CC_Minutes_2013_1125 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Regular City Council Meeting Monday,November 25, 2013 Page 26 Mayor Roe called for discussion based on the motion to approve the liquor license transfer. Councilmember Willmus recognized the substantial documentation received from both parties: the Minnesota Licensed Beverage Association in opposition to the transfer, as well as from the applicant. Councilmember Willmus noted that the City Attorney testified on several occasions that he had reviewed the information and was comfortable in the City Council proceeding forward. Based on his re- view of materials and the guidance of that legal advice, Councilmember Willmus spoke in support of the transfer. Councilmember Laliberte concurred that there had been a great deal of infor- mation provided by both sides on this issue; and concurred that she also looked to the City Attorney for guidance. Councilmember Laliberte advised that the City Attorney had, following his review of those materials, on several occasions and consistently found no reason for the City Council to deny this transfer request. Councilmember Laliberte recognized that there had been a great deal of commu- nity input, with the majority opposed to the requested transfer. However, Coun- cilmember Laliberte opined that the City Council was not in the position of pick- ing small versus big or winners versus losers;but in a position to encourage small, independent businesses to provide personalized service to customers in the mar- ketplace, that should allow them to maintain their loyal customer base. Based on the City Attorney's review of information and his guidance, and within the pur- view of what the City Council was being asked to do, Councilmember Laliberte spoke in support of the liquor license transfer. Councilmember McGehee spoke in opposition to this liquor license transfer based on her opinion that the City Council had not done its due diligence in allowing facts to go forward, completion of the investigation by the City of Bloomington, MN, or the investigation by the State of MN Attorney General, or final review of public information requests of the Minnesota Licensed Beverage Association. Councilmember McGehee opined that the City of Bloomington was surely far more experienced with liquor licensing; and she saw no benefit in moving for- ward so quickly. Councilmember McGehee opined that from her perception, this was an unsuitable applicant and project for the City of Roseville to undertake due to the nature of the allegations and actual activities documented in various ways, including the applicant's own materials as well as their failure to include some of these cased in their application, making their application false and therefore in vi- olation of State law and City Code. Councilmember McGehee expressed her dis- appointment at the outset of tonight's meeting, based on and referencing City Code, Section 302.07, Section 302.03, and the League of Minnesota Cities hand- book's relevant information specific to liquor licenses. Councilmember McGehee further opined that the City Council was not required to issue its full contingent of off-sale liquor licenses, or transfer any of those licenses if not in the best interests