CCP 06022025 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Ethics Commission Meeting Minutes Wednesday, May 14, 2025 Page 2 1 Aldine right-of-way should be a part of the city’s pathway plan was a recurring theme 2 throughout the meeting. 3 4 City Attorney Tierney discussed the legal concepts of the but-for test and clear and con- 5 vincing evidence. She concluded that there was insufficient evidence to prove that Coun- 6 cilmember Strahan’s relationship with her sister-in-law influenced her decision, and she 7 was open to answering any questions. 8 9 Chair Murphy thanked City Attorney Tierney for the thorough report and opened the floor 10 for questions from commissioners. 11 12 Commissioner Cyra agreed with the findings and praised the process for allowing residents 13 to raise concerns. 14 15 Commissioner Boulton also agreed with the findings and had no further comments. 16 17 Commissioner Vemireddy questioned the application of the “but-for” test in general. 18 19 City Attorney Tierney explained the “but-for” test and its application to the case. 20 21 City Attorney Tierney explained that the ethics code goes beyond financial benefit and 22 includes broader considerations. 23 24 Commissioner Cicha found it hard to believe Councilmember Strahan would vote differ- 25 ently due to her family relationship. 26 27 Chair Murphy concurred with the findings and the recommendation for the city council. 28 29 Commissioner Cyramoved,agreeing with the investigation's findings, and forwardingthat 30 recommendation to the city council for action, seconded by Commissioner Vemireddy. 31 32 Ayes All: Motionpassed. 33 34 City Manager Trudgeon noted the recommendation will be brought to the City Council at 35 its June 2, 2025, meeting. 36 37 V.Other Business 38 None. 39 40 VI.Adjourn 41 Commissioner Cichamoved to adjourn the meeting at approximately 6:20p.m., seconded 42 by Commissioner Vemireddy. 43 44 Ayes All: Motion passed. 45 Qbhf!9:!pg!385