposal from Elfering and Associates to provide these services on
an hourly basis under the direction of John Anderson. and my estimate of the
hours required and Elfering and Associates hourly rates, it is estimated their services will amount
to about $185,000 total.
Elfering and Associates is the firm that provided preliminary engineering services based on
proposals from three firms. They have also provided resident inspection services for several
recent projects including the 2011 PMP, Valentine Park Improvement and the 2013 PMP. They
are providing the same staff member, Roger Bialke, who is familiar with City staff and our
project requirements.
Attachment
Attachment A: Letter of Proposal from Elfering and Associates
11
Page of
ATTACHMENT A
May 6, 2014
Mr. Terry Maurer, Public Works Director
City of Arden Hills
1245 West Highway 96
Arden Hills, MN 55112
RE: Round Lake Road Improvements Project Construction Phase
Dear Mr. Maurer:
It is our understanding that the City is anticipating awarding the Round Lake Road
Improvements Project in May and moving into the construction phase. Based on your
request we are providing information on how we can work to assist Staff with
construction services. Roger Bialke, Senior Field Inspector, is available to provide
construction inspection services and a survey crew would provide construction staking.
We would also provide construction administration services as the Engineer that
completed the design.
Roger has provided construction inspection services to the City for the past couple of
years. He inspected the 2011 and 2013 Pavement Management Program project and is
knowledgeable on City requirements and standards. The survey crew that we would
utilize to provide assistance has also worked within the City of Arden Hills in the past. In
addition, our team is well aware of the specific aspects of the project having provided
feasibility and design services.
We appreciate this opportunity to submit a schedule of rates for staff that are available to
assist with the construction phase:
Project Manager $100.00
Senior Field Inspector $ 70.00
Survey Crew $130.00
Engineering Technician $ 70.00
Our survey crew would provide staking for the following items:
Provide staking for the proposed utilities
·
Watermain
o
Storm sewer
o
Provide staking for curb on Round Lake Road
·
Provide grade staking necessary outside of the street area
·
Storm Tech System
o
As-built the project
·
Elevations on the top nut of hydrants
o
Watermain valve locations
o
Casting elevations on sanitary sewer and storm sewer structures
o
Storm Tech System volumes
o
10062 Flanders Court N.E. Blaine, MN 55449 Phone: (763) 780-0450 Fax: (763) 780-0452
Page Two
May 6, 2014
Mr. Maurer
Based on this understanding of the proposed improvements and our discussion with you
we estimate our fees to be approximately $185,000.00. Elfering & Associates would
assist the City Staff through the construction phase with administration, inspection and
staking, under your direction. We are prepared to assist you as soon as directed.
Please feel free to contact us directly at (763) 780-0450.
Sincerely,
Elfering & Associates Accepted:
Kristie Elfering, P.E.
Principal City of Arden Hills Date
10062 Flanders Court N.E. Blaine, MN 55449 Phone: (763) 780-0450 Fax: (763) 780-0452