HomeMy WebLinkAboutCCP 04-08-1996
I ~~
I
AGENDA
I- ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL MEETING
NEW BRIGHTON COUNCIL CHAMBERS
I MONDAY, APRIL 8, 1996, 7:30 P.M.
7:30 P.M, 1. Call to order/roll call
I 7:30 P.M. 2. Agenda Adoption
I 7:35 P.M. 3. Approval of Minutes
a. March 25,1996, Regular Council Meeting
b. March 18, 1996, Council Worksession Meeting
I 7:40 P.M, 4. Consent Calendar
a. Liability Insurance Coverage Changes
I b. Claims and Payroll
I 7:45 P,M. 5. Public Comments
7:50 P.M. 6. Unfinished and New Business
.. a, Planning Case #96-02, Stephen Nelson - Front Yard Setback Variance and
Utility & Drainage Easement Vacation
b. Resolution #96-25, Accepting Bid and Authorizing Execution of Contract in the
I Matter ofthe Lift Station #6 Modifications.
8:30 P.M. 7. Administrator Comments
I 8:40 P.M. 8. Council Comments
I 8:50 P.M, 9. Adjourn
I Mav Meetin2S Auril Meetings
May 1 - Planning Commission, 7:30 P,M, April 3 - Planning Commission, 7:30 P,M.
May 8 - Human Rights Committee - 7:30 P.M, April 8 - Council Meeting, 7:30 P.M.
May 13 - Council Meeting - 7:30 P.M. Apri19 - Human Rights Cumminee - 7:30 P.M,
I May 15 - Economic Dev. Committee - 8:00 A.M, April 15 - Council Worksession - 4:30 P.M.
May 16 - Public Works\Safety - 7:30 P.M, April 17 - Economic Dev. Committee - 8:00 A.M,
May 20 - Council Worksession - 4:30 P.M. April 18 - Public Safety/Works -7:30 P,M.
I May 23 - Finance Committee -7:30 P.M, April 24 - Park & Rec. Committee - 4:30 P.M,
May 28 - Park & Rec. Committee - 7:00 P,M. April 25 - Finance committee - 7: 30 P. M.
May 28 - Council Meeting - 7:30 P.M. April 29 - Council Meeting - 7:30 P.M.
I
I'~
I
.- ~.
I CITY OF ARDEN HILLS
1_ MEMORANDUM
DATE: April 5, 1996
I TO: Mayor and City Council
Brian Fritsinger, City Administrato~ )
FROM:
.
SUBJECT: Administrator Comments for AprilS, 1996, Council Meeting
I 1. Agenda Items
a. ADDroval of Minutes
I The Council is asked to approve the March 18, 1996 Council Worksession and
March 25,1996, Regular Council Meeting Minutes.
I b. Consent Calendar
1. Liability Insurance Coverage Chan~es
The Council is asked to approve changes to the General Liability
I Insurance coverage carried by the City. Specifically, the Council is asked
to approve new coverage for Open Meeting Law Defense and change its
election on Excess Liability coverage to not waive the monetary limits on
Ie tort liability established by MN Statutes.
2. Claims and Pavroll
. The Council is asked to approve claims in the amount of $82,662.65 and
payroll for the period most recently ended, The Council may note
I expenditures to Ramsey County for Law Enforcement services. This
expenditure was offset by the credit received for 1995 overpayments for
service, Also included in this claim report is payment of$47,023 to
I Metropolitan Council for wastewater charges.
c. Unfinished and New Business
I 1. Stephen Nelson Variance and Easement Vacation
The Planning Commission has recommended approval of a front yard
setback variance for the construction of a new home at this Sandeen Road
I property. They have also reviewed and approved a vacation of a drainage
and utility easement to accomplish the project. Please review Mr.
Ringwald's memorandum for more information.
. 2. Resolution #96-25. Lift Station #6 Improvements
I The Council is asked to adopt Resolution #96-25, accepting bid and
authorizing execution of contract in the matter of the lift station #6
modifications. The Council authorized this project in late 1995 and
it budgeted for it in the 1996 budget. The engineer and Mr. Stafford are not
I
.... II.
recommending the low bid in this case, They are recommending Quality I
Flow Systems with a bid of$23,544,50, This bid is the only one including
site restoration and other items, -.
2. Non-Agenda Items
a. Recycling Stuffer
Enclosed is information about the Municipal Recycling Program. This will be .
included in the next utility billing and sent to all Arden Hills residents. Should
the Council have any suggestions or comments regarding this document, please .
contact Mr. Ringwald,
b. Cable Television Problems I
Thcre have been some ongoing problems with the audio of recent Council
Meetings. Staff is working with the Cable Company to attempt to correct the
problem. We are also investigating the relocation of the system at City Hall and .
some equipment improvements.
c. 1996 Budget Books .
The 1996 Budget book is completed and enclosed for the Council's information.
I anticipate discussions regarding the 1997 Budget to begin with the City Council
at the May Worksession. I
d. Year End Audit
Abdo Abdo & Eick will start the annual financial audit next week. They are ell
expected to be at City Hall for the next week or two in order to complete field
work for the Audit Report, .
e. February 15.1996. Ramsev County Sheriff Contract Group Meeting Minutes
f. March 27, 1996. Letter from Shoreview Mavor. James Chalmers .
Shoreview is requesting a joint meeting to discuss proposed improvements to
Lexington A venue. During 1995 the rumor was being circulated throughout the I
Karth Lake neighborhood in regards to this project proceeding. Staff received
numerous phone calls from local residents opposed to this project. Mr. Stafford
will be contacting Ramsey County to receive additional information which can be .
forwarded to the Council.
g. March 27, 1996. Letter from Michele Brouse. Principal of Valentine Hills I
Elementary School.
h. Perry Park Project .
The Parks Department has raised a total of $12,000 towards the new playground
structure at Perry Park. It is expected that at least a similar amount will be .
received from Bethel College for the structure. I would also like to remind the
--
.
I
I" - .
Ie Council of the Grand Opening event planned for June 1st. Ms, Walsh is still open
to any suggestions for activities or funding for the event. Please contact her if you
have ideas.
I I. Planning: Commission
1 The Planning Commission recently discussed a variety of ordinance and code
issues which need review. The Commission will be breaking into subcommittees
to begin work in areas such as; pawnshops, sexually oriented businesses,
I subdivision regulations, wetland setbacks and tree preservation. The Commission
would be interested in any direction the Council may have in regards to the
wetland or tree ordinances.
I J, Aprill. 1996. Letter from Kristi Rollag Wangstad of Alliant Techsystems
I k. Water MeterslWater System
Staff is investigating several new alternatives to the water system. These
alternatives have an impact on the need for water meter replacement and other
I items, The Council should expect to have an in-depth discussion in regards to this
project at the April 15th Worksession.
1 1. TCAAP Controlled Burn
The Army and MN DNR will be conducting a controlled burn for restoration of
.. native prairie this spring. It is expected to take place for one or two days between
April 15th and May 10th.
m. Bondin!! Bill
I The City was unsuccessful in its attempt to obtain flmding from the State of
Minnesota for the proposed joint public facilities at TCAAP. The project was
1 included in the Bill several times throughout the process, but the final version did
not include our request. Staff will be re-evaluating the options available to the
City in regards to the public facility needs and TCAAP reuse process,
I n, Miscellaneous News Articles
1
1
I
~.
I
I
.>> "
~. ()?
#4~
.
MINUTES .,.
. CITY OF ARDEN HILLS, MINNESOTA
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 25, 1996
. 7:30 P.M. - NEW BRIGHTON COUNCIL CHAMBERS
. CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL
. Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, Mayor Probst called to order the regular City
Council meeting at 7:30 p.m.
. Present: Mayor Dennis Probst, Councilmembers Beverly Aplikowski, Susan Keirn,
Paul Malone, Dale Hicks,
. Absent: None.
.. Also present were: City Administrator, Brian Fritsinger; City Accountant, Terry Post;
Public Works Superintendent, Dwayne Stafford; Community Development Director,
Kevin Ringwald; Parks and Recreation Director, Cindy Walsh; City Engineer, Greg
. Stonehouse; and Recording Secretary, Cathy Sorensen.
ADOPT AGENDA
. Mayor Probst stated Item G, Receiving 1995 Treasury Report, needs to be added to the Consent
Calendar.
. MOTION: Aplikowski moved and Keirn seconded a motion to adopt the agenda for the
. March 25, 1996, Regular City Council meeting as amended. The motion carried
unanimously (5-0),
. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
March 11, 1996:
I No corrections.
. MOTION: Keirn moved and Aplikowski seconded a motion to approve the March II, 1996,
Regular Council Meeting minutes as presented. The motion carried unanimously
it (5-0).
.
~ *.
<{?
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 25 1996 1~r.1
CONSENT CALENDAR .
A. Appointments to City Committees I
B. 1996 Business License Renewals
I
C. Adopt Resolution #96-22, Relating to Apportionment of Assessments Relating to
Improvement No. W-78-5 .
D. Adopt Resolution #96-23, Relating to Apportionment of Assessments Relating to
Improvement No. ST-8l-2 .
E. Planning Case #95-16, Balfany Preliminary Plat
F. Claims and Payroll I
G. Receiving 1995 Treasury Report .
MOTION: Hicks moved and Aplikowski seconded a motion to approve the Consent Calendar
as presented, and authorize execution of all necessary documents contained ..
therein, The motion carried unanimously (5-0),
PUBLIC COMMENTS I
Mayor Probst invited the audience to address the Council on any issue not already on the agenda. I
There were no public comments at this time. I
UNFINISHED AND NEW BUSINESS
A. Adopt Resolution #96-21. Approving the Plans and Specifications and Authorization .
for Bids for the 1996 Street Improvements
Dwayne Stafford, Public Works Superintendent, stated that after numerous meetings with I
residents and staff, they have come to a tentative understanding on the street improvement .
project. He stated one issue remaining is the street width on Pascal Avenue, He noted that based
on the City Council's direction, the City Engineer was to look at the feasibility of keeping the
street 21 feet wide. He noted that Terry Mauer, Consulting Engineer, has made the I
recommendation that the street be narrowed from the standard 32 foot width to 24 foot wide
measured face of curb to face of curb. Mr. Stafford also noted he contacted the Lake Johanna ..
Fire Chief, Don Szurek, who recommended a 24 foot street for safety purposes.
I
." .
~. bJP
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 25. 1996 ~~j::
l'
. Mr. Stafford stated the Public Works Staff recommends approval of Resolution #96-21,
. supporting the 1996 Street Improvement Plans. He also noted that Staff would like an Oak
A venue representative to be given the opportunity to inspect the plans and specifications,
. Councilmember Hicks inquired if there could be a liability issue with regard to tlle street width
of 21 feet. Greg Stonehouse, City Engineer, stated it is difficult to ascertain if there could be a
liability. He stated that if cars are parked on both sides of the street, it may be difficult for an
. emergency vehicle to get through. He stated 24 foot street widths allow sufficient room for
emergency vehicles to pass.
. Councilmember Malone requested to see the updated Pascal Avenue plans, Discussion was held
regarding the plans.
. Mayor Probst inquired if there is a difference in the amount of vegetation between the two plans,
Mr. Stonehouse stated the difference is only in the amount of grass; the number of trees remained
the same.
I Mayor Probst compared the emergency vehicle safety issue to the Amble replatting request that
.. is upcoming on the Agenda. He stated the Amble property include four homes, with no concerns
identified from the Fire Chief, where Pascal Avenue has five homes. Mayor Probst stated he
does not see the value to the community to lose more trees for an additional three feet of
. pavement.
Mayor Probst inquired if there was anyone in the audience from Pascal Avenue who wished to
I speak, No one responded.
COllncilmember Aplikowski stated Mr. Sean McDermott of3632 Pascal Avenue sent a fax
. regarding Pascal Avenue prior to the Council meeting. Councilmember Aplikowski stated she
does not see a problem with the street width of21 feet.
. Gloria Kuehn, 3581 Ridgewood Road, inquired what the plans were for Ridgewood Court.
. Brian Fritsinger, City Administrator, suggested Mr. Stonehouse review the Ridgewood Court
plans. Mr. Stonehouse stated an overlay would be done, with the narrowness of the street at an
inverted crown, sloping to the center. He stated this will allow the water to drain to the north end
. of the street, and allow the grade to surface drain to the ditch along Lake Johanna Boulevard. He
stated there will be no need for curb and gutter, and they will be adding berming to assist with
the draining as well.
. Mayor Probst verified that the water ultimately drains to Lake Johanna, and they are not
~ changing that.
I
. ~I
~o .
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 25. 1996 ~):-_
Mr. Greg Smith, 1644 Oak Avenue, stated the plan fits well with what they had envisioned, I
and it is the best solution at this point. I
MOTION: Hicks moved and Aplikowski seconded a motion to amend Resolution #96-21,
Approving the Plans and Specifications and Authorization for Bids for the 1996 .
Street Improvements, to include Pascal A venue street \vidth to be constructed at
21 feet. No vote was taken,
Council member Malone stated he is concerned with the 21 foot street width. He noted the I
Amble property is a private driveway, not a public right-of-way as is Pascal Avenue. He
inquired the street width of Reiland Lane in Shoreview. He stated he believed it to be 25 feet, I
and noted the Fire Department has had problems with access at that width. He stated the 24 foot
street width would better serve the community.
Mayor Probst stated Council member Malone has a valid point, and his own comments should I
not suggest the absence of a safety issue, but noted there is also a need to weigh the
"counterbalances." Mayor Probst stated he is comfortable with the 21 foot street width. I
MOTION: Hicks moved and Aplikowski seconded a motion to adopt Resolution #96-21,
Approving the Plans and Specifications and Authorization for Bids for the 1996 ..
Street Improvements, including the 21 foot street width for Pascal Avenue. The
motion carried (4-1), Malone voting nay. .
B. Adopt Resolution #96-20. Aceepting Bid and Authorizing Execution of Contract in
the Matter of the Bike Trail Im\lrovement of 1996 I
Cindy Walsh, Parks and Recreation Director, reported to the Council that Staff recommended to
the Council to approve the base bid and two alternate trail segments based on receiving the I
Cooperative Trails Grant from the Minnesota DNR, She noted that all three segments could be
complete in 1996, with the far northern section in 1997, based upon receiving the grant.
Mayor Probst noted a revised resolution was distributed. He inquired if the length of the .
alternate trails is much different from the original bid. Mr. Stonehouse replied it is reflective of
the contractor's desire to do more work. Mayor Probst noted the alternate prices are very good. I
Mayor Probst clarified what portion of the project the grant would cover. Ms. Walsh stated the I
grant would cover $45,191.50 of the project, and includes the northern segment that connects to
Highway 96. She stated the project needs to be completed by November 1,1997.
Councilmember Malone inquired of the funding approval. Ms, Walsh stated the entire project .
funding is $45,191.50, contingent upon doing the entire segment before 1997, ..
I
------------
I. .
~t
~. ' t!'t
""i")
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 25.1996 ~,3.'7
...,A
G<i"'" .~
I ,
Councilmember Malone inquired how much it would cost to do the north segment alone. Ms,
I Walsh stated they did not have the estimates at the meeting, but that Mr. Stonehouse may have
some estimates. Mayor Probst verified the City had budgeted $45,000 for the project.
I Councilmember Malone stated the estimate shows $37,400. He verified the trail lengths of I ,000
feet from Colleen A venue to Arden View Drive, and an additional 1,050 to Highway 96.
Discussion was held on trail lengths and locations.
I Councilmember Malone stated his estimate is $50,000. He stated he did not realize the grant
required other construction.
I Mayor Probst stated the entire project cost is $105,000, and the City budgeted $40,000 in 1996
and will receive $45,191,50 from the grant; therefore, the cost to the City in 1997 will be
I approximately $20,000, Councilmember Malone stated he wanted to understand the full project
cost before making a decision.
I MOTION: Hicks moved and Aplikowski seconded a motion to adopt Resolution #96-20,
Accepting Bid and Authorizing Execution of Contract in the Matter of the Bike
.. Trail Improvement of 1996. The motion carried unanimously (5-0).
C. Planning Case #96-01. Amble Preliminary Plat
I Kevin Ringwald, Community Development Director, reported to the Council that the applicant is
requesting approval of a preliminary plat consisting of four lots on a 2,99 acre parcel zoned R-I
I Siugle Family Residential District. He stated the property currently contains two single family
homes, which are serviced by an existing bituminous driveway. He stated the applicant wishes
to subdivide the property to place the two existing structures on their own separate lots, and to
I create two additional lots for their other two children to construct homes on,
Mr. Ringwald noted the Planning Commission had previously postponed its review to allow the
I applicant to modify the side lot lines of Lot 3 to maximize the lots buildable area in relationship
to the ravine which extends up from Karth Lake,
I Mr. Ringwald stated the City Council may grant a variance from the Subdivision Ordinance in
Section 22-12, (a), of the City Code based on the following conditions:
I (I) There are special circumstances or conditions affecting said property such that the
strict application of the provisions of this chapter would deprive the applicant of
I the reasonable use of his land;
,. (2) The variance is necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of a substantial
property right of the applicant; and
I
<}o. "I
.fr~ ."
. .0-, I
",^" A
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 25. ] 996 6 ~.,'.
(3) The granting of the variance will not be detrimental to the public welfare or I
injurious to other property in the territory in which said property is situated,
Mr. Ringwald stated the Planning Commission recommends approval of Planning Case 96-01, I
preliminary plat including a subdivision variance allowing the provision of a private driveway,
subject to the following conditions: I
I, Provision of the required driveway easement prior to final plat approval; I
2, Provision of adequate sediment and erosion control measures;
3, Payment of the appropriate park dedication fee; I
4, Provision of a driveway which is consistent with the requirements of the Fire I
Code; and
5. Provision of signage at the southerly edge ofthe driveway (West Amble Road) I
which identifY the addresses located on the private driveway,
Councilmember Hicks inquired if the driveway width will be 30 feet. Mr, Ringwald stated the ..
existing driveway will be used and will need to be extended to the northern property line of Lot
2,
Mayor Probst noted that the lot lines on Lot 3 bows on both sides. He stated the Council has I
taken great pains to avoid this design in the past, and inquired why it was being done now. Mr.
Ringwald stated the original plat had parallel lot lines, but the Planning Commission felt the I
revised lot lines maximized the buildable area of the lot. He noted they will pull the building pad
as far west as possible, so it is closer to the private driveway and to the existing structure, I
Mayor Probst verified that all setback requirements would be met.
Mayor Probst noted the ease of processing of this application compared to a previous planning I
case (Buetow), Mr. Ringwald noted that both applicants have been working with Staff since
November, 1995, I
Council member Malone noted the building envelope goes beyond the ravine, east towards the
lake, and stated that the building pad is speculative. He noted the original plat could not fit a I
house, and that this modification should solve the problem. Mr. Ringwald agreed with
Councilmember Malone,
Mr. Paul Amble, 1211 West Amble Road, 'noted that the square on Lot 3 is an existing garden, .1..
not a building pad. -.
I
I' . .
,"1. ;)
< l/
"",f'
I. ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 25. 1996 7~~~">,
I'
I MOTION: Malone moved and Aplikowski seconded a motion to adopt Planning Case #96-
o I, Amble Preliminary Plat, including the subdivision variance allowing the
I provision of a private driveway, subject to the following conditions:
I 1. Provision of the required driveway easement prior to final plat approval;
2. Provision of adequate sediment and erosion control measures;
I 3. Payment of the appropriate park dedication fee;
I 4. Provision of a driveway which is consistent with the requirements of the
Fire Code; and
I 5. Provision of signage at the southerly edge of the driveway (West Amble
Road) which identify the addresses located on the private driveway.
I The motion carried unanimously (5-0).
ADMINISTRATOR COMMENTS
.. Mr. Fritsinger had no further comments.
I COUNCIL COMMENTS
I Councilmember Aplikowski stated that four "no-parking" signs have been placed on Dell view
Road within her ncighborhood, and she will remove them if they appear in her yard. She stated
her understanding was that the signs would be placed if a resident wanted them. Mr. Stafford
I stated that Council member Aplikowski is correct, but to his knowledge Public Works has not
placed any '.no parking" signs in neighborhoods since November, 1995. He was unsure who
placed the signs.
I Councilmember Keirn stated the Human Rights Committee meeting is April 9, 1996, not April
10,1996, as stated on the agenda sheet. She inquired which staff has been designated for that
I meeting. Mr. Fritsinger stated it has not been decided yet.
I Councilmember Keirn inquired when the next Council meeting is, Mr. Fritsinger replied it is
scheduled for April 8, 1996.
I Mayor Probst stated the County's public information meeting on Cleveland Avenue is on March
27, 1996, He suggested that a Councilmember attend. Councilmember Hicks stated he would be
f1' available to attend.
I
,
Ce., '.
4 C/ c'
, , >.
~'" I
ARDEN HILLS CITY COUNCIL - MARCH 25. 1996 8 ,f'I.
Mayor Probst noted he will not be in attendance at the April 8, 1996, City Council meeting. .
Mayor Probst inquired of the status of the Bonding Bill. Mr. Fritsinger replied there was no I
update to share at this time,
Mayor Probst stated he felt it was important for the City to increase the public's awareness of the I
activities surrounding TCAAP, and will be contacting a reporter at the St. Paul Pioneer Press.
Mayor Probst stated the Metropolitan Council is sponsoring a workshop on regional I
communities through the Livable Communities Act. He stated the workshop is on April 9, 1996,
and will be held at the Humphrey Institute for no charge. He suggested a Councilmember or I
Staff member attend.
ADJOURL~ I
MOTION: Hicks moved and Keirn seconded a motion to adjourn the meeting at 8:15 p.m,
The motion carried unanimously (5-0). I
..
Dennis Probst Brian Fritsinger
Mayor City Administrator I
NOTICE OF MEETINGS I
The next regular City Council meeting will be held April 8, 1996, at 7 :30 p.m. at New Brighton I
City Hall.
I
I
I
I
..
I
I
I MINUTES
{t CITY OF ARDEN HILLS, MINNESOTA
WORKSESSION
MARCH 18, 1995
I 4:30 P.M. - CITY HALL, PUBLIC WORKS LUNCHROOM
CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL
I Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, Mayor Dennis Probst called to order the City Council
worksession at 4:32 p,m. Present: Councilmembers Paul Malone, Dale Hicks, Susan Keirn, and
I Beverly Aplikowski; City Administrator, Brian Fritsinger; Parks & Recreation Director, Cynthia
Walsh; Public Works Superintendent, Dwayne Stafford; City Accountant, Terry Post; and
Community Development Director, Kevin Ringwald.
I Roundtable Discussion
a. Committee Reports
I Councilmember Hicks updated the Council in regards to the recent Public Safety
Committee Meeting. The Committee has an opening for one member.
I Councilmember Malone updated the Council in regards to the March 6th Planning
Commission meeting and the three cases which will be acted upon in April.
.. Councilmember Malone briefed the Council on discussions by the Fire Department
Benefit Association. Mr. Malone reminded staff that Attorney Filla was to have provided
I a legal opinion on approving pension changes. Mayor Probst also indicated a desire to
look at a joint powers agreement and opening discussions with other cities regarding fire
department services.
I Councilmember Aplikowski informed the Council of several upcoming Parks Department
activities. The Easter Egg Hunt will be in April, flower plantings in June and Perry Park
I Grand Opening in June. Councilmember Aplikowski also noted that Land O'Lakes will
assist the City with the preparation of the Economic Development marketing brochure.
I Councilmember Keirn requested that a staff member be appointed to serve as liaison to
the Human Rights Committee. The Council concurred.
I b. Department Head Reports
City Accountant Post briefly updated the Council in regards to the water meter
I replacement project. Mr. Post specifically requested input regarding the hiring of a
consultant to assist with the preparation of an RFP. The Council directed staff to move
forward without consulting assistance,
I
it
I
I
Public Works Superintendent Stafford advised the Council on the County's support for I
several optic an installations within the City. Staff was directed to inform the County that ..
it supported opticons when necessary and that the City would budget in 1997 to pay for
the 1996 project.
Mr. Stafford also updated the Council regarding the possibility of extending the I
watermain along Old Highway 10 to residents by Round Lake. This area is not currently
serviced by municipal water. Council directed staff to proceed with a feasibility study and I
hold an informational meeting with residents to discuss the proposed project.
Parks & Recreation Director Walsh indicated that Earthday will be in April and local boy I
scouts will be performing community service by picking up trash in park and trail
locations.
c. T.C. Field & Company I
Mark Lenz, T.e. Field & Company, advised the Council as to his findings while
reviewing the insurance coverage carried by the City. The Council should consider I
changes in its boiler and machinery, open meeting and excess liability coverages. The
City should also review managed care for its Workers Compensation coverage.
Councilmember Hicks requested that these items be reviewed and discussed at the earliest I
opportunity. The Council concurred. ..
d. Administrator Comments
Administrator Fritsinger reviewed several issues with the Council. Mr. Fritsinger advised I
the Council of liability concerns regarding the construction of Pascal A venue at twenty-
one feet.
e. Council Comments I
Councilmembers briefly reviewed several subjects with those in attendance.
Councilmember Malone asked that the Council be given an opportunity to review I
proposed assessments related to the 1996 street reconstruction projects prior to formal
public hearings.
Mayor Probst will be absent from the April 8, 1996 Council meeting. I
f. Education Update I
Mayor Probst briefly discussed his attendance at the 1996 National League of Cities
Conference.
1996 Ramsev Count)' Street Improvement Plans I
g.
The Council requested that staff continue to track the proposed County CIP projects and I
involve the County in the 1997 Budget discussions,
The meeting adjourned at 7:02 p.m. ..
I
r .
~ CITY OF ARDEN HILLS
MEMORANDUM
DATE: April 4, 1996
I TO: Mayor and City Council
I FROM: Brian Fritsinger, City Administrator @
SUBJECT: Municipal Insuranee Coverages
I Baekground
I At the March 18, 1996, Council Worksession, the City Council reviewed the current insurance
coverages carried by the City. Mr. Mark Lenz, T.C. Field & Company, was in attendance and
identified several areas of coverage tor City consideration.
I At the request of the City Council, I have investigated two areas of coverage for consideration at
this meeting; Open Meeting Defense and the Waiver of Monetary Limits Related to Excess
I Liability Coverage,
Open Meeting Law Defense
.. The City Council last considered this coverage in February, 1994. At that time, the
recommendation from Staff was not to proceed with this coverage as it was erroneously assumed
that general liability insurance would cover this issue.
I The existing general liability insurance does not cover this issue, The Open Meeting Law
I coverage would reimburse the defendent for defense costs for Open Meeting Law lawsuits up to
$20,000. The annual premium for Open Meeting Law coverage, through LMCIT, is $536.
I Exeess Liability Coverage
The City last considered this coverage in January, 1994. The City has historically carried Excess
Liability Coverage in the amount of $1 ,600,000. This includes the statutory limit of $600,000
I plus an additional $1,000,000. In 1994 the Council elected to waive the monetary limits on tort
liability established by MN Statutes. The rationale behind the Council's decision was any
coverage beyond the basic $600,000 was an acceptance of liability beyond the statutory
I limitation of $600,000. The assumption was the maximum the City would be liable for was
$600,000.
I The attached documentation supports the comments of Mr. Lenz that the liability limit under MN
Statutes is $600,000. However, the City is exposed to some kinds ofliability to which the
statutory limits either do not or may not apply. One example is Federal civil rights claims or
I claims made under Federal jurisdiction. By waiving the monetary limit the City actually was
stating the higher coverage limits would be available for all claims, including claims to which the
it statutory liability limits would have applied.
I
. I
I
Recommendations -.
Staff recommends the City Council authorize the additional insurance coverage for Open
Meeting Defense and elect to not waive the monetary limits on tort liability established by MN .
Statutes in the area of Excess Liability Coverage as detailed above.
I
I
I
.
I
..
.
I
.
I
I
I
.
..
I
I -t . ~ ~ : .I':' wi:,::,,'! ~ ~ .' . ; I ;.i':;. ..:-:-:
". _. ., _ "' ,.. L. . ~ .
LEAGUE OF MlNNESOTA CITIES INSURANCE TRUST
I MUNICIPALITY QUESTIONNAIRE CONTINUED
Ulcrr EXCESS LIABILITY COVERAGE
,. Cities obtaininr excess cover~e from the Le~e of Minnesota Cities
Insurance Trus must decide wliether or not to waive the statutory liability
limits to the extent of the excess cover~Ilurchased. This decision must be
I made bbthe cifO council. CITIES PUR SING EXCESS COVERAGE MUST
COMPL E AN RETURN THIS FORM TO LMCIT BEFORE THE EFFECTIVE
DATE OF THE COVERAGE.
I For i'uItllu hllaftlll&tiOZl, refer to the llooompll.lI1lq lDemo. City ol'SeklA mt.1 also wazat to cUsC1U9
theM IssUII!: with .the city attorzae,.
I The City of accepts exeeM liability coverage
I limits of $ _ irom the League of Minnesota Cities Insurance Trust.
Cheek O1Ie:
I The citY. DOES NOT WAIVE the mone~ limits on tort liability
:- establislied by Mmnesota ~tatutes 466. 4.
I - OR-
_ The city W AlVES the monet~.limits on tort liabililrn~rablished
.. by Minnesota ::ltatutes 466.0 ,to the extent of the 'ts of the
~~ess liability coverage obtained from the Lea,..,aue of Minnesota
Cities Insurance Trust.
I Date of city _Zion mootizag:
I S{gzaatUfCl:
Pocitioza: _
I Retv.rZl this eompletClcl fOfm to Berkle, Risk Semces, 920 SeC:Ollcl AftZllIe SOlltb, Suite 700,
I MiZlZleapolis, M1f SS402-4023.
I 4/92
LMCl'l'31 (2)
I
I
f'
I
I
- I
~
145 University Avenue West ..
League of Minnesota Cities St. Paul, MN 55103-2044
EXCESS LIABILITY COVERAGE AND LIMITS I
The League of Minnesota Cities Insurance Trust offers cities two options in purchasing excess I
liability coverage:
. LMCIT makes it possible for cities to obtain excess coverage without waiving the statutory I
liability limit of $600,000 per occurrence. Under this option, the higher excess coverage
limits would be available only for those claims which are not covered by the statutory limits. I
Alternately, cities may choose to waive the statutory liability limits to the extent of the excess
.
liability coverage purchased. Under this option, the higher coverage limits would be available I
for all claims, including claims to which the statutory liability limits would apply.
Cost I
,
The city's premium for excess coverage are approximately 25% lower if the city chooses not to eI
waive the statutory monetary liability limits.
Background I
LMCIT's basic liability coverage provides limits of $600,000 per occurrence. LMClT also offers I
cities the option of an additional $1 million, $3 million, or $5 million of liability coverage limits.
Since the statutes provide that cities and city officials and employees can't be held liable for I
amounts over $600,000 per occurrence, city officials often ask why it would ever make sense to
buy coverage limits higher than $600,000.
There are several reasons why a city might choose to buy limits of coverage greater than the I
statutory liability limits:
I
First, the city is exposed to some kinds of liability to which the statutory limits either don't or
might not apply. Some possible examples are: I
. liability under the federal civil rights act
. I
. certain types of liability tllat the city has assumed contractually, in an indemnification
agreement for example ..
AN EqUAL OPPORTUNITY/AFFIRMATIVE ACTION EMPLOYER
(6l2)281-l200 (800) 925-1122 TDD(612)281-1290 Fax1612l281-11
I
I
,. liability for actions in another state; e.g. by a city official attending a conference, or under a
mutual aid agreement with a political subdivision across tlle border
. liability for a zoning action under an "inverse condemnation" theory of law
I
I Second, the underlying coverage might not cover the filii extent of the city's exposure within the
statutory liability limits in all cases. LMCIT applies a $600,000 aggregate limit to the "products
liability," the "limited pollution," and the optional "inverse condemnation" coverages. This is an
I additional limit, besides the $600,000 per occurrence limit that applies to all liability coverage.
The annual limit is the maximum amount the policy will pay for this kind of liability, regardless
of the number of occurrenccs. Thus, if part of the annual limit is used up in one occurrence,
I tllere may not be adequate coverage limits available if there is a second loss of that type. Excess
coverage can help protect against this risk.
I Third, cities sometimes cover other political subdivisions under the city's coverage; since each
entity is subject to liability up to the statutory limits, you could /"1m out of coverage if both
I entities were found liable in a single occurrence. HRA's or EDA's are corrunon examples of
separate public entities that might be covered under the city's coverage. A fue relief association,
.. which is legally a separate corporation, could present this issue as well.
Under the statutes, these entities are legally separate public corporations and political
I subdivisions in their own right. This is true even if the city council serves as the HRA or EDA
board. As public corporations, these entities are exposed to liability themselves up to the
statutory limits. It's possible there could be a situation in which both the city and the HRA or
I EDA were liable on the same claim. The single $600,000 coverage limit per claim would not
fully cover the two entities' liability if the sum of the city's and the HRA's or EDA's liability
exceeded $600,000. Excess liability coverage is one way to address this issue. Another solution
I is for the HRA or EDA to carry separate coverage.
I Fourth, the city might be concerned whether the statutory liability limits will stand up in court.
The statutory liability limits have now been upheld in several Minnesota Supreme Court cases,
so this is now less of a concern. However, it is always difficult to predict the future course of
I court decisions.
I Carrying excess liability coverage can protect the city against these kinds of risks. The city
council must weigh these risks against the cost of the excess covcrage.
I . Sometimes city officials reason that "we're only a small city, so we don't need high liability
it coverage limits." But if anything the opposite is true. A big city has much more tax base and
many more taxpayers over which to spread, say, a $1,000,000 excess judgement. In a small city,
the burden per taxpayer could be enormous.
I
. 1
Waiving tlte statutory limits I
..
There is another issue cities need to consider. Some cities may feel that the statutory limits are
not high enough to provide adequate compensation for very serious injuries, or for multiple
parties. That is, the city might in effect say "We want to have at least $1 million (or $.J million I
or $5 million, etc.) of coverage available, so that if we injure someone he won't go
uncompensated ifhis injuries really do exceed the statutory limits."
LMCIT's standard excess liability coverage is structured so that the statutory liability limits I
remain in effect for those claims to which they apply. However, LMClT also gives the city the
option, for an additional premium, to waive the statutory liability limits to the extent of the city's I
excess coverage limits. 1bis "waiver" option would make more funds available to an injured
party on a claim where the statutory liability limits would otherwise limit the amoullMhe
claimant could recover. I
Buying higher liability coverage limits gives the city better protection against the risks it faces.
It's important to understand, though, that buying the more expensive "waiver" option doesn't give I
the city any better protection than tlle "non-waiver" option provides; ratller, it gives the person
the city injures better protection by allowing him to recover more than he would otherwise be
able to from the city. I
There's no simple "right" answer to the question of whether your city should buy excess liability ..
coverage limits, and if so whether to do so under the "waiver" or the "non-waiver" option. These
are discretionary decisions that only the council can decide. The council must determine whether
the added protections (for the city and for the party the city might injure, respectively) are worth I
that additional expenditure of city funds.
Wfzat does tlte city need to do? I
Every city should periodically review the question of whether to carry excess liability limits, and I
if so whether to waive the statutory liability limits. LMCIT quotes for excess coverage show the
premiums for both options. The decision to waive or not to waive tlle statutory limits must be
made by motion or resolution of the city council. A form to show the council's choice is I
enclosed with each quotc. That form must be completed and returned to LMClT. If the city
indicates that it wishes to waive the liability limits, LMCIT issues a special endorsement as part
of the coverage document showing that the statutory liability limits are waived to the extent of I
the coverage purchased.
PST - 11ll/95 I
.
I
..
I
(. .
I
~ OPEN MEETING LAW DEFENSE COST
REIMBURSEMENT AGREEMENT
I I. OPEN MEETING LAW DEFENSE COST the Minnesota Open Meeting Law; however.
COVERAGE LMCIT shall have the right to intervene at its
expense in the investigation or defense of such
I LMCIT will reimburse a city official for 80 percent of legal action.
the defense costs incurred by the city official in 3.
defending an Open Meeting Law lawsuit, if the The city or the city official shall give prompt
I following conditions are met: notice to LMClT of any actual or threatened
legal action against the city official seeking
1. The date on which the Open Meeting Law penalties against the city official for an alleged
I lawsuit is commenced must be within the violation of the Minnesota Open Meeting Law.
term of this agreement; and
4. The city and the city official shall at all times
I 2. The date on which the violation took place or cooperate with and promptly respond to
is allegcd to have taken place must be on or LMCIT's requests for information,
after the retroactive datc. if any, shown in investigativc data. records, or any other
the Declarations. material documentation,
I An Open Meeting Law lawsuit is deemed to be 5. The city official will be reimbursed only for
.. commenced on the date the city 'official is served defense costs incurred with respect to legal
notice of the lawsuit. services actually rendered and expenses
actually incurred,
II. LIMITS
I 6. The city official shall have complete freedom
The Open Meeting Law Defense Cost to choose an attorney licensed in the State of
Reimbursement Agreemcnt Limit is $20,000. This Minnesota to provide the city official with legal
I is the most LMCIT will reimburse anyone city services with respect to which defense costs are
official for defellSe costs for Open Meeting Law reimbursable under this Agreement.
lawsuits commenced during the term of this
I agreement, regardless of the number of lawsuits, the 7. It is the express intent of the parties to this
number of actual or alleged violations, or the date Agreement that neither the city nor the city
the defense costs are actually incurred. official waive any immunities, defenses, or
I limitations on liability available under
III. CONDITIONS AND EXCLUSIONS Minnesota statutes or common law.
I 1. The term of this Agreemcnt shall be one year 8. In the event that a city official makes a
beginning with the effective date stated in the recovery of defense costs from any third party,
Declarations, Subsequent rencwals of this LMCIT shall be reimbursed for any payment it
I Agreement shall be treated as separate terms, has made under this Agreement after the city
official has been fully reimbursed for his/her
2. LMCIT shall have no duty to provide a 20 % sharc of the defense costs,
I , defense to a city official with respect to a 9. LMCIT may cancel this Agreement by mailing
legal action against that city official seeking
,. penalties based upon an alleged violation of or delivering written notice to the city at least:
LMCIT OMLRA-t (11-93) (R", t 1-94) lof2
I
1
a, Ten (10) days before the effective 3. "Defense costs" means reasonable and I
date of cancellation for nonpayment necessary attorney fees, court costs, court ,e.
of the charge for this Agreement; or reporter and transcript fees. general witness
and expert witness fees and expense. and
b, Thirty (30) days before the effective similar defense related costs. Defense costs
date of cancellation for any other does not include any fines or penalties, or any I
reason. attorney's fees awarded to a plaintiff in a suit
charging a violation of the Open Meeting Law,
If LMCIT decides not to renew this .
Agreement, LMCIT will mail or deliver to 4. "Joillt powers entity" means an operating entity
the city written notice of nonrenewal not less created by two or more governmental units
than thirty (30) days before the expiration entering into an agreement as provided by I
date. statute for the joint exercise of governmental
powers, An intergovernmental agreement will
10. It is mutually understood and agreed that the be deemed to create ajoilll powers entity if the I
city and all other LMCIT pool participants agreement establishes a board with the
are jointly and severally liable for all claims effective power to do any of the following,
and expenses of the pool. The amount of regardless of whether the specific consent of I
any liabilities in excess of assets may be the constituent governmental units may also be
assessed to LMCIT pool participants when a required:
deficiency is identified. I
a. To receive and expend funds;
IV. DEFINITIONS b, To enter into contracts;
..
I. "City" means the city or other governmental c. To hire employees;
body or entity first named 111 the I
Declarations. Unless specifically named in d, To purchase or otherwise acquire and
the Declarations, city shall not include a gas, hold real or personal property; or
electrical, or steam utilities commission; port I
authority, housing and redevelopment e. To sue or be sued.
authority. economic development authority,
area or municipal redevelopment authority, 5. 'TMCIT" means the League of Minnesota
or similar agency; municipal power agency; Cities Insurance Trust. I
municipal gas agency; hospital or nursing
home board or commission; airport 6. "Open Meeting Law lawsuit" means a lawsuit
commission; welfare or public relief agency; seeking penalties against a city official based .
school board; or joint powers entity, on an allegation that the city official has
violated M.S. ~471.705, commonly known as
2, "City official" means any former or present the Minnesota Open Meeting Law, I
elected or appointed official of the city or
any present or former employee of the city.
I
I
LMCITOMLRA-l (11-93) (Rev, 11.94) 20f2 ..
I
I ,
CITY OF ARDEN HILLS PAGE1OF2
I ACCOUNTS PAYABLE CLAIMS REPORT
TO BE APPROVED AT THE 04108/96 COUNCIL MEETING
Ie
I CLAIMS PAID SINCE LAST COUNCIL MEETING (03125196)
1 CKi# ItKibA1llI\IEJ!ll)()R I AMOUNT I COMMENTS -:;;;;g
I 1 1
10068 03/21196 DCA. Inc. FSA Department 210,70 Medical Reimbursement
10113 03126196 St. Paul Book & Stationerv 548,44 Various Office Sunnlies n_
10114 03126196 Lowell G. Milbrath 14.38 Final Billino Credit - Utililv Accounl #134
I 10115 03129196 Green Liohts Recvclino. Inc. 44.70 Recvclino of fluorescent Bulbs
10116 03129196 Burger King 22.50 Vacation Day Trip - 03/29196
10117 03129/96 Discoverv Zone 38.251 Vacation Dav Trio' 03/29(96 ii
10118 03129196 Science Museum of Minnesota 41.00 Vacation Day Trip - 03/29(96 ,
i
I 04(01(96 Ramsey County 47.043.00 Law Enforcement - April
I 1,220.07 3M Opticon for Squad Car
148,263.07 Reverse 1995 NR Accrual INet Check - $0.00'
i , 10119 04(01(96 Metropolitan Council Wastewater Services 47.023.00 Sewer Charge ADril
I 10120 04(01(96 Cily of Bumsville 51.00 Munici - Pals Snrino Banouet. Lund & Saencer
10121 04(05(96 Public Emvlovees Retirement Assn. 2.287.88 First Avril Pavroll
10122 04(05(96 ICMA Retiremenl Trusl - 457 1.699.82 Firsl ADril P avroll
I 10123 04(05(96 Stale CaDitol Credit Union 2.589.78 Firsl Avril P avroll
1 1
1 Su btotal Paid Claims 54.571.451
.e
I Paid Claims From Above - 54.571.45
I Add Unpaid Claims, Page 2 of2 28,091.20
Total Accounts Payable Claims
I I for Couueil Approval, 04/08 82,662.65 i
I
I
Note: Checks for unpaid claims tolaling $55.589,96, were issued on
I March 26. 1996 after approval allhe March 25th. 1996
Council Meeting. They were check numbers 10071 - 10112.
This sequence corresponds to unpaid temporary numbers
Tl-T42. Check numbers 10069-10070 were used for alignmenl.
I
ClAIMSZ
.-
I
I
CITY OF ARDEN HILLS PAGE20F!
I ACCOUNTS PAYABLE CLAIMS REPORT
TO BE APPROVED AT 04/08/96 COUNCIL MEETING
e
. UNPAID CLAIMS REGISTER:
I It'EMP..fI...i..cg,llAt'E.I....WNDOR iAMOuJilT..ICOMM.ENTS '.'.:...:.1
I I
TOOl 04/09/96 I American linen Direct Sales 54.65 Uniform Purchase Saxe
I T002 04/09/96 I Animal Conlrol Services. Inc. 188.00 Do. / Cal Enforcement, 03/05 03/19
T003 04/09/96 ! Bover Ford Trucks. Inc. 79.59 Vehicles #101 and #106 Repair Parts
T004 04/09/96 LuAnn Brunn 200.00 City Hall Janitorial Serviccs. 03/15 04/15
T005 04/09/96 Copy Duplicating Products, Inc. 220.87 Toner for Laser Printers
I T006 04/09/96 Davies Water Equipment Companv 297.00 Repair Gas Detector
T007 04/09/96 E- Z RecY~lin". Inc. 4.714,00 March Service
'1'008 04/09/96 Earl F. Andersen. Inc. 71.36 Street Si.lU)s for Colleen Court
'1'009 04/09/96 EDAM 300.00 Summer Conference Fritsin.er & Rin1!Wald
. '1'010 04/09/96 Focus News 40.32 Notice for Public Hearin~
TOll 04/09/96 Garelick Steel Company, Inc. 234.82 Shop Supplies
'1'012 04/09/96 Gopher State One-Call. Inc. 68.00 Febru3rv Service
'1'013 04/09/96 Government Finance Officers Assn. 120.00 Annual Membership' Posl
I '1'014 04/09/96 W. W. Grainger. Inc. 78.90 Shorty Jack and Combo Wrench
'1'015 04/09/96 Juliet Hanson 11.00 Refund Recreation Trip
T016 04/09/96 High Point Creative 422.10 Perrv Park Malerial Ph ase II
I '1'017 04/09/96 Ilen Chevrolet Company 277.55 Vehicle #2 Reoair Parts
'1'018 04/09/96 Kathv Johnson 20.00 Refuod Fla" Football
T019 04/09/96 Kath Auto,Supply 263.93 March Purchases Reoair ParIs
'1'020 04/09/96 Larkin, Hoffman. Dalv & lind.ren. LId, 3.207.00 Legal Services February
I '1'021 04/09/96 Madden Resorts 499.68 EDAM Conference - Fritsinger & Ringwald
'1'022 04/09/96 McDonald Batterv Comoanv 135.84 Vehicle #103 Batteries
'1'023 04/09/96 Medica Health Plans 2,565.43 April Insurance
T024 04/09/96 Metro Fire, Inc. 79.88 Rechar.eable Flashlight
I '1'025 04/09/96 Metropolitan Inspection Service, Inc. 1,596.00 Electrical Inspections March
'1'026 04/09/96 Meyer Enlerprises 133.13 Vehicle #50 - Alternator !
'1'027 04/09/96 Minnesota DCDarment of Revenue 2.226.00 Sales Tax Remittance for 1Q96 I
'1'028 04/09/96 Minnesota Department of Health 64.00 Water Licenses Stafford and Saxe
I T029 04/09/96 MN Deot. of Trade & Economic Dev. 695.00 Economic Dev. Finance Class Rio1!Wald
'1'030 04/09/96 Mortoo Salt 799.76 Road Materials I
'1'031 04/09/96 Northern States Power Company 3,769.50 Current Invoices I
"
I T032 04/09/96 Northern States Power Comoanv 958.92 Slreel lightiog II
'1'033 04/09/96 Tracy Petersen 52.70 ReImbursement March MiteaQ:e :1
'1'034 04/09/96 Plaisted Comoanies, Inc. 507.79 Road Materials Coarse Sand I
'1'035 04/09/96 Dennis Probst 614.89 Reimbursement N at'l League of Cities Conf.
I '1'036 04/09/96 Ramsey Counly 692.90 Diesel Fuel & Uoleaded Gas - Februarv 'I
'1'037 04/09/96 Kevio Rin1!Wald 62.51 Reimbursement Milea"e and Meetinj!S
'1'038 04/09/96 Safety- Kleen Corporation 93.72 Servicing Machines
'1'039 04/09/96 T.A. Schifskv and Sons. Inc, 13.69 Recvcled Base
I '1'040 04/09/96 Snap, OoIocorporated 17.72 Sockets and Wrenches
'1'041 04/09/96 State of Minnesota 8.00 Decals - Certified Insoection ofVehicIes
'1'042 04/09/96 Kathrvn Slranskv 3.00 Refund Easter Eg" Class
I T043 04/09/96 Surplus Office Supplv 265.75 Two Used Bookcases
'1'044 04/09/96 Timesaver Off Site Secretarial 105.50 Council Meeting 03/25
'1'045 04/09/96 US West Communications 1.204.19 Current Invoices
T046 04/09/96 Cvnthia Walsh 56.61 Reimbursement March Mileage
. I J
I Total Unpaid Claims - 28,091.20 I
c"""~
.-
I
I
. ~8g~8 888 ~g 88:'88
_::cicioo5M ccici -od doddd
........ .. .... 0 l- C'<
,-- PiJ:, t':, """ ....~ N~
=tt: Z.... ...."<t
Ie c:i I
ti:" ,,..,,..,' I>
- =. II
U
l- ~ N g N l- l- ~ C N ~ ~ 0 0 :3 g ~ N ~ "<t :~ ~ ~ C'< N C
I . ~ ~ ~ N ;.4 ::l ::l '_r ;j d ~ ~ ~ ci ..; ~ ;;; ;2 :;J ;;J :~ :;$ ~ ~ ~ ~
~": N ~ .... C .... "<t C'< ~ .... C'< 2 ~ ~ "<t N .... .... ~ l- ~ ~,- l- """ N .... 0
.~~~"<t ~ . ~~. ~ ~~~~_ ~-~~-
co :. N .... .... .... ....:No N ~ ~ ~ l- 'N ~ ~....
m .. "
~ 1<< ~
~' ""
I g ~.
8 02 jl . ~
I Cl ffi I 1i .0 B ..'1 ,~ ,~8 < tl'
W- . L .~ \-4! ';: Q t) - t' u lr'l
f-<- 8 I t -~ ~ .,.'. . ".I;:J '~8 .g 8 M..... Ii: tl' 3
< .., :>~",., ,"c c ~ ~ 0
.... C .... u" ., -0 ;:J" ~ I 10 0 N
Cl ~ 0 ~ ..~ '. ~ ~ ... ~ -~ - .
','.'. ~ u la ",.... ',. u~oo ~ ~ ~ '" ..... < t> "'@J ~
.. la S u ~ .... ',_ ~ C ~ ~ ',. Vl ,~ la
en .;._ ._ .0 ::J "'0 .:- -': 0 ~ 0"0 5 < ~ ...D .- .0
I ~I....., ~ 'E '~ ~ ~ ..~ .C" ~ ~ ~ ~ ]- 0 ~ ~ ,..10.,..,.. ~ 'J'l c1l ~ -g
Ow R o~ ~~oJ ..~ u.~~-o ~i~B. ~2~O~
!Ii! c5< 1'0"< '.,.; ~~,.; ~~~" 03~i:lUH i:lr~<<
I 6..<~ ~ ~ Ii: ~ ~ ~ ~g g: ~g ~ ~ ] g: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ] ~ ~ ~
Illi'.""".[]]] [IJ '" fj ~
I .~.....~.. . . . :~ ~
! ~ ~
, '~ ~
.e i '" :;: <! <! 11
t: ~ d ~ ~ <'l
..J ... &!.. .."..... I I ~ ~
....J e \0 I I :5 ~ ~.~
o " ~ E E '" '" "~~
I a: .lib 0 ]] ~ ~ I ~ e:
>- ~ I:lI '" '" > > ",,,:::i
< I 85':8~~8
a. I vi ,..;; M ~ r-: od
- ~
I ...Ji u) ddddd~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ N 0 ~ , '
1"1 ........""""....~~~~t--<<IOO'<1'OO<<lOlOaoOlOaoroaoaororo N...-< =~2
:< ~ ...-<~-_....... ..... ~2~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 8 0 ~ ~ ~ ....... ro M ~ ~ 0 ....... - ~ t-- '<1' t--IN ~ ...-< ~ ~ E ~ 0
I cn~ ii~~i~ci~:;:1;~~~~~~~~d~~~;;:;;~~ .m," "C.~~
N M - ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ...-< ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ q ~ ~ ~ ~ q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 ~
[I: - ...-<...-< ~ """'00 .,l:l~..s
- ~. ~.i;j'"
IJ.. __ I#' e 0 ~
I 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ 0 0 0 ~ 0 ~ ~ t-- ~ ~ ~ <<I N 0 0 ~ N 0 0 0 :~ M & ~
q q q q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ q ~ q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ q q q :~ ~ Q ~
~1rlV10VlOlO'<1'aOt--...-<~aoO~N~r--NCl'.~\O'<1'0\0\\O~O :"<::i O~~
~ \0 \0 0 ~ on t-- N t-- <<I ~ N ....... 0\ N \0 ~ N r-- t-- N r-- N t-- \0 ~ ao '0 ~ M
NNN~ ~::;:3<<1t--'::'<1':3:::~:1::}.~:-:3::~:1.:::'~"""''''-<.~ .~E;;:
. :o'a.s
I "'""" ~ HE
. E-t q;l Q
..... ~ e
!" 8,. ~
(/) '. I I e t;l -g
..J :. ..Q ~ '0 'I 8 ~ e
1 ....J :Ii ~ I::~ t'j - 0 I,: -I!-q;l~
-. G [; i .S ~.~ .- fj ~ .Q t'j ~,,:,' ~.;:]
I ~. ~ _,:Q'~ ';:: 1; ;:: "3 ..!l ~ :.;;.c -;:: ~ C ~ ~ :0 -- ~ :>. -t; "" Iii '" P-
I 0 I:: ..... I"-, OU U 0 ~ ~ ~ OU 0) .....:;;:.s l-o .- () :<: .g .e-.
Z .8... ~~~~~~~~~d~~gE:;;;1l~~~~~~~~f-<~~a ~... E~~
w .. ~ CI ... ~ ~ 0 0 .... "0 ., l-o b;l 0) 0 l-o .,~.,..... kt ~. v ...... O' d r" \;o;f. "d:;j f
I Cl ..'... ~. g is - ": ~] ~ i'i t ~ '; ~ S ": g '" d Iii '2 .t <i .d 1;] 'ii d ~ R ~ '0 ..'J
. 1S 0 ~ r.n .I=l ~ OU U ,,'0 0 12 '0 .:2 0., 0 ~ ~ l-o 0.... ~
~ I !11~~~i~!!I!!I~i~liJ3~1~!!~a ~
I- ~ II ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ I~~d i = ~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ = ~ ~ : ~ = S ~ ~ 8 a s ~ ~ ~ ~
;l:X">., \0 ~ '0 ~ \0 \0 \0 \0 ~ ~ \0 \0 \0 \0 ~ \0 \0 \0 ~ \0 t-- t-- r-- r-- t-- t-- t--
o :.....:::.:JIiOI' ~t:"'l~t:"'lt:"'l~t:"'lt:"'lt:"'lt:"'l~t:"'l~l""\""'''''''''''l''''\~t:'''l''''''''''o:<''lf''\'''''''''''''''
I
I'
~. CITY OF ARDEN HILLS
MEMORANDUM
I
DATE: April 8, 1996
I TO: Mayor and City Council
I FROM: K""" Ri'...'d, C,~=ily Dml'pm9t D""t'~
SUB-TECT: Planning Case 96-02
I The following is a brief review of the request and the recommendation of the Planning
I Commission. The Staff has previously provided the City Council with the Staff memorandums
on these cases as well as the minutes of the March 6, 1996 regular meeting of the Planning
Commission.
I Case 96-02. Stephen Nelson. 3280 Sandeen Road. Utility Easement Vacation
I A. Reouest
The applicant is requesting approval of a utility easement vacation (sanitary sewer).
.. B. Backl!round
The applicant is requesting approval of a utility easement vacation to allow for more
I buildable area on the subject property (Exhibit A). The applicant is requesting that the
utility easement be vacated and rededicated to allow for greater buildable area in the
direction of Lake Johanna.
I C. Planning Commission Recommendation
The Planning Commission recommends Planning Case 96-02, utility easement vacation,
I be approved, subject to the following conditions:
1. Construction of the new sanitary sewer line and demolition of the existing
I sanitary sewer line is to be accomplished without the loss of service to any
residential property;
2. Payment for the relocation of the sanitary sewer line is to be the responsibility of
I the applicant;
3. Provision of plans and specifications for the new sanitary line which are designed
to City engineering standards;
I 4. Approval of plans and specifications for the new sanitary line by the Council;
5, Inspection and acceptance of the new sanitary sewer line by the City prior to the
I elimination of the existing sanitary sewer line;
6, Installation of silt fencing is required between the construction area and the lake
,. prior to the commencement of construction activities;
7. Approval of the necessary grading permit;
I
-~-- ----
, ~ '.
8. Provision of the smallest amount of bare ground is exposed for as short a time as .'
feasible;
9. Provision of temporary ground cover, such as mulch, is used and permanent
ground cover, such as sod, is established; I
10. Provision of methods to prevent erosion and trap sediments are employed;
11. Provision of fill that is stabilized to accepted engineering standards, approved by
the city engineer; I
12. Compliance with the requirements of City Code, specifically Chapter 20.5.;
13. Applicant will indemnifY and hold the City harmless for any damages arising out I
of the construction of a sanitary sewer; and
14. Applicant would convey to the City by appropriate bill of sale all of the sanitary
sewer pipe and appurtenances which are constructed as part of the sewer I
relocation project. Conveyance would be made prior to the issuance of any
building permits for the property.
Case 96-02. Stephen Nelson. 3280 Sandeen Road. Variance - front vard setback I
A. Reauest I
The applicant is requesting approval of a 10 foot variance from the required front yard
setback.
B. Background .
The applicant is requesting approval of a variance to allow a 30 foot front yard building ..
setback when a 40 foot front yard setback is required (Exhibit B). The applicant is
requesting the front yard variance so that this property would have a similar building
setback from Sandeen Road as the adjacent properties. I
The property at 3280 Sandeen Road is located within the shoreland management zone of
Lake Johanna, Therefore, the property is subject to the Shoreland Management I
regulations (Chapter 20.5) of the City Code.
C. Variance I
The conditions required for the approval of a variance are found in Section Vlll, D, 4, c,
of the Zoning Ordinance which states the following: "Adherence to the provisions of this
ordinance is required except for special cases which arise because of the configuration of I
a particular parcel. The condition shall not have been created by the landowner. A
variance or variances may be granted from specific provisions of this ordinance because I
such land factors as length of a side of a lot, the shape of the lot or the unusual terrain
prohibit reasonable development equivalent to that which would be permitted without
variance on a similar size lot located in the same district, but which lot has no unusual I
configuration. Economic conditions alone shall not be grounds for a variance."
1. Lot Configuration. The petitioners lot is relatively rectangular in shape, it is .
approximately 109 feet in width along Sandeen Road, 60 feet in width at the lake,
181.5 feet in depth on the South side of the property, and 184.6 feet in depth along ..
the North side of the property according to the Ramsey County parcel map. The
I
,
I
I
I R-2 Zoning District requires single family lots to be at least 85 feet in width, 120
~ feet in depth, and contain 11,000 square feet in area. The petitioners property
exceeds the R-2 Zoning District Requirements, in terms of; lot width, depth, and
area. However, the property is adjacent to Lake Johanna and therefore has a 75
foot rear yard setback versus the 30 foot rear yard setback that non-riparian lots
I have.
2. Terrain. The property is steeply sloped from Sandeen Road down to Lake
I Johanna. The property drops approximately 34 feet from the road to the lake.
The variance which was granted to the McCloskey property (3290 Sandeen Road
- Planning Case 87-09) was based primarily on the steep topography in this area.
I " Reasonable Use. The property currently contain an existing structure. The
~,
I existing structure is a legal non-conforming use and subject to Section IX of the
Zoning Ordinance.
I The properties in the adjacent area typically do have front yard setbacks which are
less than the required 40 feet. As previously mentioned the McCloskey property,
which is to the North of the applicant's, has received a variance which placed that
I front yard setback at 35 feet. Also, the structure (legal nonconforming) to the
South of the applicant's (3260 Sandeen Road) has a front yard setback of
approximately 35 feet.
.. 4, Economic Conditions. The application did not contain any evidence of an
economic hardship.
I D. Planning Commission Recommendation
The Planning Commission recommends approval of a five (5) foot front yard variance in
I Planning Case 96-02, based on the property's steep topography and the prevailing front
yard setback on the adjacent properties, the recommendation is subject to the following
condition:
I 1. Compliance with the requirements of the City Code, specifically Chapter 20.5.
I
I
I
1
it
I
I
I ,"--
{' t=)(J~-nN~~-,'~,"-~'-"'--'---
, /' /
i ~EMEIJ"T '- >-
: ,~
I ' ~
I. " "1 'i ~
~~~ ~
I 3Z'jo II I '"
~ J"2 ;; 0 :1 '0
~~' "
I I Q I lil~~ -"',' '
'" .>__ 0 .- '
,> : I~"::: I ~ '_." [ · · · ' I
.z ," -I", - .j' ..< '
~ . 0 "'-::_,-' 'o,.~, !I ... &.lj 00 en ,:l:, !
1m '<..... ,-, to. . 'f '-" . m'
m ' 1_ '<- 7 < -.
, '. _ 0" .
. z ' -." - ' .' .
,'" _ ."
" , _J '-- I _'.! · ] I
I 0 I" l f' It,'i co "
'E; ; '< '-'>,- "', ",~ / l~l~' '
I ' _ · - '" 0 :J - =.
, " . . ..'" '
I .,.,.. '_'_" ~-:. '0> I
I ' .......".. ,'" . '::0," ' .
, .,_. '. ,",< !
, _<("<'" : I" " I
. <0. - .< ·
"'~ ,_... ' ''''',' l I
.. _' '. .. ,~< "" I
.. _. .,' , I
~:ll' '
-'lBO' . --.:.':~. ,',.' l.l, -\
I ,m . I
,., . " .
. ," .,." ----.c: I '
~ 0,< - ~'
- ' - . . '
,'. ~.'
I ~.~"'
'1 g I
- ,I \
I ,,- ,I
-' .
_ FR~ STRE.E:r TO FRottT ~
.. OF .BUlLDlHG SITE."
-... - ~
I - -"1 n" - - ".
. ' _ _ _ 10 " " 'if;
. - '.
Ii I .. .--- .' :.;f==c~:,'j:'~""-'- .~14")'" ~l II
. I ,"- -116---
" . " -- .. ,.
l " ,,~ i
"'~ e t ~ .
.. . ,! .'
, . .~ ," '-, '
I ,I !. :~,~ 01,. ,.1
, , . I ., a" '.~ I
.. " '. r. II. I
I ' . -, - m ,0.' " ,~I
" ' ,...,." ." .,."'" ,'0'
iii '>',- or ,. I 2 ~ P :l: .0 ,,'3 '\
.. .. ,..' .
,. ,.~, , .,' o. ,.
~~., :' .,"
~.~ ,I ~ ,~
_ 8 - :r. '.
,or ::0'
~,. ~
g I:'
. ..
; t -
,01
I .~~ ,I
\ . , ;
. ..' '_I -.,
"
"
- ----- . -.~
Z./~.
---::::=J~;,~~-~~~~~~~~~~;~~;~~-..........-~===.... .1.
'(FROr.lAS;~ON.S'tItUC"tEp:~lU)l'tf.Nr ",.. ""':'
....... ....... ....... ....; ............................,.............................:.............................,............. ........... ...:............ .............................m.......... ........................ .....
, , ,
'j'j: "J~6~~' ,. I
: .910, .} if""':"" I
I
I
I
.
..
I
,,",' ,,', "," ,.."",............... ..,.... I
ij ...i!. ...ii ..i. .ijit]i I
, ",~,<,! "; "':: "I" {....I "..',>1..;
. ".' ..""..................., ".. ....,.., , I
; : ............: .......................:.. ;.. .......:..
. ". . . . .
. . . ... -....,. .. ...... ....... ....
, "
, '
.., ., ,.....................:..........,
. ..1 i;; ......... il .:: .1.............I-iI' I
I"" "" .."""""" """" "",..' .""""""", ,',',"",: """""",., """.,'"",.......,:..."""L"...,:,.,:::,.,:.."..,..,".""....(:~t~~~:~; I
.
-' . .---.---- _._~_.-..
--..
._--~,..
I
,
I 3/0
, ,,---'---'--" . ,-,.- '--,- --- '--" H________'. .. ----- .--.. -- --r------- .--..-- -"-'-.
~. ('.{. .
I '0
I I ' ~, ~
i "~'i ~ ~ !
I i. 'H i ~/,/ 1 '"
i ~;;o c;l ..~ i
' Q.~ . &,ll 0
I ' ~il ~ l1: I: .
s-,g. Il,......:r r
,
_ 3.' o:~. I
~ f 1 < .~: \
. II' 17.- - C1 a .
U1 -;' il!l
I
~ c ~. (s----' ".~l~
1m, .. / ~5" I
m I ;"0 Ci fa :
_zrlg. i'~O:' ',\ !
;;0 , ~-_.. . . . '-.< 'i \ i
!
~ : l;~ ,<'l; 11 ,
I c \ ~).l i i
\ '--0 ,I . I
\ ' 1 ,
I ~.....~___,: 1 . -i
1 --_ ~ . ':::0 \ l
I ' '~', 1\ ,
'- ',---.- !..OT,. \---- .... . ~;~ r ,
,
.. l~T~__~c:.' __~_~__ ----.-_8.>....-.:::: ,', I
!
Ie 3z8(:) _~. --.:= i
.='-
E' ,
,(ll _. !
<0'(5"'" '.;!
I lQ_<.e 'i I
'" ...... III ,::I
"! ';..;,C'.<c
,0 '::ll ,~
.,::1 8, i
I ., I
I I
!
I "00' FROM STRE:E;rTO:r~ ,OF BUILD.rtG SrTE-. I I
.. - LOT 2f)~ '0.00', - --- __1 \ ,
I
J .... - _ ~ ~. ,-,
I .. , --~ -- ---.--..---<:,...,='c:~:=C~-;----116 .../
m ~ ! ".'H
z I
2 'oi:
~ . .! U t., ;, S':i' ~.lj; ,
I I .. .;:rr:'
, ",-};, rtill s.; dl ~CD
g ~ ~: ~ 1 <;~ r- '~..:c...
~~ ,g.:ll CD:;O .
0';::1'
" 0 ~ t (>11\ ",'I: . . ,m
,,"-... o . p:r ::I,
I ~,~ ~.. z ... .::1
. ,Ill
3l~ W ,. I ~ " ~
, _. C I R '"
~.~ , ~e... 0"1' VI j -< .
....
DIl: '<0 ';lIl 'C: ~ t ~ .
I ~'" ;..... ;.<' ::I, ~ ::I'
, ~ c ~~ CQ- <: Z t.
;. ~c: ' ~
1Il ..... '0" = f' t
'::I ,8 ~
it ' . I !t
,., .
,- ,s.
. t L ..,-!
. ~r
il
.. ' ,
~...~, ..
. ,j
'\ ' ,;-,
",
-,--- -...---"^----. --~--------
~ I
..
I
~ ,____n..._..~__..........__~___~_. . - ",,_. _..~..,,"'--.~-- ""........._~ ... .
"1-~'1!~~~oi~~~~~1~J'~d~)~,~"d'~A_~~lr~
. "., m "'.,.....':"..ALCtbN~t~@tibN~i-iA([:CON~:Ji'~ifTo:mE'~TANOAAo:S?ECIFrC~T1bNSFOR::'.:': '. '" ,.. lmm
: :uTiLITY'GONSTRUCTlbN"AS'PU8~ISHEO BY T~E MINNEsOTA ClfY'ttNGINtI:a:~'S': ,..: ':
, : ":~~~~iAT1~A~~:T? t~~::~t~~?1R~~'9F jH~ 91~~FA.~0N H.ll~S. .:. ..,,'::: ;: : I
,.. ....... ..,..., ....,HEMO\I.E,f.NO.DISP.O~E:OF, 30~.:M:P..f.LEANO.2.1:.;Ol\K.,.P.RESER\t.E..30':..QA1S ..:' : ..:,:.... .:..,......,.,.. .....,:....:. ,. .:.. .910.
uu' . ,u . ,. , , ,..", ,." ,..,,' .... ...... , ,,' '.. ,... , ,..,. . ... .. ' ,...... ,.. ~ "",'u
",..,:.. :~.P9~~d;"P(E~;oNdF1iiEsAN,T.hRY:sEwE~J,RE69NslRklRErAIN,~GwAi:[: ,i=,: "'::'"J uul
rmu ..:.!~6.;:i~~~~~~~~~~~~t.~~~;:1 ~I~~,?~ T~fF.~D f'REA1. ,p.~~:: :':~,::l
"'" m__ . """".." 7~'m..uu' .a"t!Y.csw Q 894 64 '~E ~ 895;pofl
"
~roi. No. Sheet No.' of::'
f
I, u -. --~._-_.- ---- I
.~
------
1-
-- ..'r....
I" . . f'" . ....,~ · · ,.,.. .
..1 . .'1..:.. 111111,.r' ,:lil,!1 ..
r ........... .,.,'l '. . o~.
Z . . ..,..... ( . ,'" .' A .,....,..., .,1> ....l.
I'. ."~ .1' '.1. '. .. ,..~l..~ ..,......
I .+.' ,!t 1\~1.1 !':TH :HJ_hTII:nw!': .!~~[ "1111:\11":
.. ' L .. \ . '",
.en"" .. Gmr~"l"l' · ,...," . ," '
f Z . ' , , r ~.. ..... ,.
Q: II ~, : . : I~". · i::::,C11ill.U !: l
"n..: ~.~ ' ..11l .' .,1 .' ' .. .
,l~l('; . :: -,,~l.:!~ilk ':,,11;::11:11
'LL' I " , · J' . ..", I ..' .,'
I'~'llll!' : 'U ...JI\i\lil~1 ,__h ',$~, ~,\,I ....\.\.. 'T.';'\
I . ., I ,I,.r1.' .' ~p .,' ' ' '
,),' "fill"! ~',-j'",""""""
, ...' " ,,,,'I' I ,n. '
, '
, '
, '
I I
- ,
!
-- ------.- i
..-~- j
u -- - -
_u .-...
,
! , " 11
, . ! ! !II! .'t' I !: '.
:,:",:: '; Yfl! alJ~ !'...: i ~ ,oJ::
" .:,"'ii'" "l\->--_-.,-_ Ii, J " I, _L~'C
I.~ ".,,,.~".,,,,Tl~'fT. Ill, ~ I ",-;rl::
: i-i:I'l~!::;;1 c:~ ":, ___...:- I r /" ; ,: . I. '_,:I::
I ",'.,.I,'I'.~.'..il.".:I:I<:'::'" '.'. II' J l '! !, ".l?,,~ ,
I "i,. i\'WQ'i\''/ i- -', ' ; L I , .,....:_~:-(,1'11
I ,,,.,,-,",,,,,1..,, ..., ""~' ..' -"'-0 " I
'''I'''''''''''''' "'" ~l' ' ---;- I,
'1 ":"!i!'I';'~' ."'.- ' [ f' I , i -Z:;J:
! ;:rriHi'f[r:/:..- r, Ifl.j '''__~;' ~ i-'~;
,....,I '"'4~. ..1I""~ C"F'-,' ---~ .
il,,::!:,:r:~~_~.\\-->l- i(,(: ~\I II : ,I
! , " i :', ',!, ,I _;.~;; \ \ ';"'.,; - i E ~ \.
",'b~I:!llU1U!l:"":,~~J':'---JL ,', ,'!I!!', 1 " , I
I "~'I,,.,,,,j"H,h, . ,....." ."'~!,"~ , '-> T' ..."
,-"""",,1,,,<., 'i.. ".. ..,. ,-"~I II 'I I: , '
~~'!:l!i~I,"IP .,:.., ". ' ,I ' '-'I'~ I . , I' I !
~,~!i~:-mi,; ~ 'j ,~ ~~~;;;: .~:.;,~, : : <~~_~_ '. ..:...J.! H I --== ~= ... ,
'II" ,,' !:
i'j.:i: '"" >.: I
2>, -.," ~.;. :' ,.1 Z','"
, .'i' <;:.',-..\_!
"~_"_,,,, -- ' ':li,;,;!
Ul~~~;.~, .: L~igl ",
I!l!!.:t i. '"... ' I
" :';,- -, ;," >
1J,lt,l} ~~ "., \,~
,I~c,c"" -<" 0 I
03;;1::' ~~'"'~: ~ c<.
J :~ ' :~~ it "?' 6 il
~:1II_: ~i~ ~ -z. ...~
Ik" ,i!' ~ 'Z ~ m
, " ~~~ 1 ____....... "?' Q
"", I
i, ~~5 ~ \,..
1_ ~,-". [. ~~~ ~
1 '''I, i \lil' ' ! ' r I :'! ~
i":::,l !Plj : t 1I'lii II' !l f ~
" I . . ~ ,,: ~ 8 ~ ~ ~f!h! iII 11 HIli i I
: ,,'__." 'n.' ~'I . I 'f" '~ ~
,-...,..,..--Q. ll. t...1 ll. - .
i :i;'~I,,,I, ,l[ , L~q' 1,1111 I' ,; I ,~.,~! \ j
1,.,.,..',,',.',iftl~"\!.,i:.j.hi,:j~l\.~~~'I' : ~ I'II:~! II Ill') t d I ";',a; ~'i.' ~~"
""",'i11"""'::Ji:\'" ,~ "II ! I 'I "pl' "I
.."T,-,~:'l ,'~f~tHt!;,~:,:\ ~~ '; J ~ ~ i I I~fll I ~r, i~~hi~... z
i' , - ~11l. 11.1" I J >11\- ~...:z ...
'\,.....,..,:.... '.i ~.,....,.. :HI i i,i'!fil I ~I~~~ ..~;~,-~, ~
, 'I" p} . t " : "J' "~~.. --
i. \, '; g l.! :;;lilt'!! ~ t. ~ ~ -'. ' ..
i" , . ~ i I ~: ! 0" l I , . ! "
, 1]1, '." _1"1 ~'rl J! ji
I ! C" ~. ~ J.~..,.
.\'..,', "'. ,,,~, ,,:, -i',-'! ,I I /
[!! {~~ ! ,.,j,' !I-!;' :.:l~i-j ~ ".
Il~i j!\ ~. HI [. ,;. . / I I
'It.., 8 / If
"\[" "'f'''' ,..,," --....-- / ~ -
'_ \ ,I' "~ ' > M........, I ,
'v ..! li( I \
'^:~ ,."0'., IL~" __n" iq~ ! /! Y. I
a ij' i :,in\.'" "=--....J!i I II r(, .
Cll .-' I f;~' . , 0"'-- i" 0 I ' ' '
"." +.."+ '. 'I""\.I tl'l I'" ~'~!: '
~ I,' I.... ',' .,', -:U. II" ~ I! "'. iI/id'
o . .'.' . L' "'. ., ~ ! 'A .~.
";'"' : ".' ! : I '! I .a ~~ I '! [__ I ..: _
, .. . < "" -. ~".. ~. , t .
Z "',."...,'..'..,'.0""'-"'=-...,........\'\"."...11'. _..,...'~'-, "~'-"'~~ ~ ',I' , !. ~""" qll, , I
(0';: I _,'I I I ' ,: ' :~ \~~". 'I I' :w;1 I
~.:',' i',i i ,.:,: ' .. 1 "'.1 i ,::,":, hi J '
',...,',...11\ "1" .~ 'II 'j I; f~'
",..j ,;.,;1;;;" ,-' " : <> m . I
'leo7" '1""+'1'" \ ,I "..' ,. "'n' . Z .' "
,""!h't....,"..!I'," "'O'H""~" ,. I rr'~
""~""'?":':""'I" \'\'\ " 'jO~1 p" 'F~ 0', I . I
:::1" :l~!it,HH-!:Hi:!!\ : '. '.~ a :~~ ':: ~~~::oii~ i; ,- .". p;
,:ilti.,'l' >',. I,",'~"".,~,'.' " ..o"o,>.8....oo..'.~',0 . - J
<111~~.:,:"'...'I. .~ml.'^~~,~ "!-, '\'-..""', ~
'. i.1,\;.1.%\I",I".'. ',.'.,..'., ,Ii . '.8~1'..~.'. 5'." · "",.. J6 i ' ~ '
~~~nl~iJUJJ::_~"t _ _ ""~~,~,,_:.fL,,,~,~:i~~~~:~ ~ ..... ____-"11___' i _" ~ "-~
"lilL!"..,..'.i~i' '.. i!;~" !H~n,' """'I <<',I . '\~"'" ~ .,,-!-~- I
'~.~~:'iG:j>,::::j:it~: ~ .-~ i~~i:,~: .~g-'~~'... 81- ~ j i/;, I \~ ". ' J
'l\ -.'1 "",- ""I., .m, ,- ' ,l:im.:;'; ,.., ,....... -..... -. '. l
,..I'.'."...".'..'.'.'."J.'.'.' 1. "'.'o..~.,!~.jj.-s..~'j! ".l q, /I~,';<'-~-'~ I
L~~-::< ":]'01" C'l , i:t~=<'fiI iil~'J:: ;o.iQ '5"r ~Ill ,I "~ ~','; ...
~~'ii';::':'!::i: iIII i ..., ~ :~z.%:,~. ~oc; :,: ~ ~ a.')i' ': ~t\"
'~IH'''''1 If' ,', ' : 'I " ~.~ ' ; , --J ';'"PI" I
~:i1r~~:!,:'~+th+----, 'i ~~ ~.; i ~i-~ Qi~ -'-,~i ~ _ _'_~],--;": -. \
'..'1 <;'..." '.....1. · I : ,I .~ ~ "I ~ -,-.-..,..-..-- ",' ~
V'l :': " f"f' ii";;: ": !O ' , '8 0 ~ii: j '4"- ';> ~
:r,,:,:~~';t!'NfWlol'UG..2-, 4~ ~.... ~ ~ l ,,__. "'... --_-- 0,
lD :: ::,.,;;;. ".T." ',..- : ., 'I . .0 "l _
,..,.I,,~,,~, L,~,'.~'L""~"',~~-", ,.o-R .1l.~ , " ".
~ --r,<I':!;""I',_"'j;. !edl I~ '. ~~ ~ "Ql!l :~'! i .. d~ ' ,~ 116
Z ";.,1,':.""."",., J..,.ll '~, . ~~ ~ ~~~ 2. -I' II '\, ,/ f H
o '~";":!T ~;'mOO:" ~zo. If .- ._
. fifi.I' il!..lr.~;'ii..I;; I r.,,'! H: . ~n ' U -;,t "I! I' II \~ l;:, ;i ~I 1 ~ I
'.'i 'I"~'"' ~ . , 11.",.1 I ,I .' " ~. ! ..
o .' . il;Z'~i zr: ',.' . ~!:I :.,t ~
-,~. " "[" 'I 0 '0,," ~.,,~- '" \, , r"" . ~ "
...t -::J ~;~':KI ;! 1I , . i I .., Ii :;, :, 1 ":!
~ . , .' 1 I. '. ", · ' ., ' , I
.. "'l < ,.1; r, "'f \ I"~; , . i=' ~ oG . ,
.f<li "I!i 6 I: ~': "1 ~"Ii ' ' ~ 3 f", I .
VI -~--~_.y-t.":'i :..~._.......sl: '- ." L I' 1
,. "I' 8"1. Go" < ..
III -...;, I! 'co '" ~..~ 8 ~ I t I
~ ::::; ~ ~ I i I!!;: ~ ~t/I! Q ." 01 . : ~
. 'i , . I
~.I ~~" ^(-:,fi ' 7 _d_
I! ~". I".... II..
i_ I "'-, p~ E VI r "
I )' 35' Y. ~~p Ii' I ~
\.)I '" s. i i / / ~'C1
l: I ~ ~ J~ i{~ 'oj Al~~
D _ s.1l. V ,," c
o - tl-
> ~,~." ~ "~ < '
~ Q" a: ;J '" .:I:
. po Cl.lj co (!>'.
_ __ . m 0
,m ' __ ,".""-- . .' 1111 i' C.J ?i Q.' -:"
, ,- ,,'
,Z : ~ '" "",,J~ .it-.::~/ ' i
10;:0 I 'Or" r ::----.c. "'00 I ~ / l~~/ Ii "':
I 13." 0- . . .. /" CI 0,"< . ~
> ' '" '. '" ' / '!!'","
o ' -., ,'~ >- "". : ,.
I 1 ''''''' , -' "" -I / -,P cc
, " .....-. . ,.'
~ ,'-"'!>" _ ~_:::., / .~ :0-......'<,. ',' \
, ' <;O-d d. . . . ",' 0
, ",d" <r""'-'" ' . . '., ~,,,., "
I ___:'. _.1QL.!.! _' --:--1' .. -', r:""...!'~' ,: ,I
". ~..., '.. ' ' :o-c..~," '
, "... .. , ' , .~~" 'j
. _ _ _ _ ..:.:,._,. ~ _ _ _ j , . , ' 1:?~,> ,- , .!,
"..Cd"" ...' """,'i'.,,," " ,.t -'~
i i .. '" ' ,:-,---.. " \ ,..,'
, ----, -- " ~~' ,''-." ..':~:;
. -- t' ~. ",--..'
.. ~ ,,:m. :p.ll / '1 ' . ,~It "':_'.':\
"" ,co)< - ~ 1 I ,~... ",. ---..; ",,'
,..... <.0 :::;"'. =' I' ,..,.'., - ,- ' , ,
. 0 w .. 'j" ~ t' ,.. - '
~ ~_<.,<::: I, ' i/, I ".,", , I
\r,. ,~ => ' II ';J
I 0 N)5'.IO, ll.~' /JZ~/ Ii"'... \~' 'iJ'!
,_=> ,:;!l ..'~ 1-,' { " '.,
- I I' ,""
8 ' i, ~ . . , I \ ~ '" ~ ' ' ,..'
~, _ I ' / I ' .,1. ,--
. '
"xr~' ~ ,I I I ~ .....,
.~.="..._~ "" .
I ' " - BU1Lll""'sm I - -~ . ,.,
_ _ _ . _ _ _ 1 1-" _ .' > I I < -. -(<0
___--"'- .~.. I ',-:;
. , . ' , . . , .0
. ' -: .. .. . , ' ',~, !
Iii _ __,.--- _ __~-:, -,.. g'.. '"- .~\1 i
> " .. .,. ...,.... .' ""
, " .,., -. ,"
"" ~?'l' "
,<' ..' I " ' /' '
l i '05 'I' BI." 1! " ',:
I '~"~ (A'fJ?W--.) l'i~ ','i ~ ) I ~g :g:,g-g:,; I
p . 1 "<l o'~ ", Ql .
, " ; ,< _.r < "
I .0 .. .0 r ' .. 0
m ~ ~ _'. ,t;';I; -s. ,: 0. 'Ol ,~
o ,0 .-' .-
, ", .. N< ,0
, ' _', ;,,!l' ,,, 'I 2. ~ p:r; ,0 '5f
," IV- ,p' ,,' o' '
I 6'.~ ..' , ..,. -::l
O,o;.Q) 10' ~ ~ I .,"1. ,~
. .c: ' " .' -.'
....'O..'~ " ~ ,..., ~
,_ ,. ~ _ 2. ,<
=> ,8 ~ t'"
It ,::," ~ t:J
g I 1, 0
, ' t I 75' .~' "2 r
o ,- '
I .. " , .,
" ,,' '" ,):
... -. .~
," ., ,-".' ..'..:~' , ,"
.. (c.it..o.CI'" ' ,'" " . ';.-'1
~~~~,""",,'.' ~ -:r;<~;:~
_ .,,,,,..-.E<.lT i -;.-;'< :,';
-/ . --r ri1 i I ~ / zf3 'I
/' II Ii J~I//I I
,-~j
10 II J f1 f' ~ ' / / I /) -I
~ 1 ~ ' " / /y, I '
6' , /1 )11 ( ,,/ I /' I
- .;:. ( J I I J d/"',
u j V1 / I (r\ ! I , , I (I I! 'llJi VlI
.:p 'r i "\ "---- i 1 '. \L. ' ,\ I' r ::
C / (! \ 32\00 ~ I \ \ \ \ ~\+i \ " '\ ) =-rf"
S>- I" , "\ .. "".
I ,~~ \ \ \ I, \ l 1 J. ("
;J'" I . ! '-. \ \ \ \~ i i il " 1"-1
..;~, \. \, ',\. \ \ \., I I! " i
! \ '-- \ \ \ \ \ I
i d ~\ '. ~ 'y \:\\\"') \1/1 I I
-..J I 'i? ,<'0" ,'-<:2:. '-.../ \ \ I; I
II to f\0f/'~ r"~,J 'v \ I rI
' \ '1 \ \ 1 I ...,...
(" I I Q \ ~> "\\ \ Cl:l cf rl
~I I: \ ...f I \" :' l !
c:! I) I>! II --\ '\- I'l
'-, I "I i . ') ,
] V I -!- .>J) I I ,0 i I i ~ II s ; I
i , I I ' \ ~
..9'ii I \ \ [fl i:g ,A- I
'0 \ I\::) CJ I C\) I
/ :Q ~
'C>zl
....
I \ I
;
....,
I
"-0 I
-
~ I
,. ,.
\ ;.........
. . ":&~
. . ~.
,:, '. "~ ~ .-:-1
\ . \;.~'.. 3 { f.'
.. .. ~ . .,
. .... .::.. ~. .
--
I ----'. :3 /3
~ "'" ,.
~~~&@u&
Ie (, DE P A ~~e~ ~2~ ~am<?r ~d" ~ tJ ~ !s'ik6'6~f SOU R C E S
I PHONE NO(612) 772-7910 F'LE NO
F-~ E-" i-~.~, ~::. ~ \ / C' i~-
March 7, 1996
I Mr. Kevin Ringwald 1 ';'\('!
~;;f' r" 1 '\'1 1.~
Community Development Director Utr\~. . '.,.'"
I City of Arden Hills -"
1450 West Highway 96 ;'
Arden Hills, Minnesota 55112
I RE: City Planning Case 96-02, Stephen Nelson Utility Easement Vacation and Variance Request.
Dear Mr, Ringwald:
I Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the above planning case. I have reviewed the information you sent this
office and have the following comments.
I I. I do have concerns for the variance request for the front yard setback. The OHW setback of 75' should be
maintained. Neighboring homes meet the 75' setback requirement, I see no reason to grant a variance for less
I than 75'. Also, the city's shoreland ordinance has a maximum allowable impervious area of35% for R-2
zoning. I am concerned that the increased buildable area would lead to the maximum impervious area of35%
being exceeded, which would also require a variance.
.. 2. I also have concerns about the proposed relocation of the septic system, The relocation of the sewer line will
increase the buildable area of lots 19 and 20. As in the comments above, we would object to this request ifit
I would facilitate the development of the lots in excess of35% impervious surface.
3. 1 assume that lots 19 and 20 will remain under single ownership (neither meet minimum water frontage width
I standards). I would object to the granting of the variance requests if the result is to build two homes where
now there is only one. 1 believe that the intent of the city's shoreland ordinance (Sec. 20.5-42 Substandard
lots), is to require that nonconforming contiguous lots under single ownership remain combined.
I 4. Utility lines are specifically exempt from shoreland setback requirements. However, we are concerned about
the erosion potential during construction. The area of the proposed work has steep slopes and the potential
for erosion would be high, Strict erosion control practices and inspection should be required.
I Thank you for the opportunity to comment. If you have any questions, please call me at 772-7910.
I Sincerely;! ,4
// / '/ ;I'
,/>. .' r /
",'/ " .'/;,... ,-"
-~---~--._,{-.-_._-// ./ J/ --'''7 )
I i'-6-A:A._4~"';c~ //
Peter A. M,-r.;eete
Hydrologist
~. P AMLikl
c: Stephan Nelson
I Lake Johanna (62-78) file
I AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER
I
I. CITY OF ARDEN HILLS
- MEMORANDUM
I DATE: April 4, 1996
I TO: Brian Fritsinger, City Administrator ry)
FROM: Dwayne Stafford, Public Works Superintendent
I
SUBJECT: Lift Station #6
I Background
Lift Station #6 had been identified earlier for modifications due to its age, type of construction
I and for safety reasons. Public Works Staff had previously received permission from Council, at
its October 30th, 1995 meeting, to prepare specifications and to seek proposals to modifY Lift
Station #6 to today's standards, Proposals were received on December 6, 1995, from three (3) of
I the major lift station contractors in the Twin Cities area, These companies were:
Tri-State Pump and Equipment Company
I Waldor Pump Company
Quality Flow Systems
.. Recommendation
After reviewing the three (3) proposals with Mr. Janski, the Engineer from MSA who specializes
I in lift stations systems, the Public Works Staff recommends accepting the bid of$23,544.50 from
Quality Flow Systems. In addition to this amount the Public Works Staff recommends the City
spend an additional $250.00 for stainless steel pump lifting chains, verses the standard
I galvanized, as the chains are attached to the submersible pumps and are subject to heavy
corrosIOn.
I This bid is higher than Tri-State's bid of$18,128, however, Tri-State's bid did not include a new
concrete top with aluminum hatch for the existing lift station which is needed for removing and
servicing the new submersible pumps. Mr. Janski felt this bid was vague on other issues.
I The bid from Waldor Pump was slightly less at $23,341.48. This bid, however, did not include
site restoration.
I The bid from Quality Flow of$23,794,50 includes site restoration, which could be a significant
I amount based on the steep slope to the site and the possible encroachment on private property.
See attached proposals and recommendations from MSA.
I. Funding:
Originally Public Works Staff and the City Accountant had proposed using monies budgeted for
a new lift station alarm system to pay for the #6 Lift Station modifications. Since that time,
however, $26,600 has been included in the 1996 budget just for this modification.
I
I
\
I'
I CITY OF ARDEN HILLS
I- RAMSEY COUNTY
RESOLUTION NO. 96-24
I
I A RESOLUTION ACCEPTING BID AND AUTHORIZING
EXECUTION OF CONTRACT IN THE MATTER OF
THE LIFT STATION #6 MODIFICATIONS
I WHEREAS, the City of Arden Hills had ordered plans and specifications be prepared for the
modification of Lift Station #6; and
I WHEREAS, the City Engineer has solicited bids for the modification of Lift Station #6; and
I WHEREAS, the Company of Quality Flow Systems has provided to the City of Arden Hills the
best bid and proposal; and
I WHEREAS, the City of Arden Hills has identified $26,600 of the 1996 Capital Improvement
Budget, specifically for this modification,
.. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Arden Hills, that
the modification of Lift Station #6 contract be awarded to Quality Flow Systems in the amount
I of $23,794.50, as per proposal.
PASSED AND ADOPTED THIS 8th DAY OF APRIL, 1996.
I
I
DENNIS P. PROBST, MAYOR
I
I
ATTEST:
I BRIAN FRITSINGER, CITY ADMINISTRATOR
I
~
I
M~ '.
\ I
December 26, 1995
File: 520-000-00 -I
,-
CO\SlL T1\G E\GI.\[I]l~
1326 Energy Park Dri....e Mr. Dwayne Stafford
City of Arden Hills I
51. Paul, MN 55108 1450 West Highway 96
612.644-4389 Arden Hills, MN 55112-5794
1.800.888.2923 I
Fax: 612.64,.9'46 RE: PROPOSED LIFT STATION NO.6 UPGRADE
Dear Mr. Stafford: I
As requested, we have reviewed the proposals submitted for the referenced project, and I
have made a few lelephone calls to clarify some questions. Proposals were received from
Tri-State Pump and Equipment, Waldor Pump, and Quality Flow Systems.
The Tri-State submittal proposed using Myers, submersible, explosion proof, 5 Hp pumps I
and a basic undefined control panel. The proposal did not include excavation costs, gate
CV~L ENGIN::\;;'<G valves, electrical work, restoration, or debris removal. Bypass pump rental was listed as I
EW:;ONMENTAL an extra $1,200 to the base proposed price of $16,928. The lack of the excavation and
MuNICIPAL electrical costs make it difficult to compare this proposal with the others on a cost basis.
P:....i..~lN!NG The total proposed cost of $18,128 does not include potentially significant costs for ..
SCUD 'tIAS"~ subcontractors to install the new cover slab and wire the electrical controls,
S7RIX~lJAL
5J,'/~"(:~.G The Waldor Pump submittal proposed using Flygt, submersible, non-explosion proof, 3 I
fRAF::C Hp pumps and a basic USEMCO control panel. The proposal quoted $12,771. 48 for
T.~A~jS?OR;,~ i:QN equipment, $9,720 for labor, and listed potential options of stainless steel chain for $250
and explosion proof pumps for $600. The proposal did not specifically list check valves 1
E _:::~KI CALl ,',lEe,.. Ai\liC t..:. but Mr. Goehring of Waldor Pump indicated that they would be provided. Mr. Goehring
:\.G;"c:~".G anticipated installation of the gate valves inside the wet well structure, so excavation for
''""','J:..:: I
;;Cw:~ DjSFL3YiO~. outside installation would be an extra cost. The proposal did not include site restoration.
S("'C:A With the stainless steel chain and the explosion proof pump, the total price of the Waldor
5'!$TE\\ CON~ROLS proposal would be $23,341.48. I
The Quality Flow submittal proposed using KSB, submersible, explosion proof, 3.4 Hp
pumps and a basic Consolidated control panel. The proposal quoted $14,164.50 for I
equipment, $9,380.00 for labor, and listed a potential savings of $2,000 if the restoration
work were completed by the City. The proposal included a master electrician and permits
to complete the electrical portions of the project. Stainless steel lifting chains were not I
included, but Mr. Bill Meline of Quality Flow indicated that they could be added for about
$250. Mr. Meline also indicated that they had anticipated placing the gate valves inside I
OFFICES IN: the structure so excavation for outside installation would be an extra cost. To compare the
quoted price from Quality Flow with the Waldor price, the credit for restoration by the
MINNEAPOLIS City should be deducted and the price for the stainless steel chain should be added. The ..
PRIOR lAKE comparable price becomes $21,794.50.
ST, PAUL
W ASECA .
An Equal Opportunity Emplo)'er
I'
.
I Mr. Dwayne Stafford
,. December 26, 1995
Page Two
I The proposals from Waldor Pump and Quality Flow would provide basically similar
system and operating capabilities, The Tri-State proposal lacks significant costs for the
subcontractor work and, therefore, is not actually comparable, The Quality Flow Systems
I proposal at $21,794.50 is approximately 7% less than the similar system proposed by
Waldor Pump,
I We have submitted all three proposals to our electrical engineer for review of the proposed
control panels, In his opinion, the proposals from Quality Flow and Waldor were similar
and suitable but, before final acceptance, there should be clarification that phase failure
I protection is provided.
Based on our review of the proposals, we would recommend award of the project to
I Quality Flow Systems. The amount of the award should be left open at this time until the
proposed storm sewer improvements in the area are better defined. There is a good
I potential for some additional savings on the lift station project if the excavation work can
be done with the proposed storm sewer work,
.. After the final scope of the work on the lift station is defined, we would request an
additional quote from Quality Flow Systems,
I Since this lift station is located in a rather sensitive area, we would recommend meeting
with the two adjacent homeowners prior to construction to discuss the proposed work and
possible restoration options or landscaping to minimize the visual impacts.
I If you have any questions or need additional information. please let us know.
I Sincerely,
MSA, CONSULTING ENGINEERS
I ~~~~.E.
I
I CRJ:tw
OOO.2202.dec
1
t'
I
-------- --------
'.
.
QUALITY FLOW SYSTEMS .1
6861 Flying Cloud Drive (612)944-9445 ..
Eden Prairie, MN 55344 Fax (612)944-9661
I
December 4, 1995
To: City of Arden Hills .
Mr. Dwayne Stafford 'f':_ '.: ~; -
" ' -
Public Works Director I
1450 West Highway 96
Arden Hills, MN I
Project: Lift Station #6 Remodel I
M r. Stafford: I
Quality Flow Systems is offering to sell equipment and services
described in this proposal. If these conditions do not satisfy your ..
requirements, we will be pleased to requote you accordingly. We
appreciate the opportunity to provide our services to the city.
Submersible Lift Station Remodel: .
Two (2) "KSB" Model KRT F80-200/24X, 3.4HP, 1750 RPM, 230/3
phase, 4" explosion-proof heavy duty submersible sewage I
pumps capable of 100 gpm at 30' TDH. To include:
- 3.4 hp, 1750 rpm, 230/3 phase explosion-proof motor.
- 4" base discharge elbow. I
- 30' of power cord.
Two (2) 4" base discharge elbows. .
Two (2) Upper guide brackets.
Two (2) Complete stainless steel lift-out assemblies for 15'
deep stations. I
Two (2) 15' lengths of galvanized chain and shackles.
Two (2) 4" check valves.
Two (2) 4" gate valves. I
One (1 ) Cable rack.
One (1 ) J-hooks.
I
..
.
I
I'
1 Page 2
It One (1) "Consolidated Electric" Nema 3R duplex control panel for
I operation on 230/3 phase. The equipment shall provide
control for two submersible pumps in a pump down mode.
The control system will be complete and include the
I manual transfer switch and generator receptacle. The
panel will include a UL lable and Nema rated
starters. The panel will include the following as a
I minumum:
- (2) Circuit breakers.
- (2) Nema rated motor starters.
1 - (2) Overload relays.
- (2) Run lights.
- (2) Motor overtemp lights.
I - (2) Running time meters.
- (2) Hand-Oft-Automatic switches.
I - (1) Duplex automatic solid state alternator.
- (1) Condensation heater.
- (1) High water alarm light.
.. - (1) Intrinsically safe module.
- (1) Manual transfer switch
I - (1) 100 amp generator receptacle
- (1) U.L. label.
Four (4) "Consolidated Electric" Model LS float switches with 20'
I of cable and weight kits.
One (1) Lot of all internal piping and fittings required.
One (1) "USEMCO" (30" X 30") 300# aluminum access cover and
I frame.
One (1) Concrete 60" dia. top slab with the above lid embedded.
One (1 ) Lot of miscellaneous accessories that may be required.
I One (1 ) Lot of start-up service and operator training.
One (1 ) Seven year pump warranty.
I One (1) Ten year guide cable system warranty.
I Equipment Selling Price- - - - - - 13,300.00 X 1.065 = $14,164.50
Labor - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - $ 9,380.00
---------
---------
I Total Cost For All Equipment and Labor - - - .$23.544.50
Freight and tax included
f'
I
I
Page 3 I
Notes: --
Note #1 : I
We include a master electrician and permits in our above price. We also include
new conduit and cable from the iift station to the panel at the top of the hill. I
Note #2:
We include $2000,00 in the above price for restoration of the area and hill after I
completion. If the city wants to do the restoration, please deduct $2000.00
from the above price.
Note #3: I
We would execute the remodel within 4-6 weeks after receiving award from the
city. We would like notice to proceed ASAP. This would allow us to insulate the I
area to be dug with hay bails to avoid freezing of the ground.
Note #4: I
The above proposal is based on the city gaining the neccessary permission
from the land owners for access of a truck and back hoe to the station. We
feel the least amount of restoration will be necessary if done during the winter ..
months while the ground is frozen. It is also assumed the city will discard all
removed equipment and concrete from the station.
Note #5: I
At the option of Quality Flow and the City of Arden Hills Public Works Director,
we will offer an additional $2000.00 credit off the above price if the existing I
top slab remains and we cut the new pump openings into the existing top slab
and install the access cover at grade using concrete filler rings.
Note #6: I
We include by-pass pumping including all neccessary hose. It would be the cities I
responsibility for any baracades or warning lights. It would also be the cities
responsibility to notify it's snow plow staff in the event of snow. It is our intent
to bypass for 6-8 hours maximum. I
Deliverv I
Pumps = 4-6 weeks
Controis = 4-6 weeks
Access cover = Stock I
Concrete section = 2-3 weeks
..
I
!
I
.
~ Page 4
Please note that our price does include all electrical service work
and by-pass pumping. We also do include the excavating and
I manhole placement. We can supply and perform all work within six
weeks of receipt of order or at dates that conform with the city.
We are offering the city a premimum quality pump with the longest
I warranty offered in the industry.
If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to call Bill Meline or
myself.
I
Thank You,
I -P~ n~
I Patrick Malay t
I cc. Bill Meline - QFS
Mr. Charles Janski, P.E. - MSA
..
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
"
I
WALCCR I='UMI='
-
& EQUIPMENT CO.
9700 HUMBOLDT AVE. SO.
MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55431
PHONE(612)BB~5394 FAX (612) BB~3239 ~M :~~({t.~?~:~-~~
December 6, 1995
I
city of Arden Hills I
ci ty Hall
1450 West Highway 96
Arden Hills, MN 55112 I
Attn: Mr. Dwayne Stafford
PUblic Works Director
RE: WPE Quotation #951203 I
Dear Mr. Stafford: I
Wollowing please find our proposal to upgrade existing Lift station I
6. It is our intention to remove the existing pumping and control
equipment and install (2) new "Flygt" submersible pumps and duplex
controls. We will provide temporary by-pass pumping to maintain
service to the home owners during renovation. ..
The itemized list of supply will include the following:
Two (2 ) Flygt CP3085-434 3 HP 230j3-phase submersible sewage pumps. I
Two (2 ) 4" base discharge elbows.
Two (2 ) 2" upper guide bar brackets.
Two (2 ) 12' lengths of galvanized lifting chain. I
Two (2 ) 4" gate valves.
One (1 ) 4" Tee.
One (1 ) 4" 900 elbow. I
Four (4 ) Lengths of 2" galvanized guide pipe.
One (1) Cable rack.
One (1 ) 3D" X 48" aluminum access hatch cast into a 6' diameter
concrete top slab. I
One (1 ) 6' diameter x 24" high barrel section, added to the existing
wetwell.
One (1 ) NEMA 3R Duplex pole mounted control panel for operation I
on a 240j3-phase 4-wire service to operate ( 2) 3 HP Flygt
submersible pumps in a pump down mode and to include the I
following:
- Inner door
- 100 amp Main breaker (service entrance rated) I
- 100 amp Emergency breaker with interlock
- (2 ) pump breakers ..
DISTRIBUTORS OF PUMPS )COMPRESSORS 'ELECTRICAL CONTROLS & INSTRUMENTATION oWATER & WASTEWATER TREATMENT EQUIPMENT
I
I
I
.- WPE Quotation #951203
12/6/95
.- Page 2
1 - (2 ) NEMA size 0 FVNR starters with ambient insensitive
overloads and resets
- Control breaker
- UL 508 label
. - Duplex FGI outlet
- Condensation heater and thermostat
- Intrinsically safe float circuit
. - High level light
- Alternator
- ( 2) Hand off autos
- (2 ) run time meters
. - Overtemp shutdown
- 120 VAC external alarm light
- Dry contact (high level)
. - 8" x 8" space for telemetry
- Terminal strip
- Factory wired and tested
. Four (4) Float switches
One (1 ) Lot of discharge piping, fittings hardware, etc.
One (1) Lot of labor and miscellaneous items to remove the existing
.. pumps, control etc., and install the above listed new
equipment including a licensed electrician to mount the new
control panel up the hill near the road and trenching of
. conduit down the hill to the lift station, connecting and
wiring of equipment.
I Materials: $11,992.00
Labor: 9,720.00
Tax 779.48
I TOTAL INSTALLED SELLING PRICE: $22,491.48
I Please note: The restoration of disturbed grass or residents lawns
would be by others.
I We offer the following options for your consideration.
OPTIONS:
I #1 Standard Access Cover is included in the above price; options
available include:
- slamlock $100
I - Recessed padlocks $225
- Spring assist $120
,.
#2 If stainless steel lifting chain is preferred, add $250 to the
above price.
1
.
".
WPE Quotation #951203 -.
12/6/95
Page 3 I
#3 If stainless steel guide pipe is preferred, add $560 to the I
above price.
#4 If explosion-proof rated pumps are preferred, add $600 to the I
above price.
The schedule for submittal drawings would be approximately 1-2 weeks; I
and approximately 6-8 weeks for equipment delivery after release to
production and 2-3 days actual working time.
With the city's best interest in mind, we are quoting equipment that I
meets the highest quality standard available, specifically the pumping
equipment and controls. I
I have included typical data sheets for your information to help in
your evaluation process. If upon your review, you have any questions
or need any further information, please feel free to contact us. I ..
hope this proposal meets with your approval and I thank you for the
opportunity to offer a proposal.
sincerely, I
WALDOR PUMP & EQUIPMENT COMPANY .
p..r~ 4~-}
Bryan Goehring I
Sales Representative
attachments .
I
I
I
..
I
i
I TRI-STATE PU:\IP & CO:\"TROL, I!\"C.
I 885 Tower Or,ve 612/473-2000
PO Box 333 FAX 612/.173-2060
r-..,'1edina, MI\J. 55340 1-800-537-2040
I Sales. ::,::rvice. Re~tars' Municipal & Industria: . P:...mps & Accessories
-
.
I December 5 , 1995
Ci ty of Arden Hills
I ATTN: Dwayne Stafford
1450 West Hwy 96
Arden Hills, MN 55112
I Dwayne,
I Thank you for the opportunity to provide recommendations and
a quotation for your Lake Johanna 1 ift station 116 remode 1 .
The proposal attached is for submersible pumps, local above
I ground control pane 1 , and remote (street) pole mounted
service entrance pane 1 .
.. Equipment as quoted provides for 4" explosion proof pumps
(necessary to comply with applicable codes) and 80 GPM
performance required to maintain 2' per second discharge
I (scouring) velocity through the existing 4" forcemain. This
is necessary to meet current engineering design standards.
The 4" non-clog pumps quoted are among the most electrically
efficient pumps available for this service. They wi 11 offer
I more service life without adjustment or parts replacement
over grinder or other pump types currently available.
. The stainless steel enclosures and pump lifting chain wi 11
not suffer deterioration that steel components (painted or
galvanized) will over time. These items wi 11 look and
function the same without maintenance many years from now.
I
The installation as quoted will allow one person to perform
routine service and maintenance without the safety concerns
1 existing at the present installation.
If you have questions regarding any of the items I have
I covered, please call.
Sinael'ely,
Tri-State Pump & Control, Ino.
I ~~
,.
~ruc'e F,. HorF~o
rOll ~ l' ,... ( ) r. . . ( l .
DD lc~tlon3 Op.lneer
A!}!)t 1 (:.'1 r.1 ()fl:. ',r1Slllt't'r'
I
i\ TRI-STATE PU~IP & COl\'TROL, I:'IT. .
805 Tower Dnve 612/478-2000 -.
PO Box 333 FAX 612/4 78~2G6J
:&1 Med,na, MN, 55340 1 ~SOQ~537~2040 ~
Sales. Service. Rentals' Municipa: & Ind.lst'i:3.1 . Pumps & Accessories
- .
.
QUOTATION
TO: City of Arden Hills I
ATTN: Dwayne Stafford
PROJECT: Lake Johanna Lift Station DATE OF QUOTE: 12-5-95 .
116 Remodel
QTY DESCRIPTION AMOUNT I
2 ea Myers heavy duty submersible pumps,explosion proof,model
4VX50, 5 HP,3/60/230V, 25' cords, performance to exceed
80 GPM @ 33' estimated TDH I
2 ea Myers/BPIU 4" guiderail system including:
A) 4" base elbow and pump sealing flange
B) Upper and lower guiderail brackets .
C) Stainless steel pump lifting chain assy
D) Galvanized guiderail pipe, length as required
1 ea U. S. Foundry single door aluminum access hatch, model APS150 ..
3611 X 48" wi th lock staple
1 lot Cover casting and delivery .
1 set SCT 5 HP duplex control panel(s) as follows:
two cabinet construction1 NEMA 3R SST padlockable enclosures
with inner door and U.L. 508 labels .
Street pole mounted panel to be service entrance rated includes:
Main and emergency circuit breakers
Mounting and wiring customer's existing generator receptacle I
Pump run time meters
Pump run lights
Auto test button
Anti-condensation heater and thermostat .
Local pad mounted lift station panel with legs and skirts includes:
Circuit breakers (one per pump)
Control circuit breaker I
NEMA rated combination starters
Intrinsically safe duplex controller
Hand-Off-Automatic switches I
Pump run lights Accepted this day 01 19 -
by
Company I
QUOTATION BY: Address
TRI~STATE PUMP & CONTROL, INC, --
Note: Quotation does not include any applicable tax and is subject to the terms and conditions on reverse side. I
I
I TRI-STATE PUMP & COi'lTROL, Ii'lC.
I 805 Tower Orive 612/478.2000
P,O, Box 333 FAX 612/478.2060
Med,na, MN, 55340 1.800.537 .2C 40
I Sales ~ Service. Rentals' Municipal & Industrial' PUr:1PS & Accessories
-
.
I QUOTATION
TO: City of Arden Hills
Page 2
I PROJECT: DATE OF QUOTE: 12-5-95
14 ea Anchor Scientific suspended mercury floats, model S30NO with
with 30' cords
11 ea Stainless steel cable support bracket
Interior piping to include :
2 ea 4" Val-Matic swing flex check valves
12 ea 4" 900 DIP elbows
2 ea 4" FL x PE DIP length as required
!tea 4" uni or kwik flanges
lot Nuts, bolts, gaskets as required
I~ lot Anchor bolts as required
lot Mechanical installation labor to include:
Assistance in removal of existing cover, assistance in setting
I and orientation of new cover, removal of existing lift station
components, installation of above equipment
1 lot Warranty and start up supervision LUMP SUM $ 16,928.00
11 lot By-pass pump rental, installation and removal $ 1,200.00
NOTE: Excavation of existing discharge piping and installation
I of two buried 4" plug valves and valve boxes with parallel
4" piping stubbed into station (26" split) REQUIRED - NOT incl.
Heavy equipment required to remove existing cover and to reset
new cover - NOT included.
I General contractor capable of quoting the notes above is
Widmer, Inc. ; Mr. Tony Vanderlinde (446-1495)
Electrical installation required by a licensed electrician
I NOT included - electrical contractor capable of quoting the
above is Aid Electric Service; ~r. ~~r~r Koskjnijmi (571-7267)
ccep e t , ay 0 19 -
~uo,^m" " by
Company
Address
TRI.STATE PUMP & CONTROL, INC,
I Note: Quotation does not include any applicable tax and is subject to the terms and conditions on reverse side.
----.-
1\ TRI-STATE PUt\IP & CONTROL, INC. .
1\ 805 Tower Drive 612/478-2000 . .
~~I P,O, Box 333 FAX 612/478-2060
Med,na, MN, 55340 1-600-537-2040 ~
Sales' Service' Rentals. Municipal & Industrial' :JUrT';PS & Accesso."ies
- I
.
QUOTATION
TO: City of Arden Hills .
Page 3
PROJECT: DATE OF QUOTE: 12-5-95 .
OPTIONAL: I
1 ea Thern model 5334Ml transportable Davit crane with 534F socket
base (to be mounted in lift station cover) $ 1,137.00 aI
3-point latch for control panel enclosures $
100.OOe
Pump run time meter viewing window $ 228.00
Deduct $325.00 for legs and skirts for local lift station I
panel if not required
..
I
FOB Factory-freight allowed .
jobsite-NO tax included
OUR terms are NET 30 days-l~% mo. thereafter-NO retainage .
I
I
Accepted this day of 19 - 1
by
Bruce G. Bottko Company I
QUOTATION BY Address
~ )),.p~ ..
TRI-STATE PUMP & CONTROL, INC,
Note: Quotation does not include any applicable tax and is subject to the terms and conditions on reverse side, I
." ,-
MINUTES OF A MEETING OF THE JURISDICTIONS
I WHICH CONTRACT WITH RAMSEY COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT
FOR POLICE SERVICES
" FEBRUARY 15, 1996
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Roland Birkebak, Chair, called the meeting to order at
7:35 a.m. The following members were present:
I
- Roland Birkebak, City of Gem Lake
- Dick Dornbusch, Undersheriff / Chief Deputy, Ramsey County
I Sheriff's Department
- Brian Fritsinger, City of Arden Hills
- Joel Hanson, city of Little Canada
- Dick Lange, city of North Oaks
I - John Luey, Undersheriff, Ramsey County Sheriff's Department.
- Jan Reagan, White Bear Township
- Terry Schwerm, City of Shoreview
I - Bill Short, White Bear Township
- Jerry Urban, City of Vadnais Heights
I APPROVAL OF MINUTES
The Minutes of December 21, 1995, were approved as submitted.
I REVISED 1996 MEETING SCHEDULE, AGENDAS AND DEADLINES
.. Urban moved to approve the revised 1996 Meeting Schedule, Agenda
and Agenda Deadlines. Schwerm seconded. Ayes all.
I YOUTH TRUANCY CENTER = DEPUTY JULIE URBAN
Deputy Urban reported on the Executive committee that was formed
to work toward getting a Truancy and Curfew Center together. To
I date, the county has received a $250,000 start-up grant from the
state of Minnesota. A building site has not yet been
determined. The Truancy Center will be manned mainly by Youth
. Service Bureaus. All youth brought to the Center will go through
an interview which will be followed up by a meeting with a parent
or relative.
I Deputy Urban noted that there will be one uniform curfew for all
of Ramsey County by June or July, 1996.
I MEETING WITH SHERIFF BOB FLETCHER
Sheriff Fletcher reported on continuing increases in juvenile
I crime, and the lack of government resources to impact the
problem. He explained that the problem began in 1982, when crack
cocaine was brought into the Metro Area. In 1989, there was a
dramatic increase in violent crime throughout Ramsey county, and
I gangs were being formed. He stated that the average age of the
first juvenile arrest is now eight years old.
..
I
I
"", -.
Sheriff's Contract Group Meeting
February 15, 1996 I
Sheriff Fletcher reviewed the results of Ramsey County's --
Strategic Planning Effort as follows: 1) citizens want to be
more involved in their community's public safety; and 2) there
is a need for greater collaboration between governments. He
noted that Dick Dornbusch is in charge of the collaboration of I
county-wide police functions, including the 800 mhz communication
system. He explained a new program called Volunteers Involved in
Public Safety (VIPS) . This is Sheriff's Department campaign to I
recruit citizens into a community / police partnership. Through
this program, citizens will be involved in creating a community
wide support system. A main group called Community Affairs
Officers will focus on programs within the community that promote I
public awareness and involvement in safety and crime prevention.
A Youth Safety and Development Partnership with the Ramsey County
School Districts will also be developed. Retired st. Paul Com- I
mander Larry McDonald and Deputies Mark Petit and Allan Rossman
have been hired for the VIPS program. Their goal will be to
provide an avenue for participation. A citizens Academy, for
those who want to know more about the work and services provided I
by the Sheriff's Department, is planned for the end of March.
Sheriff Fletcher reviewed the status of the radio communications I
proposal with the City of St. Paul.
ANIMAL CONTROL REPORT ..
Rick Ruzicka, A.C.S.I. , distributed the Animal Control Activity
report from October 1, 1994, through December 31, 1995. It is
his opinion that cats are the most costly part of his service. I
He stated a need to educate owners to provide proper
identification on their pets so they can be returned to them.
Bad checks were discussed, and the Group directed Mr. Ruzicka to I
continue with the present policy of taking checks written in the
community's name.
It was decided that it was not necessary for Mr. Ruzicka to I
attend the April Meeting, and that he should be prepared to
report back in July.
PATROL DIVISION ORGANIZATION 1
The Group stated their appreciation for John Luey's I
comprehensive crime report of 2/1/96, and asked that he continue
to provide it in advance of the meetings, to allow time for
review.
LONG RANGE GOALS L PLANNING I
Tabled until next month. I
2 ..
I
.- -
Sheriff's Contract Group Meeting
~ February 15, 1996
DEFIBRILLATOR FUNDING
Shoreview, Arden Hills, Little Canada and North Oaks have
obtained defibrillator funding. White Bear Township is seeking
I matching funds for a contribution from the White Bear VFW.
WEIGHT RESTRICTION TRAINING
I Luey will request Deputy Vaughn to provide a procedure policy for
each community to follow.
I OTHER DISCUSSION
OPTICOMS: Lange moved to authorize the Sheriff's Department to
. provide funding for opticom units in the squad cars through the
1995 budget reconciliation. Urban seconded. Ayes all.
I The meeting adjourned at 9:25 a.m., with the next meeting
scheduled for March 21, 1996, at 7:30 a.m.
I Respectfully submitted,
.- ..fl C ~
Jan Reagan
I Recording Secretary DATED: March 5, 1996
I
I
I
I
I
~e
I 3
I
-----
I CITY OF SHOREVIEW CITY COUNCIL
4600 North Victoria Street. Shoreview, MN 55126 Jim Chalmers, Mayor
I i!j~ Tom Landwehr
(612) 490-4600 (612) 490-4699 Fax Jim Olson
. (612) 490-4750 VoicerrDD Mady Reiter
Ben Withhart
I .."".
I -\". \
"i<\
March 27,1996
I
Mayor Dennis Probst
I City of Arden Hills
1450 W. Highway 96
I Arden Hills, MN 55112
Dear Mayor Probst:
I At our March 18, 1996 meeting, the City Council asked that we consider striping
Lexington Avenue between Victoria Street and T.H. 96 for four lanes of traffic. This
I matter has been reviewed by the staff of both cities and with Ramsey County Public
Works staff during the last few years.
.. It is our understanding that Ramsey County would prefer that this restriping be
considered in conjunction with improvements to T.H. 96/Lexington A venue intersection.
Therefore, we are requesting that Arden Hills review this matter soon since the roadway
I improvements are planned in 1997.
I It may be helpful to have ajoint meeting of the two City Councils later this year to
review this issue. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me.
I Sincerely,
O. "
I '\ C( .MI-D ~,J ""-'-"7
J~es P. Charmers
Iv! or
I cc: Brian Fritsinger.
Paul Kirkwold
I Dan Soler
:-
I
I Valentine JJ;/~ Gfementary Sch.oof
1770 West County Road E2
I. Arden Hills, Minnesou 55112
Michele Brouse, Priacipal Phone 63HJ737
I
I -; "
,~ ... '\ j. ,}
.__r I'=..
(:7 'r':\-..: ,~ -,^,':~
f\ ,.
I __,4, ';/,":.) '-,
,~;\)., ':- -' .
'.' '-' \ \-\::..'-~
((; '\ ".J;' ,\....
I March 27, 1996
I Arden Hills City Council
c/o Dennis Probst
1450 West Highway 96
I Arden Hills, MN 55112
I Dear Mr. Dennis Probst:
.. I would like to express my appreciation to the Arden Hills city
Council for the financial pledge that is being made on behalf of
the new playground at valentine Hills Elementary School.
I We will appreciate the opportunities our students will have because
of this new equipment. We know that the families of this community
will also appreciate the play, exercise, and relaxation during the
I non school time, that a quality playground will afford.
Thank you for joining in partnership with our PTA as they work
I toward the goal of fund raising for this venture.
with warm regards,
I 7;21u~Ab(v OZc:kvaU
I
/?;/7c~a/
I
I
I-
I Equal Oppor1Uniry for Eduanon md Employment
I
I IIIIIIIITE&HSYSTEMS
I.
._~
I Krist! Rollag Wangstad Alliant T echsystems Ine Tel 612931-5250
V,ce President, Public Aftairs MNll-2043
600 Second Street NE
I Hopkins, MN 55343-8384
April 1 , 1996
I Honorable Dennis Probst
Mayor of Arden Hills
I 1450 W. Highway 96
Arden Hills, MN 55112
I Dear Mayor Probst:
I am writing to tell you Alliant has been informed that an anti-land mine demonstration
I will be held at Alliant's Hopkins facility on Tuesday, May 7th. This event is being
organized by the Midwest Institute for Social Transformation in support of the
Minnesota Campaign to Ban Landmines.
I You have an important relationship with Alliant, and we want you to know the facts
about the U.S. position and Alliant's position on the land mine issue. As you may
.. have read or seen in media reports, there is an extensive problem in many countries
caused by long-lived landmines. These tend to be inexpensive devices that have
I been used by warring parties, governments within their own borders and by terrorist
organizations. They continue to remain lethal until someone or something causes
them to explode, which has resulted in many civilian deaths and injuries.
I The only landmines ever produced by Alliant have been self-destruct, self-
deactivating mines, which have been an integral requirement in U.S. strategy to
I protect U.S. soldiers. Self-destruct times for U.S. mines range from four hours to 15
days, after which the mine is destroyed and completely removed. Backup self-
deactivation, which renders the mine inoperable through exhaustion of the battery,
I never fails - the batteries always die. These are the only types of mines supported
by the U.S. Arms Control and Disarmament Agency, which represents the United
States in international negotiations on the United Nations Convention on
I Conventional Weapons. They have not contributed to the problem caused by long-
lived landmines.
I Several years ago, the U.S, Army ceased procurement of antipersonnel systems.
Today we support U.S. contracts for two antitank systems called Volcano and Gator,
which each contain a small number of self-destruct, self-deactivating antipersonnel
I mines.
.. The United States has not caused the worldwide landmine problem, but is committed
to providing leadership in addressing the issue within the international community.
I
-
I
To do so, the U.S. government has declared its intent to eliminate the use of all .1
antipersonnel mines, and the Department of Defense is undergoing an intensive
review to determine how it can transition to a total ban without negatively affecting I
protection of U.S. soldiers.
We support the Department of Defense on today's requirements for conventional I
defense systems and on plans for future requirements. This commitment reflects our
mission, which is and always has been to help the U.S. government fulfill its national I
security strategy.
If you have any questions about this issue, please call me at 931-5250. I'd be happy I
to provide you with any additional information you may require.
Sincerely, I
)}z/ \ (
___.__.~. . -.__ 1/ d7)/cv(
/< S Y7;! J ,l
Kristi Rollag Wangsta~ I
KRW090a I
..
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
..
I
I
"0 ~Cl\) --, 'V'-I:: Oll.) ~<1J"'Oe >,'lu........- ~"O.....
i ou 0 .... c .- ..c:; 0 C >..c:: 0,_ -- 8 d} U v 0 .... O..c:; 0 d ~ tv 0
-+-' c ~ >. . .:01 _ .... r:: <1J 0 .... _ eo V) -ci::::.- d} r/,I ,- '-.... c c
0 o .... ......"'0 i5..(;j L.. Vl U bO'- ..8 -5 '';: ,- ,- o..::.! U 0.. co...... ,_ V1
'- .- ,- ...... 0 ,- <:..) lIJo a (j > <1J V) U ll.) "0 0._ - ~ 'v;
ill .2 "0 ~ ~ 0 Vl ~ -- u Jl ~ <r: a g ~ ~ ~ -5 d}'C ~.o E'f] ~ ~ U >.
~ ~ 'Vi C ......:.c c .-:.~....... 0.. cUE .... 0 0 c -5 w .~ .9 .... 2 Z g L.. d
.---' e .... c ~ ~I):: f5. g -5 c ~ 0.'- C E~' 0:: .2.0-0 ('.) - " 2 '<i) r..l U 5 ; <3
I 0 2 Vl 0...::..:: ._ '- 0 V1 0 a. d ...... 0 '<:t 0 u ........ t/J CJ::::: co ~ '- e..c .- dJ .-
c:.:: C 0. '...J "0 0:-:: ~ ,-..c:: c .- ........ L..._ 0 ('.) C:._ ~ r.J 0 .... (':I .0'- ~
:...... ;; '...J ;j.c 0 v:; 2 . u.,g ~ .2::: E t: 0..... J:i -0 ~J ~ t; if, Q. u "0 .u t/J'~ U')
_ ;.... UJ c 'C .... ...... ;;.. 2 ...... '- ~ t/J <I'.: E ~ c c' u c
0.. ,~::'j ~ u::2 ~ 0 UJ r..l ~ <:..)... "Ll ...... ~ ~O <( 0 r.J 0 I-. C r.J.,g C';l d.2 c 0
...... d 0:> U:J C V) ..c::..o u V) "Ll r.'l ~ C c:: e::: ..... "0 0::: 0 dJ::r:: __ C::'j. t/J
c: .o..:::l E d 0 ~;;; 0 ~ ~ '- dJ ;0 I:: - <1J._ ~"O E ..... <1J '- G.l ;..= v.:: ~
:...... :=: de'.::; V)::: d r/,I --........::: ..2 ''::; ro 8 d} u':": ~.) (; ~.D ~ 0 E . .. c ..... 'C
I ~ U g v ~ c: !\) >. ~o 0 E .:..:'g ~;j ~ ~ e u.:;,,::.- ~ ~ ~o ~ 0 B .9.......~ ::'j UJ
ill ';:j 0 O'~ eo.9 -5 ~ ~ c: v ~ ll.) -:..l ..r:: ...........0 ~..c ~ g; o..c:: d.~ -g C ,~"O e..l ~
-+-' ..c::-5..c0'-UL..i5 0:0..0 ....._~';; .:::::0-g;:~ 0 o...~~;j1:U:g8~~
-- ...... <II - 0 .=: C 0 -'- ..c U Il) V'J >.~
C ......-5tn.,2 dE;........c:: ~tn~~oo.u:~ :::-g ~v....:~ gooE"O~V'J dbb02
o L.. "0 u ........ tn '1.) r--- ~ ~ ~ t-< E ...... >........ ...... "'0 L.. -<.D 0,)._ . Q d V t c ,:: L.. 0..
~ ill .....:::lL..L.........c 0.. C(':j.Vl--OO tn....--O c........ 0-1-.0..
t;:: o:.c:::l 0 ,~ 0\ 0'" ~ e.o ~ :..a .3...... Q ~ ~ 'Cj d g a ~ 0.. a.. 0 E
() ('.) '+- ...... 0.. u.... - d __ ('.) '--' ...... ,..CI 0 ..c:: u r.fJ r.fJ E .~ <Il ...... V"J U"J ...... ......
"0 tI'l ,..; tn "0 . 0 - .;:.! 0 Vl 0..- ll.) '"0 ~ -:::l 00 ou I... ('.) "O! ~ ., " I
ill a ~c:: 5 -5:; E.D:n ~ - ~ E ~.:: .~ g ~ g _9.~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~o ~ .5 E 5
I . c 0 eo...... 0 U'l d} ~ c.. ...... .D .... U L.. 0'- Q) 0 .0
0 vi ~n 'Vi..c:: ~ ~ ~ Vl ~ 0.. "0 E u B E =a E >. ~ ~ s: ~ ~ ='..c:: ~ >. 0.. E 11,}
- 'C .~ 00 Vl u"'c; ~ ~ ~ (OJ <:.) 0 <:.) 0..... 0 ~ ~ ~ '- (OJ on - S tn ~ C'::: Vl 8-5
"- E ~ '- .- e > x u 0 0 E c:: 0.. <Il .-
-5 sr :;; ll) >."0'- .... C ~.- .... ':..1 U ~ '- is (J:2 0 'C >. tn L.. ~ C 00 Q)
:...... ~ "0 E -: E ~ c:; ~ en ......0 ~ OJ) C ..c::""" .D ..c:: 8.. :::l "0:2 Q. en 0 1l,).5:! 0.5 1;
0 o ~ - c1.... .... 0 c: V'J u...::..:: c - '"0 .-...... .c
I :E @ u.....: E >. L.. 0 {"j _ ;:::: 2 c:.S2 .5 v ~v:. <Il ~..... go.::; U _"::: 0.- t.rJ ~
, c:: ..... ..... 0 ~ <J'l _ 0 I-. x'- <J'l >."0 c.:..:: ~..c:: ._ 0 4-0 L..::J ,~o.. c
'+- \F)::: 0 d} ;;;:;.2..... Q) ll) .- Il,) 0"0 t.rJ .D (\.}.3 0 U t.rJ -g ...... >..c ~ "'0 0 E'U c1
- ~ -5 E 0 ~ ~ g.~ ~ ~ E c:: O'E "O:g gEe ~ ~ >.,~.= ~:.? c::: 6''::; ~
-+-' ...: ll.) 4-o'~..c: E .0 ,_ .... <Il .- E dUE g 1........ 0 ...... 01)_ ~ L.. U tn 0 c1 on 0 8 0
C u..c:: 0 E - E.;;;; U'l Q) ~ E:::l U 0 (\.) 3: ..... d (;j U v d Q....c >, c u o....c::
0....... , E C 0 c ,:::: .~ E Vl c.. (OJ 0 ..... c:: ~ . . (;.!:ll+- 0 2 E t.rJ 0'- ('.) .....
Le ill ..S == 0..... U & E c 01) 0 tn..3 u .~ Q) :::l ~. ~J) ..c >, Q).c t: ~ I:"j 0.:.0:: ~ .,g -5 ;j
C <J'l :::l U "Ll Vl E.- ,:: U'::: 11,} ~ ~ > U 0.:..::''::; en oU..c I., E U u u.::.! .u...... -5
o 1-..0 .0] 0 "0 L.. > E g . c v :3: u ro ..:..::...... d) v 0.- 0 Vi ...., .... .8
E ia g ('.) E ""Cl ...... '- 0 "Ll 0.""'; IU"O ll) c<;l IJ"l d d) U o.;:.! 0 g c =::.~ E "0 "..c:: ll.) ::l d...... V'J
Q)..c ..c::._ _ c:: !1.l U 2: tn -S ..c:: c::: "'0 '-.;:.!...... tn''''' 00..c:: Vl ~.L:'- 2 v ;::I =' .t:l '- L.. "'0 ..c:: :::l'::;
-+-' 8 ~ t-- e g ~ ~ ~ ~ -g Q f- ;-g 2'c,~ ~.~.& g & <( -g E -g:= ~ g ~ ~ .~o g ~ go:~
IJ -- ,_ r- ._ 3: ~ C f-._ c1 c u c1 c..u.l '"0 Vl U'l.o 0 r;;1.'::; c1 0 ._ E L.. Uot L.. ._ c
E >, (;:I E ~ ~ u IF) C .!..~ ~ ~ " ll) "0 C ll) C 0.. c1 .~ !1.l ll) 0. ~ .8 ' _.2.. .:.0::
E Cd,);'::; b...c Q) . E Q) g..c:: .2 C ~:; o.~:; :.c v ...... fi .~ t5 L.. !5 C ~
'"':""1"0 Q) -- 0 0 tn .- , 0"0 :::l 8-
o U 0 v _ 0._ u E u __ ' c..... E ~ ...... - V L..o > G) "0 -:- 4- "0.. 0 U E
I tn C ...... '-.- Q.. (oj c:::.... --:2 '-.~ ..... U ~ (;j IV r;;1 u'~ (";j 0 (".,I IJl ::: ....; 0
0 .,g~~o-gg<l.l~ 8'E~~Bl ~~ 2~~.gg-d ~~.~~ d~o~'E;.sg-E
0 U._ ~ :::l -5...c: IF) E 0.. g c: E "0 ~ c: E v -'C:; 0 o'V .c a.. tl) '- ltJ E 0 U c
~ .~ ~ ~ 2 g;...: .2 0 : ;...13 <J'l d ~ ~.: "i:: ~ ~ g.g 2>. K ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ E ~.;;
c L.. U ('j !\) ...... C _ U ::l.=: 0 ...... 00 ':f; Il,) 0 G) t:: ..c .0 C "0 ...... L..
I Cd ::l 0.. ~ o...c c: '5 'u .... f.) -::: ti ~.5 0 8 -:: u "8 ~ ~."::: gJ r.,l C g';;; d ~ -8 (\) 0 6
o ~ Vl f- E 0.. g (",j d .g c.. ~ ~ ", ,- ~ L..:.c u ...c p t.L.. g. (J lu c ou (;j Ci >..:::;
U 2 g..i:'~ .~.~ 0 ~ E d.J ".; .:: E (;j::: 000 3: ti Q.~ c:: 5. ~..... 0 -5 f/J E g..2 0
0 >, Gl ._ s..= E -5 U I r;;1 -5 L.. .- 0 0 >-. c...._ _ .- u 0 0.. (",j::l '- N
.... ~..r:: U 0 d.J 0 ~ U e ::: C c::: ..... a ~ u.- ...... >. t/J . ~.i: c:: 0.."0("')
.- CJ t;;) E ...... "lJ 0 C U .... "lJ U t/)...... (1) Vl (\) L.. -- ~
U ..c::"::": {) U ~ c N .c "'d...c ::l 0 COd (\)..c: C 0 d G)'u ..c I... L.. ~ C tl) c::::l-
C .... 0: oS d.) 0 >. .C:; (\) ...... c'- 0 t.,.;. :::l .s !:l.l.I.......@..s '-:u .... ~ (\) 0 E (",j 0 00
I lU,,;;.. ~ ~ U q Iii...c >-. (OJ 0 U..8 0 Il,) 0 0 - '- ...... g I., ::l ~ >-..- ~ 0.. ~ c
Cd .::: <iJ .; C'- O:t .... ..0 C L.. (\) . U ~ > ~ .D tCI ~ u ,5 <iJ I... d ~ '" :..::
(",j ~ t:: s;"O C >, o.......E 0 ~ rS g ~ (\)..s.2.... ~o :.c -5" ~ -g 0'0 V) -e.5 0 g fij
C .-~OL..CG)c~:::l''''' (",j~ "lJ ~'-o~ -.... ~._~
~CO~-s;B.2-g~ o~o.~E~'.gV) e......-5~b (\)ti8::J~g::lE::: ,~Vl
'+- ~ :.a ~ ~ Cj E.S ~ S; E ~ E ~ ~ g.v ~'u .:: ~.!d ; 3:.,g 8 ~ E .g
I c ~ ~ ~ ~ c =[; C:. ti ~ E ~ ~ a c:::.~ a~ ~ ";j ~ ~ ~ ~.:: ~ ~ ~ ~ q..!. 13 ~
0 -.... E';=;;O c::o>>~o Ec:lo....gEIl,) -~~5~.Ct..lc '-f/J~'ug.u~
.....to- _u ::lUtnc lU ~~UE>-' .... ..c::'-L.. E(I) l1)-roI1)UdJ>
o 0 .~ co "'0 0 (\) c::l (':j. o'V ..... N ~ d tn"O <r: o.c .... .c c::l...c u 8 0..U)
E s::: U..r:: o'V >, 0 ..c:: ,- ..... u ::l '- . - 0 c: x
I CJ) ~t: "Oc::l ......S::E ;-oo~::::oU2:' -'L..=;8tn:::lrnO:9"'O!:l.l.I80vltl~
'E: 2.. 5 ~ ~ ~ 0 :;>> ~ r: ~ d ~ ~ d ~ ~ ~ - .~ E ~ ~ ~ 0 E <Il IU ;;;. f/J a..
C .... U ,- - 0 - Vl O,)::l E tn,.::.( '- ~ ::l (.tl 0 (\) :;:l 0 .- -<
tI'l t..l ~ 0 U 0 "",'- '- tn c:l C v) <lJ 0 C 0 (J 0 0 ~ V'J U Q. tn - ......
:...... ~ a t ~.~ Vi g d U ~:::l ~ g N .0 ~ .~ ~ ~08 -5.2 ""..c ~ i3 e.2.~ d ~.E
0..0"0 "0 o::l_"'O<':io'VOQ OJ) V'l 0
I ill g ~ ~ ~ 50 '5.8~ g .3 ~-5 00 d} V} =; .-:c g.~:g"O ~ -g .:: Z6 ~ :o.~ -g -5] . =G
0 ..c eo t;d....'" _ oV'J,-og(\) Il,) c1=O ~_""~cd}C:c
~ ..c:: ...... c c:: 00 0:: lri '- ~ co...... =' 0 ~ > 0 ~ "lJ C E .- N 5 .- ~ "00.. t;d :;:l
u 0 c: IA"O.- '- ~ U"J ..r:: c::: U ~ . ~ ~ u ...... 0.. - 0
C (.tl ~ _ 0';;; c: "0 ':;j 0,) 0.; 0,) ~ 0 _ 0 ...... .- o.g v eo 0 c:: u 0 dJ E 0.. U
'- ._ Vl 0..... 0 0 c cd'--' U ._ .... ~ 1..0 8 :::::....... E '" c..s::::: ::l 0 ..c:: -- 0 Vi
0,:: :5 U e 0 ~o u .- - lU g'.......... c:l -5 N 00 00,> ~ z;..c -;:: ,- 'v C 0'2 i2] u U ~
I +-' 0 Vl c::: U "'0 c: E i3 .c 1-0 4-0 0 '- V} C s:::............_ u . d.J d U L.. L.. tn d) ......
_=,. ~~ voL..> - 0 >.~......_ O_....U:::l<l.JC_lri vo..o..s:::::ro'':'""'IO
() 'u E U .:a..c:: (";j . "lJ i5.. '=: B V"J :;".... (.tl - "0 O"E E'C u (\) E.~ 'u ~ N ..c:: L.. ~ I.....c:: e ....
c v...... .- Vl ~ U o'V - 0 L.. L..._...... -< c c1.s ,.. - f- Q) (1) 0.. 0
-- ::l E'O' - ~ ~ E tn 2"O.D A:l g 0 ::l ::l 0... C B :::l 0.. 3: ti (1) a V} c 00 ~ tt:: eJ)
OOL.. ,.c'-lU c::......co :::..r::oo~Eu oEcO..c,.c::l..... oCv~e;o
ill u U a. .... 0 U ...c:; U'l :::l co (.tl ..r:: ..r:: 0:: ~ U ,_ o..c:: .... .... 00 c1 U ''::; .D f/.l ...... ......
I.~ m > 01) tn C 4-. .... d 0 "0 - 0 (l) Vl 0,),...... c: U'l E (\).:.0:: \0 ("j ""Cl >......... tn '- (1) - ~
Cd c:::"O ~ 0 ~ .... c: g c a "0 . oS'u':.- t L.. -5 "5 ~ ~ .;;..0 0 (':j. 8.. -E == .~
.~ c..o.s:: '0' ~ V'J C';$ .s:: '-..c:: c::: '€ O:::l </l 0 o'V .0 0 0 0..-0 do) ..c: 4-. ~ U
o('l:l~_ L.. (1) tnVl~Vl::S C::Vl..o4.lo....,.= ....c voo;; -080 ....
0' Q) ...c E E.D ~ 0.."::' ~ ~ v .. "'0 ~ ::3 :;; ~ v):E Ul OJ) ~ .s lri ~ gf 'c;j V'J ~ 0 0 5 ~
N Il,) ::s L.. .c .- u ..::.t: - 0 ~ 0 0 c (A L.. 0 ~ u E ......
I c 4-. "'0 tn Ol) .s.... E ~ c:: '- g..:::. 4=.t lU 0'- ~...c 0 c d.J ..c::'~ v -5 C 8 c:::
~ ill o C::E oc:: 00,) >.:..::.=: ..._~u I1)bb.DC ~ u>.
0 "g-5v 0 O::oo..:::~-50UC""""('.)U@: E:::l 0>, f:lri(;j e.o
J... Vi ...... L.. -5 cEO > > 0 ::l adO ..... 0.0- ~ 0.0
:;: C C ~ 0 .- U c: c:l G) 0"0 "lJ c:::.c E d}.c -5.-::: c: 0 '- .D '5 .- .D ~ -0
('I:l 0.. c: -o.D 0 .s:: ~ .:..:: c > ._ E .... ..... tn..r:: 0,) tn >>0 0 lU
>- ltl._ .s vOJ)::1 0 djOc:l >.8 Vl,.r,~~ ---oo'VE ....en-5 ~>
0 E U V'- .... c: tn U ..s::::: L....s::::: Vl - E ........c:: 0 - ::::l .- "0 0
Cd .-..c: 3: '" .- U ~ _ 0.. c: 0 o.~ c::: ...... .... ~ ~ (1) c:: 'C c 0 1..0 . d.J '-
U ......_ o......c:.~ 7"'-O::s.....u.....('I:l.....c :::l-o-:::'o..
'C 'I- ~ c >-. L.. 0 ,- Ul '1.) Z 00 ~ 0'- 0 t;d G) >'2 ~ 0 ~ Vl 0 C ... !U 0.. E Q.:> C5 0 Co
~ - ~ ~ .:: = . E E -g ~ E "'0 c:: a -5 5 So 8...c:; a::l Vl Vl 8 - 2:...c t ~ E 0 8 u 0.. d
I CO "'0 O':::! ~ ._ ~ 0:) '';:: - 'C ~ :::. .. 0.... E c:: c V) ('li; (1) .~ L.. ~ .... c::...... (\)
0 Q g E 8..:..: tn C 0 "'0 <Il g ~"'O -g c:J 1:" ~ g ~ E'S ~ 8 ca.:: ~ E ~ 8"'g 8.9 '5.D
..... u 0.. Q) .....- ~ ;3 (1)"'- ~ ...... V) C "lJ "lJ 0 .;:.! ...... ....
l:J :-:: ~'';:: Vl 0 ::l V e ~...c: . c:J a ~ t1:: E 8: Ul .... C ~ ;g c ;.. L.. u n.i ..c tn u 2 ...., 0
U C 0 Q)..c:: o.D 0 0 ...... dJ 0 .:..: ''::; U .- .- dO.... 4-0 0 E U ('I:l ('.) "lJ -
~:~.~ ti ~ 0 ~:: ~ <.~.~] ,= ~ :.s.~ g ~ ~ ~ g .g.s c:::: a -t1.~.z W ~ ~ ~ fS ~
I 'iQ C o x c ~.l:::::: c1 ~ 0 ...- '- d 1..0._ I., ''::; <Il.c 0 0 0 '- .- 0 t;d ~ 8 v e 0 (':j.:
Q) Cd -S v 0 c1 Dr) ..c:: _::: co o....l (':j.: > 0.. ~ ._ ...... u u.o 0 E u .0 ...... ,_ ..0._ U ...c:
w :>.
"- >-.0 L..OC;;O"'C: OQ)o'Vll,) a..;..,~0,)"O Coc';"'=UO c~<J'ld.)o
-< .+-J CJ) - U ~ ..c: ._..c h Il,) >.. ...c: ~ .~ -5 =' .- ..c:: -s ~ .- 0) 0,) ~ iii :..:: -S 0 t' -5 4=.t
"- tJ) "0 - - ...... - 0 dJ...... .... "0 C Q) l-o V'J ..0 ..... 0
I ~ .~ l:J ..... ..... _ '2 ..0:":: c E do) c:: 0 _ ...... c 0 E on _ :::l b ~ 0.. ~ t;d
3: 0.."0 v C':l ,- 0.. (':j.:..... ..c:: ..... .0 0 V) ,- <Il vol c:J ~ 0 .8 Q. .- U') ~ o'V
W ~ C::c1 :;:l "OU"J<J'l1l.l 0...... -Ov....(\)I:;lOO 0 L.. E L.."'O
Z .- I...::l t;dO c::'-"'O.... "'0 - Vl'- u'" ..c:eOV'J(J &--
u 0 0.. CJ 'E c oS ~ ..c '0 Il,) -0 ::; g '~ -5:e e fr.g :::: t .8 ~ ,5 ~ f: E C;; 0 0
@ C v .. G) L.. _ > (\) .... Vl C ll.) '- lU .~ ~"O "0 0.. C 0 C -S
ro ro .~ ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ g a E.5 E E ~ & ~] 8 ~ E c.. ~.~ E ~
- -<
a: ... 00 <l.l V d c.. "0 C.8 E.- 'Vi V) E "'a o'V Oil C ...... (\) U C c:: g 0 z C';:l >
-C (\) L.. c::: U U Eo>...... .=: g .- :::: ._..0 C ll.) c: S-~ d 0"'0.... c.. "'0 .-
- E 0 .- ..... ...... '-.:= '" c E ~ ~ u o.~ 0'2 E -0 Il)'C ~ 0 @ 0.0 Vl Q) - ~
~ 0: .- -- c - '" c:: -< 0.. 0,) (J 0 E C . "0 C U c > C .........., c - U (1) '-..c ::l c:
S _...... .... . C ll.) t::.c .c .;:: 0 .- 0 ::s ..... <":l d'- V'J::l - '- U ::l _ 0 0
C "C .- 00 t) ("j ltJ 0 - C d .- rn 04-. E(\)o t'..l :,..c - E d'- o.r:: ~ 0 L.. V ~ U
o "B .:: .~ 0.. ~ Q. d.3 >, ; = u -S''::; "U -5 -:";"0 0.. E a -5 U 0.. g ti 2 ~ ~"O ~
0 ~0J) ~.co ,U"JdOtll.D .....~'-Od.J..c:Q "oc~o :2>'~(";j~...:.-.' E:::lC:::~
0 ,.C;C l..o c c: u :s.. v '- _.- Ul Vl "'0 C c:: .D U .......- c::: ~ C':l -S U E ~ -::: >. E'- Vi ro 1-0 c::l ....
0 d.l .- ~ ~ ==::l c1 '- IU';::: v E.... ~ ...- "'0 U,- tn ...... c 0 U.o V'J "'0 ~ 0 .... C
U () ~ gO U ~ ~ ~ ~ .g -& ~ E ~ 8 .~6 ~ ~ ~.s ~ ~.~ E ~ tS E .s ~ ~.g ~ F ~ ~ 8
>-:E 0. 0 ~ t;d ;:1 i 0 fr eN E 00;; o'i:: ~ e c ~ e o.g 6 ~ ~ ..c 0 8
,.Q.. <t$ U. ~._z. Q.) .U ....,...-...O".N..t.j_I'Vi. _. __.o:l.).c...._. _........... ~ U._
----
I C:;o uld turtle endanger The Blanding's turtle
~..\,.
the developer species? ! ~_.'.
I \
,
, \mmGn/
BLAKE MORRISON STAFF WR'TER EmiiE )
. <
(' TWin
I No one had actually seen one. But they Development 1 CitieS. Kellogg ~
, Winonae Blandlna;'s.
heard that a friend of a neighbor had l concentration
talked to someone who had seen one of those yellow-neck . Size: 9-10 inch shell
I critters ambling across the developer's land. . Coloration: Black or dark blue,
And with that, residents who live near the Proposed Develop- dome-shaped shell with yellowish
ment Du Jour might stand before their city council and ally spots and bars, It has a bright
themselves with the Blanding's turtle, a threatened species that yellow chin and neck.
I may play a prominent role in coming battles over open space . Habitat: Shallow, slow.moving
in northern Ramsey County, water with mud bottoms, vegetation.
TURTLE CONTINUED ON SA ~ PIONEER PRESS
.
. .
I
SA,.q PAUL PIO'\FER PRESS \10,DAY, APRIL l. 1996
. PAGE 1
...ROM
IrORTLE "That's kind of too bad," said Joan
Galli. nongame wildlife specialist with The Blanding's turtle
the state Department of Natural Re-
I CONTINUED FROM lA sources who doesn't want residents, de- The Blanding's turtle range is from the.
velopers Or city officials to forget that Upper Midwest U.S. 10 a few Canadian
saving the turtle and developing open provinces, They begin basking in April
The docile turtle, says one Arden Hills space aren't mutually exclusive, and nest in undeveloped sandy
Ificial, has become "the endangered She said statistics kept by the D.S, Fish grasslands in June.
'mbol of the city" - one that has been and Wildlife Service show that between
ted before city councils and planning 1987 and 1992, only 54 of 96,832 projects
commissions in Arden Hills, Shoreview nationwide were stopped because of en.
fd Vadnais Heights and may be men- dangered species concerns, And neither
ned more and more as a means of she or other local DNR officials remem-
eserving open space, ber any projects stopped in these parts.
Why? Because some residents argue "To my knowledge, we haven't really
,at if a Blanding.s turtle lives nearby, stopped projects or changed them, but we
ty officials should do all they can to let them know some things they can do
otect the dinner-plate-sized amphibian, just to protect the turtles," said Ellen
And to many, that means stopping devel- Heneghan, endangered species environ-
1~_ltOgether. mental review coordinator for the DNR.
" nly, people have learned that "I think what the citizens were saying . Don't mow ditches until
re , 'ies are one way they can throw in mentioning the turtles was one point. in order to preserve cover and
a monkey wrench into development, and while the bigger issue was how to handle maintain travel corridors for the
I this part of the state, it's the Bland- the land," said Galli. an Arden Hills resi- . Avoid using fertilizers and
g's turtle," said Tom Landwehr. a dent who followed the Ogren townhome pesticides.
oreview City Council member and battle in the newspaper. "It's not really . landscaping should be left as
NR biologist. "But it was never intend- the turtles, They're just the symbols used natural as possible, and trees should
ed that the designation would be a tool by the residents. But one thing a develop- nOl be planted .in known nesting sile~?
t stopping development. It's a tool for er should do is say, 'Yes, I hear your . Report Blanding's sightings to the.:
iding development, not stopping it:' point. I'm going to go back to the DNR DNR (296-3344).. '. '. ....
Statistics show the mere mention of and see what they say.' ~ ~?iZ~~@;;;gg:l:
the turtle has lillle effect, and officials "This isn.t another endangered species I ,_ l~ I I'~< ';..". .Yk);'.:'LlB~:',:1_!':
10m around northern Ramsey County that stops development:' Galli said. "I . Inform workers that Blanding.'s.". ...'"
y development is seldom altered by its don't know of one project yet that's been turtles may live inthe.area.
perceived presence. stopped by the presence of those turtles, . All wetlands should be protected n
But the side effect of such tactics con- "The message is just that a lot of from road run-off, lawn and other
Irns naturalists, They worry that spuri. people care about these resources too chemical run-off by a buffer strip of
s claims of Blanding's sightings may and want to see a place for them," sbe vegetation.
ove the undoing of legitimate ones. Or said. . Avoid placing roaci$ between
worse, that developers who hear the That place is usually in shallow, slow- wetlands and adj~cent uplands.
landing's invoked won't bother to inves- moving water or marshes that border . Report Blanding's sightings to the
ate. rivers, That's where the turtles hibernate DNR (296-3344).
Case in point, developer Dan Ogren, He until they emerge in April and begin Source: Minnesota DePartment of Natural
heard the turtle claims from residents nesting in June, Resources, Section of Wildlif.e
1st year, when he gained approval for a DNR officials say they can't estimate
wnhome complex along Old Snelling how many of the turtles live in northern PIONEER PRESS
venue near County Road E2, Ramsey County. But they do keep reo will keep the turtle at the forefront of
"They were throwing out just about cords of Blanding.s sightings, classifying
Iything they could, and I had heard that them as verified by a specimen, verified many land-use debates,
landing's turtles were a pretty common by a photo, or observed with a good "Typically, you have a list of common
, ing to bring up," Ogren said, "So I description. Forty sigbtings have been re- concerns tha t everyone has anytime
nev;wn bothered to do any research corded, 33 of which have been verified by there's a large parcel of land to be devel-
It. I think it was just a roadblock. photos or specimens. The earliest dates oped, and it's usually brought up," said
hat's e way I felt:' to 1949, and many have been logged at Vadnais Heights administrator Gerry Dr-
Were Blanding's turtles living on his Snail Lake Regional Park and the Twin ban,
land, just across the highway from Val. Cities Army Ammunition Plant in Arden Arden Hills City Council Member Bev-
ltine Lake? "I have no idea:. Ogren Hills, erly Aplikowski said: "I think we'll hear
id, The heightened awareness of the turtle more of it, Ifs the endangered sym.bohf
That's because he never cbecked. and its threatened-species status likely the city,"
- ---- ~_.._---
.
,;:~~:."",;,*,'.~"4'~,~~:~",~~.:;:,;tli:;;,-,,,.":;""" ,,- ',.,' /),'" ,...~.;,.,....,;,~",',~..".., ,'~
I
Pal!e 12 Wednesday. Aori13 1996 THE BULLETIN I
-~ .~- ---.-.-' - - -~- -- ~
Fire damages LJFD's $475,000 ladder truck
by uenlse Becker New' Brighton fu-c station in order to One of tllC firefighters kept his foot the New Brighton Fire Department
It's something not many have p;;rfonn some training exercises. on the brake pedal, while the other for help.
seen before: a fire truck on fire. When they turned onto New put blocks behind lhc UlICk's wheels Using firc-suprcssing foam, the
A ladder truck owned by the Brighton Boulevard from County to keep it stationary. two dcpartmcnl'> were able [0 put the
Lake Johanna Volunteer Fire Road E2, the truck suddenly lost "I('s surprising that lhccc wnsn't blaze out in ubout two minules.
Department (UVFD) and valued at JX)wcr. any injuries becllusc it was ~ very SZtlfek said he doo<;n't know if
S475,000 cnught fire March 28 at The two firefighters "smelled intense fire," 5.1id Szurck. the lnJck Cilfl be repaired, or if it must
New BrigtltOl1 Boulevard nnd County something strange," looked behind The fire was fed by the truck's be replaced. The fire department
Rood E2 in New Brighton. them from the cab and saw smoke 100 gallons of hydraulic fluid. which purchased the truck in 19B5.J!JJ
lJVFD Chief Don Szurck said coming from the engine ar~. is used 10 raise und lower the insured for replacement value.
_hat on Wednesday at 4 p.m,. Szurek said the emergency brake ladder/crane.
Jrefighters Dave Fuller and SCOlt wouldn't hold <llld the truek bcganto Fuller and Brandt caUed the The cause of the rire is not
. mndt were driving the truck to the roIl backwards onto Coumy Rood E2. Lake Johanna Fire Department and known a1 ulis time. said Szurck.
,,~--- ~-._", ~,- _n'_
____.~....D........._~'''"_.... _. --- "....... '"'--"-~ -'~-~-
-
-
I-
... .
...