|
<br />-.
<br />
<br />e
<br />
<br />e
<br />
<br />e
<br />
<br />DRAFT
<br />
<br />ARDEN HILLS CTlY COUNCIL - MARCH 8.1999
<br />
<br />3
<br />
<br />B.
<br />
<br />Resolution #99-07, Accepting Bids and Anthorizing Execution of Contract in the
<br />Matter ofthe Improvement of West Round Lake Road, Phase I
<br />
<br />Mr. Brown explained that on January 14, 1999, eleven bids were received and opened for the
<br />West Rormd Lake Road, Phase I Improvement Project. The bids came in with a tight spread.
<br />The lowest bid was 10% below the estimate, there were a total of four bids below the estimate
<br />and seven bids above the estimate. The three low bidders were Don Zappa & Sons, Inc., Amt
<br />Construction Company, Inc., and Forest Lake Contracting.
<br />
<br />The project was bid in four parts:
<br />1. The Basic Roadway, including storm sewer and ponds, watermain, and sanitary sewer.
<br />2. Alternative A, removal of all excess soils from the Indykiewicz property.
<br />3. Alternative B, landscaping, including trees, shrubs, sod, seed, and irrigation to the median
<br />area.
<br />4. Alternative C, paver bricks in the narrow areas of the median versus concrete.
<br />
<br />The bid Alternate A is the most significant item and it ties in with the acquisition of the property.
<br />Most bids for Alternative A had been between $80,000 to $100,000, which is a common
<br />excavation price. With the exception of Jay Bros., the bids did not include a credit for the black
<br />dirt. Jay Bros., Inc. offered a $0.60 credit per cubic yard which would significantly reduce the
<br />cost for excavation, however, Jay Brothers would still be the sixth lowest bidder.
<br />
<br />If the Base Bid and Alternative B were chosen, Don Zappa & Sons would have the lowest bid. If
<br />Alternative A is included, Forest Lake Contractors would be the low bidder. The bids for
<br />Alternate C would not change the order of the lowest bidders.
<br />
<br />The City Staff had performed an extensive review of alternatives to avoid having the contractor
<br />deal with the black dirt. The hope was to find someone to buy the dirt to recoup some of the
<br />costs. The result of this effort was that the City did not receive any offers other than minor
<br />credits, which are not guaranteed. In most cases, when the transportation of the dirt was
<br />considered, there ended up being no credit.
<br />
<br />An option was offered to the three low bidders to extend the time for the removal of the black
<br />dirt. The original contract had stated a date ofJuly 31,1999. The bidders where asked, if they
<br />were allowed until the end of the year to remove the black dirt, would this change their bids.
<br />Revised quotes were received from Don Zappa & Sons, Inc. and Forest Lake Contracting. Forest
<br />Lake essentially proposed to remove the soil free of cost with the extension. Don Zappa & Sons,
<br />Inc. had offered a $2.06 unit price to remove the soil. This was lower than their original bid,
<br />however, it was still higher than the bid by Forest Lake Contracting.
<br />
<br />Based on research by Staff to attempt to sell the black dirt, which did not result in a profitable
<br />route, including Alternative A in the contract pushes the award of the bid to Forest Lake
<br />Contracting. If the City includes Alternative B for the landscaping package, as recommended by
<br />the Staff, Forest Lake Contracting's awarded bid would be $794,725.05. The City Cormcil may
<br />also consider awarding Bid Alternative C, which would add approximately $10,000 to the
<br />contract.
<br />
|