2015-10-07_PC_Agenda_Packet - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Attachment A development and replacing those trees that may be found lacking from some perspectives. Councilmember Willmus clarified that he was not interested in an ordinance governing or requiring a private resident to cut down an old tree or having to approach City Hall to get a replacement tree permit, but was more concerned with an ordinance addressing subdivisions or redevelopment and consistent and fair questions to ask as part of that process. While recognizing that the Planning Commission as a body didn't have authority over what the City Council ultimately adopted as an ordinance, Chair Boguszewski noted the individual comments of commissioners, and their willingness to serve on a task force or advisory board to assist the City Council in their efforts. Mayor Roe noted that got back to the balance question and what triggered enforcement; and his tendency to agree with Councilmember Willmus' interest in a reasonable approach to promote adding trees, but recognizing while there may not be much old growth from a technical sense, the community still had some significant trees. Councilmember Etten agreed that it was necessary to decide the City's purpose in having such an ordinance, with an excellent list available in the annual Arbor Day Resolution addressing the City's regulatory function and benefits for the community and its overall health and public good. Councilmember Etten noted the involvement of the Tree Board as part of the Emerald Ash Borer (EAB) infestation; and encouraged Mr. Gozola and Reeder to review the staff RCA prepared for the November 17, 2014 and past discussions. While perhaps not being a desirable species, Councilmember Etten noted there was value in a 70' tall Cottonwood tree as a significant tree, even though not considered a specimen tree, a common sight in Roseville. Councilmember Etten expressed his interest in incentives to preserve such trees; and noted his frustrations in not tying together a tree preservation plan drawing with the grading plan drawing during review of land use cases during the Planning Commission and City Council review, opining that they needed to go together to understand the overall impact of building in a readable format. Under current code, Councilmember Etten noted the negative potential to clear all trees in the right-of-way, such as evidenced near Lady Slipper Park on West Owasso Boulevard, but recognizing the positive impact with the replacement berm embankment and appreciation of it as a justification to clear the area, and not just because it happened to be on the right-of-way. Councilmember Etten noted the big impacts to neighborhoods, and solar considerations to address and how to balance those interests as part of the process. In referencing the previously-noted Pulte Development, Councilmember McGehee noted the need to address tree protection during the construction process, and her concern in the impacts of the Oaks with compaction of their root mass during that construction process, without any guidelines in place to address that. Councilmember Etten also addressed the Pizza Lucé development as an example and the lack of staff resources to continually monitor every development without professional assistance to maintain quality trees. Councilmember Laliberte expressed her appreciation of this presentation and examples from other communities. Councilmember Laliberte stated her biggest concern was with the Pulte Project serving as a wake-up call for her in the potential for clear-cutting trees and starting from scratch. Councilmember Laliberte agreed that she was not interested in the city assessing or approving a private property owner's need to remove a tree for insurance and/or structure issues, nor in their being required to jump through hoops to accomplish that work, given the expensive nature of such a venture to remove a tree already. Councilmember Laliberte spoke in support of coordinating with various departments and commissions as an integrated part of the decision-making process for the City Council