HomeMy WebLinkAbout09-12-22-SWSAGENDA ITEMS
Roundabout Staging Discussion
Ramsey County and SRF
MEMO.PDF
ATTACHMENT A.PDF
ATTACHMENT B.PDF
COUNCIL/STAFF COMMENTS
ADJOURN
Mayor:
David Grant
Councilmembers:
Brenda Holden
Fran Holmes
Steve Scott
David Radziej
Special City Council
Work Session Agenda
September 12, 2022
Immediately following Regular
City Council meeting
City Hall
Address:
1245 W Highway 96
Arden Hills MN 55112
Phone:
651 -792 -7800
Website :
www.cityofardenhills.org
City Vision
Arden Hills is a strong community that values its unique environmental setting, strong residential
neighborhoods, vital business community, well -maintained infrastructure, fiscal soundness, and our
long -standing tradition as a desirable City in which to live, work, and play.
CALL TO ORDER
1.
1.A.
Documents:
2.
Page 1 of 1
AGENDA ITEM – 1A
MEMORANDUM
DATE: September 12, 2022
TO: Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers
Dave Perrault, City Administrator
FROM: David Swearingen, P.E. Public Works Director / City Engineer
SUBJECT: County Rd E and Old Snelling Intersection Improvements – Construction Staging
Budgeted Amount: Actual Amount: Funding Source:
$ N/A $ N/A N/A
Council Should Consider
Council should consider the construction staging options related to the roundabout improvement
at the intersection of County Rd E and Old Snelling.
Background/Discussion
Ramsey County and Engineering Consultant, SRF, will be presenting the construction options
and are requesting input from Arden Hills City Council. The presentation (Attachment A) will
discuss the options in better detail, but essentially Option 1 provides a more efficient
construction but is more restrictive on transportation through the site. Option 2 provides
transportation access in all directions throughout the entirety of the project but would cost more
and prolong the duration of construction.
Budget Impact
N/A
Attachments
Attachment A – Presentation Slides
Attachment B – Bypass cross-section
County Road E (Lake Johanna Boulevard)
and Old Snelling Avenue Intersection
September 12, 2022
Project Update
Project Update:
•Met with private
utility companies
•Identified project
limits/impacts
•Initiated Right-of-
Way process
•Conducted several
one-on-one
meetings requested
by stakeholders
•Integrated other
improvement
projects
3
Current Project Layout
Project Update
Looks nice…but how
are we going to
construct it?
4
Roundabouts can be constructed under
three types of traffic conditions:
Project Update
-Divert all traffic away
from work area
-With some of the
traffic diverted
-Under full traffic
5
Special construction considerations for
Roundabouts
Project Update
Temporary traffic control during
construction activities must
provide clear guidance to drivers,
who in some cases are unfamiliar
with roundabout operations.
Lighting, signing, striping and
landscaping are integral to
roundabout function and safety
6
Two construction options were developed
“with some of the traffic diverted”
Project Update
Option 1: Detour thru traffic
(but maintain some local
access)
Option 2: Construct bypass
(with some restrictions and
detours still needed)
7
Option 1: Implement Detour Routes
•Close intersection to thru
traffic
•Maintain local traffic but
some partial closures
required
•Advantages:
–Safer work zone
–More efficient
construction
–Lower cost
•Challenges:
–Inconvenient for
traveling public
Project Update
8
Option 1: Detour (Stage 1)
•Relocate private utilities
•Replace/Repair public
utilities
•Construct new commercial
driveway apron on CR E
•Traffic:
–Close Southbound -Use
Detour
–Close Eastbound -Use
Detour
–Northbound converted
to “Out Only” with side
street stop
–Close Westbound, except
for business access -Use
Detour
–Maintain private
driveway access
Project Update
•Possible
Detour
Routes for
Eastbound,
Southbound
and
Westbound
leg closures
Project Update
10
Option 1: Detour (Stage 2)
•Move Lindey's entrance to
CR E
•Complete new
construction areas
•Traffic:
–Continue Southbound
Detour
–Continue Eastbound
Detour
–Continue Northbound
“Out Only” with stop sign
at Lindey's entrance
–Continue Westbound
Closure/Detour, except
for business access
–Maintain private
driveway access
Project Update
11
Option 1: Detour (Stage 3)
•Complete remaining new
construction areas
•Shift Lindey's main
entrance to new
commercial apron on
Snelling
•Traffic:
–Continue Southbound
Detour
–Continue Eastbound
Detour
–Close Northbound “Out
Only” (short term)
–Open Westbound
•Maintain private driveway
access
Project Update
12
Option 1: Detour (Stage 4)
•Complete remaining new
construction and site
restoration
•Traffic:
–All movements open
Project Update
13
Option 2: Construct Bypass
•Build bypass and use
temporary widening
•Maintain local traffic but
some partial closures
required
•Advantages:
–Allows (most) traffic to
continue using
intersection
–Moves intersection away
from work zone
•Challenges:
–Multiple traffic shifts can
be confusing
–Additional costs and
longer duration
–Inconvenient for
traveling public
Project Update
14
Option 2: Bypass (Stage 1)
•Relocate private utilities
•Replace/Repair public
utilities
•Build temporary bypass in
NW quadrant (need light
pole)
•Widen south side of east
and west legs by 12' (lots
of utilities in this area)
•Traffic:
–All traffic movements
open (but may need
some temporary lane
closures for utility work)
Project Update
15
Option 2: Bypass (Stage 2)
•Construct ~75% of
Roundabout
•Consider temporary
drainage needs
•Add lighting and critical
Roundabout signage
where possible
•Traffic:
–Move traffic onto
bypass/widened areas
–New 3-legged
intersection is all way
stop with no turn lanes
–Northbound converted
to “Out Only” with side
street stop
Project Update
16
Option 2: Bypass (Stage 3A)
•Remove bypass &
temporary widening
•Construct remaining
portions of roundabout
•Install remaining critical
Roundabout signage
•Traffic:
–North leg: restrict
Southbound traffic (need
detour)
–East leg: restrict
Eastbound traffic (except
from south leg)
–South leg: restrict
Southbound traffic
–West leg: closed for 1 to
2 weeks (need detour)
Project Update
17
Option 2: Bypass (Stage 3B)
•Remove bypass &
temporary widening
•Construct remaining
portions of roundabout
•Install remaining critical
Roundabout signage
•Traffic:
–North leg: restrict
Southbound traffic (need
detour)
–East leg: restrict
Eastbound traffic
–South leg: restrict
Northbound traffic
–West leg: Full access, but
EB traffic is diverted onto
SB leg (need detour)
Project Update
18
Option 2: Bypass (Stage 4)
•Construct any remaining
portions of roundabout
and sidewalk
•Traffic:
–All movements open
Project Update
19
Project staff recommends Option 1:
Implement Detour Routes
•Advantages:
–Safer work zone
–More efficient
construction (estimate 8
weeks faster)
–Lower cost (estimate
$100,000 less)
•Challenges:
–Inconvenient for
traveling public
Project Update
Planned Schedule
We seek your
support!
Planned Schedule:
•Next Open
House: October
6th, 2022 at City
Hall
•Complete plans
•Secure permits
•Cooperative
Agreement
•Construction
planned for 2023
Contact Information
21
Joey Lundquist, Ramsey County Project
Manager
josephine.lundquist@ramseycounty.us |
651-266-7114
Contact Project Staff:
Thank You
MB
MB
MB MB
MB
MB
SP
G
U
U
T
T
T
TTT
T
T
T
T
T
TT
51+00
900
910
920
50+00 52+00917.854VPI 50+55.000ELEV 917.088-2
.
3
2%
60.00' VC
K = 18
ex = 0.25'VPI 51+45.000ELEV 917.966+0.98%-2
.3
0%
60.00' VC
K = 18
ex = -0.25'917.264VPC 50+25.00 ELEV 917.78VPT 50+85.00 ELEV 917.38VPC 51+15.00 ELEV 917.67VPT 51+75.00 ELEV 917.27930
GRADING GRADE
MNDOT SPEC 2360, (SPWEA340B)
1.5" TYPE SP 9.5 WEARING COURSE MIXTURE (3,B)
CLASS 5, MNDOT SPEC 2211
6.0" AGGREGATE BASE (CV)
MNDOT SPEC 2360, (SPWEA340B)
1.5" TYPE SP 9.5 WEARING COURSE MIXTURE (3,B)
TEMPORARY PAVEMENT
BYPASS
12.0'
THRU
GRADING GRADE
0.02
12.0'
THRU
{ BYPASS
GRADE
PROFILE
SHLD
6.0'1.5'
0.02
MATERIAL
SUITABLE GRADING
EXISTING GROUND
BYPASS STA 52+48.3 TO 57+43.1
6" TOPSOIL
1:4
12" EXCAVATION - COMMON
INSET
TYPICAL SECTION - BYPASS
SHLD
6.0'
0.02 0.02
1:4INSET
1.5' 50 51 52 pw:\\srf-pw.bentley.com:srf-pw\Documents\Projects\14000\14411\03_Design\Graphic\14411_gr01_Bypass.dgn7/15/2022
Job #14411
Figure 1
CR E and Old Snelling Ave
Staging Options - Bypass Design
City of Arden Hills, Ramsey County
100050
SCALE IN FEET
SNELLING AVE NCR E/LAKE JOHANNA AVE
{ BYPASS