Laserfiche WebLink
Roseville Maintenance Facility Report <br />Comparison Study <br />102617.B <br />This section takes a closer look at Roseville in comparison to the next smallest city, Crystal. Between <br />2014 - 2015, Kodet Architectural Group worked with the City of Crystal to build a maintenance facility <br />that met their needs. After exploring all available options, Crystal decided to replace their existing <br />building with a new facility on the same site. The services and facility sizes of the two cities are similar. <br />However, Crystal serves an area less than half the size of Roseville. <br />Program Deficiencies <br />The chart below shows that the existing Roseville Maintenance Facility has less space than the smaller <br />city maintenance building and yard in every aspect except Mezzanine Storage. The greatest deficits in <br />Roseville's program are the vehicle storage, shops, on -grade storage, and offices. Roseville does have <br />more mezzanine storage, however this is only effective for seasonal storage and small equipment. <br />Roseville's existing vehicle storage does not contain the full existing inventory list. The Roseville <br />workshops for meter repair, sign production, and Park & Recreation workshop are one-third the size of <br />the smaller city. Larger workshops provide adequate space for staff, tool and material storage. The extra <br />area also creates a designated welding area adjacent to repair bays. <br />Site <br />Existing Roseville Crystal (2015) <br />Maint. Facility Maint. Facility Difference <br />Vehicle Storage 41,800 <br />44,600 <br />-2,800 <br />Wash Bay 900 <br />1,600 <br />-700 <br />Repair Bay 3,800 <br />4,200 <br />-400 <br />Meter/Sign/Work Shops 900 <br />2,800 <br />-1,900 <br />Mezzanine 4,500 <br />2,500 <br />2,000 <br />Storage 2,600 <br />4,700 <br />-2,100 <br />Office 7,300 <br />9,900 <br />-2,600 <br />Building Subtotal 61,800 <br />70,300 <br />-8500 <br />Covered Storage 3,000 4,030 <br />Yard Storage (acres) 1.35 acres 1.67 acres <br />Exist. Fueling Station 1,000 1,280 <br />Total Site 3.98 acres 5.33 acres <br />Site Deficiencies <br />-1,030 <br />.32 acres <br />-280 <br />1.35 acres <br />Crystal's 5.88 -acre lot did not accommodate all yard storage, the city was willing to continue storing the <br />largest portion of yard materials (sand and salt) off-site. Roseville, although a larger city, has less onsite <br />yard storage than the smaller city with no additional yard storage off-site. <br />KODET ARCHITECTURAL G ROU P, LTD. 15 Groveland Terrace, Minneapolis, MN55403+1154 T:(612)377-2737 <br />11 <br />