2002_1014_packet - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Based on the preceding evaluation of the interview panel, I recommend and appoint, subject to Council concurrence, Campbell Knutson as Roseville's City Attorney. Here are additional observations about the four firms. Details Our panel interviewed two firms in the morning and two in the afternoon. From the morning interviews, the panel selected Ratwik and Roszack as the stronger applicant. 7ensen Bell was excellent. They ha�e good city attorney experience in Ramsey County and great knowledge of Roseville legal history. But Ratwik Roszack impressed the panel with a customer-oriented, resident-focused approach to legal services. 7ay Squires of that firm was particularly impressive. Unfortunately, Mr. Squires is committed to attending Red Wing City Council meetings on the first and third Mondays of each month; were his firm selected another member of that firm would ha�e to cover other Roseville council meetings. The panel viewed this division in meeting attendance and attorney responsibilities as a significant drawback. In the afternoon, the panel evaluated Campbell Knutson as the stronger applicant of the two law firms interviewed. Kennedy Gra�en is plainly an excellent firm. But the attorney proposed as Roseville's City Attorney lacks city attorney experience for a community our size. In addition, their answers were not as crisp and comprehensive as Campbell Knutson's. Then, in comparing Campbell Knutson to Ratwik Roszack at the end of the day, the panel felt that Campbell Knutson's experience with city law ga�e them a decisive edge. Ratwik Roszack is an excellent firm that specializes more in school law than city law. In addition, Campbell Knutson has a stronger connection to the Minnesota League of Cities; Mr. 7amnik worked at the MLC for many years. That kind of legal networking was deemed a strong positive by the panel. Fiscal Impact Sufficient funds are budgeted in our current Council-approved 2002 budget and in the preliminary Council-approved 2003 budget to pay for city attorney services. Council Action Requested Motion to concur with the City Manager's appointment of Campbell Knutson as City Attorney, subject to negotiation of a final legal services agreement.