CC_Minutes_2009_0518 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Regular City Council Meeting Monday, May 18, 2009 Page 16 d. Adopt a Resolution Approving the Request by AT&T (with Presbyterian Homes) for a Planned Unit Development (PUD) Amendment to allow the in- stallation of cellular antennas at 2925 Lincoln Drive (PF09-008) City Planner Thomas Paschke provided staff's analysis, as detailed in the Request for Council Action dated May 18, 2009, of the request of AT&T Mobility, in co- operation with Eagle Crest Senior Housing LLC, for a PUD Amendment in order to allow installation of three telecommunication antennas and an equipment shel- ter on the roof of the Eagle Crest building at 2925 Lincoln Drive. Mr. Paschke reviewed plan sheets for the request; and noted that the request was similar to that recently approved by the City Council for T-Mobile on the same site; and was recommended for approval by staff, subject to conditions as detailed in the draft resolution included in the packet. There was no one present from the public to speak to this issue; and Mr. Paschke advised that there had been no public comment at the Public Hearing held at the Planning Commission level. Councilmember Ihlan noted three personal contacts she'd received from residents expressing concern with the placement of the antennas and possible public hear- ing concerns associated with this type of cell phone tower. Councilmember Ihlan noted that no information had been provided to the City Council on that perceived risk; and recommended that the City Council postpone a vote on this issue until those residents could bring additional information forward for City Council re- view. Mayor Klausing noted that he had received two of the three e-mails; and further noted that this health concern had come up before with installation of wireless an- tenna on the Hamline Office building; and that, while recognizing the expressed concern, no evidence of adverse health issues had been received. Mayor Klausing opined that he wanted to be responsive to resident concerns; but noted that those concerned citizens should provide at least a minimal effort to provide that infor- mation, rather than anticipating that the City Council would hold up action to meet their timing. Mayor Klausing noted the need to provide clear evidence of such a risk, rather than just a perceived fear of such a risk without basis. Councilmember Ihlan noted that the residents raising their concern had been un- able to attend previous meetings, as they had been out of town. Councilmember Ihlan reiterated her preference that, as a precautionary principle, the City Council should delay action until they were able to evaluate this additional information. Councilmember Ihlan noted that a secondary issue was related to the actual placement of the antenna and that further delay may benefit that discussion as well. Councilmember Roe noted that, with his role as the City's representative to the North Suburban Communications Commission, he had researched FCC rulings re-