HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-26-21 Chair:
Tony Peleska
Secretary:
Gary Gerding
Board Members:
Aisha Elmquist
Linda Hansohn
Kathy Johnson
Susan Johnson
Renee Marino
Staff Liaison:
David Swearingen
Karth Lake Improvement
District Board
REGULAR MEETING
Tuesday
October 26, 2021
1245 W. Highway 96
Arden Hills, MN 55112
651.792.7800
www.cityofardenhills.org
Agenda
Board Meeting Convenes at 6:30 PM
CALL TO ORDER
1. APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
3. PUBLIC INQUIRIES
4. OLD BUSINESS
4.1 Remediation of BMP #1 Site
4.1.1 Progress Report - David Swearingen
4.2 Add Grit Chambers to storm drains that empty into Karth Lake and do not have Grit Chambers now. Next
steps: Plan to identify them; identify likely dates for adding Grit Chambers.
4.2.1 Grit Chamber Status Update - David Swearingen
4.3 Proposed changes in lake level control process. Background: At the last meeting Renee Marino proposed we
stop the pump before we reach the target level to allow for evaporation and avoid the very low levels that a
drought could cause.
4.3.1 Define current process: When is the pump turned on and off? What is the pump capacity? - David
Swearingen
4.4 Results of removal of excess weeds and debris for 2021 – Susan Johnson
5. NEW BUSINESS
5.1 The City Council recently rezoned Little Johanna from a Recreational Development Lake to a General
Development Lake (see ORDINANCE NO. 2021-007). (Karth Lake is classified as a General Development
Lake.) What is the significance, advantages, disadvantages, etc. of each of these classifications? - David
Swearingen
5.2 Discovery of a few specimens of purple loosestrife, an invasive plant, on the Karth Lake shores and preliminary
plan to remove them. – Susan Johnson
6. NEXT MEETING
7. ADJOURN
Draft Minutes of Karth Lake Improvement District Board
Regular Meeting 6:30 PM, Tuesday, July 13, 2021
1.Call to Order/Roll Call
1.1The meeting convened at: 6:49 PM.
1.2 Present:
Board Members: Gary Gerding, Secretary; Aisha Elmquist; Linda Hansohn;
Susan Johnson; Renee Marino (chaired meeting)
Staff Liaisons: David Swearingen, Interim Public Works Director; Kyle Axtell,
Water Resource Specialist / Project Manager, Rice Creek Watershed District;
David Grant, Mayor.
1.3 Absent: Kathy Johnson, Tony Peleska, Chair
2. Approval of Agenda
The agenda was approved as modified.
3. Approval of the minutes of the previous meeting: The minutes of the previous
meeting on April 13, 2021, were approved as written.
4. Public Inquiries: None
5. Old Business
5.1 Remediation of BMP #1 Site
5.1.1 Progress Report – David Swearingen
Construction will start in August. Estimate one month to complete. Found that sediment
was plugging the existing storm drain at the end of the road above the site.
Renee M.: Can we plant under the power lines?
David S.: The contractor will seed above the drain according to MNDOT standards. The
contractor will not be paid until the site is established and erosion stops.
5.1.2. Karth Lake BMP 1 Observations and Questions – Renee Marino
Karth Lake BMP 1 Observations and Questions – July 2021
• This photo shows
that the lake gauges
are completely out
of the water and a
bolt has come off of
the new stick. We
should ask David to
have this repaired.
[see Discussion
below.]
• Erosion and silt
flowing down from
the parking lots at
the BMP1 site.
• Several feet of dirt
have eroded after the
concrete ends from
the parking lots
• Silt has flowed over
the walking path. It
comes down the hill
and around the “dry
creek bed” by the
bench.
• A view up the “dry
creek bed.” This is
the outlet for storm
sewers and does not
carry water from the
parking lots.
Importantly,
although it is very
hard to see in this
photo, this sewer
outlet only has a few
inches open above
the silt. This is
therefore a different
issue from the
drainage off of the
parking lots. With
this much silt
coming from the
sewer outlet, we
should ask about grit
chambers at drains
that feed into this
sewer line. [See
discussion below.]
• This shows the
water crossing to the
north side of the
road above BMP 1,
just as is shown in
the storm sewer map
David had
previously provided
to us (labeled A in
the photo below)
• These photos
correspond to
David’s storm sewer
map as follows: The
flow of the water
and silt from the
road, around the hill
and over the walking
path by the bench is
shown at D. The
“dry creek bed”
storm sewer outlet is
at C. The water
crossing the road is
at A.
• I wonder the area
marked as B has
been considered as
an alternative
remediation. There
is a low area south
of the walking path
where B is pointing
that sometimes holds
standing water and
drains into Karth
Lake when its level
is high enough. This
probably acts like a
catch basin to allow
grit to settle before
going into the lake.
It looks to me like it
could handle holding
more water, similar
to the pond that is
shown between the
lines marking A and
B. This area was
mentioned in the
Karth Lake plan
from 2009 as an area
that could filter
water before
draining into Karth
Lake. Would it be
possible to run a
short storm sewer
line from the
parking lot under the
road to empty into
A B C D
B? It looks like there
is a sharp drop-off
there, so water at the
outlet would drop
into that the
depression like a
waterfall without
eroding the hillside
on the way down.
This solution would
probably handle the
majority of the water
that currently runs in
the path marked D
and would probably
be far less expensive
and also remove the
needed maintenance
of emptying the grit
chamber in the
current BMP
remediation design.
The Karth Lake
Board had asked if
we could use the
area in B (in
accordance with the
2009 Karth Lake
Study’s
recommendations)
to address BMP 1,
but were told it
would have to be a
future project, since
the current BMP 1
remediation design
is complete.
Wouldn’t this
alternative approach
offer a win-win
solution for all
concerned?
5.1.2.1. Discussion:
Mayor Grant: In the winter, consider drilling a good anchor for the lake gauge and
install a gauge that is more robust.
David S.: Re grit chambers: there will be grit chambers at the entrance to the new drain.
Re alternative remediation that Renee has proposed: Construction plans have been
reviewed, approved and contracted and construction will proceed as planned
5.2. Maintenance and improvement of Art Larsen Memorial Garden –
5.2.1. Background: The city planned to upgrade the sprinkler controllers in mid-May
and then set them to water the garden.
5.2.2. Sprinkler Status and Plans - David Swearingen: The new irrigation controllers
are installed and the sprinklers are watering the garden.
5.3. Add Grit Chambers to storm drains that empty into Karth Lake and do not
have Grit Chambers now. Next Steps: Plan to identify them; Identify likely dates
for adding Grit Chambers.
5.3.1. Background, David reported at the April meeting that: A Crew will inspect and
clean the grit chambers in the spring. The City hired WSB to create GIS record of storm
drains and grit chambers. Will include this on the list by mid to late summer. Pavement
upgrade scheduled for 2024 for Amble and neighborhood. Automated rating of streets
will be done soon. David will give updates at future meetings.
5.3.2. Grit Chamber Status Update - David Swearingen: The GIS record has not yet
been completed. They did find that the Karth Lake Circle storm drain did not have a grit
chamber so a grit chamber will be installed the next time that road is repaved.
6. New Business
6.1. Proposed changes in lake level control process - Renee Marino
Renee proposes that we do not pump the lake all the way down to the level set by the
DNR. This will allow for evaporation and help to prevent the extremely low lake levels
that we have experienced when there is a draught. Renee asked that David S. determine
the current pumping policy regarding pump start and stop levels. David said he would
also determine the pump capacity.
6.2. Plan for removal of excess weeds and debris for 2021– Susan Johnson
Susan said she would again invite donations for the removal of excess weeds and debris
from the lake. Susan said she would contract with Holtz Landscaping again this year to
do the weed removal. She will also have the Dive Guys remove the weeds from around
her dock and shoreline to see whether their method is more effective.
6.3 Report of highlights of phone conversation Paul Dykstra, President of the Lake
Johanna Improvement Society on 6/27/21. Gary was contacted by Paul Dykstra.
Paul currently obtains funding for lake improvements through voluntary Lake Johanna
Association dues. He is frustrated by the lack of participation and is considering the
possibility of setting up an improvement district so they could tax everyone around the
lake.
Paul asked: Is the KLIDistrict used to assess residents for annual lake maintenance?
Gary: No, we invite donations through the Arden Hills Foundation except for pump
related improvements.
Paul: A major expense is for chemically treating invasive curly leaf weeds for which they
have a permit. They also round up 20 geese/yr. with a permit granted due to swimmers
itch. They do not remove silt from the lake bottom.
7. Next Meeting: Tuesday, October 12, 2021 (later revised to October 26, 2021).
8. Adjourn