2015-10-07_PC_Agenda_Packet - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Attachment A Mr. Reeder noted other ideas in communities, and software applications to establish a baseline, such as by addressing canopy coverage vacillating, to consider where to go in the future. Commissioner Daire spoke in support of that approach. Chair Boguszewski opined that underpinning the whole concept, the key seemed to allow part of the comprehensive plan to involve a quantitative plan by holding a broader public discourse around the entire concept and not just the city deciding they have authority of trees in a private yard, but agreeing to a good, long-term goal for the entire community. Chair Boguszewski opined that it certainly made things more palatable rather than his initial concerns that a tree ordinance was within the realm of government overreach. Mr. Gozola continued with examples from other communities, including addressing either mechanism during development and/or construction (Maple Grove), limiting tree preservation to a subdivision versus zoning ordinance (Plymouth), or cash in lieu of tree removal or restoration (Minnestrista). As outlined in Attachment A of Sambatek's memorandum dated July 6, 2015, Mr. Gozola reviewed his current project understanding and observations of the community's current status. Chair Boguszewski noted the points discussing flexibility on the part of the community and the overarching goal of why to keep or increase trees as part of the educational piece as well. Mayor Roe noted the need to justify any city ordinance with some kind of policy. While hearing a lot about tree preservation from Planning Commission discussions, Councilmember Willmus stated his observation of their deliberations was based on how they were interpreting the letter of the law with the zoning code and comprehensive plan. However, Councilmember Willmus noted that the Tree Board, as a role of the Parks & Recreation Commission, had not yet been heard from, and expressed his desire to make sure they weighed in on this discussion as a vital part of the equation. During his eight year tenure with the City, City Manager Trudgeon advised that he was not aware of the Tree Board being involved much or being aware of their actual role. However, going forward, Mr. Trudgeon advised that he would incorporate them into these discussions. Councilmember McGehee opined that Public Works was also part of the equation, as this involved the entire city, whether private trees, right-of-way or boulevard trees, or those located in parks or general common spaces. Councilmember McGehee opined that some of the issues of importance to her included grouping trees or massing them to identify certain areas; recognizing the flyway migratory areas; retaining vegetation in natural areas; diversity with boulevard tree planning, as well as its spacing for maintenance and to ensure tree survival, and how to address use of underground stormwater storage in irrigating trees. Councilmember McGehee also noted her concerns heard from residents in their lack of confidence with tree inspections requiring the expensive removal of apparently diseased trees, and subsequent discovery when analyzed by the U of MN that they were not actually diseased at all. Councilmember McGehee expressed her lack of support for planting elsewhere in lieu of the immediate development area, opining that provided nothing but wasteland in some areas and overcrowding in other areas. Councilmember McGehee further noted a recent newspaper article about one old growth tree species (the state's largest Butternut tree) in the community that needed to be preserved. Councilmember Willmus agreed with Councilmember McGehee in the need to call attention to old growth trees, with much of the tree planning occurring as the community grew from farmland to residential during the 1950's through 1970's; and impressive growth achieved without any actual tree preservation plan in place. During the Pulte Housing Development project, Councilmember Willmus admitted it had served as a real eye opener for the City Council in clear-cutting that area for