Laserfiche WebLink
City of Roseville <br />Construction - Proposal Package F(Tennis Courts) <br />Best Value Selection Summary <br />Section 1: Summary of Scores <br />Raw Data <br />Possible <br />No Criteria Points F-1 F-2 F-3 <br />1 Cost Proposal -Total Base 250 $737,000 $648,500 $750,330 <br />2 Interview Rating 350 6.7 5.1 5.2 <br />3 Risk Plan Rating 150 5.0 4.3 4.3 <br />4 Project Capability Plan Rating l00 6.7 4.3 3.7 <br />5 Value Added Plan Rating l00 4.3 4.3 4.3 <br />6 PPI 50 9.5 10.0 6.6 <br />Total Availble Points 3000 <br />Section 2: Ranking <br />Vendor Total Difference <br />F-1 967.5 -- <br />F-2 861.9 105.6 <br />F-3 805.3 56.6 <br />Section 3: Committee Ratings <br />Project Manager Interview Ratings <br />F-1 F-2 F-3 <br />Evaluator <br />Evaluatorl 5 5 5 <br />Evaluator2 5 1 1 <br />Evaluator3 5 5 5 <br />Evaluator4 5 5 5 <br />Evaluator5 10 10 10 <br />Evaluator6 10 5 10 <br />Evaluator <br />Evaluatorl <br />Evaluator2 <br />Evaluator3 <br />Evaluator4 <br />Evaluator5 <br />Evaluator6 <br />Risk Plan <br />F-1 <br />5 <br />5 <br />5 <br />5 <br />5 <br />5 <br />5.0 <br />F-2 <br />5 <br />5 <br />5 <br />1 <br />5 <br />5 <br />43 <br />F-3 <br />5 <br />5 <br />5 <br />1 <br />5 <br />5 <br />4.3 <br />Site <br />Evaluator <br />Evaluatorl <br />Evaluator2 <br />Evaluator3 <br />Evaluator4 <br />Evaluator5 <br />Evaluator6 <br />ntendent Interview <br />F-1 F-2 <br />5 5 <br />5 5 <br />5 5 <br />5 5 <br />10 5 <br />10 5 <br />Capability Plan Ratings <br />F-1 F-2 F-3 <br />Evaluator <br />Evaluator 10 5 5 <br />Evaluator 5 5 1 <br />Evaluator 5 5 5 <br />Evaluator 5 1 1 <br />Evaluator 10 5 5 <br />Evaluator 5 5 5 <br />Average 6.7 4.3 3.7 <br />F-3 <br />5 <br />1 <br />5 <br />5 <br />5 <br />5 <br />March 13, 2014 <br />Points <br />F-1 F-2 F-3 <br />220.0 250.0 216.1 <br />350.0 266.9 271.3 <br />150.0 130.0 130.0 <br />100.0 65.0 55.0 <br />100.0 100.0 100.0 <br />47.5 50.0 33.0 <br />967.5 861.9 805.3 <br />Value-Added Proposal Ratings <br />F-1 F-2 F-3 <br />Evaluator <br />Evaluatorl 5 5 5 <br />Evaluator2 5 5 5 <br />Evaluator3 5 5 5 <br />Evaluator4 1 1 1 <br />Evaluator5 5 5 5 <br />Evaluator6 5 5 5 <br />Average 4.3 4.3 4.3 <br />