CC_Minutes_2007_1217 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

RealEstateJournal IPrint-Friendly ~ Est,ate Journal.com TfiE WALL STREET JOUR\AL ct<:~e cr, t'rnperr~/ Print 'JVindo~rr Close Window Homeowners Love Cul-de-Sacs, Planners Say They're Perils By Amir Efrati From The Wall Street Journal Online One of the most popular features of suburbia is under attack. Jail 1 lV / 12/17/200701:03 PM ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~-~-v~d ouf- For many families, cul-de-sac living represents the epitome of suburban bliss: a traffic-free play zone for children, a ready roster of neighbors with extra gas for the lawnmower and a communal gathering space for sharing gin and tonics. But thanks to a growing chorus of critics, ranging from city planners and traffic engineers to snowplow drivers, hundreds of local governments from San Luis Obispo, Calif., to Charlotte, N.C., have passed zoning ordinances to limit cul-de-sacs or even ban them in the future. In Oregon about 90% of th state's ~a~ cities have changed their laws to limit cul-de-sacs, while 40 small municipalities outside Philadelphia have adopted restrictions or bans. Even when they're not trying to stamp them out, some towns are keeping a close eye on how cul-de-sacs are being built. Earlier this year, the city of Pekin, III., established new rules to make cul-de-sacs more maneuverable for service vehicles like fire trucks and school buses. While homes on cul-de-sacs are still being built in large numbers and continue to fetch premiums from buyers who prefer them, the opposition has only been growing. The most common complaint: traffic. Because most of the roads in a neighborhood of cul-de-sacs are dead ends, some traffic experts say the only way to navigate around the neighborhood is to take peripheral roads that are already cluttered with traffic. And because most cul-de-sacs aren't connected by sidewalks, the only way for people who live there to run errands is to get in their cars and join the traffic. In Charlotte, where the suburbs have emerged as a leading cul-de-sac battleground, a recent study by transportation planners found that almost all of the city's heavily congested intersections were located near residential developments from the 1960s, '70s and '80s, which are filled with cul-de-sac neighborhoods. The biggest traffic problems aren't in the old central cities these days, says Orlando, Fla.-based traffic engineer Walter Kulash, "but rather in the suburban periphery." Land-use planners trace the origin of the American version of the cul-de-sac, which means "bottom of the bag" in French, to a development in Radburn, N.J., in 1929. Land planner Ed Tombari of the National Association of Home Builders says the design became popular during the housing boom after World War II, when many families turned away from the congested grids of central cities to live on quiet cul-de-sacs with lawns and winding roads more reminiscent of the countryside. To ensure privacy, developers limited the number of roads leading in. According to the Census Bureau, the population of American suburbs grew 12% from 1980 to 2000, while the total population in center cities grew by just 1 %. Likewise, from 1997 to 2003, the total percentage of American housing units located in the suburbs rose to 62 million, an increase of about 9%. The influx of homes in the suburbs, and the traffic they bring, has become the chief concern of planners across the nation, many of whom are struggling to mitigate the impact of car culture. To some of them, cuf-de-sacs have come to represent a failed experiment that has produced more isolation and more traffic by forcing people into their cars. David Schrank, a transportation researcher with the Texas Transportation Institute at Texas A&M University, says the old "peak hour" of traffic in many suburbs has been replaced by a longer "peak period." As new developments spring up, he says, "sometimes the transport network isn't in place to support them." In some growing suburbs, "cul-de-sac" is becoming a dirty word. At a meeting in April with the planning commission in Northfield, Minn., a suburb of Minneapolis that has adopted rules preventing the use of cul-de-sacs, developer Lynn Giovannelli of Miles Development says she was "blindsided" by a chorus of objections about a single cul-de-sac she was including in plans for part of a new subdivision called Rosewood. "The land parcel was a funky shape, and I told them the only way to do anything with it is to do a cul-de-sac," she says. One commissioner told her to put in a park instead. http://www.realestatejournal.com/forms/printContent.asp?url~http%3A//...I.com/buysell/markettrends/20060605-efrati.html&skyscraper=undefined Page 1 of 2