2008_HRC_Minutes - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Discussion ensued regarding the incident. City Manager Malinen said he provided a complaint form to use if he chose, in accordance with the City's normal procedure. Chair Delmore suggested that she contact the complainant to advise him of tonight's discussion, as well as the existence of the surveillance tape. Commissioner Singleton noted that with a complaint process in place, it appeared that the complainant was seeking to go around that normal process. Commissioner McKenzie said based on her past experience on the HRC in addition to her work in the legal field, she preferred to follow the process and recommended that the complainant file a complaint and submit that prior to further HRC involvement or discussion. City Manager Malinen questioned whether the HRC was the proper forum for the complainant, given that a grievance process is in place. City Manager Malinen assured Commissioners the Police Chief, the Police Department and he took formal complaints seriously. Malinen said he was unsure why the complainant was reluctant to file a written complaint if he was not satisfied with discussions. Commissioner McGehee suggested that Chair Delmore contact the complainant to advise him of tonight's HRC discussion, and to encourage him to fill out a formal complaint form, and in addition, to provide the HRC in writing his point of view and review of the situation, and his preferred outcome of this situation. Commissioner McGehee opined that the complainant didn't have to attend an HRC meeting; but suggested that Chair Delmore could request the video tape for the HRC to review at an upcoming meeting. Commissioner McGehee opined that it was recourse if people didn't trust the process. City Manager Malinen opined that, while a complaint process was already in place, the HRC was promoting that one individual who may not like that process, a complainant could circumvent the process, serving to undermine the Police Department and a process by which citizens would get problems addressed. Chair Delmore took issue with City Manager Malinen's interpretation of the number of citizen complaints being heard. Commissioner Crump opined that he would prefer to see a written complaint; and if he has an issue, the complainant follow the process by submitting the complaint to the Police Chief, with a copy to City Manager Malinen, and possibly the HRC. Commissioner Crump expressed concern that, if there was a danger of potential litigation, the HRC needed to remain moot until that litigation was resolve. Commissioner McKenzie said when there was a complaint with the Police Department with an official complaint and investigation in process, the Roseville HRC could not do anything, reminding Commissioners that they were an advisory commission to the City Council. Commissioner McKenzie noted there used to be a mediation team that a majority of Minnesota