Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout05-28-25-SWSPUBLIC INQUIRIES/INFORMATIONAL This is an opportunity for citizens to respectfully bring to the Council ’s attention any items which are relevant to the City. In addressing the Council, you must first state your name and address for the record. Comments shall be limited to three (3) minutes or less. Written documents or other materials should be handed to the City Clerk for distribution to the Council prior to or during the meeting. Council will generally not respond at the same meeting where an issue is initially raised by a member of the public but the Council may refer the issue to staff for further research and possible report or action at a future Council meeting. RESPONSE TO PUBLIC INQUIRIES AGENDA ITEMS Zoning Code Update Discussion Jessica Jagoe, City Administrator MEMO.PDF ATTACHMENT A.PDF ATTACHMENT B.PDF ATTACHMENT C.PDF ATTACHMENT D.PDF ATTACHMENT E.PDF Chickens And Ducks Discussion Jessica Jagoe, City Administrator MEMO.PDF ATTACHMENT A.PDF ATTACHMENT B.PDF COUNCIL/STAFF COMMENTS ADJOURN Mayor: David Grant Councilmembers: Brenda Holden Emily Rousseau Tena Monson Kurt Weber Special City Council Work Session Agenda May 28, 2025 Immediately Following Special City Council Meeting City Hall Address: 1245 W Highway 96 Arden Hills MN 55112 Phone: 651 -792 -7800 Website : www.cityofardenhills.org City Vision Arden Hills is a strong community that values its unique environmental setting, strong residential neighborhoods, vital business community, well -maintained infrastructure, fiscal soundness, and our long -standing tradition as a desirable City in which to live, work, and play. Members of the public may attend a meeting in -person at City Hall or they may view the meeting remotely on the City ’s website using the below link. Meetings are also broadcast on Cable Channel 16 for those that live in Arden Hills. https://cityofardenhills.org/320/Watch - City -Meetings This meeting will be streamed live on local Cable Channel 16 and available for playback on our website. CALL TO ORDER 1. 2. 3. 3.A. Documents: 3.B. Documents: 4. PUBLIC INQUIRIES/INFORMATIONALThis is an opportunity for citizens to respectfully bring to the Council ’s attention any items which are relevant to the City. In addressing the Council, you must first state your name and address for the record. Comments shall be limited to three (3) minutes or less. Written documents or other materials should be handed to the City Clerk for distribution to the Council prior to or during the meeting. Council will generally not respond at the same meeting where an issue is initially raised by a member of the public but the Council may refer the issue to staff for further research and possible report or action at a future Council meeting.RESPONSE TO PUBLIC INQUIRIESAGENDA ITEMSZoning Code Update Discussion Jessica Jagoe, City Administrator MEMO.PDF ATTACHMENT A.PDF ATTACHMENT B.PDF ATTACHMENT C.PDF ATTACHMENT D.PDF ATTACHMENT E.PDF Chickens And Ducks Discussion Jessica Jagoe, City Administrator MEMO.PDF ATTACHMENT A.PDF ATTACHMENT B.PDF COUNCIL/STAFF COMMENTS ADJOURN Mayor:David GrantCouncilmembers:Brenda HoldenEmily RousseauTena MonsonKurt Weber Special City Council Work Session AgendaMay 28, 2025 Immediately Following Special City Council Meeting City Hall Address:1245 W Highway 96Arden Hills MN 55112Phone:651 -792 -7800Website:www.cityofardenhills.orgCity VisionArden Hills is a strong community that values its unique environmental setting, strong residential neighborhoods, vital business community, well -maintained infrastructure, fiscal soundness, and our long -standing tradition as a desirable City in which to live, work, and play.Members of the public may attend a meeting in -person at City Hall or they may view the meeting remotely on the City ’s website using the below link. Meetings are also broadcast on Cable Channel 16 for those that live in Arden Hills.https://cityofardenhills.org/320/Watch -City -MeetingsThis meeting will be streamed live on local Cable Channel 16 and available for playback on our website.CALL TO ORDER1.2.3.3.A. Documents: 3.B. Documents: 4. Page 1 of 2 AGENDA ITEM – 3A MEMORANDUM DATE: May 28, 2025 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers FROM: Jessica Jagoe, City Administrator SUBJECT: Zoning Code Update Discussion Budgeted Amount: Actual Amount: Funding Source: N/A N/A N/A Council Should Consider Council should discuss and provide direction to staff on zoning code updates within HKGi Summary of Work Session #2 memo and recommendations brought forward for consideration. Background At the May 12th work session, the City Council began the review of the HKGi Summary of Work Session #2 memo and recommendations. Feedback was given on the Lot Standards and Site Standards portion of the memo. During the review of the Permitted and Accessory Use Tables, the City Council tabled the discussion of the remaining items in the consultant memo to a Special Work Session scheduled for May 28th. Below are the remaining discussion items that staff is looking for direction from the City Council on which will then be shared with HKGi: • Principal and Accessory Use Tables – HKGi has prepared the proposed principal and accessory use tables for non-residential zoning districts. The consultants have made recommendations on revisions for naming of uses and optional additional non-residential uses to consider, as well as those uses for discussion of transitioning to Permitted with Standards. The consultants are not proposing to remove Conditional Uses altogether, but this would allow the City to apply the same conditions and would remove some barriers to development (i.e. application review time and expense). o Permitted Use has few additional standards beyond the usual lot and site requirements such as lot size, yard setbacks, height, impervious coverage, etc. o Conditional Use requires a public hearing to ensure that any potential impacts to surrounding properties are mitigated through conditions that are tailored to the specific use and circumstances. Page 2 of 2 o Permitted with Standards do not require a public hearing but do have additional performance requirements listed in code that must be evaluated by Planning staff to ensure they are being met before a proposed project may apply for a building permit. • Development Standards - HKGi reviewed existing ordinance language and discussed with the Planning Commission several other development standards for parking, signage, landscaping, exterior storage, and outdoor lighting which are summarized in their memo to the City Council. In July, HKGi will have a third Work Session with the Planning Commission focused on use specific standards, the subdivision code, and various procedures for land use applications. Budget Impact N/A Attachment Attachment A – HKGi Summary Memo Attachment B – 051225 WS Memo Attachment C – Draft Non-Residential Use Table Attachment D – Zoning Map Attachment E – Existing Sign District Table & Sign Code HKGi 800 Washington Ave N Suite 207, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401 (612) 338-0800 ~ www.hkgi.com CITY COUNCIL SUMMARY MEMO TO: Arden Hills City Council FROM: Jason Zimmerman and Kendra Ellner, Consulting Planners DATE: May 6, 2025 SUBJECT: Summary of Work Session #2 – Zoning Ordinance Update OVERVIEW On April 9th, HKGi held the second work session with the Planning Commission to discuss various recommended updates to the City’s Zoning and Subdivision ordinances. The report to the Planning Commission is attached. This summary memo is intended to brief the City Council on the material presented, the questions and discussions that occurred, and the general direction offered by the Planning Commission. WORK SESSION TOPICS Two broad topics and several sub-topics were discussed at the second work session; the discussion around each will be summarized in turn: • Nonresidential and Mixed Use Districts o Lot and Site Standards (District Requirements) o Principal and Accessory Use Tables (Land Use Charts) • Development Standards o Parking o Signage o Landscaping o Exterior Storage (Commercial) o Outdoor Lighting NONRESIDENTIAL AND MIXED USE DISTRICTS Lot Standards HKGi focused on the lot standards for the Business Park (former B -4) and Gateway Business zoning districts and recommended simplifying both the use types that were addressed as well as the minimum lot sizes that were associated with those uses. This would help reduce confusion as well as bring a number of existing nonconforming lots into compliance. Of the nine properties in the B-4 district, none meet the current 5 acre minimum. Of the 10 developed lots in the GB district, only one is more than 20 acres and only two are more than 10 acres. City Council Summary Memo – Work Session #2 – Zoning Ordinance Update– May 6, 2025 2 Existing Lot Standards District Use type Minimum Lot Area B-4 Mixed Use Project or Multiple Occupancy Center 5 acres Single Use Project or Freestanding Building 2 acres Gateway Business Non-Residential Uses 5 acres Mixed Use Project or Multiple Occupancy Center 20 acres Single Use Project or Freestanding Building 10 acres Proposed Lot Standards District Use type Minimum Lot Area Business Park --- 2 acres Gateway Business --- 5 acres Commissioners agreed that changing the minimum standards to allow more lots to be conforming was a good objective. They did not see the need to distinguish between multiple occupancy and single use projects, and supported the recommendations for updating the lot standards. Site Standards Looking at the site standards for nonresidential and mixed use zoning districts, HKGi recommended reducing the required front yard setback for the Mixed Use (B-2) zoning district to help support a pedestrian and bicycle friendly street environment. This would allow buildings to be placed closer to the street and could encourage parking lots to locate to the side or rear of buildings. The corner side yard setback in the B-2 district is already set at 20 feet – the front yard setback should match this. The 50 foot front yard setbacks in the Corridor Business (B-3) and Business Park (B-4) districts could also be reduced. Commissioners supported this approach to creating better pedestrian environments. HKGi noted that the maximum height of 35 feet is currently exceeded in both the I -1 and INST districts (Boston Scientific as well as Bethel and Northwestern). Staff noted that these campuses were likely approved via PUD and that allowed the exception. Comm issioners suggested that rather than increase the maximum height by-right across these districts, additional height could be allowed by Conditional Use Permit so that individual proposals could be evaluated. Many of the lots in the Business Park (B-4) zoning district have lot coverage in excess of the 25% allowed. HKGi recommended increasing this amount to 40% to make more of the lots conforming. On a related note, the minimum amounts of required landscaping in the B-4 and CC districts are currently 25% and 20% respectively. A low maximum lot coverage for structures (smaller building footprints) combined with a low minimum landscaped area may encourage extensive surface parking lots. HKGi recommended bringing these standards into better alignment in order to encourage the right amount of landscaping. Commissioners agreed. City Council Summary Memo – Work Session #2 – Zoning Ordinance Update– May 6, 2025 3 Principal and Accessory Use Tables HKGi proposed two use tables – one for Principal Uses and a second for Accessory Uses. The proposed Principal Use table was reorganized from an alphabetical list to one organized by use categories and sub-categories. The labels of some uses were revised to aid in understanding what use was being described, while a handful of uses that are not currently included were suggested as optional additions. Based on the updated zoning district purpose statements, HKGi suggested changes to the districts in which certain uses were allowed. Finally, for a number of uses HKGi recommended adjusting how a use was permitted – by-right, with standards, conditionally, or prohibited. The full tables showing all recommended changes are attached. A few specific comments about the use tables are noted here: 1. The way in which the current CC district is described allows for a wide range of uses – from residential to funeral home to school to restaurant to fitness clubs. This may have been appropriate when the district was envisioned as a mixed use community center, but with the current focus on government services the types of uses allowed has been significantly reduced. 2. It is recommended that multifamily be removed as a use from the GB district. If they City wants to support a multifamily development south of Round Lake , a better approach would be to rezone the parcel(s) appropriately. 3. HKGi suggests splitting Automotive Service Stations into Major and Minor in order to restrict more impactful activities from less intense districts such as the MU district. Similarly, dividing Retail Sales and Services between Large and Small would allow for more targeted placement of commercial activities. The appropriate threshold size to make the distinction between Large and Small would need to be determined. 4. Because the I-2 district was eliminated, Exterior Storage is recommended to be allowed as an accessory use in the I-1 as permitted with standards. This would accommodate the existing lumberyard. Commissions asked a few questions, but also requested time to review the use tables in more detail and provide comments or revisions following the meeting. One set of comments was received following the work session. DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS Parking HKGi reviewed the existing parking standards and proposed changes to (a) better align the uses with those in the Principal Use table, and (b) simplify and in some cases slightly reduce the amount of parking required for certain uses. Draft standards for Electric Vehicle (EV) charging stations were also shared, aiming to balance requirements for the installation of EV charging stations for some uses while only requiring other uses to be “EV ready.” Commissioners had a handful of questions about proposed changes in parking standards, but felt the approach to EV charging was appropriate for Arden Hills. City Council Summary Memo – Work Session #2 – Zoning Ordinance Update– May 6, 2025 4 Signage Staff and the Planning Commission shared that their perception was that a better approach to maximum sign area was needed, perhaps based on a percentage of the building façade. HKGi discussed moving away from the use of Sign Districts, what do not have clear boundaries to show which parcels are included, and instead moving to aligning sign standards with zoning districts, as is done in most communities. Accommodations would be made to ensure businesses that front on major roadways have additional sign area allowances. Dynamic displays were discussed and Commissioners were open to expanding their use beyond menu signs to other uses, but did want to have tight controls on potential impacts such as movement, flashing, brightness, etc. It was also requested that the use of lights as a form of “signage” or advertising be addressed. Landscaping HKGi noted that Arden Hills requires tree planting based on a formula tied to the gross square footage of the structure. In other communities that have recently updated their zoning codes, this approach has occasionally resulted in too many trees being required on-site, with a result that some may be crowded and not grow in a healthy manner and potentially need to be removed at a later date. These cities have taken a new approach which determines the number of trees required based on the amount of pervious or landscaped area on the site, in additional to any street or parking lot tree requirements. Commissioners were wary of reducing the number of trees that a developer might need to plant, but acknowledged that overplanting was also not a good outcome. HKGi will analyze recent developments in Arden Hills and compare the two approaches to tree requirements in order to understand how they might differ. Exterior Storage (Commercial) HKGi covered a handful of recommended code adjustments to help address the outdoor storage of commercial vehicles and equipment. Commissioners were supportive of the approach suggested. Outdoor Lighting Discussion of outdoor lighting centered on the need to control excessive lighting that might be a nuisance to adjacent residential properties. Commissioners suggested looking at Dark Sky lighting standards and incorporating them into the zoning code. OTHER UPDATES Commissioners asked about the likelihood that property rezonings will be needed. HKGi confirmed that this question will be addressed towards the end of the project. Staff has already identified a handful of properties that should be rezoned in order to come into alignment with the City’s Future Land Use Map in the 2040 Comprehensive Plan. Following changes to zoning standards being considered as part of the update, it may be that some lots fit better in another district. If so, these additional lots would be identified for potential rezoning actions. City Council Summary Memo – Work Session #2 – Zoning Ordinance Update– May 6, 2025 5 Public engagement is anticipated to take place through three avenues in the early summer. Staff will help prepare an update for the City newsletter to be published in June/July. This update will contain a link to a project page on the City’s web page, wher e a summary of the work that is being done will be posted. HKGi will work with staff to develop targeted questions that address topics regulated through the City’s zoning requirements as a way to gather additional feedback on how the code should be updated. NEXT STEPS The third work session, tentatively scheduled for June, will focus on use specific standards, the subdivision code, and various procedures for land use applications. Draft code language associated with the topics that were discussed at the second work session will be shared with the Planning Commission at that time. ATTACHMENT • Memo to the Planning Commission dated April 9, 2025 HKGi 800 Washington Ave N Suite 103, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401 (612) 338-0800 ~ www.hkgi.com PLANNING COMMISSION REPORT TO: City of Arden Hills Planning Commission FROM: Jason Zimmerman and Kendra Ellner, Consulting Planners DATE: April 3, 2025 SUBJECT: Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 MEETING DATE: April 9, 2025 OVERVIEW HKGi was selected by the City of Arden Hills to complete an update to the existing Zoning and Subdivision ordinances. The Planning Commission, as the body most involved with the application of the code, will help conduct a technical review of the proposed changes and provide recommendations to the City Council. The first work session covered some of the foundational elements upon which the rest of the ordinances will be built – base zoning districts, residential uses, and the required lot and site standards. BACKGROUND The current zoning and subdivision ordinances were adopted in 1993 but have been amended several times since – occasionally resulting in inconsistencies and poor formatting. In addition, procedures and some content need to be updated to reflect modern administration and new tools and technologies. HKGi has conducted a full evaluation of the current code and will be working throughout 2025 to meet with the Planning Commission and City Council in order to revise the organization and contents of the zoning and subdivision chapters. The project has been broken down into four phases: Phase 1 – Project Kick Off and Understanding [COMPLETE] Phase 2 – Diagnose the Current Ordinances and Frame Approach [COMPLETE] Phase 3 – Prepare Draft Codes Work Session #1 – Zoning Districts and Uses [COMPLETE] Work Session #2 – General Development Standards and Provisions [WE ARE HERE] Work Session #3 – Development Procedures and Subdivision Regulations Phase 4 – Final Ordinance Adoption and Implementation Each work session with the Planning Commission will be focused on a handful of topics. The City Council will be briefed after each meeting on the discussion and recommendations of the Planning Commission. A web page is being developed and targeted stakeholder groups will be involved throughout the year as needed to provide input on various topics. Consideration and adoption of the new code is anticipated for late fall of 2025. Planning Commission Meeting – Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 – April 9, 2025 2 WORK SESSION TOPICS At the first work session, the Planning Commission provided feedback on the City’s zoning districts, district purpose statements, housing types, and lot and site standards for residential uses. The draft zoning text for these topics is attached to this memo. There are two broad topics and several sub-topics that will be discussed at the second work session: • Nonresidential and Mixed Use Districts o Lot and Site Standards (District Requirements) o Principal and Accessory Use Tables (Land Use Charts) • Development Standards o Parking o Signage o Landscaping o Exterior Storage (Commercial) o Outdoor Lighting Nonresidential and Mixed Use Districts Lot and Site Standards Currently, most lot and site standards are contained within one large District Requirements chart. The first work session examined the standards for residential uses and recommended ways in which this table could be simplified. HKGi has the following recommendations related to this section of code for nonresidential and mixed use districts: 1. Both the Business Park (former B-4) and Gateway Business zoning districts distinguish between “Mixed Use Project or Multiple Occupancy Center” and “Single Use Project or Free Standing Building” uses. This is not a typical distinction in a district requirements chart and we are struggling to understand the purpose. Our recommendation is to simplify these districts and remove the callouts to these two types of development. 2. Given the simplification of number 1 above, we are recommending the minimum lot sizes for the BP and GB districts be reduced. Currently, the B-4 district requires 5 acres for mixed use / multiple occupancy buildings and 2 acres for single use / free standing buildings. Of the nine properties in this district, none of them meet the 5 acres minimum (even though most are multi-tenant buildings). Only five are greater than 2 acres. Keeping the minimum lot sizes as they are currently stated makes each lot nonconforming. In the GB district, minimum lot sizes of 20 acres (mixed use / multiple occupancy buildings), 10 acres (single use / free standing buildings), and 5 acres (other nonresidential uses) are required. Planning Commission Meeting – Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 – April 9, 2025 3 Of the ten developed lots, only one is more than 20 acres. Two of the remaining nine are more than 10 acres. Again, keeping the current minimum requirements creates nonconforming lots. 3. Looking at site standards, many of the nonresidential front yard setbacks require 40 to 50 feet. This is on the large side for most communities we work with. At a minimum, reducing the front yard setback in the Mixed Use (former B-2) district below 50 feet would help establish a more inviting pedestrian experience as redevelopment occurs. If any front yard setbacks are revised, the corner side yard setback should be reduced accordingly to match it. The MU corner side yard setback is already set at 20 feet. 4. In most nonresidential districts, height is limited to 35 feet. This is already being exceeded in the I-1 district (Boston Scientific) and the INST district (at both Bethel and Northwestern). It may be appropriate to increase the maximum height in these two districts. 5. The maximum lot coverage (for structures) is set unusually low in the Business Park district at 25%. In fact, it appears the majority of the current lots have coverage closer to 40%, making them nonconforming. This current percentage should be increased. 6. Relatedly, the required amount of landscaped area in the BP and CC districts is quite low at 25% and 20% respectively. A low maximum lot coverage for structures combined with a low minimum landscape area may encourage extensive surface parking lots. Adjusting these two requirements in a coordinated fashion would help reduce the chances of this happening and encourage the right amount of landscaping in targeted districts. Barring indications that other lot or site standards need to be addressed, the majority of the requirements have been left as they are. A second set of draft tables for lot and site standards are included with this memo as a starting point for discussion. Principal and Accessory Use Tables Examination of the current Land Use Chart has two parts. The first is to look closely at which uses are called out in the chart and evaluate in which districts they are allowed to locate. The second part is to determine how they are allowed (by-right, permitted with standards, conditional, etc.). HKGi began the revision of a principal use table by grouping uses into categories such as Residential; Public, Social & Institutional; Commercial, etc., and then by sub-categories such as Household Living, Group Living, Lodging, Retail Sales & Services, etc. This helps a user navigate the table more quickly. Second, where possible HKGi revised the list of uses, sometimes consolidating similar uses into a more general line item and sometimes suggesting the addition of new uses that are missing. Planning Commission Meeting – Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 – April 9, 2025 4 Third, for each use it was determined which zoning district was the correct “fit” given the history of zoning in Arden Hills as well as the updated purpose statements for the zoning district. In some cases, uses did not seem appropriate for a given district. In other, a use seemed to align with the intent of the district. Fourth, the way in which a use is allowed was revisited. HKGi is advancing a first draft of use permissions – prohibited, permitted, permitted with standards, and conditional. Finally, a shorter table of accessory uses was prepared as a complement to the principal use table. The full tables can be found in the attachments. New or modified language is shown in RED. A red X means the permission for that use in that district is suggested to be removed. A BLUE notation with a strikethrough indicates where a permission was changed. A few specific comments or questions about the use tables are noted below: 1. The way in which the current CC district was described allowed for a wide range of uses – from residential to funeral home to school to restaurant to fitness clubs. This may have been appropriate when the district was envisioned as a mixed use community center, but with the current focus on government services the types of uses allowed has been significantly reduced. 2. We recommend removing multifamily as a use from the GB district. If they City wants to support a multifamily development south of Round Lake a better approach would be to rezone the parcel(s) appropriately. 3. We recommend splitting Automotive Service Stations into Major and Minor in order to restrict more impactful activities from less intense districts such as the MU district. Similarly, dividing Retail Sales and Services between Large and Small would allow for more targeted placement of commercial activities. 4. A few new uses are included for consideration: Liquor Store, Animal Veterinary Clinic, Off0site Service Business, Construction Contractor Yard, Personal Storage Facility, and Outdoor Commercial Recreation (as a principal use). 5. A number of specific principal uses stand out and raise questions: a. Boarding House is listed as a current use. Should this be retained? If so, should it be allowed in the R-4 and MU districts? b. Hospitals are listed in the use table but not allowed in any districts. Which districts, if any, should allow hospitals? GB and I-FLEX? c. The current code makes provisions for Micro Breweries and Micro Distilleries, but does not allow Breweries or Distilleries. Should they be allowed? d. Nursery seems to be incorrectly allowed in all residential districts. Allow in I-FLEX? e. Pawn Shops are strangely only allowed in the POS district. That seems inappropriate – where should they be allowed? I-FLEX? f. Public Use is currently allowed by conditional use in almost all districts, yet public facilities are only located in the CC district as well as the MU district (future fire station). Planning Commission Meeting – Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 – April 9, 2025 5 We recommend making this use permitted in the nonresidential districts and allowing it in the CD district to accommodate existing uses. g. There is no explicit Park / Open Space use listed. We recommend adding this and allow it by right in the POS district. 6. A handful of changes are recommended for accessory uses: a. Remove some uses that are listed as accessory but are really principal uses: Business Services; Clubs, Sports and Fitness; Personal Services. A Dog Run is an accessory use that does not need to be called out but can be handled similar to other accessory structures/uses such as sheds, gazebos, play equipment, etc. b. We recommend allowing Drive-up Windows and Solar Energy Systems in additional districts. c. Because the I-2 district was eliminated, we recommend allowing Exterior Storage in the I-1 as permitted with standards. This would accommodate the existing lumberyard. QUESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION • Are there questions or concerns around any of the recommended lot and site standard changes? • Are there other changes to the principal and accessory use tables that should be considered? Development Standards As part of this code update, reviewing the City’s current development standards provides the opportunity to assess whether or not there are topics that need further regulation or increased flexibility. Beyond general reformatting and clarification edits, HKGi has identified key topics that necessitate a policy discussion for the updates. These topics include: Parking, Signage, Landscaping, Non-residential Exterior Storage, and Outdoor Lighting. Background on the existing provisions will be provided, with a recommended approach for the update. Commissioners’ feedback on the proposed approach and discussion of any other topics of concern are welcome for consideration in providing direction on the code update. Parking • Minimum Parking Requirements Regulating minimum parking requirements ensures that all uses provide sufficient on-site/off- street parking to mitigate traffic and circulation concerns. The current minimum parking requirements table has been identified as a necessary element to update for this topic, due to inconsistencies with the use table. There are also some concerns that certain uses may be required to provide more parking than necessary. While there is no perfect calculation to determine the appropriate number of stalls to require and the requirements can be highly customizable, it is beneficial to understand the current parking demands for different uses. During the meeting, we will explore adjusting some of the use terminology to be more generalized and consistent with the use table for easier administration of the code. The Planning Commission Meeting – Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 – April 9, 2025 6 minimum number of parking stalls required will also be reviewed to be updated with more current parking demands and best practices. In preparation, please consider your experience and observations in the community regarding the amount of parking required versus what is actually utilized for certain uses. See the existing and proposed parking tables below. Existing Parking Requirements Use Required No. of Spaces Bingo Halls 1 for each 1.5 max. seating capacity Bowling Alleys 5 for each lane plus spaces for related uses Business & Professional Office 1 for each 250 sq. ft. of gross floor area Call Center 1 for each 150 sq. ft. of gross floor area Churches, Theaters, Auditoriums, Mortuaries, and Other Places of Assembly 1 for every 3 seats (based on design capacity) Clinics 1 for each doctor or dentist plus 1 for each nurse, technician, or professional and 1 for each 200 sq. ft. of gross floor area Daycare, Nursery, and Pre-School Facility 1 for each teacher or employee plus 1 for each 5 individuals receiving care (design capacity) Dwelling, single and two-family 2 for each dwelling unit Dwelling, multiple family 1.1 per efficiency and 1 bedroom dwelling units; 2 for each 2+ bedroom dwelling units Inside Motor vehicle Leasing or Sales 1 for each 250 sq. ft. of gross floor area used for showrooms, sales, and offices Motels/Hotels 1 for each employee plus 1 for each unit Multiple Occupancy Structure 1 for each space required for each separate use Other Business and Industry 1 for each employee on major shift plus 1 for each vehicle used in conducting the business or 1 for each 1,000 sq. ft. of floor area, whichever is greater Recreation Facility 1 for each 1.5 persons at design capacity Residential Facility or Group Home 1 for every 4 residents plus 1 for each employee on major shift plus 1 for each on-call medical professional Restaurants, Bars 1 for every 2 seats Restaurant, Fast Food 15 stacking spaces for each customer pickup window plus 1 for each 2 seats Retail Sales 1 for each 150 sq. ft. of gross retail sales floor space Schools, Elementary, and Middle School 1 for each staff member plus 3 per classroom Schools, Secondary 1 for each school employee plus one space per 4 students Service Station 3 for each enclosed bay plus 1 for each employee on peak work shift Uses Not Specifically Noted Including Public Uses As determined by City Council after recommendation by Planning Commission. Planning Commission Meeting – Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 – April 9, 2025 7 Proposed Parking Requirements (notable changes in red) Use Required No. of Spaces Automotive Service Station 3 for each enclosed bay plus 1 for each employee on peak work shift Business and Professional Office 1 for each 250 sq. ft. of gross floor area Clinic, Medical Office 3 for each 250 sq. ft. of gross floor area Daycare Facility 1 for each teacher or employee plus 1 for each 5 individuals receiving care (building occupancy) Drive-thru 15 stacking spaces for each customer pickup window plus 1 for each 2 seats Dwelling, single-unit and two-unit 2 for each dwelling unit Dwelling, multi-unit 1 per efficiency and one bedroom dwelling units; 2 for each 2+ bedroom dwelling units Hotels/ Motels 1 space for each guest unit; additional facilities (i.e. restaurant or assembly space etc.) shall be calculated within this table according to the use, added to the total Multi-tenant Buildings Sum of the spaces required for each separate use Other Business and Industry 1 for each employee on major shift plus 1 for each vehicle used in conducting the business or 1 for each 1,000 sq. ft. of floor area, whichever is greater Place of Assembly (Religious Venues, Theaters, Auditoriums, Mortuaries, and other Places of Assembly) 1 for every 4 persons based on maximum building occupancy, plus any additional spaces required for additional uses Recreation, Indoor Commercial 1 for each 2 persons base on maximum building capacity Recreation, Outdoor Commercial 50 spaces per field or sports court plus 1 space per 3 fixed seats for spectator area Residential Facility 1 for every 4 residents plus 1 for each employee on major shift plus 1 for each on-call medical professional Restaurants 1 for every 4 persons based on maximum building occupancy Retail Sales and Service (small and large) 1 for each 250 sq. ft. of gross floor space School, Elementary or Middle 1 for each staff member plus 3 per classroom School, Secondary 1 for each school employee plus one space per 4 students School, Specialized Education 1 for every 4 students Uses Not Specifically Noted Including Public Uses As determined by the Zoning Administrator. Planning Commission Meeting – Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 – April 9, 2025 8 • Electric Vehicle (EV) Standards Electric vehicles are an emerging transportation technology that has been driving demand for more charging stations available to the public in recent years. Many cities are exploring incorporating standards into their codes to allow or require developments to provide EV charging stations. There are a range of options for communities to explore when adding these standards to their code. The spectrum typically starts with discretionary standards that generally allow EV chargers with basic parameters. It can then increase to requiring certain types of uses to be EV ready, which means requiring the installation of the electrical infrastructure for the eventual EV charging station to be installed. The more prescriptive regulations can directly lead to requiring the installation of EV charging stations; these standards often vary depending on the scale of the use. It is also helpful to understand that there are different charger levels demonstrated by the following graphic: trigger Since Arden Hills is starting from scratch, HKGi recommends a combination approach for residential and nonresidential uses that combines requirements for some EV charging stations to be installed with those only requiring uses to be EV ready. The initial draft language is proposed below. We will look to the Planning Commission to help determine if this is the appropriate level of intervention or if there is a desire to increase or scale back the requirements. Planning Commission Meeting – Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 – April 9, 2025 9 Subd. 1 Electric Vehicle Charging Stations (EVCS) A. Electric vehicle charging stations are allowed in all zoning districts. B. All new single-unit or two-unit dwelling developments shall be provided with an EV ready Level 1 or higher wall plug for charging an electric vehicle. C. Minimum number of EVCS required. 1. For all multi-unit dwellings and nonresidential developments with new parking areas, and existing parking areas proposed to be expanded or reconstructed by more than 25%, the following are required to be provided: a. 5% of the parking area shall be EV ready; b. At least two level one or higher EVCS shall be installed; plus c. At least one accessible parking stall with access to an EVCS level one or higher. D. Accessible Parking Spaces. An EVCS will be considered accessible if it can serve as an accessible parking space as defined and required by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). It is not necessary to designate the EVCS exclusively for the use of vehicles parked in the accessible parking space and it shall not count toward required ADA parking requirements. E. Reductions to EVCS requirements. 1. This number may be reduced by the City if proof can be provided that: a. The cost of installing the EVCS required by this Chapter exceeds five percent of the total project cost; or b. It is not feasible to provide sufficient electrical capacity at the site to power the EVCS. F. EVCS shall be designed and installed to meet the following minimum design requirements: 1. EVCS must be securely installed and protected within any of the following methods: a. A parking island; mounted to an adjacent pedestal, wall, or similar structure. b. Free standing EVCS shall be protected by bollards, structures, or curb. 2. EVCS must be located adjacent to the designated parking spaces in a garage or parking lot, as long as the devices do not encroach into the required dimensions of the parking space (length, width, and height clearances). 3. EVCS shall be setback at least three feet from any property line. However, upon written request from the property owner, the City may reduce this setback requirement pursuant to a finding of necessity and public convenience. 4. Where EVCS is located within three feet of the public right-of-way, the location must be approved by the City. 5. EVCS shall be designed and located so as not impede pedestrian walkways or vehicle circulation. 6. EVCS cords must be retractable or have the ability to be hung sufficiently above the ground when not in use. The cords shall not extend across sidewalks or trails during charging. Planning Commission Meeting – Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 – April 9, 2025 10 7. EVCS must be installed per manufacturer specification, with contact information provided on each charger for reporting or maintenance concerns. 8. EVCS must comply with all applicable building codes and relevant ADA requirements. 9. Any EVCS in a single-unit or two-unit dwelling shall be stored on the exterior wall of the home, in the garage, or on a freestanding pole with footings within the property adjacent to the parking area. 10. EVCS shall be maintained in good condition and functional at all times, including free of any rust. When an EVSE is not operational for 30 consecutive days, it shall be removed or have a repair plan approved by the City through the procedures in Section 1370. Signage The Sign Code was updated fairly recently to comply with the Supreme Court ruling in Reed vs. Town of Gilbert (2015) acknowledging that governments cannot regulate sign content because it's protected as free speech under the First Amendment. The Sign Code is currently separate from the Zoning Code; through this code update it is proposed to be included in the Development Standards chapter for easier administration. HKGi suggests changes to allow more signage for businesses, simplify the City's review and permitting process, and make permanent sign regulations more flexible. We'll discuss the existing sign table to explore adjusting standards for nonresidential districts, including an overview of signage size, type, height, and illumination. We'll also briefly discuss improvements to the sign area calculation and propose to allow more dynamic display signs while ensuring the standards are appropriate and consistent. The Planning Commission should review the attached existing sign table and consider what signage looks like in other communities that could be utilized as an example to further explore. Landscaping Ensuring sufficient landscaping requirements can improve the character and natural environment in a community. However, there are times when landscaping requirements are too restrictive and create unnecessary barriers to development. HKGi has observed that this section of the code could use further review on the minimum tree planting requirements. Currently the tree planting requirements are related to the gross square footage of a building. For larger buildings with a large footprint and/or multiple floors this can require overplanting of a lot, resulting in challenges to find space for all of the required vegetation and ultimately impacting the health of the trees. Alternative approaches base tree requirements on the amount of area available to plant and use a ratio of number of trees to square feet of landscaped area to establish the appropriate number for the site. Planning Commission Meeting – Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 – April 9, 2025 11 Exterior Storage (Commercial) It is common for nonresidential properties to have exterior storage concerns, whether it’s an excessive amount or an unsightly appearance of vehicles and other materials stored on the property. The current code language is very general and vague, making it difficult for staff to administer and enforce: • Vehicles, including but not limited to cars, trucks, buses and RV's parked and/or stored in public view for more than a period of seven (7) days shall be prohibited unless allowed by the permitted business or industrial use, except as regulated in Section 1325.12. • Inoperable and Unlicensed Vehicles. Exterior storage of passenger vehicles, commercial vehicles, recreational vehicles, trucks, boats and watercraft that are in an inoperable condition or are unlicensed shall not be parked outdoors in the city for a period exceeding seven days. During the meeting we will discuss the direction that HKGi recommends pursuing for the proposed elements as an approach to increasing these standards: • Setting a maximum percentage of the property to be allocated to accessory storage. • Regulating overnight parking of various types of vehicles by differentiating between company vehicles, customer vehicles, scrap vehicles, semitrailers, etc. • Requiring the location of accessory storage and certain vehicles in the side or rear yard, including provisions for what is allowed if the property is located on a corner lot. • Requiring increased screening provisions for accessory storage or vehicles from public view. • Limiting the height of the accessory storage or vehicles with additional toppers. Outdoor Lighting Arden Hills lighting standards are very brief and generally lack detail. HKGi believes they could be dialed up to ensure that lighting is not impacting health, safety, and welfare. Currently the code regulates illumination as: • Any light or combination of lights shall not cast light that exceeds a meter reading of one foot candle on the travel lanes of adjoining public streets or 0.4 foot candles on adjoining residential property. HKGi recommends including provisions that state that lighting shall not impact visibility and also prohibit flashing, moving, or intermittent lighting which could be hazardous. Another recommendation is to reduce the 0.4 foot candle allowance at the property line to zero to ensure no lighting is disrupting adjacent properties. In addition, dynamic displays are currently only allowed on drive-thru menu signs. This restriction is out of touch with other metro communities and should be expanded to allow reasonable use of dynamic displays in nonresidential districts. QUESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION • Are there any concerns with the proposed approaches for the identified topics? Consider if some topics are too restrictive or too flexible. Planning Commission Meeting – Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Revisions – Work Session #2 – April 9, 2025 12 • Are there any development standards or aspects of the identified topics that should be further analyzed or are in need of updates? • Aside from the topics identified, are you seeing any other concerns in the community that could be addressed through development standards? What about regulations around Fences/Screening? NEXT STEPS Following Work Session #2, HKGi will draft revisions to the zoning code text and review the proposed changes with staff. A summary of the session will be forwarded to the City Council. Work Session #3 will focus on use specific standards as well as recommended changes to the general procedures and the subdivision code. ATTACHMENTS • DRAFT Zoning Text from Work Session #1 • DRAFT Lot Standards Table • DRAFT Site Standards Table • DRAFT Principal Use Table • DRAFT Accessory Use Table • Existing Sign Table Page 1 of 3 AGENDA ITEM – 3F MEMORANDUM DATE: May 12, 2025 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers FROM: Jessica Jagoe, City Administrator SUBJECT: Zoning Code Update Discussion Budgeted Amount: Actual Amount: Funding Source: N/A N/A N/A Council Should Consider Council should discuss and provide direction to staff on zoning code updates within HKGi Summary of Work Session #2 memo and recommendations brought forward for consideration. Background At the April 9th Planning Commission meeting, the consultants from HKGi presented their second memo for the zoning and subdivision ordinance updates which included discussion topics for non-residential districts and development standards such as parking, signage, landscaping, exterior storage, and outdoor lighting. Included with this memo as Attachment A is the summary memo prepared by HKGi that provides comments and recommendations for City Council consideration. This process is currently in Phase 3, which is when the technical updating and drafting of regulations occurs. As part of the tasks in this phase, the consultants will prepare minor code update language for the Planning Commission and City Council. Based on the Council feedback, HKGi will also start in this phase to conduct community engagement, including online mapping tools, creation of a project page on City’s website, community in-person events, and/or other outreach tools. Page 2 of 3 As a next step, staff is looking for direction from the City Council on the discussion items that will then be shared with HKGi. This feedback will be shared with the consultants and incorporated into the draft ordinance language that is being prepared. Items for discussion include consideration of the following: • Lot Standards – For the Business Park (former B-4) and Gateway Business zoning districts and recommended simplifying the minimum lot sizes that were associated with those uses (Attachment B). • Site Standards - HKGi is recommending reducing front yard setbacks in Mixed Use (former B-2), Corridor Business (former B-3) and Business Park (former B-4) to create pedestrian and bicycle-friendly environments. In addition, there are suggested standards for lot coverage and landscape area to align with off-street parking requirements and balance surface parking needs with landscaping (Attachment C). • Principal and Accessory Use Tables – HKGi has prepared the proposed principal and accessory use tables for non-residential zoning districts. The consultants have made recommendations on revisions for naming of uses and optional additional non-residential uses to consider, as well as those uses for discussion of transitioning to Permitted with Standards. The consultants are not proposing to remove Conditional Uses altogether, but this would allow the City to apply the same conditions and would remove some barriers to development (i.e. application review time and expense). o Permitted Use has few additional standards beyond the usual lot and site requirements such as lot size, yard setbacks, height, impervious coverage, etc. o Conditional Use requires a public hearing to ensure that any potential impacts to surrounding properties are mitigated through conditions that are tailored to the specific use and circumstances. Page 3 of 3 o Permitted with Standards do not require a public hearing but do have additional performance requirements listed in code that must be evaluated by Planning staff to ensure they are being met before a proposed project may apply for a building permit. • Development Standards - HKGi reviewed existing ordinance language and discussed with the Planning Commission several other development standards for parking, signage, landscaping, exterior storage, and outdoor lighting which are summarized in their memo to the City Council. In June, HKGi will have a third work session with the Planning Commission focused on use specific standards, the subdivision code, and various procedures for land use applications. Budget Impact N/A Attachment Attachment A – HKGi Summary Memo Attachment B – Draft Lot Standards Table Attachment C – Draft Site Standards Table Attachment D – Draft Non-Residential Use Table Attachment E – Existing Sign District Table Mi x e d U s e R- 1 R- 2 R- 3 R- 4 MU ( B - 2 ) NB CB ( B - 3 ) BP ( B - 4 ) GB I- 1 I- F L E X CC IN S T PO S CD Re s i d e n t i a l U s e s Ho u s e h o l d L i v i n g Dw e l l i n g , s i n g l e - u n i t P P P P X Dw e l l i n g , t w o - u n i t C PS C P PU D P PU D X C P Dw e l l i n g , t o w n h o m e / r o w h o u s e C X C PS PU D P PU D P Dw e l l i n g , m u l t i - u n i t ( s m a l l s c a l e ) C P C P C PS C C X C X Dw e l l i n g , m u l t i - u n i t ( l a r g e s c a l e ) C P C PS C X C X C X Dw e l l i n g : l i v e - w o r k u n i t C Dw e l l i n g , c o t t a g e c o u r t y a r d PS PS PS Ma n u f a c t u r e d h o m e p a r k C C C C Gr o u p L i v i n g Nu r s i n g h o m e Ca r e f a c i l i t y C C C C PU D C C X Do r m i t o r y / r e s i d e n c e h a l l C X PU D X C P Re s i d e n t i a l f a c i l i t y , s t a t e l i c e n s e d s e r v i n g 1 - 6 P P P P P P Re s i d e n t i a l f a c i l i t y , s t a t e l i c e n s e d s e r v i n g 7 - 1 6 C C C C C C Lo d g i n g Bo a r d i n g h o u s e C X C X C X C PU D C C X Ho t e l / m o t e l C P C X C X C Pu b l i c , S o c i a l , & I n s t i t u t i o n a l U s e s Da y c a r e f a c i l i t y P P P P P P P Hi g h e r e d u c a t i o n c a m p u s C Ho s p i t a l P P Mo r t u a r y / f u n e r a l h o m e P P C X Ho u s e o f w o r s h i p Pl a c e o f a s s e m b l y C C C C C C C C X C C Pu b l i c u s e C C C C C P C C P C P C P C P C P C P P P Sc h o o l , g e n e r a l e d u c a t i o n C C C P C P PS PS X Sc h o o l , s p e c i a l i z e d e d u c a t i o n C C C C X Co m m e r c i a l U s e s Fo o d , B e v e r a g e , & I n d o o r E n t e r t a i n m e n t Br e w p u b C PS C PS C PS Li q u o r S t o r e P P P Mi c r o b r e w e r y C PS C PS C PS C X C Mi c r o d i s t i l l e r y C PS C PS C PS C X C Re s t a u r a n t P C P P P X C X Th e a t e r C P C X Re t a i l S a l e s & S e r v i c e s Au t o m o t i v e ve h i c l e sa l e s , le a s i n g , a n d r e n t a l s C C Au t o m o t i v e s e r v i c e s t a t i o n (m a j o r ) C X C C C Au t o m o t i v e s e r v i c e s t a t i o n ( m i n o r ) C C C C Pr i n c i p a l U s e s Di s t r i c t s Re s i d e n t i a l Co m m e r c i a l In d u s t r i a l Ot h e r Mixed Use R-1 R-2 R-3 R-4 MU (B-2)NB CB (B-3)BP (B-4)GB I-1 I-FLEX CC INST POS CD Cannabis, mezzobusiness C Cannabis, microbusiness C Cannabis, retail sales C Nursery C X C X C X C X P Pawn shop P P X Retail sales and service (large)P P X P P X C X Retail sales and service (small)P P P P C X Studio P C P P P C X Thrift Store C C Personal Services Animal veterinary clinic PS PS P P Clinic, medical office P P P P P P X P C X Club, sports and fitness P P P P P P C X Dog kennel, commercial C C Dry cleaning and laundry, pick-up station C Financial institution and service P P P P P X P X P C X Dry cleaning and Laundry, self-service C C C Off-site service business P P P Personal services P C PS P P P X C X Business & Technical Services Business service P P P P P P C X Office P P P P P P P P X Research and development facility C C X C C P P P P C X C Research animals C X C C Industrial Uses Cannabis, light manufacturing C Cannabis, testing facility C Cannabis, wholesaling C Construction contractor yard PS Lower-potency hemp edible, light manufacturing C Manufacturing and processing: Class I P P P Manufacturing and processing: Class II PS Solar energy system C Storage facility, personal P P Warehousing C C P C Natural Resource & Agriculture Uses Cannabis, commecial agriculture C Recreation & Open Space Uses Commercial recreation - indoor P PS P P P Residential Commercial Industrial Other Mixed Use R-1 R-2 R-3 R-4 MU (B-2)NB CB (B-3)BP (B-4)GB I-1 I-FLEX CC INST POS CD Commercial recreation - outdoor C C Park / open space P Utility and Transportation Uses Truck garage C Utility distribution line P P P P P P P P P P P P P P Utility substation C Utility transmission line C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C Residential Commercial Industrial Other Mixed Use R-1 R-2 R-3 R-4 MU (B-2)NB CB (B-3)BP (B-4)GB I-1 I-FLEX CC INST POS CD Antenna, Dish or Tower C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C Business services Clubs, sports & fitness Commercial recreation - outdoor P Day care, family - 10 or less P P P P P X Day care, group family - 14 or less C C C C C X Dog run Drive-up window PS PS PS P PS PS Home occupation: Class I P P P P P P-X Home occupation: Class II C C C C C P-X Lower-potency hemp edible, retail sales C C C C C Manufacturing & processing: Class I P X P P P Personal services Retail sales & service P P P Solar energy system P P P P P P P P P P P P P Storage, exterior PS Utility distribution line P Accessory Uses Districts Residential Commercial Industrial Other ST O W E A V E LAKE V A L E N T I N E R D RE D F O X R D GR E Y F O X R D IN G E R S O N R D ROUND LAKE RD W AMBLE D R SIEMS CT SNELLING AVE N CO L L E E N A V E GL E N P A U L A V E TI L L E R L N H A M L I N E VE N U S A V E TH O M D R AR D E N V I E W D R GLENARDEN RD CHATHAM A V E AM B L E R D NO B L E R D GR A M S I E R D AR D E N P L GR A N T R D OA K A V E ED G E W A T E R A V E JE R R O L D A V E DUNLAP ST N HA R R I E T A V E FL O R A L D R W GL E N V I E W A V E KA R T H L A K E D R GA T E W A Y B L V D W Y N C R E S T CA R L T O N D R F O R E S T L N PRIOR AVE N CU M M I N G S P A R K D R RO Y A L L N KA T I E L N PINE TREE DR FAIRVIEW AVE N RIDGEWOOD RD CR Y S T A L A V E PLEASANT DR ARDEN OAKSDR V A L E N T I N E A V E BENT O N W A Y IN D I A N O A K S T R L SKILESLN BRIAR BE C K M A N A V E LA M E T T I L N M C C R A C K E N L N KEITHSON DR ASBURY AVE N NU R S E R Y H I L L L N BU S S A R D C T DA W N CI R W JAMES AVE JA N E T C T CANNON GL E N H I L L R D NORMA AVE ARDENVIEWCT R O Y KA T I E C T GLENARDENCT RIDGEWOOD C T KARTH LAK E C I R GALE CIR MC C L U N G DR WYNCRE S T LN SAND E E N R D PA R K S H O R E D R EI D E C I R NORTH-WOODS DR NU R S E R Y H I L L C T CUMM I N G S L N VALENT I N E CT IN G E R S O N C T C O L L E E N C T GLE N V I E W CT HUN T E R S CT SHORELINELN PASCAL AVE N LAKE LN N CONNEL L Y AVE TH O M C T AMB L E CIR CHATHAM CT COLLEE N CIR ROLLING HILLS RD AR D E N OA K S C T NORMA CIR INDIAN PL ED G E W A T E R A V E NORMAAV E TI L L E R L N SNELLING A V E N DUNLAP ST N ARDEN P L S K I L E S L N FAIRVIEW AVE N HAMLINE AVE N G L E N H I L L R D WYN R I D G E PL E A S A N T CI R AR D E N IN D I A N O A K S C T JAMES CIR DELLVIEW AVEDELLVIEW AVE DELLWOOD ST GA T E W A Y CT VA L E N T I N E CR E S T R D BRUEBER R Y LN BR I A R K N O L L C I R DELLWOOD AVE LAMETTI CIR WALDEN PL WE D G E W O O D CI R PR I O R AV E IN D I A N OA K S C I R CHAT H A M CIR L A K E J O H A N N A B L V D LAKE JOHANNA BLVD RID G E ED G E W A T E R A V E FAIRVIEW AVE N FERNWOOD ST SNELLING AVE N SHORELINELN K A T I E L N CO U N T Y R O A D D W SHORE W O O D DR LA K E L N CO U N T Y R O A D E W LAKEJO H A N N A BLVD GL E N P A U L A V E CLEVELAND AVE N NEW BR I G H T O N R D NEW BRIGHTON RD HU D S O N R D TH O M D R CLEVELAND AVE N BRIGHTON WAY NEW BRIGHTON RD INTERSTATE 35W CO U N T Y R O A D E 2 W C O U N T Y R O A D E 2 W LAKEVIE W C TC H A T H A M A V E SIEMS CTAR D E N P L GLE N ARDENRD OLD SNELLING ARDEN OAKS DR SNELLING AVE N OLD HIGHWAY 10 OLD SNE L L I N G VE N U S A V E INTERSTATE 35W LA K E V A L E N T I N E R D INTERSTATE 35W ROUNDL A K E R D W OLD H I G H W A Y 1 0 LAK E S H O R E P L IN T E R S T A T E 6 9 4 IN T E R S T A T E 6 9 4 HIGH W A Y 1 0 CO U N T Y R O A D 9 6 W CO U N T Y R O A D 9 6 W CO U N T Y R O A D I W CO U N T Y R O A D I W LEXINGTON AVE N LEXINGTON AVE N KNO L L D R VISTA CT DA W N CI R E COLLEEN A V E ARDENVIEWDR CO U N T Y R O A D F W INNOVATION WAY (Private) FERNWOOD ST PL E A S A N T D R AMB L E D R CO U N T Y R O A D 9 6 W LEXINGTON AVE NLEXINGTON AVE N D R CT BO S T O N S C I E N T I F I C D R ( P r i v a t e ) CO U N T Y R O A D E W LEXINGTON AVE N BENT O N W A Y AV E IN G E R S O N R D AVE N WOOD RD CO U N T Y R O A D E HAMLINE AVE N HAMLINE AVE N P r i v ate KATI E L N KE I T H S O N D R AL HILLS DR La k e J o h a n n a Ro u n d L a k e Va l e n t i n e L a k e La k e J o s e p h i n e Ka r t h L a k e Su n f i s h L a k e Li t t l e L a k e J o h a n n a Ri c e C r e e k Th e zo n i n g di s t r i c t de s i g n a t i o n s re p r e s e n t e d on th i s m a p co r r e s p o n d to th e Ci t y o f Ar d e n H i l l s of f i c i a l Zo n i n g Ma p . Qu e s t i o n s co n c e r n i n g th e Zo n i n g Ma p sh o u l d be di r e c t e d to Ci t y Ha l l . Zo n i n g de s i g n a t i o n s ar e su b j e c t to ch a n g e . Pl e a s e re f e r to th e Zo n i n g Co d e fo r co m p l e t e in f o r m a t i o n . Ad o p t e d : Ap r i l 12 , 1 9 9 3 Re p ri n t e d : Ap r i l 24 , 20 2 4 Re f l e c t iv e o f Or d i n a n c e N o . 2 0 2 4 - 0 1 Zo n i n g Ma p ¯ 0 1 0. 5 Mi l e s TR C C - C i v i c TR C C C - C a m p u s C o m m e r c i a l TR C F O - F l e x O f f i c e TR C R M U - R e t a i l M i x e d U s e TR C N R - 1 - R e s i d e n t i a l TR C N R - 2 - R e s i d e n t i a l TR C N R - 3 - R e s i d e n t i a l TR C N R - 4 - R e s i d e n t i a l TR C O M U - O f f i c e M i x e d U s e TR C O S - O p e n S p a c e TR C T C - 1 - T o w n C e n t e r TR C T C - 2 - T o w n C e n t e r TR C T C - 3 - T o w n C e n t e r TR C - W a t e r I n f r a s t r u c t u r e R- 1 - S i n g l e F a m i l y R e s i d e n t i a l D i s t r i c t R- 2 - S i n g l e & T w o F a m i l y R e s i d e n t i a l D i s t r i c t R- 3 - T o w n h o u s e & L o w D e n s i t y M u l t i p l e D w e l l i n g D i s t r i c t R- 4 - M u l t i p l e D w e l l i n g D i s t r i c t B- 1 - L i m i t e d B u s i n e s s D i s t r i c t B- 2 - G e n e r a l B u s i n e s s D i s t r i c t B- 3 - S e r v i c e B u s i n e s s D i s t r i c t B- 4 - R e t a i l B u s i n e s s D i s t r i c t NB - N e i g h b o r h o o d B u s i n e s s D i s t r i c t CC - C i v i l C e n t e r D i s t r i c t GB - G a t e w a y B u s i n e s s IN S T - I n s t i t u t i o n a l D i s t r i c t I- 1 - L i m i t e d I n d u s t r i a l D i s t r i c t I- 2 - G e n e r a l I n d u s t r i a l D i s t r i c t I- F L E X D i s t r i c t PO S - P a r k s a n d O p e n S p a c e D i s t r i c t CD - C o n s e r v a t i o n D i s t r i c t Ra i l r o a d Wa t e r Si g n T y p e Di s t r i c t 1 Re s i d e n t i a l R1 / R 2 Di s t r i c t 2 No n - Re s i d e n t i a l Us e s R 1 - R 4 Di s t r i c t 3 Re s i d e n t i a l R3 / R 4 Di s t r i c t 4 C o u n t y E F r o n t a g e Re v i s e d De c e m b e r 3 , 20 0 8 Di s t r i c t 5 Le x i n g t o n S of 6 9 4 Di s t r i c t 6 Le x i n g t o n N of 6 9 4 , 9 6 & B1 Di s t r i c t 7 I F L E X & Ga t e w a y , N o n - Fr o n t a g e Co m m e r c i a l Di s t r i c t 8 Ne i g h b o r h o o d Bu s i n e s s Di s t r i c t 9 T C A A P wi t h o u t f r o n t a g e on H i g h w a y 9 6 To t a l s i g n c o p y a r e a 8 s f 20 s f 20 s f 50 s f 80 s f 60 s f 45 s f 30 s f 30 s f Ma x H e i g h t no n e no n e no n e no n e no n e no n e no n e 14 f t 14 f t Li g h t i n g ( a ) No t p e r m i t t e d ex t e r n a l No t p e r m i t t e d E/ I / B E/ I / B E/ I E/ I No t p e r m i t t e d No t p e r m i t t e d Ty p e ( b ) M/ P / O M/ P / O M/ P / O M/ O M/ O M/ P / O M/ P / O M/ P / O No t p e r m i t t e d To t a l s i g n c o p y a r e a 6 s f 48 s f 32 s f 50 s f 10 0 s f 45 s f 25 s f 60 s f No t p e r m i t t e d Ma x H e i g h t 8 s f 6 f t 8 s f 10 f t 16 f t 12 f t 8 f t 8 f t No t p e r m i t t e d Li g h t i n g No t p e r m i t t e d E/ I E E/ I / B E/ I / B E/ I / B E E/ I No t p e r m i t t e d To t a l s i g n a r e a No t p e r m i t t e d 25 % o f w a l l No t p e r m i t t e d 25 % o f w a l l 25 % o f w a l l No t p e r m i t t e d No t p e r m i t t e d No t p e r m i t t e d No t p e r m i t t e d Ma x H e i g h t No t p e r m i t t e d no n e No t p e r m i t t e d no n e no n e No t p e r m i t t e d No t p e r m i t t e d No t p e r m i t t e d No t p e r m i t t e d Li g h t i n g No t p e r m i t t e d ex t e r n a l No t p e r m i t t e d ex t e r n a l ex t e r n a l No t p e r m i t t e d No t p e r m i t t e d No t p e r m i t t e d No t p e r m i t t e d Ma x i m u m c o v e r a g e ar e a No t p e r m i t t e d No t pe r m i t t e d No t p e r m i t t e d 35 % o f w i n d o w ar e a , n o t t o ex c e e d 5 % o f bu i l d i n g f a ç a d e 35 % o f wi n d o w ar e a , n o t t o ex c e e d 5 % o f bu i l d i n g fa ç a d e 35 % o f wi n d o w ar e a , n o t t o ex c e e d 5 % o f bu i l d i n g fa ç a d e 35 % o f w i n d o w ar e a , n o t t o ex c e e d 5 % o f bu i l d i n g f a ç a d e 20 % o f w i n d o w ar e a , n o t t o ex c e e d 5 % o f bu i l d i n g f a ç a d e 35 % o f w i n d o w ar e a , n o t t o e x c e e d 5% o f b u i l d i n g fa ç a d e Ma x s i g n c o p y a r e a pe r s i g n 2 s f 4 s f 4 s f 8 s f 8 s f 6 s f 8 s f 6 s f 6 s f Wa l l H e i g h t No t p e r m i t t e d 4 f t 4 f t 8 f t 8 f t 6 f t 8 f t 6 f t 6 f t Fr e e s t a n d i n g H e i g h t 2 f t 4 f t 4 f t 8 f t 8 f t 6 f t 8 f t 6 f t 6 f t WI N D O W AU X I L I A R Y (a ) E = e x t e r n a l , I = i n t e r n a l , B = b a c k l i t (b ) M = m o n u m e n t , P = p o l e , O = t e m p o r a r y o f f - p r e m i s e s i g n ( s e e 1 2 5 0 . 0 3 ) (c ) S i n g l e p o l e s u p p o r t o n l y . 12 - 1 3 Ad o p t e d : M a r c h 1 0 , 2 0 0 8 Ci t y o f A r d e n H i l l s C h a p t e r 1 2 - S i g n C o d e Ta b l e 1 12 4 0 . 0 2 - T a b l e 1 : S i g n S t a n d a r d s b y S i g n D i s t r i c t WA L L FR E E S T A N D I N G GR A P H I C Exist in g S i g n T a b l e 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Page 1 of 2 AGENDA ITEM – 3B MEMORANDUM DATE: May 28, 2025 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers FROM: Jessica Jagoe, City Administrator SUBJECT: Keeping of Chickens and Ducks Discussion Budgeted Amount: Actual Amount: Funding Source: N/A N/A N/A Council Should Consider Council should review Ordinance 2021-008 and provide direction to staff on the keeping of chickens and/or ducks. Background At the May 12th work session, the City Council requested that the ordinance for the keeping of chickens as well as the topic of ducks be brought to the special work session scheduled for May 28th for discussion. Between 2020 – 2021, the City Council discussed the keeping of chickens in Arden Hills. In preparing the draft ordinance language, the City conducted a survey in November 2020 and referred to the document that is used by a number of adjacent communities titled “Recommendations for Municipal Regulation of Urban Chickens” (Attachment B). This document guided the language for development of ordinance standards and best practices for licensing requirements. On September 27, 2021, the City adopted Ordinance 2021-008 (Attachment A) for the Keeping of Chickens. In August 2023, Council direction was given to add to the agenda planning list for future discussion, the potential keeping of ducks. Keeping of Ducks Staff conducted a survey of adjacent communities for their ordinance language for the keeping of ducks. Of 10 surveyed communities, six (6) allow for the keeping of ducks. The definition of a duck varied in the reviewed ordinances. Four (4) of the cities included chickens and ducks in the same definition. The following definitions were applied to ducks: Page 2 of 2 - Fowl - Non-chicken Fowl - Waterfowl - Poultry - Bird of the order Anseriformes - Non-domestic Animal City Keeping of Ducks Allowed? Notes or Applicable Definitions Mounds View Yes, as Fowl Poultry (chickens, turkeys, pheasants), Fowl (ducks, geese) New Brighton Yes, as Fowl Fowl. All domesticated barnyard and water birds including, but not limited to, chickens, turkeys, ducks, and geese. Roseville Yes, as Poultry Poultry permitted Shoreview Yes, as non-domestic animal Animal, non-domestic, means animals which are kept outside the home for purposes of food or pleasure, such as cattle, hogs, horses, bees, sheep, llamas, goats, chickens (Gallus gallus domesticus), birds, such as emus and pigeons, and similar animals. Little Canada No, as Fowl It shall also be unlawful for any person to keep, raise, breed, or feed non-chicken, fowl or pigeons within the City. Neither roosters, nor fowl shall be permitted. St. Paul Yes, as bird of the order Anseriformes Birds of the orders Anseriformes and Galliformes including duck Chicken defined separately Vadnais Heights No Keeping of Chickens is permitted Blaine No Keeping of Chickens is permitted Maplewood No, not Poultry by definition Poultry means domesticated birds in the order of Galliformes (excluding the genus Meleagris) that serve as a source of eggs or meat. Stillwater Yes, as Poultry Fowl means a bird, such as a duck, goose, turkey, or pheasant that is used as food or hunted as game. Poultry means domestic fowls, such as chickens, turkeys, ducks, or geese, raised for meat or eggs. Budget Impact N/A Attachment Attachment A: Ordinance 2021-008 Attachment B: Municipal Regulation of Urban Chickens 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 chickenrunrescue.org Page 1 9/14/15                 RECOMMENDATIONS  FOR  MUNICIPAL   REGULATION  OF  URBAN  CHICKENS   For  distribution  to  public  and  permit  applicants             SUMMARY  OF  RECOMMENDATIONS  (page  2)   BASIC  CHICKEN  CARE  INSTRUCTIONS        (page  3-­‐9)   REQUIREMENTS  FOR  KEEPING  CHICKENS  (page  10)           Mary  Britton  Clouse   Chicken  Run  Rescue   2014       Endorsed  by   Chicken Run Rescue Eastern Shore Sanctuary and Education Center Farm Sanctuary The Humane Society of the United States Sunnyskies Bird and Animal Sanctuary United Poultry Concerns Woodstock Farm Animal Sanctuary Used  by   Minneapolis, MN St. Paul, MN Cottage Grove, MN Stillwater, MN Falcon Heights, MN     chickenrunrescue.org Page 2 9/14/15       OVERVIEW  OF  RECOMMENDATIONS   •  Do  not  permit         If  permitted:   •  Permit  as  pets  only   •  Do  NOT  prohibit  roosters   •  Prohibit  slaughter,  breeding,  sale  or  barter   •  Limit  number  of  birds  to  5  or  fewer   •  Require  100%  consent  of  neighbors       •  WRITTEN  guidelines  for  care       •  Cap  number  of  permits     •  Allot  for  additional  administrative  staff  and  resources     •  Allot  for  enforcement  and  capture  training                                   chickenrunrescue.org Page 3 9/14/15   BASIC  CHICKEN  CARE  INSTRUCTIONS       CONSIDERATIONS  BEFORE  ACQUIRING  A  CHICKEN   lifespan   -­‐  Chickens  can  live  as  long  as  a  dog  or  cat-­‐  up  to  14  years  or  longer.     -­‐  Egg  laying  for  a  hen  generally  starts  at  6  months  old,  peaks  at  18  months  and  declines  with   development  of  reproductive  disease.   cost   -­‐  Start  Up  costs    for  coop,  maintenance,  tools,  cleaning,  equipment,  heating  /  cooling  appliances,  dishes,   nets,  food  storage,  scale,  fencing,  security  locks,  lighting,  motion  detectors,  monitors,  cameras,  permit   application  ($2-­‐3,000)   -­‐  Annual  supplies  per  bird  for  food,  bedding,  nutritional  supplements,  hygiene  supplies,  permit  fee,   utilities  ($300)   -­‐  Vet  care  per  bird  per  service  (office  exam  $66,  fecal  test  $28,  plus  other  services  as  needed  for  illness   or  injury).  Are  you  able  to  provide  the  birds  with  proper  veterinary  care  needed?   time   -­‐  Average  1  hour  per  bird  per  day    minimum  for  cleaning,  parasite  control,  grooming,  physical  exam,   travel  time  to  purchase  supplies,  construction,  repair,  medication,  feeding,  supervise  free  time  out  of   pen.   -­‐  Chickens  need  to  be  tended  to  twice  daily.  Will  you  have  a  person  ready  to  substitute  for  you  when  you   have  reason  to  be  absent?   space     At  least  a  6’W  x  12’L  x  6’H  space  in  a  yard  is  needed  for  a  coop  and  pen  for  4  birds  in  addition  to  a  larger   fenced  area  for  regular  exercise.   location   Coop  and  pen  should  be  located  in  an  area  that  provides  shade,  direct  sunlight,  good  drainage  and   protection  from  prevailing  winds  and  will  not  present  a  problem  to  neighbors.   uninvited  guests   Chickens  will  attract  bird  mites  and  lice,  mice,  yard  birds,  squirrels,  raccoons,  dogs,  coyotes,  fox,  mink,   opossum,  rats,  owls,  bobcats,  hawks,  snakes,  weasels,  ferrets,  fisher,  marten  and  humans.     ACQUIRING  A  CHICKEN   ADOPTION  OR  PURCHASE/BREEDING?   The  recent  interest  in  having  chickens  has  overwhelmed  animal  rescue  organizations  with  inquiries  from   people  wanting  to  give  up  chickens  who  are  no  longer  wanted.  Like  all  other  animals  surrendered  to   shelters,  rescue  organizations  cannot  help  them  all.  There  are  never  enough  homes  for  displaced   animals  so  adoption  of  birds  who  need  homes  is  always  the  kindest  choice  instead  of  purchase  from  a   breeder  or  hatchery.   adoption-­‐  By  adopting  from  a  rescue  organization  or  a  private  individual,  you  can  know  what  to  expect   with  regard  to  the  bird’s  health,  sex,  behavior  and  personality.  Reputable  rescue  organizations  can   provide  advice  on  selecting  the  right  bird,  care  information  and  generally  have  a  generous  return  policy   to  insure  that  bird  will  be  happy,  compatible  and  well  cared  for.   purchase/breeding-­‐  The  identification  of  the  sex  of  chicks  by  feed  stores,  breeders  and  hatcheries  is   often  wrong  and  not  apparent  until  the  bird  is  6  months  old.  50%  of  the  chicks  hatched  are  roosters  who   are  killed  or  otherwise  discarded  of  as  waste.  Newborn  chicks  shipped  through  the  postal  service  are   deprived  of  their  mothers,  warmth  and  food.  The  younger  the  bird  the  more  fragile  and  difficult  they  are   to  care  for.     chickenrunrescue.org Page 4 9/14/15     HEALTHY  BIRD  CHECKLIST   Eyes:  clear,  clean,  wide  open,  alert   Face  /  comb  /  wattle:  clean,  soft,  blemish  free,  healthy  deep  red  indicating  good  blood  supply,  (some   faces  are  not  red)   Posture:  head  erect,  good  balance,  stand  or  perch  on  both  feet  on  extended  legs,  good  grip  on  perch,   facing  activity   Odor:  none  or  slightly  fermented  hay   Beak  /  nostrils:  clean,  uniform,  shiny  and  solid   Legs  /  feet:  clean,  shiny,  uniform  scales  and  nails,  foot  bottom  soft  and  blemish  free,  legs  and  toes   straight  and  functional   Feathers;  clean,  bright,  shiny,  smooth  or  fluffy,  free  of  mites  or  lice   Wings:  held  close  to  body,  symmetrical,  smooth  movement  in  joints  when  flexed,  flight  feathers  intact   Skin:  clean,  soft,  pale  pink  and  translucent  (some  breeds  have  bare  red  patches  at  shoulders  and  keel),   free  of  mites  or  lice   Droppings:  70%  odorless  green/  white,  firm,  30%  stinky  brown  pasty  (cecal),  watery  if  stressed   Keel  (sternum):  Straight,  good  muscle  mass  on  either  side,  lump  free   Crop  (on  bird’s  right  side  of  lower  neck):  full,  contents  of  consumed  food  easily  palpated   Vent:  petite,  clean,  moist,  soft,  pliant   Respiration:  12-­‐37  per  min.,  inspiration  louder  and  shorter  than  expiration,  minimal  chest  movement,   closed  beak     NUMBER  OF  BIRDS   Calculating  available  space,  time,  and  cost  (see  above)  will  dictate  how  many  birds  can  be  properly  cared   for:   coop:  4  sq.  feet  of  floor  space  minimum  per  bird  for  the  interior  (an  area  2  ft.  x  2  ft.  per  bird)   pen:    10  sq.  ft  of  floor  space  minimum  per  bird  (an  area  3  ft.  x  3.3  ft  per  bird)   range/  exercise  yard:    174  sq.  ft  per  bird  (an  area  about  10  ft.  x  17  ft  per  bird)   A  single  chicken  is  a  sad  chicken.  Plan  to  have  at  least  2-­‐  they  are  flock  animals  and  need  the   companionship  of  other  chickens.  Generally,    3-­‐5  compatible  chickens  can  be  well  maintained  in  a   typical  city  environment.  Individual  bird’s  sex,  age  and  temperament  can  affect  compatibility.  Over   crowding  chickens  is  the  most  common  mistake.  Hens  should  outnumber  roosters.  Sometimes  single   birds  can  thrive  with  a  human  friend  if  they  have  special  needs.  Roosters,    single  or  in  pairs,    are  very   sociable  and  can  make  terrific  companions  if  handled  gently  and  often.         HANDLING  &  RESTRAINT   Never  handle  a  chicken  by  wings,  feet  or  legs.  Herd  bird  to  corner  using  slow  deliberate  movement.   Fast=  predator,  slow  =  less  threat.  Place  hands  over  top  part  of  wings  (shoulders)  and  hold  securely  but   do  not  squeeze.  Pick  up  and  hold  under  arm  to  keep  wings  in  place.  Support  feet  with  other  hand  if  bird   will  tolerate.  To  restrain  for  transport  or  examination,  drape  a  towel  over  shoulders  cape  style  and  wrap   around  body.       TRANSPORTATION   Consider  travel  time  and  avoid  extreme  weather  conditions.  Heat  exhaustion  can  develop  quickly,   interior  car  temps  can  reach  fatal  point  10  minutes.  Medium  sized  hard  pet  carriers  work  well  for     security,  safety,  stress.  Line  with  a  towel,  shredded  paper  or  straw.  Food  is  a  good  stress  reducer.  Offer   wet  food  like  greens  or  cucumber  for  long  trips.         chickenrunrescue.org Page 5 9/14/15 ARRIVAL   If  other  birds  are  already  present,  a  2  week  quarantine  in  a  separate  area  is  recommended  to  watch  for   signs  of  illness  and  parasites.  Avoid  noisy,  high  traffic  areas  and  allow  the  bird  to  acclimate  before   introducing  to  other  birds,  animals  and  family.       PROVIDING  A  GOOD  HOME   NATURAL  HISTORY   It  is  important  to  understand  how  chickens  live  in  the  wild  and  to  provide  them  with  an  environment   that  meets  those  instinctive  physical  and  psychological  needs  as  closely  as  possible.  Chickens  are  all   descended  from  Tropical  Jungle  Fowl  are  adapted  to  living  in  a  natural  habitat  that  is  spacious,  richly   vegetated,  diverse  and  warm.  This  presents  a  particular  challenge  in  a  small  urban  setting  in  a  cold   climate  like  Minnesota.     Flocks  have  a  highly  developed  social  structure  and  depend  on  each  for    companionship  and  security.   Naturalists  have  observed  that  they  can  recognize  and  remember  180  other  individual  flock  members.   They  are  ground  dwelling  birds.  Most  are  capable  of  low  flight  in  short  distances,  smaller  birds  can  fly   higher  and  farther.       In  the  wild  they  roost  in  trees  at  dusk  before  they  sleep  or  to  escape  predators.  They  hide  their  nests  in   cavities  in  the  ground.  The  majority  of  their  waking  hours  are  spent  active,  wide  ranging,  grazing,   foraging  for  food-­‐  plants,  bugs  and  occasionally  small  rodents.  In  their  natural  state.  They  typically  travel   1/2  mile  from  their  roost  each  day.  In  the  wild,  they  are  never  over  crowded-­‐  if  the  population  becomes   to  dense,  members  will  break  off  into  subgroups  and  spread  out.  They  move  on  from  one  area  to   another  which  allows  food  sources  to  regenerate  and  their  waste  is  not  concentrated  in  one  place  and  it   can  decompose  without  health  risk  to  the  flock.     Roosters  alert  the  flock  to  danger,  find  food  and  call  the  hens  to  it  and  stand  guard  as  they  eat.  They   select  and  build  nests  and  will  even  participate  in  caring  for  the  young.  They  also  act  as  peace  keepers  to   intervene  in  disputes  that  can  develop  between  flock  members.  Roosters  will  start  to  crow  and  display   courting  behaviors  at  about  6  months  of  age.  It  is  essential  to  gently  handle  a  rooster  on  a  daily  basis  to   establish  that  you  are  the  flock  leader  (Alpha)  and  maintain  a  well  socialized  companion.     The  hens  spend  their  time  scratching  for  food,  dust  bathing,  preening,  playing  and  napping.  Hens  begin   to  lay  eggs  at  about  6  months  of  age.  Hen  in  the  wild  produce  only  a  few  clutches  of  eggs  a  year  for  the   sole  purpose  of  reproduction.  Domesticated  hens  have  been  bred  to  lay  one  egg  a  day  but  by  18  month   of  age,  egg  laying  frequency  generally  diminishes  and  many  adult  or  senior  hens  stop  laying  altogether.       Chickens  are  sociable,  cheerful  and  intelligent  creatures  who  can  form  lifelong  bonds  with  each  other   and  other  species  including  humans,  dogs  and  cats.  Because  of  their  keen  intelligence  and  instinctive   physical  activity,  they  need  a  stimulating  environment  that  mimics  as  much  as  possible  the  rich  and   diverse  world  nature  designed  them  to  enjoy.       COOP,  PEN,  RANGE/  EXERCISE  YARD   “Housing  and  infrastructure.  The  primary  purpose  of  poultry  housing  is  to  protect  flocks  against  adverse   weather  and  predators  (coyote,  fox,  stray  dogs,  raccoons  and  raptors).  Weather  is  of  critical  concern  in   the  Upper  Midwest,  where  summers  can  be  extremely  hot  and  winters  bitterly  cold.  Housing  must   provide  shade  from  sun  and  cover  from  rain.  It  must  be  able  to  withstand  high  winds  and  snow  loads  if  it   is  to  be  used  for  year-­‐round  operation.  These  basic  housing  considerations  apply  to  all  poultry”   chickenrunrescue.org Page 6 9/14/15 -­‐”Poultry  Your  Way:  A  Guide  to  Management  Alternatives  for  the  Upper  Midwest”,  Minnesota   Department  of  Agriculture,  2005       COOP:  The  house,  closed  structure  or  enclosed  room  which  provides  shelter  from  cold,  heat,  wind,  rain,   snow  and  predators  for  protected  roosting,  nesting,  feeding  and  watering  space.   Construction  &  Materials  –  Coops  can  be  purchased  ready  made  or  in  kits,  constructed  within  an     existing  structure  or  built  from  scratch.  Local  building  codes  should  be  followed  to  prevent  damage  from   snow,  wind,  etc.  NOTE:  rabbit  hutches,  plastic  igloos,  dog  houses  and  such  are  not  appropriate   structures.   Required  features:   size:  4  sq.  feet  of  floor  space  minimum  is  required  per  bird  for  the  interior  (an  area  2  ft.  x  2  ft.  per  bird).   So  4  birds  will  need  a  coop  with  at  least  4  feet  x  4  feet  inside  floor  space  not  including  nest  boxes.   Outside  dimensions  should  be  about  5  feet  by  5  feet  x  6  ft.  high.  Overcrowding  is  the  most  common   cause  of  behavior  problems,  injury  and  disease.  Coop  should  be  high  enough  for  a  human  to  stand  up     comfortably  for  cleaning,  maintenance  and  egg  collection.  It  also  allows  for  additional  roosting.   Temperament  and  social  structures  should  be  taken  into  account,  and  partitions  should  be  available  for   birds  who  are  sick,  injured  or  lower  in  the  pecking  order.   access  to  electricity  is  required  in  free  standing  structures.     floor  –  The  floor  should  not  collect  and  hold  moisture,  be  easy  to  clean,  retain  heat  in  cold  weather  and   exclude  rodents/predators.  A  dirt  floor  draws  heat  away  and  is  not  easy  to  clean  or  rodents/predators   proof.  A  wood  floor  is  adequate  provided  it  is  at  least  a  foot  off  the  ground,  insulated  and  sealed   properly  but  is  difficult  to  sanitize  because  it  is  porous.    a  concrete  floor  is  ideal  since  it  discourages   rodents/predators  and  ids  easy  to  sanitize.  Regardless  of  the  floor  type,  bedding  strewn  on  the  surface  is   needed  is  to  absorb  moist  fecal  matter  and  facilitate  cleaning.  Leaves  or  wood  shavings  work  best  and   can  be  composted  or  easily  bagged  and  disposed  of  as  solid  waste.     walls-­‐  Materials  that  are  resistant  to  moisture  and  mold  and  easily  cleaned  are  best.  Chemically  treated   materials  should  be  nontoxic.  A  good  compound  with  anti  fungal  agents  is  good  for  humid  areas.  Clear   varnish  is  also  good.  Everything  should  be  treated  or  painted  before  it  is  assembled.  Wooden  structures   should  be  draft  free  and  built  with  double  walls  that  have  at  least    1  1/2  inch  insulated  layer  between   them.   roof:    The  coop  roof  should  be  made  of  a  material  that  will  not  collect  and  hold  heat  and  should  be  built   with  double  walls  that  have  at  least  1  1/2  inch  insulated  layer  between  them.  The  roof  surfaced  should   be  covered  with  an  insulating  tar  paper  to  protect  from  heavy  rains.  The  roof  should  be  slightly  inclined,   to  allow  water  to  run  off  and  if  it  overhangs  at  the  front  wall  it  will  protect  from  downpours.  A  few  small   openings  along  the  eaves  allow  moisture  to  escape  and  provide  fresh  air.   doors:  One  human-­‐size  door  is  needed  for  daily  access.  Doors  for  chickens  should  be  just  large  enough   for  the  largest  bird  and  can  be  positioned  anywhere  from  ground  level  to  about  2  feet  high  with  a  stable   ramp  with  cleats.  Chickens  are  ground  dwellers,  not  parrots-­‐small  doors  at  heights  greater  than  3  feet     with  flimsy,  unstable  ladders  are  not  appropriate.  Doors  must  be  able  to  be  secured  against  predators  at   night.   windows:  Chickens  love  windows  and  need  natural  light.  Double  glaze  for  warmth.  Cover  with  1/2”   metal    screen  so  they  can  be  opened  for  ventilation  in  hot  weather.  Allow  one  square  foot  of  window  for   each  10  square  foot  of  floor  space.   roosts:  Lumber  or  branches  can  be  used.  They  should  be  strong  enough  and  mounted  securely  enough   to  hold  all  birds.  The  surface  should  be  rough  for  good  grip  with  no  splinters  or  sharp  edges.  For  medium   sized  birds,  2”  or  4  “  flat  or  1  1/2”  diameter  is  best  for  foot  comfort.  The  longer  roost  the  better  to   prevent  competition.  They  should  be  set  18”  from  wall,  2  -­‐3  feet  off  the  floor.  If  mounted  higher,  rung   steps  are  needed  spaced  8-­‐12  inches  apart.  The  addition  of  a  dropping  board  underneath  and  elevated   roost  will  collect  droppings  and  keep  floor  space  below  clean  and  inhabitable.   climate:  Shelters  should  be  kept  at  a  comfortable  temperature  for  the  animals.  “Minimum  Temperature   55°(f)  ,  maximum  temperature  70°(F)”         chickenrunrescue.org Page 7 9/14/15 -­‐”Poultry  Your  Way:  A  Guide  to  Management  Alternatives  for  the  Upper  Midwest”,  Minnesota   Department  of  Agriculture,  2005     The  coop  should  be  heated  to  maintain  a  temperature  above  32  degrees  during  the  coldest  part  of  the   winter  and  cooled  below  85  in  the  hottest  part  of  the  summer.   Below  32  degrees  birds  are  uncomfortable  and  cannot  maintain  body  temperature.  Below  15  degrees   frostbite  begins,  and  hypothermia  increases.  Oil  or  water  filled  safety  heaters  (i.e.  brands  Pelonis,   DeLonghi,  Honeywell)  are  completely  closed  and  sealed  systems  that  run  on  electricity.  The  oil  is  heated   from  within  and  the  heat  is  radiant  so  there  are  no  exposed  heating  elements  that  create  dangerous   problems  even  if  they  tip  over.  Heat  lamps  should  only  be  used  with  extreme  caution  and  be  firmly   attached  at  least  3  feet  from  animals  and  far  from  any  flammable  item,  especially  dry  straw  or  bedding.   Smoke  alarms  are  highly  recommended.  Extra  bedding  should  be  available  to  keep  animals  warm  and   comfortable  in  cold  seasons.     Between  75  and  85  degrees,  panting  and  dehydration  begin,  above  85  heat  stress  and  danger  of  heat   prostration  increases.     ventilation-­‐  Doors,  windows  and  vents  near  the  ceiling    supply  oxygen,  remove  heat  from  breathing,   remove  moisture  from  breath  and  droppings,  harmful  gasses  and  dust  particles,  and  dilute  disease   causing  airborne  organisms.  Fans  should  be  provided  for  hottest  weather.   light:  Natural  light  from  windows  and/or  skylights  is  required.  Can  be  supplemented  with  full  spectrum   incandescent  light  to  follow  normal  seasonal  light  cycles  and  for  cleaning  and  maintenance.  The   minimum  light  intensity  you  should  provide  should  be  enough  to  clearly  see  the  hens  feed  when   standing  over  the  feeder.     feeders:  Food  receptacles  should  be  made  of  non-­‐corrosive  material  that  is  easily  cleaned  minimizes   spillage,  prevents  contamination  with  droppings  and  keeps  food  dry.  The  containers  should  be  large   enough  for  all  the  birds  to  comfortably  eat  at  once  or  numerous  enough  to  prevent  competition  or   intimidation.  Large  heavy  rubber  feed  buckets  work  nicely.  Hanging  dishes  or  feeders  work  as  well  and   should  be  hung  at  about  the  level  of  the  bird’s  back.  If  dishes  are  outside  the  coop,  they  should  be  set   under  an  overhang  to  keep  them  dry  when  it  rains.   waterers:  Water  receptacles  should  be  made  of  non-­‐corrosive  material  that  can  be  cleaned  and   disinfected  with  a  solution  of  chlorine  bleach,  prevent  contamination  with  droppings  and  is  spill  and  leak   proof.  The  containers  should  be  large  enough  for  all  the  birds  to  comfortably  drink  at  once  and  hold   enough  water  for  all  birds  for  an  entire  day.  They  should  be  slightly  positioned  higher  than  the  feeder  or   far  enough  away  to  prevent  contamination  with  food.   nestboxes-­‐  One  nest  box  for  every  3  hens.  A  12”W  x  12”D  x  14”H  is  most  versatile.  Chickens  prefer   wooden  nest  boxes  with  covered  opening  for  privacy  placed  on  or  as  low  to  the  floor  as  possible.  If  set   higher  they  require  a  perch  in  front  of  the  opening.  They  should  be  filled  with  2-­‐4  inches  of  straw.  litter     or  grass.    They  prefer  to  nest  in  the  South  East  corner  of  the  structure  whenever  possible.     PEN:  The  fenced  area  surrounding  the  coop  that  provides  secure  access  to  exercise,  sunlight,  earth  and   vegetation  and  is  freely  available  to  the  birds  when  they  are  unsupervised.  It  is  constructed  to  prevent   the  bird’s  escape  and  prevents  entry  by  intruders/predators.   Construction  &  Materials  –  Kennel  pens  can  be  purchased  ready  made  or    in  kits,  or  built  from  scratch.   Local  building  codes  should  be  followed  to  prevent  damage  from  snow,  wind,  etc.    Temperament  and   social  structures  of  flock  should  be  taken  into  account,  and  partitions  should  be  available  for  birds  who   are  sick,  injured  or  lower  in  the  pecking  order.   Required  features:   size:  10  sq.  ft  of  floor  space  minimum  per  bird  (an  area  3  ft.  x  3.3  ft  per  bird)  is  required  so  4  birds  will   need  floor  space  of  at  least  6  feet  x  7  feet.  If  the  coop  is  adjacent  to  the  pen  at  least  a  6  x  12  foot  space   in  a  yard  is  needed.  If  the  coop  is  elevated  2  feet  so  the  chickens  can  use  the  space  underneath,  the   coop  and  pen  can  occupy  some    but  not  all  of  the  same  footprint.  If  most  of  the  pen  is  in  deep  shade  all   of  the  time  it  would  be  conducive  to  unhealthy  bacteria  and  fungal  development.  The  pen  should  be   chickenrunrescue.org Page 8 9/14/15 high  enough  for  you  to  stand  up    comfortably  for  cleaning,  maintenance,  capture  and  also  allows  for   additional  roosting.   substrate-­‐  Choose  a  well  drained  area.  Substrate  material  for  the  pen  should  be  clean,  non-­‐toxic,   biodegradable,  readily  available,  inexpensive  and  replaceable.  Since  it  will  become  compacted  from  little   feet  and  contaminated  by  concentrated  droppings  and  parasites,  it  will  need  to  be  raked  out  and   replaced  frequently  to  reduce  odor  and  fly  activity.  Play  sand,  leaves,  municipal  wood  chips,  sod  and   hard  wearing  ground  cover  work  well.   metal  fencing  /  predator  control:  The  type  of  fencing  depends  on  what  the  most  likely  predators  are  in   your  area.  Dogs,  rats,  raccoons,  hawks  and  coyotes  are  the  most  prevalent  in  city  neighborhoods,  but   others  include  fox,  mink,  opossum,  bobcats,  snakes,  weasels,  ferrets,  fisher  and  marten.  Its  best  to  build   the  strongest  deterrents  possible.  Chain  link  panels  or  welded  or  woven  fencing  on  a  sturdy  frame   reinforced  at  the  bottom  with  small  mesh  metal  wire  that  prevents  predators  from  tunneling  under  the   fence  will  discourage  most  intruders.  Regular  inspection  is  key  to  security.   gate:  A  gate  is  needed  for  easy  human  access.   cover:  Pen  should  be  covered  to  keep  birds  in  and  predators  out.  The  type  of  covering  needed  will   depend  on  the  type  of  predators.  Covering  part  of  the  pen  with  a  roof  such  as  corrugated  fiberglass  can   provide  shade  and  rain  shelter.   windbreak:  Providing  a  wind  and  snow  break  will  give  the  birds  a  protected  area  to  be  outdoors  even  in   winter.   shade:  Shade  must  be  available  and  can  be  provided  by  vegetation  or  strategically  placed  materials.   dustbath:  Taking  a  dust  bath  is  the  closest  thing  to  heaven  for  a  chicken.  They  derive  pleasure  and   contentment  by  bathing  in  the  sun  and    in  loose  dry  soil  depressions  in  the  dirt  which  cleans  their   feathers  and  rids  them  of  parasites.  Birds  will  usually  dig  their  own  hole  for  dust  baths.  Keep  the  soil  in   the  dust  bath  loose  and  add  play  sand  if  it  is  a  heavy  clay  soil.  Adding    a  little  poultry  dust,  diatomaceous   earth  or  wood  ash  increases  the  effectiveness    of  parasite  control.  Large  heavy  rubber  feed  buckets  filled   with  play  sand  are  a  welcome  addition  to  the  indoor  coop  in  the  winter.   enrichment  furnishings:  There  is  nothing  sadder  than  a  barren  pen  when  compared  to  the  rich  jungle   environment  chickens  evolved  in.  Lots  of  large  branches,  stumps  or  platforms  provide  places  to  go  and   things  to  do  and  look  natural  and  attractive  in  the  pen.  Include  bushes,  boxes  or  other  objects  to  sit  in  or   hide  behind.  Plant  kale  or  other  safe,  edible  vegetation  around  the  outside  of  the  pen  for  forage.   Overcrowding,  boredom  and  barren  pens  are  the  most  common  cause  of  behavior  problems.     RANGE/  EXERCISE  YARD:  The  larger  fenced  area  like  a  backyard  that  provides  ample  space  for  safe   exercise,  forage,  sunlight,  earth  and  vegetation  that  is  regularly  available  to  the  birds  when  supervised.   For  regular  exercise,  174  sq.  ft  per  bird  (an  area  about  10  ft.  x  17  ft  per  bird)  is  required.  4  birds  will  need   access  to  a  40  ft.    x  70  ft.  fenced  area  in  the  yard.  If  there  is  no  access  to  a  larger  Range/  exercise  yard,   16  sq.  ft.  of  floor  space  minimum  per  bird  (an  area  4  ft.  x    4  ft  per  bird)  in  the  pen  must  be  provided.     fencing:  6  ft  privacy  fencing  prevents  or  to  discourage  uninvited  human  and  animal  visitors.  and   promotes  the  safety  and  security  of  the  birds  and  neighbors.   nontoxic  plants:  Chickens  are  inquisitive  and  voracious  eaters  of  vegetation  and  many  ornamental     garden  plants  can  be  toxic  to  them  .  Learn  which  of  your  plants  might  be  harmful  and  fence  them  off  or   better  yet  replace  them  with  safe  and    nutritious  plants.   security:  Chickens  are  susceptible  to  theft,  vandalism  and  predators  and  need  to  be  securely  shut  in  the   coop  at  night.  Security  cameras,  lights  and  baby  monitors  are  also  highly  recommended  deterrents.       PROVIDING  GOOD  CARE   FOOD  /  WATER   Fresh  food  and  water  are  required  daily  and  should  be  available  at  all  times.  Hay  ,  grain  and  prepared   feed  should  be  fresh-­‐  less  than  one  year  old  and  free  of  mold,  insects  or  other  contaminants.  Daily   intake  should  include:  60  %  nutritionally  balanced  prepared  feed  appropriate  for  age  of  bird,  20%   chickenrunrescue.org Page 9 9/14/15 scratch  (cracked  corn,  oats,  black  oil  sunflower  seeds,  milo,  barley)  20%  fresh  (nutritious  foods  and  table   scraps-­‐  Caution  toxic:  onion,  avocados,  chocolate)  Supplements:  oyster  shell  or  limestone  for  calcium,   granite  grit  for  digestion,     mineral  salt  or  ground  salt  licks.  Chickens  drink  1-­‐2  cups  of  water  a  day.   Feed  should  be  stored  in  rodent  proof  containers  in  a  cool  dry  area  inaccessible  to  animals.  Stored   feedbags  should  be  rotated  to  ensure  that  feed  is  always  fresh.  Food  that  is  uneaten  or  spilled  should  be   removed  from  animal  enclosures  daily.     SOCIAL  NEEDS  Temperament  and  social  structures  of  animals  should  be  taken  into  account,  and   separate  areas  provided  for  incompatible  birds.     VET  CARE   Locate  a  veterinary  clinic  nearby  that  will  see  chickens  before  one  is  needed.  preferably  one  that   specializes  in  avian  care.  Chickens  are  welcome  in  increasing  numbers  of  city  clinics.  Check  vet   backgrounds  at  http://www.vetmed.state.mn.us/Default.aspx?tabid=803   Have  an  isolation  area  or  roomy  carrier  and  heating  pad  for  sick  or  injured  birds.  Critical/emergency  first   aid  supplies  should  be  kept  including  roll  gauze,  gauze  pads,  tape,  vet  wrap,  blood  stop  powder,   antibiotic  ointment,  antibacterial  scrub  and  solution,  and  bandage  scissors.         SANITATION-­‐  Manure  and  wet  bedding  should  be  removed  from  coop  and  animal  feeding  and  lounging   areas  daily.  Thorough,  complete  cleaning  of  walls  and  perches,  removal  of  all  bedding,  and  disinfecting   of  coop  and  furnishings  should  be  done  at  least  once  a  year.  Keeping  shelter  areas  clean  and  dry  will   help  prevent  bacteria,  fungi,  insects,  rodents,  etc.  Rodent  levels  will  be  minimized  by  keeping  all  feed  in   rodent  proof  containers  and  removing  spilled  or  uneaten  food  promptly.  Litter  can  be  double  bagged   and  disposed  of  as  solid  waste  or  composted  but  must  be  done  in  an  area  where  chickens  will  not   scratch  for  at  least  a  year.   Housing  animals  in  spacious,  clean  and  relatively  dust  free  environments  will  keep  them  healthy  and  will   minimize  human  exposure  to  infectious  disease.           Sources: Poultry Your Way: A Guide to Management Alternatives for the Upper Midwest, Minnesota Department of Agriculture, 2005 Standards of Care for Chickens, Adapted from Standards of Care for Farmed Animals , The Association Of Sanctuaries (TAOS). Edited by Chicken Run Rescue. 6/2008, revised 4/7/09 Poultry Housing Considerations for Low Input Small Scale Producers, David Sullenberger, TimeWarrior Farm Chronicle Special Reports, Revision E, Fall, 2003 Building Chicken Coops: Storey Country Wisdom Bulletin A-224, Gail Damerow, 1999 Chicken Health Handbook, Gail Damerow, 1994                   chickenrunrescue.org Page 10 9/14/15 http://www.brittonclouse.com/chickenrunrescue/ Page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