Laserfiche WebLink
MEMO TO ROBERT BELL <br />� Dated: December 28, 1989 From: John E. Daubney <br />RE: City of Roseville vs. A Plus Industries <br />My File No: 10.035 <br />See State vs. Apple Va11ey Readi-Mix, Inc., 379 N.W. 2d 136. <br />Holding that municipal air pollution and noise ordinances ' <br />that set forth no quantifiable measurement to det�rmine whether <br />�heir air quality standards were more stringent than ambient <br />air quality standards set forth in the State Pollution Control <br />Statutes conflicted with State Statutes, and therefore rendered <br />invalid �he local ordinance. <br />M.S.A. § 116.07, subd. 2, relates to the adoption of standazds <br />by the �CA. Relating to noise standards the Statute includes <br />th� following language: <br />"No local gQverni�g unit shall set st�ndards <br />describing the maximum level of sound pressure <br />whic� are more stringent tha� those set by the <br />Pollution Control Agency." <br />It would appear that the Apple Va11ey Readi-Mix case curr�ntly <br />� establishes the supremac� of the State Statute if in conflict <br />with t�e local ordinance, citing the 1966 Supreme Court c�se o� <br />Manqold Midwest Company vs. VillaQe of Rich�ield, 274 Minn. 347, <br />143 N.�. 2d 813. <br />Sinceres � <br />t, � (� � 1 <br />; ���..1 <br />,7ohn E. Daubney <br />Attorne�r at Law <br />, , <br />IJED:kd <br />�. <br />� <br />