CC_Minutes_2014_0522 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Special City Council Meeting Thursday, May 22, 2014 Page 25 ommerided budget. Councilmember Willmus opined that this was of significant benefit for the community to see the ramifications of various steps; and would provide a more accurate picture of potential changes and how they would impact community members, which was an important exercise to do from time to time. Councilmember Laliberte agreed that, as an exercise, it could illuminate discus- sions and how services could be affected, and reflect on the City Manager's budg- et recommendations. Councilmember Laliberte opined that she saw the exercise as a preliminary to the City Manager-recommended budget presentation. At the request of Mayor Roe, and by Council consensus, the request was defined as a one-page summary similar to those received tonight, with each department outlining the impacts to their individual departments as a "big picture" summary, not in spreadsheet format. Councilmember McGehee spoke in opposition to the motion, opining that it was an unnecessary exercise and that staff was very responsible, honest and straight- forward in preparing their various requests. Councilmember McGehee opined that Roseville citizens had also been straightforward in their survey responses about not wanting reduced services, but having some control in their taxes. Councilmember McGehee further opined that her personal perspective was that there was a significant disparity in survey data and what is important to residents in comparison to City Council-supported priorities. Councilmember McGehee opined that it was the City Council's obligation to look at that survey information first to determine if the City had been providing those priorities; and based on her overall read and view, the City Council was not addressing those repeating themes related to public safety, infrastructure and parks & recreation priorities. Beyond the major effort to provide the fire station as part of firefighter and EMT needs, substantial support of the Police Department, and the large amount spent on the parks and recreation portion, Councilmember McGehee suggested a need to discuss reserves as a way to reduce the budget and levies rather than waste staff time and efforts on an exercise. Councilmember McGehee opined that there were a lot of ways to provide services in more opaque ways, such as hidden taxes through increased fees. With the Finance Commission seeking additional infor- mation as well, and providing input on the budget process, Councilmember McGehee questioned the purpose of asking staff to perform in an exercise that wouldn't result in much new information. Before action on the motion, Councilmember Etten advised that he found it an in- teresting concept based on the merits of such an activity from the Finance Com- mission and their perspective, which may prove helpful and may or may not make sense in the end. Councilmember Etten suggested that this be charged to the Fi- nance Commission for their discussion and recommendation to the City Council. Regarding the idea of levy-supported dollars, Councilmember Etten opined that any discussion needed to be fair to all departments and include all costs—whether