Laserfiche WebLink
<br />.A!l&iI-A <br />. --.... <br />..-.- - <br />I T., . <br /> <br />Minnesota Automobile Dealers Association <br />lOUIS ClAESON, EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT . 27i UNIVERSITY AVE. ' S1 PAUL, MN 55103 . lOCAL (6121291.2400 . TOll FREE 1.800.652.9029 . FAX (612) 291.2894 <br />home page http://www.mada.org <br /> <br />April 9, 1999 <br /> <br />Thomas Paschke <br />Roseville City Planning Office <br />2660 Civic Center Drive <br />Roseville, MN 55113 <br /> <br />Re: Planning File #3111 <br />Boaters Outlet <br /> <br />Dear Mr. Paschke: <br /> <br />The purpose of this letter is to comment in opposition to the referenced Interim Use <br />Permit which would allow the applicant to conduct Sunday sales of automobiles. <br /> <br />Minnesota Statutes 168.275, a copy of which is enclosed, makes it a crime for any person <br />to carry on or engage in the business of buying, selling, exchanging or dealing in new or <br />used vehicles on Sunday. It is also illegal for a person to open any lot to engage in the <br />business of exchanging automobiles. <br /> <br />It is clearly not illegal for a private party to sell th'eir own personal car on Sunday. <br />However, in this case the applicant is initiating a business venture which in MADA's <br />view is conduct proscribed by the statute. In addition, to the extent that licensed dealers <br />end up participating as "owner" sellers of vehicles on Sundays, the use of the property <br />would be unlawful. <br /> <br />The Motor Vehicle Sunday Closing Statute was the subject of extensive litigation two <br />years ago in the case of Daryl Kirk and Bud Hamilton vs. State of Minnesota. The <br />litigation was sponsored by the Minnesota Civil Liberties Union. In an opinion filed on <br />September 9, 1997 (CI-96-3614) the Minnesota Court of Appeals fully upheld the <br />constitutionality of tho:? statute. <br /> <br />MAD A is a trade association of 485 franchised new car and truck dealers in the state of <br />Minnesota. Thank you for the opportunity to present these comments. If you need <br />additional information, please feel free to contact the undersigned. <br />I <br />! <br />,.RiMerely, I,' /' <br />I-~-.--\\. ~I" <br />/':/ -" .' /----.. <br />/ '-Jam s Schutj.eF ") <br />" M~ A Counsel ,,// <br /> <br />/ <br />.' ' Enclosure <br /> <br />IA:'\' o....~ <br />