Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCC 03-27-1995 I I. I I I I I I I 14' I I I I I I I Ie - 9 MINUTES CITY OF ARDEN lULLS, MINNESOTA REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MARCH 27, 1995 7:00 P.M. - NEW BRIGHTON CITY HALL CALL TO ORDEWROLL CALL Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, Mayor Dennis Probst called to order the regular City Council meeting at 7:04 p.m. Present: Mayor Dennis Probst; Councilmembers Beverly Aplikowski, Dale Hicks, Paul Malone and Susan Keim. Also present were: City Clerk/Administrator, Brian Fritsinger; City Accountant, Terry Post; Parks and Recreation Director, Cindy S. Walsh; City Attorney, Jerry Filla; and Recording Secretary, Ruth McLaurin. ADOPT AGENDA MOTION: Aplikowski moved and Keim seconded a motion to adopt the agenda for the March 27, 1995 City Council meeting as presented. The motion carried Imanimously (5-0). APPROVAL OF COUNCIL MINUTES March 13, 1995 City Administrator Fritsinger presented the Council with a revised copy of the minutes, noting simple typographical changes. MOTION: Keim moved and Hicks seconded a motion to approve the revised minutes of the March 13, 1995 regular City Council meeting as presented. The motion carried unanimously (5-0). March 16, 1995 MOTION: Hicks moved and Aplikowski seconded a motion to approve the minutes of the March 16, 1995 City Council Worksession meeting as presented. The motion canied unanimously (5-0). CONSENT CALENDAR Councilmember Hicks requested item 4a,. Mileage Reimbursement Rate Increase, of the Consent Calendar be removed. He requested staff to survey surrounding cities and review and identify the impact this increase would have on the 1995 Budget I I. I I I I I I I Ie I I I I I I I Ie I ,ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27. 1995 2 B. Approve 1994 Operating Transfers C. Approve Claims and PayroU MOTION: Malone moved and Hicks seconded a motion to approve the Consent Calendar as amended, and authorize execution of all necessary documents contained therein. The motion carried unanimously (5-0). PUBLIC COMMENTS Mayor Probst invited the audience to address Council with any matters of concern during this portion of the meeting. Mr. Craig Wilson of1677 County Road F, wished to update the Council regarding improvement to County Road F and residents' concerns. He indicated a meeting with Consulting Engineer Stonehouse and local residents is forthcoming and any information gained at this meeting will be passed on to the City Staff. Ms. SaUy Jones of 1691 Crystal Avenue, presented the Council with a copy of the public notice regarding the improvements to County Road F, highlighting areas of concern. UNFINISHED AND NEW BUSINESS STOWE AVENUE TURNBACK - RESOLUTION #95-24 City Administrator noted the next item on the agenda was a Resolution trnnsferringjurisdiction over Stowe Avenue to the City of Arden Hills. MOTION: Hicks moved and Keirn seconded a motion to adopt Resolution #95-24 transferring jurisdiction over Stowe Avenue to the City of Arden Hills. The motion carried nn"nimously (5-0). 1995 WATER METER MINIMUM CHARGES City Accountant Post indicated this completes the action taken last fall, revised rates for larger sized waters meters were inadvertently not included on Resolution #94-52. MOTION: Hicks moved and Malone seconded a motion to adopt Resolution #95-23 authorizing a complete listing of 1995 water utility rates. The motion carried .m"nimously (5-0). I I. I I I I I I I I- I I I I I I I Ie I ,ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27. 1995 3 PURCHASE OF PARKS 1 (ONFJ TON TRUCK Parks and Recreation Director Walsh indicated the total price for the truck would be $31,100 this includes the box and plow. She noted this is still below the $35,000 that had been budgeted for this purchase. MOTION: Aplikowski moved and Keirn seconded a motion to approve the purchase of 1 (One) Ton Truck for the total price of $31, 1 00. The motion carried unAnimously (5-0). Mayor Probst indicated since the time was not yet 7:30 p.m., the published time for the public hearings, he requested to move on to Administrator Comments, Council concurred. ADMINISTRATOR COMMENTS City Administrator Fritsinger noted he had received correspondence from Everest Development regarding the Round Lake Development project. He indicated he would like any comments or concerns from Council as Staff prepares a response. Mayor Probst inquired if there is a timetable regarding this response. Mr. Fritsinger noted there is no timetable, Everest is awaiting a response from Staff. City Administrator Fritsinger indicated Mr. Post and Councilmembers Malone and Hicks have reviewed the infonnation and pay plan restructuring as discussed at the last Council Worksession. He noted although this plan apparently will allow the City to pass DOER statistical tests and be found in compliance, Staff is still working on a final form. He welcomed any comments from Council. Staff is still working on establishing a salary range. He noted DOER will then respond with any comments and then it will be provided to Council for approval. Mayor Probst inquired if there is a timetable as to when it has to be submitted to DOER. Mr. Fritsinger noted the deadline would be Apri130, 1995. COUNCIL COMMENTS Councilmember Aplikowski noted in regards to the County Road F issues addressed earlier in the meeting, if residents were available after the meeting, she would gladly meet with them to discuss concerns. Councilmember Aplikowski indicated she would like to see the return of the local newspaper the Town Crier as many residents have also voiced. She indicated Mr. Hoelscher has expressed interest in editing the newspaper. She noted this would be a good tool community communication tool if used correctly. I I. I I I I I I I Ie I I I I I I I I- I ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27. 1995 4 Councilmember Malone inquired if the Council meetings are live on cable. City Administrator Fritsinger indicated he believed the Meetings were live but would review this with the Cable Commission, to be sure. Councilmember Malone indicated he would be testifying before the State Legislature opposing Senate File 467, regarding the Regional Trunk Radio System. He was requesting support for this issue. Councilmember Aplikowski inquired if a formal motion would be desired. MOTION: Hicks moved and Aplikowski seconded a motion to formally support Councilmember Paul Malone's testimony opposing Senate File 467, regarding the Regional Trunk Radio System, to be presented on March 28, 1995. The motion passed unanimously (5-0). Mayor Probst indicated he bas recently been infonnally meeting with three Mayors from surrounding communities informally, and in the near future will provide a motion to formally set up a future meeting schedule with these area Mayors, perhaps to also include City Administrators and Managers. He indicated the Mayors have indicated their support in Arden Hills' endeavors regarding the TCAAP issue. Mayor Probst indicated due to audio problems and with a few minutes to spare until the public hearing there would be a brief recess, recess was called at 7:20 p.m. The meeting reconvened at 7:40 p.m. PLANNING CASE #95-5. OGREN TOWNHOMES PUD Mayor Probst inquired if verification of publication could be made. City Administrator Fritsinger indicated notice was publicized on March 14 and March 21 in the ~. Mayor Probst opened the Public Hearing at 7:40 p.m. Mayor Probst explained the procedure of public testimony. He indicated a brief description of the project will be presented, Council will reply with comments or question, those in favor of the project will speak, and then those in opposition will speak. He requested questions and testimonies be limited to two minutes to allow for an opportunity for all to speak. City Administrator Fritsinger briefly reviewed the project, the applicant is desiring to develop Townhomes at the northwest comer of County Road E-2 and Old Snelling Avenue. , '. , , , , , , I ,e , , , , I , I ,e I ,ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27. 1995 5 City Administrator Fritsinger indicated the use of a Planned Unit Development (PUD) gives the City greater control of the development than single family plat process. He noted the Planning Commission approved the PUD with a number of conditions at it March meeting. City Administrator Fritsinger stated the DNR has tabled its review of the proposal until Rice Creek Watershed District has completed its review. He added, Rice Creek Watershed District has also tabled action due to questions about the location of other potential wetlands on the site. City Administrator Fritsinger indicated the neighborhood has petitioned the State Environment Quality Board for an Environmental Assessment Worksheet (EA W). He explained the Council cannot approve this project until it has taken action on the petition for an EA W in which the City has 30 days to respond. Mr. Fritsinger suggested the Council could take action regarding the petition at their April 10, 1995 meeting. City Administrator Fritsinger indicated the Environment Quality Board has determined that the City is the appropriate governmental unit to decide the need for an EA W. Mayor Probst reiterated no action will be taken until findings have been established regarding the EAW. Mayor Probst noted the site is zoned R-l Single Family residential, the land is not owned by the City or County and is not a park. The property is owned by Bethel College, who currently holds a purchase agreement with Mr. Dan Ogren. Mayor Probst indicated the Planned Unit Development (PUD) procedure will allow the City to enforce additional requirements on the site. Mayor Probst explained to the audience that Staff is in the process of reviewing the EA W petition and the City has 30 days to respond and will most likely forward formal action regarding this at its April 1 O. 1995 regular meeting. Mayor Probst indicted there will be a closed Public Hearing tonight with a second Public Hearing occuring after the DNR and Rice Creek Watershed District have made their recommendations, which is expected to be sometime in May. Mayor Probst hearing no comments or questions of the Council, opened the floor for those in favor of the project. Mr. Thomas Steele of 3570 Ridgewood Road, wished to address the basic issue of property rights, and the ability to legally dispose of property. Although it is his personal preference that the property remain undeveloped, he does not want the rights of private property owners ignored. He indicated if a group of individuals are able to purchase the property for this purpose, that is also an option. I I. I I I I I I I Ie I I I I I I I .- I ,AlID.EN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27. 1995 6 Mr. Chuck Winden of 1604 Chatham Avenue, has had the opportunity to see the plans proposed for this project and believes the project is a fine addition to Arden Hills. Mr. Eugene Schmidt of 1628 Chatham Avenue, indicated Bethel College is a good member of the co=unity and they have a right to sell a property. As citizens we have a right to buy or sell property without notification to the public. He personally endorsed the project. Ms. Jeanne Winiecki of 4471 Old Hwy 10 N, indicated she was speaking in favor of the PUD process, to speak against the project would be futile. She indicated the developer has the right to develop the land with single family homes without the input of neighbors or Council, therefore she encouraged the use of the PUD process for continued input of the co=unity. She suggested the neighborhood create a committee to meet with Mr. Ogren to help achieve the best plan available, benefiting the neighborhood and the proposed project. She reiterated the use of the PUD process would better benefit the desires of the neighborhood. Mayor Probst hearing no others in favor of the project, requested those in opposition to step forward. Mr. Jay Schrankler of1748 Venus Avenue, indicated he is a member of an organization called ''Neighbors of V alentine Lake", they have been formed to review the environmental and legal issues regarding this development. Mr. Schrank1er co=ented that although this is private property it is affecting a public co=unity, and there is a need to review the needs of many versus the needs of the few. Mr. Schrankler indicated his organization contains six sub-committees; legal, government, public relations, Bethel co=unications, finance, and environmental committees. He serves on the environmental committee. Mr. Schrankler indicated there is concern for the impact of this development on the natural, residential and community environment. These concerns are the reason for the EA W petition. Mr. Schrankler indicated various critical issues will be addressed through a EA W. He stated the proposed development lies between two protected wetlands, Valentine Lake and Ramsey County Open Space, which is a concern. He noted the Rice Creek Watershed Dis1rict has raised issues regarding drainage of the proposed sediment pond and has form a TEP to review these issues. He continued that rare wildlife species will be affected. He questioned ability for the pond to border a County easement. He indicated traffic patterns that are a concern, many accidents have already occurred. He also noted the 1991 wetland inventory map is in contradiction to the developers map regarding the wetland delineation. Mr. Schrank1er requested the Council to review these issues when making decisions regarding this proposal. I I. I I I I I I I Ie I I I I I I I Ie I hJ:U)EN lllLLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27.1995 7 Mr. Mark Chapin of 3947 Rolling Hills Road, indicated there are two reasons to have a EA W ordered. First when there are more than 25 residents requesting a EA W, the governing unit shall order the study. Secondly, issues regarding the protected wetlands if sump pump problems arise. Mr. Chapin indicated an EA W is required if a wetland is affected. He indicated in his research, whenever a City has ordered an EA W, no court has reversed a decision of a Council to order an EAW. Mr. Chapin suggested an EA W be done, public comment be heard and then the Council will be better equipped to make a decision. Mr. Chapin indicated the attorney for the ''Neighbors of V alentine Lake", Tom Casey will contact the City Attorney to address these issues. Ms. Fran Holmes of1804 Venus Avenue, referred to the memomndum of Mr. Bergly dated March 1, 1995 regarding Planning Case #95-5 to the Council, she indicated after reviewing she felt there were issues still to address. Ms. Holmes indicated regarding the Comprehensive Plan and this project, the project is not a compatible use with the surrounding wetlands, there is not buffering for the proposed project, and also indicated the calculation for the density was incorrect. Ms. Holmes indicated concern that the street width should be 32 feet and not 26 feet. She noted concern that units 8, 9 and 10 would cross the County easement noted on the map. She felt drainage issues still need to be addressed. She indicated through a soil survey it is not recommended for developing. She stated a traffic study should be done and indicated an article from the Valentine Hills School, noted County Road E-2 to be a hazardous roadway currently, even without this proposed development. Ms. Holmes indicated did not feel the Planning Commission fully reviewed the Comprehensive Land Use Plan regarding this project. Mr. Craig Wilson of 1677 County Road F, a member of ''Neighbors of V alentine Lake" indicated he has been working with County Commissioner Wedell. He indicated Mr. Gregory Mack, Director of Parks for the County, had expressed in a letter, when the land becomes available, he would recommend the County accept it as a contribution to Ramsey County Open Space. Ms. Doris Canniff of 3946 Glenview Avenue, indicated she had not seen any "for sale" signs on the property. She indicated concern for overdevelopment. She also indicated concern for mistrust between the community and the City Council. Her desire is to remain proud of this neighborhood and does not feel this would be beneficial to this neighborhood. I I. I I I I I I I Ie I I I I I I I I- I ,A.ROEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27. 1995 . 8 Ms. Sonya Lyons of 3908 Dellview Avenue, referred to a report Communities by Design, put out by the Environmental Quality Board. She indicated the impact on the environment and the cost for cleaning and maintaining the environment from the hazards of the development, would be more costly than the benefits of the development. She indicated concern that the development might create a crisis for the City in the future. Ms. Lois Rem of 1679 Glenview Court, questioned why the Ramsey County Open Space was zoned R-l and indicated concern. Ms. Rem indicated the response of the community at all the public hearings should be a sign to the Council the impact of the development on the community. She indicated the citizens are also a part of the governmental process. Ms. Rem encouraged the City to establish a Wetland Ordinance, since there was no such ordinance in place. Ms. Rem briefly read an ordinance adopted by Mounds Views as an example, and then presented Staff with a copy of same. Her concern was for the preservation of the wetlands and to regulate future development adjacent to wetlands. She indicated an EA W is necessary to protect the community. Mr. Jon Hoelscher of 1750 Gramsie Road, indicated no argument with legality of process or transactions that have taken place thus far. Although he feels there is a greater issue involved, what is the right thing to do. He indicated historically uses, the pole yard property, Army Ammunition Plant, which were owned or leased for private use has resulted in serious pollution problems. Mr. Hoelscher indicated the situation has been made more difficult with flawed information regarding the two uses of this site, open space on one map and residential on another map. Mr. Hoelscher felt even though the EA W is not mandatory, the Council should order the study, to help further review the issues and to do the right thing. Mr. Hoelscher indicated personally he would like to do the right thing and take responsibility, by being taxed. He indicated if additional funds were needed to achieve a cohesive plan, to prevent conflicting maps and flawed information. Mr. Hoelscher encouraged Council to review the response of the citizens and proceed with democratic decisions. Mr. Kenneth Hanazalik of 1768 Venus Avenue, requested the Council walk the trail before decisions are made, there are various trees that will be destroyed through development and grading. Mr. Hanazalik suggested the views of the public weigh in the decision of the Council. I I. I I I I I I I Ie I I I I I I I I- I ARDEN IDLLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27. 1995 9 Mr. Bob Mullin of 1793 Gramsie Road, indicated that it is obvious from the comments, that the citizens and officials are expected to be lawyers, ecologists, hydrologists, environmentalists, traffic specialists, and also artists. He quoted, Aleksandr So1zenitsyn, in his 1970 acceptance speech for the nobel prize" ...the task of the artist is to sense more keenly than anyone else, the hannony and beauty of the world, and to sense the outrage of what man has done to it.." He hoped as a community of landowners, developers, and councilmembers, they can find a way that will be satisfactory for all, to preserve the harmony and beauty of the open space which Arden Hills already has. Preserve for this generation and generations to come. Ms. Donna Woolfrey of 1811 Venus Avenue, indicated concern for the traffic, referring to a serious accident her daughter had in this area. She believes the proposed street will cause additional traffic problems. Ms. Woolfrey recaJJed that Ramsey County in 1974 had tried to buy this property from Bethel College, but Bethel retained the property for a future homesite of its president at that time. Since then they have decided not to build, so the land was for put up for sale two years ago. Mr. Ben Krusin of 4715 Morinda Drive, stated he is Co-President of Mounds View High School Environmental, Animal, and Tree Hugger Club, although they are not endorsed by Mounds View Public Schools in any way. Mr. Krusin indicated concern if the wetlands were destroyed, the animals in the area would be displaced. Mr. Krusin also indicated concern for the traffic problems. Mr. Bill Cheney of 1732 Venus Avenue, indicated he believed this site to be a corridor between the two natural wetlands, and was concerned that if the area was developed the animals would be cut off from the other wetland and eventually disappear. Mr. Cheney referred to back issues of the Town Crier noting developments during 1970 through 1972 that were denied due to spot rezoning, traffic congestion, narrow streets, sewer line capacity, excess density, neighborhood opposition, and meeting social, and architectural qualities of Arden Hills. He indicated these reasons are similar to those proposed by residents in this case. Mayor Probst noted for clarification, that there is no rezoning involved in this case. Mr. Steve Herbst 3799 McCracken Lane, indicated although a selfish reason for opposing the development, his land overlooks the site. He would prefer to look at single family homes and not townhomes. He believed five or six homes could be developed on this site with current setback requirements, he also indicated perhaps Mr. Ogren would not see this as beneficial and choose not to develop. I I. I I I I I I I Ie I I I I I I I I- I ,AlIDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27. 1995 10 Ms. Janeen Kajerr 1434 West County Road E, indicated concern for traffic problems. Ms. Ann Marie Rundquist 3716 Chatham Court, indicated in additions to the comments made, she would like to add the issue of global biodiversity. She indicated the development would shrink the wildlife population, and encouraged the preservation of the wildlife. Mr. Dan Ogren, the applicant, indicated he is not asking for any special favors regarding this development. He indicated those interested in the open space have not yet approached him directly to work on this situation. Mr. Ogren feels the development will be approved, after all reviews have been made. Mr. Ogren indicated electronic monitoring will be established to define wetlands. Mr. Ogren indicated he has met with a landscape architect, 70 trees will be added to the site. He indicated they are trying to reduce hard surface on the site with narrower streets. Mr. Ogren indicated based on title work that has been done, there is not currently a County easement established regarding the trail, at least it has not appeared in the title work. Mr. Ogren indicated in reviewing the possibility of single family homes, he established there would be 12 homes on the site, and most likely the homes would be two story homes with full walkouts. He noted the two story homes would have much more impact on the neighborhood, than the townhomes currently proposed. Mr. Ogren apologized if any thing he has said has been interpreted as threatening, he does not wish to appear to be threatening. Mr. Ogren indicated for the record he had no special favors in acquiring this property, he approached Bethel College in regards to the purchase of the land. He sought out Bethel College and he does not personally know the college president. Mr. Chapin of 3947 Rolling Hills Road, encouraged the Council to request a copy of the purchase agreement held between Bethel College and Mr. Ogren, to show credible property interest. He indicated only one parcel in IUlder the purchase agreement and there is a 1.62 acre parcel that is not IUlder a purchase agreement. Mr. Bob Eha of3898 Dellview, indicated the townhomes are not consistent with the neighborhood, and would not be desirable. Mr. Pershan Franklin of 1823 Gramsie Road, indicated concern for the traffic during construction work. I I. I I I I I I I .e I I I I I . I Ie I ,ARDEN lULLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27. 1995 11 , Mr. Eric Lundgren of 1777 Gramsie Road, indicated on behalf of the children who play in the area, it would be a disgrace to lose the open space. Ms. Lois Rem of 1670 Glenview Court, indicated she is proud to be part of the co=unity, and encouraged the Council to take into consideration the concerns of the citizens. Ms. Shirley Franklin of 1823 Gramsie Road, indicated she did not feel it would be appropriate for residents to contact Mr. Ogren, since the issue is not the type of development, but if there is to be a development at all. She indicated concerns are for the greatest good for the greatest number of people, the co=unity. Ms. Nancy Vaden of 1795 Glenview, indicated her concern was in regards to her two small children, and the wildlife in the area. She hoped her children could continue to grow in a co=unity in which they could be proud of. Mr. Don Moberg of 1629 Glenview Court, indicated his concerns are also regarding the wildlife, he has seen deer and wild turkey. He indicated there probably is no other co=unity in the metro area that can make this claim of seeing wild turkey. He noted the development would sever the corridor for the wildlife. Ms. Doris Canniff of 3946 Glenview, indicated concern that after development, the walkway will become assumed private property and it will be difficult for residents to continue to use this walkway. Ms. Becky Freed, a student at Bethel College, indicated she is a photographer for her school paper, to keep students informed of the issues regarding this project. Ms. Freed indicated concern for traffic problems. She indicated there are various concerns regarding this development, but rights are still in place, and will need to be respected. Ms. Freed expressed concern that the perception of Bethel College is being tarnished. She wished to encourage residents not to be too hard on Bethel College. She noted Bethel College's desire is to be a good neighbor. Mr. Dan Couture of 1681 Wedgewood Circle, inquired if Bethel College pays taxes on this property. He inquired if the house across the street is owned by Bethel. Mayor Probst indicated Bethel College does pay taxes on this property, but not property included in their campus. Ms. Angela Hames of 1839 Venus Avenue, indicated she would like to encourage the student from Bethel College. She noted Bethel College has responded in a very positive way to the residents. A I I. I I I I I I I .e I I I I I I I .- I ,ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27. 1995 12, representative from Bethel College commented to the Pioneer Press that ifit was to do all over again, Bethel College would not have proceeded, because they are concerned with the perception of the community. She noted Bethel is seeking also the best possible solution to this dilemma. Mr. Joseph L. V odonik oU723 Glenview Avenue, indicated in the 1950's this area was a wetland were ducks nested and this is not the case now, due to development of the area Mayor Probst indicated there are two options, the COlUlCil may continue the Public Hearing, or close it and set a second hearing in the future. Council concurred to set a second Public Hearing in the future. Mayor Probst closed the Public Hearing at 9: 12 p.m. Mayor Probst informed the audience that the second Public Hearing will most likely be held in May after actions by the Rice Creek Watershed District and results of the EA W petition. He wished to personally thank the audience for being cordial in their participation. Councilmember Malone inquired as to a timetable regarding the PUD request. City Adrnini>:trator Fritsinger indicated the City has 60 days. Councilmember Hicks inquired if there would be a hold during the period of review of the EA W petition. City Attorney Filla believed there would be a stay pending actions regarding the EA W, the time would start again once a decision is reached regarding the ordering of the EA W. Mr. Ogren felt the study is redundant and perhaps just a stall. He requested the Council take action on ordering of the EA W by their April 1 0, 1995 meeting. City Administrator Fritsinger indicated concern if an EA W is done, would the time frame be extended.. City Attorney Filla indicated perhaps if the 45 days expire, the City Council could deny on the basis of insufficient information. PLANNING CASE #95-12 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT PUBLIC RRARTNG Mayor Probst opened the Public Hearing at 9:21 p.m. Mayor Probst inquired if proper notification of the Public Hearing could be verified. City Administrator Fritsinger noted this was publicized on March 14 and 21, 1995 in the Focus. City Administrator Fritsinger briefly reviewed the amendment. He indicated that in regards to the previous site location, it is designated on the Land Use Plan Map as Park and Open Space, and on the Park and Open Space Plan map it does not designate the easterly parcel as existing Park and Open Space nor does it identify the parcel as proposed Park and Open Space. I I. I I I I I I I I- I I I I I I I Ie I ARDEN IDLLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27.1995 13 City Administrator Fritsinger indicated staff is suggesting clarification of the inconsistent maps. City Administrator Fritsinger indicated Ramsey County Parks has not indicated an interest in acquiring this property. City Admini!<trator Fritsinger indicated the Comprehensive Plan does not have to be amended for the Ogren PUD Proposal to proceed. Councilmember Malone indicated the Metropolitan Council is looking to require review and updating of the Comprehensive Plan. He indicated a broader view of the Comprehensive Plan should be taken and all necessary changes should be made at the same time. Mayor Probst concurred with Councilmember Malone, as many as possible areas need to be identified. City Attorney Filla noted a super majority is required to pass this amendment, and since two members have already voiced their opinion, the item would not move forward. MOTION: Hicks moved and Keirn seconded a motion to table Planning Case #95-12, Comprehensive Plan Amendment for further review of problem areas. Mayor Probst noted a Public Hearing is still under way. Councilmember Hicks withdrew his motion. Mayor Probst opened the floor to those who wish to speak in favor of the amendment Ms. Jeanne Wini~ki of 4471 Old Hwy 10, indicated support to clarify the contradictions in maps. She noted the map originally was designed to show what currently existed Property designated as open space was in reality undeveloped land. She indicated it would be less confusing if perhaps two maps were drawn, one to designate current use and one to designate potential use. Mr. Jim Hanton of 3945 Rolling Hills Road, encouraged the Council to table this item until the whole community can be reviewed. Mr. Hanton indicated concern that the Zoning Ordinance was driving the Comprehensive Plan instead of the Comprehensive Plan driving the Zoning Ordinance. Ms. Angela Hames of 1839 Venus Avenue, indicated Ramsey County has by letter stated intentions, if the land becomes available to accept it as part of their open space. She would provide Council with a copy of that letter in the near future. Mr. Mark Chapin of 3947 Rolling Hills Road, indicated concern that all open spaces are zoned R-l Single Family Residential. I I. I I I I I I I Itt I I I I I I I Ie I ,ARDENJ:IILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 27.1995 14 Mayor Probst noted current zoning does not address open space, and the R-l district provides for the most control over development in the open spaces. He indicated the City can go back and identify these areas with a new designation, but it goes back to ownership issues. City Administrator Fritsinger indicated using various maps, that in 1965 the area was designated low density residential, in 1972 the same and 1974 it was desigJ1Rted as open space. Also in 1968 there was a street map identifying a street in the site. Mr. Jay Schrankler of 1798 Venus Avenue, indicated the 1968 street map is referring to a development that had been proposed at that time, but was denied. Ms. Fran Holmes of 1804 Venus Avenue, indicated the reason the development in 1968 was denied was due to drainage issues. Ms. Angela Hames indicated support for the review of the entire community for any needed changes. She indicated various realtors, and residents use the Comprehensive Land Use Plan and maps as tools for purchasing homes in Arden Hills. Mr. Gene Schmidt of 1628 Chatham Avenue, indicated since the area is zoned R-l, the Ogren project should move forward. Mr. Bob Eha 3898 Dellview, questioned the R-l district, he inquired if the townhomes fit this criteria Mayor Probst indicated the townhomes fit the criteria regarding Single Family attached, he indicated Mr. Eha is thinldng of Single Family detached which is similar to his own home. Mr. Ogren questioned if the delay of the amendment would affect his project. City Attorney Filla indicated in his opinion it would not be affected. Mayor Probst closed the Public Hearing at 9:50 p.m. MOTION: Hicks moved and Malone seconded a motion to table Planning Case #95-12, Comprehensive Plan Amendment, and asked staff to review existing land uses and change all discrepancies. The motion carried nnRnimously (5-0). ADJOURN MOTION: Malone moved and Aplikowski seconded a motion to adjourn the meeting at 9:55 p.m. The motion carried nnRnimously (5-0). I I. I I I I I I I I- I I I I I I I I- I COUNCIL - MARC 27 1995 15 rian Fritsinger City Administrator NOTICE OF MEETINGS The next regular Council meeting will be held April 10, 1995, at 7:30 p.m., at New Brighton City Hall.