CC_Minutes_2011_0516 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Regular City Council Meeting Monday,May 16,2011 Page 9 come forward with a proposal for a two-tiered penalty system for sale of alcoholic beverages to a minor, but that it had not received Council majority support. Councilmember Johnson noted that he did not hear, at that time, any compelling reasons or rationale for those penalties for off-sale establishments being treated more harshly than those on-sale establishments having other sources of income than alcohol sales. Councilmember Johnson cautioned that he wanted to clarify that there were three (3) components of the penalty structure: monetary fine, days suspended, and ultimate revocation; and he was only seeking to amend the num- ber of days for suspension and negative or disastrous impacts on off-sale estab- lishments. Since he had received a letter recently signed by ten (10) off-sale li- cense holders in Roseville, Councilmember Johnson sought to bring forth his two- tiered plan again, and under a different City Council makeup, based on his discus- sions to-date with new Councilmembers. Councilmember Johnson noted the changes proposed in amending the current or- dinance (Attachment B), with the exception of one error on page 2, where the suspension period for the first violation for sale of alcohol to an obviously intox- icated individual should be one (1) day, not zero (0) days as written. Mayor Roe questioned if an actual vote had been taken last year on Council- member Johnson's proposed two-tiered system. Councilmember Johnson responded that it had not, as there was not sufficient Councilmember support at that time; and noted that he had voted in support of the amendments as presented at that time to provide a unanimous and united front. Public Comment Deb Mosby As a licensed drug counselor and former juvenile parole officer, Ms. Mosby noted that the biggest detractor of youth health in her work with them, is definitely al- cohol, then other drugs. Ms. Mosby expressed her concern about decreasing pe- nalties for selling to youth; and asked that the City Council defer action on this item to allow other concerned citizens who may not have heard that this issue was being discussed tonight, to attend and make their comments known. Ms. Mosby presented several facts based on studies and the trends in alcohol use by teenagers and later in life, and provided several examples of alcohol sales to minors; in addition to economic costs for alcohol use in Minnesota, and to the City of Roseville in police response to underage drinking and all of its implica- tions and resulting crimes. Ms. Mosby opined that it was a privilege for license holders to sell alcoholic be- verages that they made huge profits from those sales and further opined that she felt strongly that if the City Council decreased those penalties, those license hold- ers may become lax in their diligence. While recognizing that historical statistics