CC_Minutes_2013_1118 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Regular City Council Meeting Monday,November 18, 2013 Page 9 As an Attorney and Hamline Law Professor specializing in Trust Law, Mr. Olson expressed concern with this proposed consideration of organized trash collection, opining that it not only allowed but invited collusion between garbage haulers to divide up the market place and specifically protect their market share. While this would provide a great deal for them, Mr. Olson noted the rationale in prohibiting such activity due to reduced competition and eliminating public choice; as well as preventing new contractors from entering into businesses and creating significant barriers for private parties to enter into business. If the City Council chose to fol- low Senator Marty's bill, Mr. Olson opined that it would freeze the number of garbage haulers in the metropolitan area; and while the first three years out, cost savings may be found, when negotiating subsequent contracts, the prices would increase significantly based on market concentration. Personally, Mr. Olson opined that he liked having a choice, and he didn't' want someone else to deter- mine his carrier just because one hauler's area didn't come into his neighborhood. By getting involved in this type of process, Mr. Olson opined that it was danger- ous cost-wise for the City as well as in further eliminating public choice. Mr. Ol- son opined that such a decision would not make the people of Roseville happy. June Stewart, 2807 Fernwood Street; President of the area League of Wom- en Voters A letter dated October 17, 2013 from the League of Women Voters specific to this item and supporting organized trash collection, was provided as a bench handout and read by Ms. Stewart, and attached hereto and made a part hereof Dick Houck, 1131 Roselawn Avenue Mr. Houck expressed his total opposition to this whole issue. Mr. Houck opined that it was not about any one of the eight (8) items listed on the resolution, even though they all sound good and may convince some in Roseville. Mr. Houck fur- ther opined that it wasn't about government trying to save citizens money, but on- ly how much it could take from residents, not save for them. Mr. Houck opined that it was all about freedom to choose who a citizen wanted to do business with at their home site. If the City was actually interested in saving citizens money, he questioned why they would stop at trash haulers, but why not include furnace sales; and other trucks (e.g. UPS trucks, FedEx trucks, and snow plowers) using the roads. Mr. Houck opined that government should not be involved in the free enterprise system. Nestor Riano 2347 Western Mr. Riano opined that his comparison of the costs for the City of Maplewood for implementing an organized trash collection system had not saved any money based on his website research. Mr. Riano opined that those savings were assured rather through competition and keeping happy customers. Mr. Riano further opined that neither the City nor its residents would save any money through an organized trash collection.