Laserfiche WebLink
City of Roseville <br />Construction –Proposal Package 2H (Irrigation) <br />Best Value Selection Summary <br /> <br />Section 1: Summary of Scores September 10, 2014 <br />Raw DataPoints <br />Possible <br />NoCriteriaPoints <br />2H-12H-22H-32H-42H-12H-22H-32H-4 <br />250 <br />1Cost Proposal – Total Base$222,250$146,947$230,449$215,815165.3250.0159.4170.2 <br />350 <br />2Interview Rating5.06.35.46.3280.0350.0303.3350.0 <br />150 <br />3Risk Plan Rating5.09.25.04.381.8150.081.870.9 <br />100 <br />4Project Capability Plan Rating5.010.05.05.050.0100.050.050.0 <br />100 <br />5Value Added Plan Rating5.09.25.04.354.5100.054.547.3 <br />50 <br />6PPI8.19.98.15.040.950.040.925.3 <br />Total Points:6731000690714 <br />Total Availble Points1000 <br /> <br />Section 2: Ranking <br />ProposerTotal ScoreDifference <br />2H-21000-- <br />2H-4714286 <br />2H-369024 <br />2H-167317 <br /> <br /> <br />Section 3: Committee Ratings <br />Risk Plan RatingsCapability Plan RatingsValue-Added Proposal Ratings <br />Evaluator2H-12H-22H-32H-4Evaluator2H-12H-22H-32H-4Evaluator2H-12H-22H-32H-4 <br />Evaluator 15555Evaluator 151055Evaluator 151055 <br />Evaluator 251055Evaluator 251055Evaluator 251055 <br />Evaluator 351051Evaluator 351055Evaluator 35551 <br />Evaluator 451055Evaluator 451055Evaluator 451055 <br />Evaluator 551055Evaluator 551055Evaluator 551055 <br />Evaluator 651055Evaluator 651055Evaluator 651055 <br />Average5.09.25.04.3Average5.010.05.05.0Average5.09.25.04.3 <br /> <br />Project Manager Interview RatingsSite Superintendent Interview Ratings <br />Evaluator2H-12H-22H-32H-4Evaluator2H-12H-22H-32H-4 <br />Evaluator 155510Evaluator 15555 <br />Evaluator 251055Evaluator 25555 <br />Evaluator 35555Evaluator 35555 <br />Evaluator 45555Evaluator 45555 <br />Evaluator 5551010Evaluator 55555 <br />Evaluator 6510510Evaluator 651055 <br />Vendor2H-12H-22H-32H-4 <br /> <br />Overall 5.06.35.46.3 <br /> <br /> <br />